By Tuesday the trouble had reached three people, and Gareth had stopped pretending that it was a matter of a glove.
Casper rang at noon. He did not say hello. He said, “It’s back,” and then, after a moment, in the voice of a man reading from a card, “It started again at five this morning. In bed. I said it, what you said. I said it to the ceiling, out loud, like a fool. It didn’t care.”
“It stopped for me.”
“I know it stopped for you.” The road noise was gone; he was in the depot yard, among the parked buses, and his voice came back from the walls. “It stops when you say it and it goes on when you’ve gone. My wife says I’m to see the doctor. I’ve told her it’s a trapped nerve and I’m going Thursday. I’m not going Thursday. What’s Thursday?”
“I don’t know yet.”
“You said Thursday to someone.” He was quiet. “Della said it, on the phone yesterday. *Whatever’s on Thursday, he’ll tell you.* I’ve a notion I’d like to be told before, and not after.”
“You’ll be told,” said Gareth. “First. I promise.” And he heard the word go out, and thought of the sheet of log paper in his pocket that said *I won’t promise anything I can’t keep*, and wished it back.
Della took the news standing, with her pen in her hand, and wrote it up. She had a method for whatever frightened her. She made them tidy. She put the time at the top and the source in the margin, and under *Observed* she wrote *Third person whose tapping the teacher can stop*, and under *Cause* she wrote nothing, and underlined the nothing.
“It’s catching,” said Orrin.
“It might be catching. It might be that Casper was in the room in the autumn, and it’s always been there, and your telling the truth to a glove woke it.” She shut the book. “I’d like you to think about the second. It doesn’t make it worse. It makes it older.”
“I can’t tell which is better.”
“Neither can I,” said Della. “I was only trying.”
---
They slept at the hall that night. Nobody had asked it, and nobody had refused.
Della brought two camp beds out of the cupboard behind the stage, and Orrin put his against the wall by the radiator, and Gareth took the cot in the office with the brace on his left hand and the door ajar. June had gone to bed at nine, leaving the feeds up on the old laptop in the kitchen with the sound turned down to a thread. The kettle was on its stand.
The right glove lay in its cabinet, with the lid propped, and its logger made a tiny dry tick every four seconds.
At the top of the hall the clock said eleven. Gareth lay on his back and listened to the pipes.
He did not sleep, quite. It was a kind of floating, in which he could hear every sound in the building and none of them was a threat. At one he heard Orrin get up and cross to the kitchen, and look at the screen, and come back. At two he heard the heating stop. And at some time after that, in the gray hour when the mind is at its poorest, he dreamed of a cup.
It was a green enamel cup, with a chip at the rim, set down on a scarred table by a hand he could not see. The handle was turned toward him. He reached for it, and the hand withdrew, and when he looked up the chair at his left was empty and warm.
“Gareth.”
It was Orrin, bending over him with the torch cupped in his fingers. The luminous face of the clock behind him said four minutes past three.
“What?”
“June’s on. She says come.”
---
She was in her dressing gown with her hair in a rope. On the screen the attic was gray and still, and a thin line of numbers ran along the foot of the picture: the camera’s clock, and the temperature, and the little bright digit that was the rest.
“I wasn’t asleep,” June said. “I’m never properly asleep. I get up at three and check the feeds, because I’m a person who maintains lifts. I wasn’t looking for this.” She had a mug in both hands, and she did not drink from it. “Look at the clock at the bottom.”
Gareth looked. The numbers ticked along. 03:06:57. 03:06:58. 03:06:59. And then they went, in a single step, to 03:07:04.
“It’s lost five seconds.”
“Four. The picture froze, then jumped. A fault, you’d say. A wobble in the line. But I’ve been watching this feed for four days, and it’s never jumped once.” She breathed out through her nose. “And the glove in the picture isn’t where it was.”
He leaned in. It was the same chest, with the same blanket and the same dark leather lying across the hollow where the strip had been, and the logger on its string. The glove lay on its back with the fingers loosely curled. It looked, in the gray light, exactly as it had looked for four days.
“It’s the same.”
“It’s the same *position*. It’s not the same *glove*. The cuff.” She had the earlier frame at the side, a still, and she laid the two side by side. “Look at the cuff.”
In the earlier picture, the cuff was folded back and the little tape lay open to the lens, with the dark flat-topped three plain upon it. In the later picture the three was still there. But across the tape, at a slant, from the top left to the bottom right, ran a single thin bright line.
“It’s crossed something out,” said Orrin.
“Hollis!” Della was on the phone. She had been on the phone since three-oh-five; he saw the cord of it trailing across the table. “Hollis, wake up. No. Don’t go in alone. Bring Mags if she’ll come. I’ll ring Hale. Meet at the shop door, all of you, in forty minutes. I’m coming, and Gareth, and Orrin. June stays on the hall camera, and she’s the one who tells us if the right glove so much as shifts. Bring the big torch.”
“It’s ten past three in the morning,” said Hollis, in a drowned voice.
“Yes. I’m sorry. Bring your boots.”
---
It was a clear cold night, with a thin moon in the west and ice already stiffening the puddles. They went in Orrin’s car, three of them silent in the dark, and the road to Bellwether Junction was empty as a closed book. At a quarter past four Hale was waiting under the street lamp at the shop door in his anorak and slippers with a lock-bag over his shoulder, looking like a man who had been woken by an alarm in his own head.
“Forty dollars,” he said, before anyone spoke. “I’m sorry to say it, I’d not mention it at this hour, but it’s the rate for a night. I’ve told your Della. I’ll put it on the sheet.”
“It’s on the sheet,” said Della.
“Then let’s see what we’ve got.”
He went over his own work first. That was the part that Gareth remembered afterward, among the rest: the locksmith, in his slippers, kneeling on the pavement, with a hand lamp and a loupe, going over the plate of the shop door with his thumb as a doctor goes over a collarbone. He took six minutes. At the end he said, “No scratches. No picks. The pins are seated where I put them. It’s been opened with the key, or it’s not been opened.”
“Whose key?”
“Mine’s in my pocket. Della’s is in hers.” He looked up. “Your third’s with me, in the safe at the lock shop, and so’s the spare. I’d stake my business.”
They went up the stairs in a line, Hale and Hollis ahead, the others behind. At the top the attic door was shut, and the seal on it, a strip of white tape across the frame with Della’s initials and the time, was whole. Hollis lifted it with a pair of tweezers, and Della wrote it down, and Hale put the key in the lock and turned it, and the door opened on the cold.
The room was as they had left it. The rope lay in its orange ring. The chest stood open under the skylight, which was shut and latched from within, and the case below it was shut with its seals whole. Mags’s camera on its tripod showed its small red light. The thermometer on its string said nineteen, and the room’s said eight, and the floor was dusty, and in the dust were their own boots from Saturday, and nobody else’s.
“Ring’s whole,” said Hollis, in a voice that tried to be steady. “I’ve been round it twice. No one’s crossed.”
The glove lay in the chest on the blanket, with its fingers curled loosely.
Gareth knelt. Nobody told him to. He put his knees on the boards at the rope, and held out his bad hand, and said, “Light, please.”
Hollis gave it. A hard white beam on the cuff.
It was as the picture had shown. The tape lay open, whipped to the seam in blue, and on the tape the pencil: the flat-topped three, and under it, *for G.N.*, in the faint groove, and under that, in the same fine hard stroke, *Not yet*.
And through *Not yet*, once, from the upper left to the lower right, ran a line.
It was not a scribble. It was ruled, almost, a quick clean cut, made by someone who knew how a word should be struck: one stroke, so that the words below it could still be read, and no one could mistake them for a slip. The graphite shone a little. It was fresh. It had not had time to dull.
“Who did that?” said Orrin.
“Nobody,” said Gareth, “that I can see.”
---
It was Della who found the pencil.
She had gone round the rope a third time, on her knees, with her torch held flat along the boards, as one looks for a dropped ring. She said, “Wait,” in a small voice, and stopped.
It was in the glove.
It lay in the hollow of the palm, where the glove curled round it, a short brown stub of wood no longer than a thumb, with a point at one end and a flat bare end at the other, and a brass ferrule gone green with age. It had been put there carefully. It was held, not dropped. The fingers closed over it a quarter of an inch, in the way a hand will close over a coin when it has been given one and means to keep it.
“Don’t touch it,” said Hale.
“I wasn’t going to.”
“I’m only saying it. A man gets used to saying it.” He drew a breath. “Is it warm?”
“It’s reading nineteen on the glove,” said Hollis. “I don’t know what it’s reading on the pencil.”
“Mags,” said Della. “Macro. And a tape, for scale.”
Mags had been silent on the stairs, with the camera hung round her neck and a face the color of milk. She did not say a word. She laid a small white ruler along the boards, and brought the lens down, and for a long minute there was no sound in the attic but the faint crick of her knees and the patient tick of the logger.
“It’s HB,” she said. “On the flat, in gold. I can see the stamp.” She shifted. “*County Adult Education.* Then a word I can’t read. A number.”
“County Adult Education,” said Orrin.
“It’s the name printed on the old class sheets,” said Della. “Mags, go back. The shape of the point.”
The picture came up on the little screen, huge and gray and grainy, and they leaned in around it, six heads and a crooked torch, the way people lean in over a dying fire.
The pencil had been sharpened, but not in a sharpener, and not in the common way, with one long spiral cut that leaves a smooth cone. It had been pared. It had three flat, slightly dished faces, laid one beside another, running up to the lead, each one made with a single pull of a blade, and where the faces met there were three fine ridges, as straight as the edges of a book.
Gareth knew it as one knows one’s own signature.
“I did that,” he said.
Nobody spoke.
“I mean I do that. I always have. It’s a cobbler’s habit, you pare the point on a pencil with the knife the way you pare a welt, three pulls, flat. I did it every night, in the class, to keep a point on my notes. The other students had their sharpeners.” He heard his own voice go thin.
“I cut a point on my pencil every week, in front of her. I can see it. A cup with the handle turned, and a pair of hands in a lap, and me with the knife.”
“And she watched.”
“She watched. She learned it. She learned everything. The tap, and the rest, and the pencil.” He sat back, with his bad hand on his knee, and the cold boards pressed through his trousers. “Whoever wrote that line learned how to sharpen a pencil from watching me do it. And they used it to cross out *Not yet*.”
“It could be a coincidence.”
“It could be.”
“It might not be a she,” said Orrin gently.
“No.” He looked at the three smooth faces on the pencil, shining in the light. “No. It might not.”
---
They stayed until the window turned gray. It was not a time for conclusions, and nobody had any.
Hale checked the locks again, and the seals, and the skylight catch, and the beams, and the stair, and wrote that all of it was whole. Hollis sat on the top step with the camera and went through the four seconds a hundred times, frame by frame, to prove to himself that there was nothing in them, and there was nothing in them: a blur, and a jump, and a glove that had been one way and was another.
June, on the telephone, was careful and exact. At the moment of the gap, she said, the glove’s pass count had been at the end of a rest. The rest had been sixteen minutes and some seconds, and had not been interrupted. The passes had not stopped. They simply had not begun. It had been lying still, in its own rest, and it had written in the rest.
“I’d not say *written*,” said Della.
“I’d not say anything,” said June. “I’m a woman with a graph.”
The costs they added at six, over bad coffee in a paper cup from the all-night kiosk at the junction, because it was what they did.
Hale’s night rate, forty. A second camera on a second stand, because the first had lied for four seconds and nobody could trust it again: sixty for the hire, to be added to the rest, since June would not hear of continuing without. Gareth’s share was thirty-five. He did the sum on the back of his hand and found that it left him with a hundred and ten dollars in the world until Friday, and did not say so.
“We leave the pencil?” said Orrin.
“It stays where it is. In witness. Hale’s sealing it with the glove.” Della stood, with her knees cracking. “I’ll write the whole thing to the principal tonight, in a letter that Ms. Lisle can carry, and I’ll say that we’ve seen it, and we’d like to be spoken to, and not written on.”
“You’ll write to it?”
“I’ll write to *someone*.” She put the notebook in her bag. “I’m not having letters left on my glove, Mr. Noll. I’m a custodian. If anyone leaves a message in my building, I reply.”
The sun was coming up as they went down the stairs, a red line behind the roofs of the sidings, the first light on the ice. Gareth, last in the line, stopped at the turn of the stair, with his hand on the rail.
He did not know why. He only knew that he did not want to go down. He listened. It was an old house, and it ticked and settled in the dawn, and from the attic above him, through the closed door and the seal and the cold, there came no sound at all.
And then, at the end of a silence he could not have measured, upon the wood of the rail beneath his bare right hand, something that was not his hand and was not the house tapped once, lightly, from the other side.
He counted. He could not help it.
It tapped four times. And rested.
And it did not begin again. It simply waited, in the gray, with the patience of something that has been told to, until Gareth Noll, a man of fifty-two with a hurt thumb, drew breath to answer.

