Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 49

The Key

By Tuesday the class had a smell.

It was not a bad one. It was wool and warm tea and boot polish and, from the corner where Mr. Fenn sat with his sleeves rolled, a clean sharp tang of leather dressing, and it met Gareth at the door of the community room at ten to seven like a hand on his sleeve. He stood on the threshold with his bag and breathed it in. He thought that a man could do worse than be met by that, after the week he had had.

The sign had been mended. Someone, Pip he suspected, had rewritten it in thick black marker on a fresh sheet and pinned it up with four drawing pins, and under THE TEACHER CAN SAY HOLD she had added, in smaller and more anxious letters, *and so can you*. He decided not to ask.

Eight places, eight lamps. Seven students and Orrin at the end of the long table with his left hand flat on a swatch of felt, and in the back row, in her good green scarf and with her phone face down, Rena.

She had not said she would come. She had texted on Monday, *Is class on?*, and he had said yes, and she had written, *Then I might be a back row*, and nothing more.

She had her own work. She had a timetable to publish by Thursday, and a clerk who had gone off sick, and she had made it plain, over the phone and over soup and in the careful way she folded her coat, that she was a friend who came when she could and did not come when she could not. He had come to find that restful. It was like having a window that opened.

“Evening,” she said, as he went by.

“Evening.”

“You look like a man who ate a sandwich standing up.”

“Over a bin.”

“Well, don’t tell me about it till after.” She turned her phone over, looked at it, and turned it back. “Teach.”

---

He taught.

It was the third of the four, and it was the one he had dreaded, because the first had been an event and the second a relief, and the third was only work.

He had no speech. He had the six steps on the board in Orrin’s tall draftsman’s capitals, and a tray of old scrap from the bottom of the bag, and the fact that eight people had given up a Tuesday evening and forty-five dollars a head to learn how to hand a tool across a table, and meant to be taught it.

It was Mr. Fenn who made it good.

He had brought the brogue back. It stood on the table under the lamp, on a folded cloth, in its beautiful brown with the cracked welt, and it had a new welt on it. It was not finished, but it was whole. It had been put right. The old line of stitching ran round the edge of the sole in a long unbroken curve, the holes the same, the spacing the same, with no sign that any hand had been there but the first.

“I went in from the back,” said Mr. Fenn. “On the left. You said.”

“I did.”

“It came out as sweet as a nut. I’d been pulling at the wrong end for a week, you see. A man who’s right-handed will start from the front and pull toward himself, because it’s what his arm likes. It wants to go the other way.” He turned the shoe. “He was left-handed. I could see where his thumb had pressed. I did it the way he’d have done it. I felt a bit of a fraud.”

“Why?”

“Because it was good work and it wasn’t mine.” He said it simply. “But I thought afterward, there are two sorts of fraud. There’s the man who puts his name on another man’s shoe, and there’s the man who puts the shoe right, and says whose it is. I’d like to be the second.” He looked up, and went a little pink. “That’s your sixth step, isn’t it. I think. Say who it belongs to now.”

Nobody spoke. Gareth saw Orrin look down at the felt. He saw Rena, in the back, stop with her pencil in her hand.

“Yes,” he said. “That’s the sixth step.”

“Well, I thought I’d say it.”

“I’m glad you did.”

He put the shoe back on the cloth, very gently, and found that he was looking not at it but at the tall window beyond, which showed him only his own face and the strip light, and the rain starting up again over the car park, in the dark.

---

He did not hold, that night. Nobody did.

It was only afterward, with the chairs stacked and the urn drained and the last of the students gone in a rattle of umbrellas, that Rena came up the room with her coat over her arm. She stopped by the table, and looked at him in her level way, a short gray-haired woman of forty-five who had given a great deal of her life to making buses arrive when they said they would.

“Dwayne’s put you off the bay,” she said.

“How did you know?”

“Della told me. She’s very good at telling me nothing and then telling me exactly that.” A dry look. “I’m not going to ask. I told you in the autumn, you’d tell me and I’d listen, and I’d go home. I’m still keeping to that.”

“I know.”

“I only wanted to say that Saturday I’ve the afternoon free, and I’m going to the market, and I’ll be at the soup place at one. It isn’t an offer to fight anybody.” She put on the coat. “It’s an offer of soup.”

“I’d like that.”

“Then it’s done,” said Rena, and went out through the swinging door, with her bag on her shoulder and her phone in her hand, into the wet and the dark. He stood and watched it close behind her.

He thought, quite suddenly, that it was a long time since he had been looked after by somebody who did not want to be thanked.

---

The call came on Wednesday, at a quarter to eight, as before.

He was ready for it. He had the beans on, and the notebook open, and the pen. He picked up on the second ring and said, “Tamsin?” and heard her draw breath on the other end, in a sound that was almost a laugh.

“It’s very unnerving to be known so soon.”

“Is something wrong?”

“Not yet.” She was talking quickly, and a little low, in the voice of a woman who has told herself several times in the last day that she will be sensible. “I’ll say it all at once. I’ve had a parcel. It came on Monday, through the door, while I was out at the museum store. It wasn’t posted. It had no stamp. It was just on the mat, in a padded bag, with the look of having been set down by a walker.”

He sat down.

“Did you see anyone?”

“I’ve a neighbor, Mrs. Orme, who sits in her front window like a cat. She says there was nobody. She says it was there at three o’clock, and wasn’t at two.”

A pause. “I didn’t open it at first. I picked it up with a tea towel. I’m not a fool, Mr. Noll. I read your letter four times. I put it on the kitchen table and I looked at it for an hour, and then I put on the rubber gloves I use for the dye and I opened it with a knife.”

“What was in it?”

“A key.”

---

She told him in good order, because she was a woman who had spent thirty years describing the state of other people’s seams.

It was a brass key, small, of the sort that goes in a padlock, and about two inches long. It had a round bow, rubbed bright, and a bit with two teeth cut square. It was fresh. She could see the burr on the edge where the cutter had been, and a bright line at the base of the bow, where it had been filed. It had been threaded through the bow with a cardboard tag on a loop of thread.

“What does the tag say?”

“A three.”

He shut his eyes.

“It’s in pencil. A figure three.” She said it dryly. “I’m not a handwriting person. But it’s got a flat top, and it’s very neat. And there’s a note.”

“Can you read it?”

“I’ve read it forty times. I’ll read it to you.” Paper moved. “*Dear Ms. Rowe. A small keepsake for Mr. Noll, with thanks for your discretion. It was only ever a loan. Please see that he has it, as I would not like it to go astray. Yours faithfully.* There’s no name. Not even a squiggle. It’s on the machine, the same typed paper as before.”

“It’s addressed to you, and meant for me.”

“It’s *routed through* me. That’s what I hated.” Her voice shook, for the first time, and she steadied it. “He knew where I live. He knew I’d write to you. He knew you’d write to me. It is clever, Mr. Noll, in a horrid way. I’m not frightened, I think. I’ve got a very sharp knife and a neighbor with eyes. But I’m angry. I’d like you to know that I’m angry.”

“I’m sorry.”

“It’s not yours to be sorry for.” A breath. “There’s one more thing. I did something stupid.”

---

“I picked it up,” she said. “Once. With the gloves on. I put it on my palm, to weigh it, because it looked so ordinary. It was warm.”

He did not speak.

“I thought it was the radiator. I’d put it down on the shelf above the radiator by mistake. But I moved it, and it stayed warm. It was warm like something that’s been held.” She stopped. “And my hand came out.”

“Your right hand.”

“Flat. In front of me. I was standing in my kitchen with a key lying on it and my hand held out, and it wasn’t *giving* me the key, Mr. Noll, it was holding it out. It was offering it. Like a child with a toy. To the empty room.”

Her voice had gone very small. “It was the same as before. Exactly the same. I put it down on the table and I stood there with my hand shaking, and the cat, who’s never done it in her life, got up and walked out through the flap, and I haven’t seen her since.”

“Tamsin.”

“I’m all right. I only want you to know it. The key is the same sort of thing, whatever it is. It’s been in somebody’s hand a very long time. It has the habit.” She laughed, thinly. “I’ve put it in a biscuit tin, with a tea towel. I’m sending it tomorrow, to the address you gave me, in a padded bag, by recorded delivery. I’ll pay for it. And then I’m going to my sister’s.”

“Your sister’s.”

“In Dunmere. For a fortnight. I’ve a deadline for the museum store, a waistcoat, which I’ll take in a box, and I’ll sew in her spare room.” She said it briskly. “I’m not hiding. I just think if somebody’s been walking to my door, I’d like not to be at it.”

“I’ll pay for the post.”

“You will not. You’ll pay nothing.” It was the voice that had been trained on a great many assistants. “It’s the only decent thing I’ve done in twenty-two years, and I’d like to do it on my own.”

---

The key reached Della on Friday, at ten past eleven, in a padded bag, with a green recorded-delivery label and the sender’s name in the dry blue-black hand. She signed for it, and she laid it, unopened, in the steel cabinet beside the half-square, and she rang Hale.

Hale came at four that afternoon, and Gareth was there, in his coat, off the early shift, with a cup of Bev’s tea in one hand and his stomach full of nothing. Orrin had come up on the train from Larch End, a pale and silent presence in the doorway, at a cost of twenty-two dollars that nobody had mentioned.

Hale put on the cotton gloves, with some dignity, and sat at the kitchen table under the strip light with the key in a tray in front of him. He had brought a loupe of his own, a better one than Orrin’s, with a little lamp on it, and he turned the key over under it for four full minutes, in a silence that nobody dared to break.

“Thirty,” he said at last.

“I beg your pardon?”

“It’s thirty dollars for the look. Not the key. I’m not touching the key.” He took off the loupe. “I’ll say what it is. It’s a padlock key, a brass-body padlock, a four-pin, and an old make. They stopped making that pattern a long time ago. There are a great many about, and they all take a key like this, and every one of them is a different cut.”

“Which cut?”

“I’m coming to it.” He laid a small steel gauge on the tray. “Two teeth, square, cut to depths four and two on my gauge. That’s an unusual combination, as combinations go. I’d put it at one lock in a couple of thousand.”

“Can you say what it opens?”

“I can say it *doesn’t* open the cupboard in Pellam Street. That was a lever. It’s no use there. It’s for a padlock.” He raised his eyes, which were very level. “Have you got a brass padlock, Mr. Noll? A four-pin, with a long shackle, bought in Bellwether, I’d say, by the look of the stamp, from a hardware man who closed his doors long since?”

“On the blanket chest,” said Gareth.

---

He said it slowly. It came to him out of a long way off, like a bus coming up a hill in fog. The chest in the attic. The long camphor-smelling box under the skylight, with the lid that stuck, and the old brass padlock, stiff with age, that he had put on it himself, one autumn, to keep the moth out of the blankets.

That was where the ledger had lived. Where he had found the PIECES book. Where, on a Thursday not long ago, with the time sent to Della from the steel door, he had lifted the lid and taken out a book with a leaf cut from it, at a neat angle, by a razor.

He had thought, at the time, that the cut was old.

“There are two keys,” he said. “I’ve one on my ring. The other’s in the shop drawer, under the till. I’ve never lent either.”

“Where are they?”

“I’ll check.”

He checked, at once, in front of them, with his hands not entirely steady. The ring came out of his coat. The brass key was on it between the shop door and the bicycle lock, worn dull, and it was the right key; he knew its shape in his thumb. He rang the shop on the mobile, and the part-time boy who sometimes watched the door on Saturdays, a lad called Tolly, answered on the fifth ring and was told to look in the drawer.

“It’s here, Mr. Noll. It’s under the till, in the envelope. It says CHEST on it.”

“Is it bright, or dull?”

“It’s dull. It’s got fluff on it.” A pause. “Why? Has somebody died?”

“No, Tolly. Thank you.”

He rang off. He sat back, and said, to the table, in a low voice, “It’s a third.”

“A third key,” said Hale.

“The chest has two. Somebody’s cut another.”

“From a mold. From an impression. They’d have had to have it in their hand for a few minutes. They’d have to have known where the lock was.” Hale closed his bag. His face was no more expressive than it had been in the hall. “That’s why I said the thirty. It’s one thing to open a cupboard that somebody’s oiled. It’s another to have a key to a man’s own chest.”

“How long’s it been cut?”

“The burr’s new. I’d say the year, no longer.” He looked at Gareth directly. “I’ll say one more thing, and then I’ll go home to my tea. The key’s got a second hole in the bow. Not the one for the tag. A small one, filed in. For a bit of thread.”

“There’s a thread on it?”

“There was. It’s gone. It was tied on and pulled off. You can see the polish on the edge of the hole where it ran.” He rose. “Somebody had it on a thread for a good while. Then they took the thread off to put on the tag. That’s as far as I go.”

Nobody spoke. Orrin was staring at the tray. Della had stopped writing.

“What color was the thread?” said Gareth.

“I couldn’t tell you. There’s no fiber.” Hale looked, for the first time, uncertain. “But there’s a stain on the brass, in the groove. Very faint. I thought it was verdigris, and it isn’t. It’s dye.”

“What color?”

“Blue,” said Hale.

---

They stood for some time in the warm kitchen, with the rain on the window and the key on its tray, and no one touched it. Then Della took the lid of the biscuit tin, which had come with it in the parcel, and set it carefully over the brass, as one covers a bird.

“I’m logging it,” she said. “Time, weight, color, the lot. And I’m saying, for the record, what I think, since I’m not to make speeches. Somebody has been in your attic, Gareth. Or somebody’s had a long look at a key.”

“The chest was locked when I got there.”

“I know. They’d have locked it again.” She wrote. “That’s what they do. They go in, and they put it back. They oil the lock. They set the alarm. It’s their style. It’s very tidy, and very quiet, and it leaves us with nothing but a feeling.”

“And a key.”

“And a key, on a plate, with a note. It’s an invitation.” She laid down the pen. “You’ve been asked, quite nicely, to come back to your own shop and open your own chest, with a third key on a blue thread. I think it would be a very bad idea to do it alone.”

“I won’t.”

“Then say when,” said Della. “And say who comes.”

He looked at his hand. It was lying flat on the oilcloth, palm up, in the middle of the table, the fingers not quite closing, the thumb a little drawn. He had not put it there. It lay in a pool of the strip light, open and still. He did not move it. He turned the other, the good one, over beside it, so that the two lay together, as for a coin.

“Saturday,” he said. “At nine. Orrin, and Hale, and you. And I’d like Rena to be told.”

“Told, not asked.”

“Told, not asked.” He looked at the tin, and the lid, and the little rim of brass that showed beneath. “I think that’s what I’d want, if it were me. To be told.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!