There were thirty-one households in Pinch Gap, and on Tuesday morning Silas Ketterman knocked on the first of them with a clipboard that did not belong to him and a sentence he had been rehearsing since four a.m.
"Good morning, ma'am. I'm sorry to bother you. I'm trying to write a song."
The woman who opened the door was in her sixties, with a dish towel on her shoulder and a cigarette she had hastily hidden behind her back. She looked at Silas, and at Gene Tolliver beside him in her navy uniform, and at Toby Wray on the step with his fiddle case, and said, "Oh, Lord. Is this about the light?"
"Yes, ma'am."
"I wondered when somebody'd ask."
It was the first surprise of the day. He had expected closed doors. He had imagined thirty-one polite refusals, in thirty-one kitchens, to a stranger asking the very thing a hill town does not say. But Gene had gone ahead of him at seven that morning and knocked on every one of them first, in uniform, and said: this is Imogene Tolliver, Lyda's granddaughter, and I need help. It turned out the county's captain, with her tight ponytail and her pained, courteous face, was a person nobody in Pinch Gap could say no to. They had all known her father.
By noon they had been in nine kitchens.
The first woman, whose name was Edna, said she had never missed a week of the oil in twenty-two years, and that she had never known why. She said it was only that the light was lonesome. A man named Buddy, who carried it with his brother Ray on alternate Thursdays, said nothing for a long time, and then said he had not told Ray he loved him in sixty years, that Ray was seventy-one and had a bad heart, and that if the Lord took Ray first he would not know how to carry the oil by himself. Ray, in the next chair, said, "Aw, shut up, Buddy." And then he put his hand over his eyes.
At the third house, a girl of nine came to the door in a unicorn sweatshirt and said that she was not allowed to talk to strangers, and then said, in a rush, that she had seen the boy.
"What boy?" said Gene, very gently.
"The one with the gray coat. He waved at me." The child's chin quivered. "He waved at the light like he knew it. Like it was a dog. I didn't tell anybody. They'd say I was making it up." She looked at Silas with huge, accusing eyes. "Is he going to be okay?"
"I hope so," said Silas.
"That's not a real answer."
"No," he said. "It's the truest one I've got."
She considered him, and nodded, once, with the air of a small judge, and shut the door.
They had a rhythm after that. Silas would ask, in the doorway, what the light was to them; and what they had never said to anyone on that hill, about that light; and whether they would be willing, on Thursday night, to say it aloud, once, with others, at the foot of the chute. Toby would stand quiet at his elbow, with the fiddle at his side, listening with his good ear. Gene would say nothing. She would stand behind them with her thumbs in her belt, and at some point in the conversation, in every kitchen, the person who answered would look at her, and look away.
Doug and Laurie Spicer said that their son was a freshman and that they were afraid of him, a thing they had not known how to say. A deaf man named Orville, who had not spoken in eleven years, wrote a single sentence on the back of an envelope and held it out. Silas read it. HE WAS MY BROTHER AND I WAS GLAD. It was the first of the unsayables that he did not know how to answer, so he took the envelope and put it in his breast pocket and kept his hand on it for the rest of the day.
A woman in a green parka, whom Silas recognized from the church steps, said that she did not want to say a thing and that she would be glad if they went away. Then she said it. She said she had hated the lantern for thirty years because her father had gone up the chute one night to carry the oil and she had thought he was with someone else, and that she was fifty-one years old and had never told her mother she was sorry for what she had said at the funeral. Then she shut the door, quite gently, and they heard her sit down on the other side of it.
"That's four," said Toby, in a very small voice, on the step.
"Four what?"
"Four true things." He had a pencil behind his ear and no notebook. He had said he would not write anything down, that it was not his to keep. "I think I'm going to remember them all."
"You can't help it," said Gene, in the tone of a woman who had been told the same thing a week ago. "You'll remember them for the rest of your life, kid. It's the price."
By two in the afternoon the day had gone gray and cold. They sat on the church steps with a thermos of Lyda's coffee and counted what they had. Twenty-six households. Twenty-four had agreed to come on Thursday. Two had shut the door without a word.
"Five left," said Gene. "The last is the old schoolteacher at the top."
"I've got most of it," said Silas. He looked at the clipboard, on which he had written nothing. He had it all in his head, a great warm heavy mass of it: the hand on the cold glass, the brother that no one had said it to, the child who had seen a boy wave. "It's not a stave yet. It's a, it's a lot of weather."
"That's how they start." It was Toby who said it. He had his fiddle out, and had begun to tune it on his knee, with his head tilted. "Pearline says a song's just a lot of weather somebody had the nerve to write down. You don't make it. You just stand there."
"You make it sound easy."
"It's not easy," said Toby. "It's just simple."
The last house on the hill was the highest and the oldest, a gray two-story with a deep porch and a gone-wild boxwood hedge, and on the porch, in a rocker, with a shawl over her knees and a Bible in her lap that she was not reading, sat an old woman whose name was Corinne Gaskill.
She was eighty-eight. She had taught the first four grades at the Pinch Gap school for thirty-one years, and she looked at the three of them coming up the walk with the air of a woman who has seen a great many children arrive late.
"Imogene Tolliver," she said. "You were in my third grade. You chewed your pencil."
"Yes, ma'am."
"And you're that Ketterman. And the Wray boy, with the ear. Sit down. Don't stand there dripping on my boxwood. I've been expecting you since Sunday."
They sat on the porch steps, in a row, with the rain beginning to run off the eaves in strings. Mrs. Gaskill listened to Silas without interrupting, which was how he knew she had been a teacher. When he had finished she closed the Bible and set it carefully aside.
"I'm not going to say what I never said," she said. "I'm eighty-eight, and I've said everything. That's the one benefit of the age." Her voice, high and a little cracked, was perfectly steady. "But I'll tell you what I have got. It isn't mine. It was my mother's. She had it from hers, who came up out of the mill camp in eighteen ninety-something. You'll understand it was never a hymn. It was just a thing she'd say when somebody was late coming home. Over the supper table. To the child, or the husband, or whoever it was, as they came in the door."
She folded her hands. She looked out at the rain, and the long gray valley, and the far-off iron lines of the chute going up into the pines. In a high, plain, quavering voice, not singing, only saying, in the rhythm of a thing said ten thousand times, she gave him the last line of the day.
"Keep a chair by the fire for the one who's late."
Silas did not move. Beside him, very softly, Toby drew a long, slow, sweet note from the fiddle, and held it, and the old schoolteacher's mouth trembled, and she turned her face away.
"That's what the light's for," said Corinne Gaskill. "I've known it sixty years. It was always a chair."

