By dusk on Sunday the frost had come back to the Lip as if it had never left, and thirty-one people stood on the cold grass round the cairn with their breath going up in the lantern light.
Silas counted them, out of habit. Dovie at the first stone with her cane. Wyatt, in his borrowed suit coat, a little behind her. Dale Pruitt with the green ledger in its pillowcase, and Marian with her map, and Cade and Everett and Rena in a folding chair with her oxygen purring. June stood beside the gate with a casserole nobody had asked for. Pearline had come with her hymnbook, and Vance and Annie Harlan beside her, and Fee Sutter, in her barn coat and rubber boots, with Jody carrying her stool. Toby stood at the edge of the light with the fiddle under his chin and did not play.
At the end, up the Gap Road in the last blue light, Marian carried a kitchen chair, and behind her walked a thin woman in a black cardigan with a pencil behind her ear. She set the chair down at the far side of the lantern, and sat, and clicked a small steel counter once.
"Thirty-one," said Opie Rudd. "And one who isn't here."
"Where do you want us?" said Dale.
"Where you stand. I'm only the count."
Dovie stepped to the first stone, which was worn like a spoon, and laid her cane across it. She had taken the wax out of her ears at the first frost of November, and she had not put it back. Her face in the light was very white and very young. She tilted her head to listen, and for a moment nothing came up from the dark, and then, from a long way down, so faint it was almost a thought, there came a sound like a girl clearing her throat.
"Hello, Dove."
"Hello, Ruth." Dovie's voice did not shake. "I brought them. All of them. I'm sorry it took so long."
"I'm busy," said the voice, tired and dry and a little amused. "Somebody has to be at the top of the bottom. But I heard you were coming. Is it a big crowd?"
"There's a woman with a casserole."
"Oh, good," said Ruth Rankin. "I'll hold the door."
Dovie put one hand over her mouth, and took it away, and straightened. "You start it," she said. "It's yours. I want the whole county to hear."
Silas had the notebook open. He held the pencil in a hand that did not shake. He had been afraid, for a week, that he would not be able to write at all, and now, with the lantern on the page, it came as easily as breathing.
From the ninth stand, plain and a little hoarse, in a hill voice he had last heard on the coldest night of his life, Ruth sang.
I'll sit while the light is low.
It went up out of the Hollow slowly, like a bubble through water, and the frost on the lip grass shivered as it passed. Nobody moved. When it was over there was a hush, and into the hush Fee Sutter put down her cup of cider, and stood, and folded her work-roughened hands in front of her.
"I don't hold with an audience," she said. "But it's my mother's. I'll do it for her."
I'll keep the kettle and the door.
It was the plainest sound he had ever heard. It fell into the place Ruth's line had left as if it had been cut to fit, and he saw Jody, behind her, put a fist to his mouth. Beside the cairn, Annie Harlan took a long breath. She looked at her father. Then she closed her eyes, and sang, in a low clear kitchen voice, without any show at all.
I'll lift the lamp when the night is long.
The lantern flame leaned. It did not go out. It leaned toward the Hollow like a candle in a draft, and held, and the whole frost-ring seemed to take one deep slow breath. From somewhere far below, a long way past the ninth stand, past the place where any sound ought to carry, something answered. It was not a voice. It was a kind of warmth coming up the stair.
"That's three," said Wyatt softly.
"That's three." Silas wrote. "One more."
Opie Rudd had not moved. She sat in her kitchen chair with her hands in her lap, a thin straight figure in black, in the full light of the lantern, with the counter silent beside her. She looked as though she had been carved there. She had on her face the expression of a woman at a window, waiting for a vehicle to come up a long road.
"I have kept this for fifty-five years," she said. "I want it noted that I've never sung it. Not once. Not to the stone, not to the creek. I was afraid if I did, it would stop being the only thing I had."
"You don't have to," said Silas.
"I do. I said I would." She took the pencil from behind her ear, and held it a moment, and put it back. She stood.
She sang it unaccompanied, in a tiny, cracked, perfectly true voice, like a wire. She stood very straight and sang it to the dark, and there was in it every night of the booth, and the kerosene, and the tin soup, and the long thin tally of the counting.
And I will count you, and count you more.
Then there was a silence that went on and on.
It was not an ordinary silence. The frost had stopped forming. The lantern had stopped ticking. Nobody breathed. Silas stood with his pencil lifted over the last line, and understood that a very long time ago somebody had made a ballad and left a blank in it, and that every blank in that ballad had been a door, and that this was the last door of them all.
"The blank," said Opie. She said it in her ordinary dry voice, and it shook. "I said I'd tell you. It's the true thing that the one who goes says to the one at the bottom. It's the only blank in the ballad that's never been answered. And the stave can't be sung from the top, Silas. It can't. Not one word of it. We've said the lines. We've put them in a row. But it has to be begun from underneath."
"Who goes?" said Dovie.
"I don't choose."
"But you know."
"I count." Opie's pale eyes went round the circle, from face to face, and she did not stop on any of them. "I only know it can't be someone already held. It can't be someone called. It has to be somebody who's free to go, and who chooses it, with nobody coming after. It's not a rope. It's a beginning." She hesitated. "You'll know it when you feel it."
"Feel what?" said Wyatt.
He did not need an answer. They all felt it.
It began very quietly, as a lean. It was in the ground, a kind of slope, as though the whole of the Lip had tilted by a hair, and every standing body on it swayed a fraction toward the hole in the hill. The lantern flame bent. The frost on the grass crept downward toward the first stone, in a thin white fan. Silas felt his own weight go forward onto the balls of his feet, and he took a step to catch himself, and found that he had taken it onto the first stone.
It was warm through his boots. It was warmer than it had ever been.
"Silas," said Wyatt.
"I'm not doing it."
"I know."
"I'm not going. I'm standing here. It's just the stone."
"Then step back."
He tried. He had never in his life been so frightened, nor so completely, absurdly calm. He knew what it was. It was the oldest thing he knew, a pull, a pressure at the back of the knees, the long slow beckoning of a road. It was not a call. It had no voice in it. It only leaned, patiently and without malice, in the dark, toward the one person on that hill who had ever walked eleven hundred miles in the wrong direction and might, just possibly, know how to walk one in the right one.
His foot would not move.
"Somebody has to go down," said Opie Rudd, very low, "and start it. And it cannot be somebody who is already held."
Everyone looked at Silas. And Silas, standing on the warm stone in the lantern light with a pencil in his hand and his brother's fingers closing on his sleeve, looked down at his own boots, and saw that they were glowing.

