Sheriff Dale Pruitt had a wood stove in his office, which was against county regulations, and a green clothbound ledger in the bottom drawer of his desk, which was not against anything, and on Monday afternoon he sat with both of them in front of him and listened to a nineteen-year-old tell him that his sister was warm.
It took Silas four tries. He had rehearsed it in the truck, with Wyatt silent beside him and Cade at the wheel, and every version had been worse than the last. In the end he said it plainly, standing in front of the desk in a coat that smelled of woodsmoke, with his hands in his pockets. A boy had come up from Pinch Gap on Thursday night. He had been on the fifth stand for twenty-one days. On the sixth there was a girl in a wool coat, with the collar turned up and a tortoiseshell barrette in her hair, who said her name was Hannah Pruitt.
Dale did not move.
He was sixty-five, a heavy slow man with gray in his mustache and reading glasses pushed up on his forehead, who had been sheriff of Pell County for twenty-four years and a deputy for twelve before that. He had a face made for sympathy and a manner that gave none. He sat behind the desk with his big hands flat on the blotter, and the stove ticked, and outside, down the corridor, a dispatcher laughed at something on the radio.
"She said to tell you she's warm," said Silas. "That she never was cold. That you were a very small baby and you shouldn't feel bad about not remembering, because she remembered enough for the two of you."
The sheriff took the glasses off his forehead. He looked at them. He set them down on the blotter, very precisely, in the exact middle.
"Say the last part again," said Dale.
"That she remembered enough for the two of you."
"That's what my mother used to say." His voice was quite level. "About the, she'd say it about herself. When I asked why I couldn't remember Hannah. She said, 'Don't you fret, hon. I remember enough for the both of us.'" He stopped. "Nobody else knew that. Mama's been dead since ninety-eight."
The stove ticked. Silas stood very still.
Dale pulled open the bottom drawer. He took out the green ledger and laid it on the desk. Then, from beneath it, from the back of the drawer, in a nest of old rubber bands and a tin of mints, he took out a small flat object wrapped in a white handkerchief. He unfolded it on the blotter.
It was a hair barrette, an old one, curved tortoiseshell with a tarnished clasp. One tooth was missing.
"She had it on when she left," said Dale. "She was seventeen. First of November, nineteen sixty-one. She'd gone to Rankin Gap with her boyfriend's sister, who said she'd heard a song. The girl came back by herself. Mama found that in the Gap road, in the frost, a week later, the day she quit hoping." He touched it with one thick finger. "I've kept it in this drawer since Mama passed. I never knew why. It's the only thing I ever took out of a case file."
"I'm sorry," said Silas.
"Don't be." The sheriff's eyes were red-rimmed and perfectly dry. "I'd like to know where she is. That's all. I'd like a direction." He drew a long breath and let it out. "My father shut this book on her. Forty-two names, and he stopped writing the day she went. Said it wasn't a thing a sheriff should be recording. And I took the job anyway, and I never opened it, either." He looked up. "I opened it in October. Drunk. I want you to know. I put her on that fool Salter's waiting page, and I listened to him read her name, and I've been sitting here for three weeks wondering what kind of man does that."
"The kind who wanted her found."
"That's a kindness." Dale gave a short rough laugh. "I'll take it."
He opened the ledger. It fell open at page thirty, as if it had been opened there many times, and he laid his palm on the faded entry: HANNAH L. PRUITT, 17. 1 NOV 1961. RANKIN GAP. NOT FOUND. In a clean hand beneath it someone had once added the single word SORRY, and someone had scratched it out.
"She's on the sixth stand of a staircase twenty-two miles west of where she went in," said Dale slowly. "That's what you're telling me."
"Yes, sir."
"That's not possible."
"No, sir." Silas hesitated. "But Toby's got a recording. And I think Marian has a map."
Marian Voss's map was on the wall of the conference room.
She had put it up on Sunday, with a roll of green painter's tape and a county road atlas, and by Monday afternoon it had become the most remarkable object in the Pell County Sheriff's Office. It covered the whole of the north wall. She had drawn the county on a blueprint sheet, in pencil, with every ridge and hollow, and over that she had stuck nine pins with colored heads. She had not stopped there. Between the pins, in loops and zigzags, she had strung red embroidery thread, and where the threads met she had written, in her small exact hand, a number.
Dovie Rankin sat in front of it on a folding chair with her cane across her knees, in the black coat, with the stubborn alert posture of a woman who is not going to be talked out of a seat. Toby Wray sat cross-legged on the floor with a laptop. Wyatt leaned in the doorway.
"There's nine," said Marian. She did not stammer. She had not stammered at all since the Lip. "Rankin Gap. Pinch Gap. And seven I'm calling by their trailheads, because that's all I have." She tapped each pin with a blue pencil. "Cutler Ridge. Sorrel Spring. The Old Mill Road. North Fork. Sutter's Knob. Bell Hollow. And one up by the state line the Open Lantern map just calls 'the other one.'"
"The threads?" said Dale. He had come to stand beside her, with the ledger under his arm.
"Toby's pitches." Marian drew her pencil along a red line. "He can hear each Lip hum a different note through the rock. The notes move, they're not fixed, but they're all moving toward one another. I think, and I'm not a geologist, I'm a folklorist, I think they're not nine staircases. I think they're nine doors in the same house."
Dovie said nothing. She was looking at the map as one might look at a photograph of a person one had loved a long time ago.
"So Hannah," said Dale.
"Went down at Rankin Gap in nineteen sixty-one. And is sitting, on Danny Beck's report, on the sixth stand at Pinch Gap. Which means either she walked, down there, twenty-two miles, in the dark, in sixty-three years, or the stair is one stair." Marian laid the pencil down. "And that means every name in your ledger might be anywhere on it."
A silence settled over the room.
"That's forty-three," said Dovie, finally. Her voice was quite soft. "And three hundred and eleven at the Hollow. And God knows how many at the others. And Silas has a stair he can't go down without somebody's song."
"I'm not going anywhere," said Silas. "Not yet."
"No, you're not." She turned her head and looked at him. "But somebody's going to have to. And I'd like it to be somebody who knows the song."
"Which brings me," said Marian slowly, "to the part I didn't want to say."
She took a printed page from the table and held it out. It was a flyer, in bright green and white, with a picture of a smiling family on a mountain trail, and a heading in bold: FAMILY TRAIL DAY. Underneath, a date, and a list of locations.
"It's a state tradition," said Marian. "The Friday after Thanksgiving. Guided hikes at the state trailheads, free, for families. Kids in strollers. Last year it was four thousand people at eleven sites." Her voice stayed perfectly flat. "Five of my seven are on that list. Cutler Ridge. Sorrel Spring. North Fork. Sutter's Knob. Bell Hollow. And none of them has a keeper, a lantern, or a Dovie."
"That's Friday week," said Dale.
"Eleven days." Marian turned the page over and laid it face down on the table, very gently, as one lays down a sleeping thing. "There are seven Lips with no one at the top. And on the twenty-eighth of November, the state is going to put about three thousand people on five of them with a thermos and a map and a smile."

