He walked back through the dark with the letter inside his shirt, and the far-hearing lend told him everything.
He heard an owl turn its head on a branch. He heard a creek fifteen miles off clear its throat. Near four in the morning he heard, a long way ahead, an old woman’s cane tap three times on a porch board, and then three times again, patient as a clock.
Dovie was waiting under the lamp in the doorway, wrapped in the wool coat, with the radio on low.
Silas didn’t say hello. He held out the page, folded so the last line showed.
She took her time with it. She read it by the lamp with the paper held at arm’s length, and her face did what it had done at the Lip, which was nothing at all.
“Walk with me,” she said. “I’ll tell it once.”
They climbed by flashlight, then by gray dawn, up the shoulder of the north ridge to a flat gray slab that overlooked the whole saddle. Below them lay Rankin Gap, the cairn like a thumbprint, the pull-off, and the long green fold of Long Hollow going away into mist.
Frost lay on the rock in crystals thick as salt. Somebody had cut letters into it with a knife, a long time ago, and the lichen had grown into the grooves.
R.R. D.R.
And lower down, cleaner, cut with a nail and no great skill: W.K.
“Ruth’s Seat,” said Dovie. “She’s my sister. Two years older.” She lowered herself onto the rock with both hands on the cane, facing the Hollow, so that she didn’t have to face him. “Our people have kept the first stave since before there was a county. We were the family who walked down to the edge and came back, and the Hollow knew us. It called Ruth the winter she was nineteen.”
“Called her how?”
“Sang. At the first frost, you hear it, if you’re the right blood. It sang to her. She went down on a Sunday and I stood up top.”
“You were her caller.”
“I was seventeen. Our daddy was dead, and Mama had the shaking sickness, and there wasn’t anyone else of the blood.” She picked at the cane. “We lined it out. You know what that is? Mama’s church did it. No books. The leader sings a line, the people sing it back. I’d sing the line down, and Ruth would sing it up, and she climbed. Nine nights was the promise, and she climbed a stand a night.”
The wind turned the frost on the rock to smoke.
“By the sixth night she was at the third stand, close enough that I could hear her breathe. And on the seventh, she stopped singing the lines.” Dovie’s voice dropped. “She started singing my name. Not Dovie. Dove. It’s what Ruth called me when I was five. Dove, come down, it’s warm down here.”
Silas said nothing.
“I was seventeen, hon, and I was afraid. I knew then if I went down, I’d stay. So I stood at the top with my lantern, and when I came to my blank, the one I owed her, I sang, ‘I’ll sing till you’re home.’” She shut her eyes. “And I went to the cabin and put wax in my ears. I sat out the eighth and ninth nights with my hands over them.”
Her fingers tightened on the cane. “I’d had her to the third stand. The rope went slack, and I felt her slide, all the way to the bottom. I’ve worn the wax every frost since, so I wouldn’t hear her still at it.”
It was the longest speech he had ever heard from her. She seemed to have used her whole day’s breath on it.
“And Wyatt?”
“Four years ago, he walked up my run humming the same flat third you did. I fed him. He heard her his first frost here, at the Lip. He didn’t have wax.” Her mouth twisted. “He came back down to the cabin white as paper and asked, Aunt Dovie, who’s Dove?”
She was crying a little, he saw. She wasn’t making a sound about it. The tears just ran down the creases of her face, and she let them.
“Nobody had called me that in nearly sixty years.”
Silas stood up. He hadn’t known he would. The anger came up from the soles of his boots, clean and hard, aimed at her and past her at the whole last three years.
“You knew he was down there,” he said. “Three years. You knew, and you taught him the way.”
“I couldn’t stop him.”
“You gave him the first stave. You told him where to find the rest.”
“I couldn’t stop him.” Her chin came up. “He’d made up his mind before he ever knocked on my door. What I could do was send him better armed. And you.” She turned her wet, hard, small face up to him at last. “You let him go down alone.”
It landed. It landed exactly where she had aimed it.
Neither of them spoke. A crow went over, complaining. In the white oaks at the Gap, small birds had begun, and the sun came over the ridge and lit the frost to a million tiny lamps.
“I told Odell four words,” Silas said finally. “In the box.”
“Which four?”
“I should have come.”
“Is it true?”
“Yes.”
“Is it all of it?”
He didn’t answer, and she nodded as if he had.
“A half-truth’s a lie wearing a clean shirt, hon. Odell let it by. The Hollow won’t.” She wiped her face with the heel of her hand, briskly, like a woman wiping a counter, and the old crisp Dovie came back into her spine. “Sit. You can be angry sitting down. I’ll teach you to call.”
He sat.
“You’ll have four staves by the time you stand at the Lip, if you go on to Rena Lyle at the Sink,” she said. “Four lays your rope down about three stands. No farther.”
She held up one dry finger. “And you don’t throw it. That’s the mistake. Folks think a calling is a shout, and they holler into the dark till they’re hoarse. You lay it down. Like a rope. One line, long and low and even, so the one down there can take hold of it, and then you give them the next. You’ve got to be patient as a fence post. They’ll climb on your voice, or they won’t climb.”
“And the closing verse? Wyatt wrote one.”
“The caller needs a closing verse. The old one’s been lost a hundred years. Your brother made you a new one, which is the cleverest and most foolish thing I ever heard.” She laid her hand flat on the rock. “It’s got a hole at the end like all of them. And what goes in it is the thing you hid.”
“I know.”
“You don’t. Not yet.” She squinted at the Hollow. “I’m going to tell you what happens if you put a lie there, and then I’ll never mention it again, because it’s no use scaring a boy who has to sing.”
She opened her mouth and sang one note.
It was not a note. It was a gate dragged through gravel, a long, dry, tuneless scrape with no pitch in it at all, and every crow in the white oaks went up into the sky at once, shouting.
The sound died away. Dovie closed her mouth, and the rock was quiet, and the frost smoked, and she folded both hands on the head of her cane.
“I was a singer once,” she said. “Ruth was good. I was better. That’s what a lie in a blank takes, hon. And that’s the lucky kind.”

