An empty chair is a rope. Granny had said it, at twenty-five, to a man in a pewter coat, and I had heard it said from a reel of dying tape, and until Pruett Kane said *I do not want anything at all* I had thought it was an expression.
It is not an expression. I watched it become a fact in about forty seconds.
“Mr. Kane,” said Mr. Penn.
The fair young man had been standing by the register with his cold and his folder and his plastic sleeve, a few paces from the place where he had been made to give up Granny’s plate. He had gone, since the tape, the color of oatmeal. Now he came two steps forward with the stiff, anxious, well-meaning walk of the very junior, and he held out a sheet of paper in both hands.
“I am only a clerk, sir,” said Penn. “I want to be clear. I haven’t any instructions. It’s only that I have here, as a convenience, a short form of assignment. For the lease. It would simplify matters before the hearing. If Mr. Kane felt, that is, if it were his *wish*—”
“I haven’t a wish,” said Kane, quite kindly. “I told you.”
“No, sir. I understand. Then I suppose it would hardly matter.”
I saw it go along the counter. It went like a draft under a door. *It would hardly matter.* Of course it would hardly matter. A man who wanted nothing would sign anything; there was no harm in a signature; it would save everybody a good deal of trouble. I felt my own head nodding. I felt, in my mouth, the faint dry taste of agreement, and I do not know what would have happened if I had not remembered what Granny said about taste.
“Mr. Penn,” I said. “Have you eaten?”
“I beg your pardon?”
“You took no pie. You’ve had nothing since you got in. I’d like you to sit down at that stool and not say another word until you’ve had a cup of tea.” I took the paper out of his hand, gently, as one takes a knife from a child. It was only paper, and it weighed a good deal. “That’s not a request, Mr. Penn. It’s Table.”
He sat. I heard him say, to the zinc, in a tone of faint, helpless indignation, “I was *going* to sit.”
“I know you were.”
I laid the lease form face down on the counter. I put the saltshaker on top of it. And I stood there with my hands flat on either side of it, and I thought: *Four minutes.* I had held that room for four minutes with a plate of biscuits and a spilled stack of saucers. I could not do it again.
---
“Ruth,” I said.
“Here, honey.”
She had come out of the kitchen without my seeing her, the way she always did. She stood at the pass-through in her flour-white apron with a dish towel over one shoulder, a short, broad, worn woman with her gray hair in a net, and she looked at me with the faint wry patience of someone who has been waiting twenty minutes for you to remember she exists.
“What day is it?”
“Thursday.”
“The date.”
“The eighth.” Ruth’s eyes were steady. “Why?”
“Granny’s Thursday pie.” I could hardly get the words out. “The one that went to Salem. The lemon.”
It is odd what a face does. Hers did nothing for a moment. Then something went across it, very slowly, as a cloud-shadow goes across a field, and she took the towel off her shoulder and held it in both hands.
“I wondered when you’d ask,” said Ruth.
“You’ve been—”
“Every Thursday. Since the spring your grandmother died, when I took over the book.” She said it in her usual flat, practical tone, but her mouth was not steady. “I’d have said, if anyone had asked me. Nobody asked. She had it down in the book before I came. *E.K. Lemon. Thurs.* Back to 1991. Thirty-odd years. I thought, well, it isn’t my place to stop.”
“Ellen Kane,” I said.
“I’d never met her until the last winter.” She smoothed the towel. “She was in a place on Commercial Street, Salem, a nice place, with a bay window. I took the pie in on a Thursday, and she looked at it and said, *Is that Hollis’s?*
And I said yes. And she said, *I always knew it was Hollis’s. She put a little lemon zest in the crust where you’d never see it.*” Ruth’s voice broke, very slightly, and righted itself. “She died in January. Four years ago. The Thursday before, I took her the pie.”
“Did she eat it?”
“She ate a slice. She ate every one.”
---
The diner had gone quiet in the way a church goes quiet, with a thousand small sounds under it. Someone’s spoon. The faint steady tick of Old Betsy’s violet flame. I put both hands on the counter.
“Mr. Ardent,” I said.
He had not moved from stool twelve. He had finished his biscuits. The plate sat in front of him with the fork laid across it, turned down, and the napkin folded beside it in a perfect square.
“Yes, Ms. Brandt.”
“You told this room, an hour ago, that Ellen Kane never sat at this counter. That she was never fed here. That you had inquired.”
“I did.”
“Did you inquire at Commercial Street?”
“I inquired of the register,” said Ardent. “It is the Table’s own form. It records what is served *at the counter.* Mrs. Kane was never at the counter.”
“She was fed.”
“At a bay window, in a nursing home, in another town.”
“By a pie that came out of my kitchen.” I took a breath. “I know the form, Mr. Ardent. You said it yourself: the Table feeds, and what it feeds, it knows. It’s your whole case. The Table knows its own. Well, my grandmother carried that pie out of this diner in her own hands for thirty years, and then Ruth did, and you can’t tell me it wasn’t the Table’s food. It had the sign over the door on the box.”
“I would not tell you that.”
“Then it fed her.”
“It did.” He said it very slowly, and I could see that it cost him nothing, and that it hurt him anyway. “I did not know of it. I should have. It is the sort of thing I ought to have found. I took the register as the record. I have, in my life, been faithful to a number of records.”
“Mr. Ardent,” said the judge, from stool one.
“Yes, sir.”
“Am I to understand that your side concedes that the name *Kane* on the plate on that stool refers, in the language of this establishment, to two persons who have been fed?”
“I believe I must, sir. As a matter of the form.”
“Then I suggest,” said Tate, with the voice of a man who is eating a conscience instead of a sandwich, “that somebody explain to me what the form does about it.”
---
“It’s a seat with two keys,” said Verna.
She had pushed herself up on her stick. She stood at the end of the counter with her scarf over one shoulder, like a small stern ancient sparrow, and the pack along the wall turned its heads to her as one. She was one of the last people alive who had sat at the Table in 1974, and she was enjoying herself, in a terrible, tight, shaking way, like a woman who is being proved right at her own funeral.
“I told you it was a Table, Hollis. I told you in the cellar. It isn’t a room. Thomas used to say a room was only the place where the Table happened to be standing.” She rapped the stick once on the tile. “A plate carried out of this door is the Table.
A pie in a box in a bus on the Salem road is the Table. A bowl of soup left on a porch is the Table, if it was meant, and it’s been known to feed a man who never came inside in his life.”
“What of it?” said Maude.
“The plate says *Kane.* It doesn’t say which.” She turned her face to Ardent. “Julian Ardent made a very nice point this morning, that the Table won’t ask. Well, that cuts both ways. The Table won’t ask which. It’ll take both. *Both* Kanes have been fed. There’s a plate on that stool with a name on it, and two people answering.”
“One of whom is dead,” said Penn, faintly, from his stool.
“Is that in the form?”
“I—no. I don’t believe it is.”
“No,” said Verna, with deep satisfaction. “It’s never mattered. The Fourteenth was held for fifty years in a dead man’s name. A name’s a name. The seat will hear Pruett. And it will hear Ellen. And what it’ll do, when it hears two people who both have a claim and one of them is *silent,* is wait.”
“For what?”
“For them to agree.” The old woman looked at Kane. Her face had gone soft. “It’s what a seat with two keys does. It can’t turn on one. You’d need both.”
---
“That is a very beautiful theory,” said Ardent. “It is not a plan. A dead woman has no voice.”
“She has a pie,” said Ruth.
I turned.
Ruth had stepped back into the kitchen. She came out, now, in the plain brown boots she wore for the walk-in, with something in both hands. It was a pie. It was a whole one, a good eight inches across, in a tin that had been dented and straightened a hundred times.
The top was a soft pale yellow with a tremble at the center, and the crust was cut in the old Table way, a star at the middle and a ring of little crescents round the edge.
I could not smell it. I knew what I would smell. Lemon, and butter, and the faint high note of zest under it, hidden, like a sin.
“I bake Wednesday for Thursday,” said Ruth, “and I never took it off the list. It was on the rack when you came in, honey. I did it before dawn. I said to myself, well, I’ll put it by, and Lord knows somebody will eat it.” She set it down on the counter in front of stool fourteen, in front of Kane, and she did not look at him. “I’d have thrown it out Saturday. I always do. I tell the girls it’s for the pack.”
“I can’t taste it,” said Kane.
“I know.”
“I couldn’t tell you whether it was a good pie.”
“Nobody’s asking you to tell me. I know it’s a good pie.” She wiped her hands on the towel and she took a clean plate from the rack and a knife from the drawer. “I’m asking you to cut it.”
---
I had not known that he had a way of looking at a pie.
He took the knife from her, and he stood a moment on his feet beside the stool with the blade in his hand, a thin gray man in a waistcoat with a grief he had carried too long. He set the point in the center of the star. And he leaned on it.
The crust spoke. It was a small dry crackling sound, like frost on a window or a bird in a hedge, and every person in that room heard it. It was the sound of a crust that had been made right: the lard cut cold into the flour, the water added by the spoon, the rolling pin turned a quarter at each stroke.
Kane’s hand stopped.
“She did it with a knife,” he said.
“I’m sorry?”
“My mother. She never used a cutter. She had a paring knife, with a black handle, that was her mother’s, and she used to cut the little crescents round the edge freehand, one at a time, so that no two of them were the same.” His voice was very low.
It was the voice of a man reading something off the inside of his own eyelids. “I stood on a chair by the counter in the evenings, in the house on Maple Street, and I was not allowed to touch the knife. I used to count them. There were eleven. There were always eleven. I thought that was how many a pie had.”
“There are eleven here,” said Ruth.
“Are there?”
“Count.”
He counted. His lips moved. I saw him go round the edge of the pie, one crescent at a time, with the tip of the knife, and I saw him come to the end, and his mouth shape the word, and no sound come.
“I did not ask you to cut me a piece,” said Kane.
“No.”
“I find that I want to give her one.”
It came out of him very quietly, in the plainest voice I had ever heard him use, and I heard the whole diner take a breath. Down at the end of the counter my mother had put her good hand over her mouth.
*There,* I thought. *There it is.*
It was a want. It was the first he’d had in half an hour, and it had come up out of a pie crust like a minnow from a pond: not a roof, not a sum, not a stone, but a boy on a chair, counting.
---
I did not need Granny’s ledger to tell me what came next.
I took a clean plate and I set it on the zinc, at the end of the counter, in front of the empty place on Kane’s right. It was no stool I had ever fed. It was only a patch of zinc, an arm’s length from stool fourteen, with a clean napkin and a fork, and a glass of water I poured myself.
“Cut it for her, Mr. Kane,” I said. “Set it down. Say what you want.”
“I want my mother to have eaten here.”
“Say it to the seat.”
He drew in a long breath. He laid the first piece of pie on the plate, a clean, quivering wedge with a crescent on its crust. He set the plate down. He stood with both hands on the back of stool fourteen, and he did not sit.
“I should like,” said Pruett Kane, in a perfectly steady voice, to the empty place at the counter, “for Ellen Kane to have a slice of lemon pie at the Table, and for it to be eaten.”
I have thought a great deal about what I expected.
Nothing happened. That was the first thing. There was no flash. There was no wind. For a long, long count of five, there was only a pie on a plate, steaming faintly into the cold air of the diner, and a man with his head bowed.
And then, down the whole length of the counter, as I had seen it go before and never in this direction, the heads turned. They turned from Kane. They turned to the place at his right. Maude, and Emmett, and Verna on her stick, and ninety wolves, and a judge with a thermos: all of them, with that quiet vegetable pivot, as plants turn from one window to another.
On the plate, the fork moved.
I do not say that it rose. I did not see anybody touch it. It was a fork on a plate, and it was a fork on a plate, and then in the half-second between those two it was a fork *turned down* across the plate, with the tines against the china, in the old signal that means *I have had enough, thank you,* and the pie was gone.
It was not a mess. It was not a crumb. The plate was clean. It shone. It might have been licked.
“There,” said Verna, in the smallest voice I ever heard from her. “That’s a guest.”
---
Kane put one hand out and touched the rim of the plate.
I watched his face. I could not have helped it. It did what it had not done in two weeks of breakfasts or two hours of orders: it fell to pieces, quietly, from the inside out. He did not make a sound. The tears ran down his cheeks and into his collar and he did not wipe them, and he stood with his fingers on the china as if it were still warm.
Then he laughed, once, a short, cracked, wondering breath.
“Lemon,” said Kane.
“Mr. Kane?”
“I can taste it.” He put the back of his wrist against his mouth. “That is a quite extraordinary thing, Hollis. I have just tasted a lemon pie. It is on my tongue. I think it has been there since I said what I wanted.” He lifted his head.
He looked at me. “I believe that it was the only thing I was ever very sure of. And the seat has taken it, and it has been *granted.* I think it is the first thing in a very long time that I have been given by being asked.”
“Is the want spent?”
“I believe so. I believe it’s quite used up. I do not think I could want it again.” He smiled, wet-eyed. “I find that I do not mind.”
“Then what does the seat do now?” said Judge Tate.
“It waits,” said Verna. “It’s got two names and one of them’s been served. It won’t do anything for Pruett that Ellen didn’t have the chance to say first. It’ll listen for her.” She lowered herself onto the nearest stool, one painful inch at a time. “We’ve all the time in the world, Judge. A dead woman’s very patient.”
“Mr. Kane may leave,” said Tate, slowly, “if he wishes.”
“I’ll sit,” said Kane. “If I may. I find the stool is not so cold.”
---
I thought it was done.
I mean that I let myself think so, for exactly the length of time it took Ruth to put the rest of the pie under the glass dome. I let a breath go. My legs wanted to shake.
Beside me, Dane had finally, finally, stepped off the mat: he had crossed the black tile in four strides, as soon as the string went slack, and he was holding my wrist in his burnt hand. I felt the heat of him, and the cold of his bandage, and I thought, *We’ll be all right.*
“Is the door open?” I said.
“Try it.”
“I’m afraid to.”
“Try it, Hollis.”
I went to it. The bolt came back in my fingers under its own weight, smoothly, without a word. The door swung an inch on its hinge and a draft of cold air came in. Outside on the pavement, I saw the dark shape of Lyle Gorman, and the brown cruiser, and a morning gone suddenly bright with snow-light.
“Ms. Brandt.”
It was Deputy Okonkwo. He was standing at the end of the passage with his hat in his hand. He was the tall one, the calm one, the one who wrote things down. I had sent him at 11:50 to the cellar door to confirm that the county’s seal was intact. He had come back as he went, in his slow, even, patient walk, and I did not like his face at all.
“Is the seal whole?”
“It’s whole, ma’am. Not a tear in it.” He cleared his throat. “I’ve checked it twice. The tape’s whole and the door’s locked, and the padlock’s the one the clerk put on. But I looked at the lock plate, the way you showed me. The little brass wheel.”
“What does it read?”
“It reads five.”
I did not understand him. Then I did.
I had put my own hand on that wheel in the dark at 3:09 that morning, with Strand crying in the pantry and the Westclox ticking in the safe. It had said *three.* I had written it in pencil on the back of my hand, and the smudge was still there under my sleeve.
“It was three at three this morning,” I said.
“It was three at half past nine, ma’am, when I came on. I wrote it in my book.” Okonkwo turned the page of the little notebook in his hand so I could see it. “Somebody’s been in that cellar twice since.”
“When?”
“That I can’t tell you. The wheel doesn’t keep a clock. But I’d say this, Ms. Brandt, with all respect.” He looked past me, down the length of the diner, at the ninety faces, at the judge with his thermos, at the long gray figure on stool twelve with the clean plate in front of him.
“Since a quarter to eleven, nobody has been out of that room. I’ve been watching the door myself. If it was after the bolt went home, the one who opened that cellar is standing in here with us.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!