At 6:22 p.m., I explain to Greg that my grandmother is not a reliable source of consent.
“She’ll ask whether you’re hungry. If you say no, she assumes you misunderstood.”
We walk up Ledge Road under the blue evening light. He has left his duffel at the Pemberton Arms and changed absolutely nothing about himself. I have changed earrings, shoes, and the seating plan twice. His binder is folded back to the page headed FAMILY SENSITIVITIES.
“This section is longer than the section about you,” he says.
“My family has more sensitivities than I have accomplishments.”
He looks at me. “You run a business.”
“We are saving that phrase for when somebody calls it a hobby.”
I stop beside the buckets of sweet peppers outside Rosa’s cottage. Yellow siding. Blue door. The kitchen window open because Abuela believes a house should smell like dinner before anybody enters it.
“Rules. Do not discuss income, politics, or my former fiancé. We met at a fundraiser. You had spinach in your teeth. I told you. You admired my directness.”
“I can see how that would happen.”
“If Carmen asks about children, say we believe every family has its own timeline.”
“Does Greg have opinions?”
“Not without written authorization.”
He closes the binder, smiling a little.
“Understood.”
Rosa opens the door before I knock. She wears a flowered apron over a navy dress and carries a wooden spoon, making her the only person here with an undisputed chain of command.
She looks at him. For a moment her face goes completely still. Then she taps the spoon against her palm.
“Open.”
“Abuela,” I say. “He isn’t a casserole.”
Greg opens his mouth.
She peers at his teeth. He permits it with astonishing dignity.
“Good molars,” she says. “You may keep him.”
“Thank you for the provisional license.”
He bends to kiss her cheek.
“Bendición.”
“Dios te bendiga, flaco.”
They separate before I can decide why that exchange feels rehearsed by somebody other than me. I put a mental star beside it. Then Rosa pulls me inside by the wrist and tells me to wash my hands.
The long table reaches from the kitchen into the front room. Rafa has brought folding chairs from the Grange. Carmen rearranges them because she objects to a card table’s implication that she is an overflow guest. Tomás fills water glasses with the focus of a man defusing something.
Greg automatically pulls out the chair at Rosa’s right.
“Not there,” I say. “That’s where Abuela puts whoever she’s feeding the most.”
“Then let him sit,” Rosa says. “Look at him.”
I look. It creates more problems than it solves.
Dinner consists of rice, beans, pernil, salad, and a bowl of lobster meat delivered by a neighbor who insists it does not count as a birthday present because the birthday is Sunday. By 6:37, Carmen has extracted Greg’s alleged dental specialty and is beginning to describe a concern near her lower left gum.
“He doesn’t consult at dinner,” I say.
“I’m not asking for a consultation. I’m just asking.”
Greg lowers his fork.
“I’d be worried about giving an opinion without the right examination.”
“A protocol,” I add.
“Exactly.” He turns to Carmen. “Have you been able to see someone?”
It is masterful. He has offered concern without a diagnosis. Carmen tells him about the receptionist at her dental office. Within a minute he has become a better listener than her actual dentist, a profession I worry we may have to abandon before dessert.
Rafa pushes the lobster toward him.
My stomach drops.
Page five. Greg is allergic to shellfish. I included this because I thought it made him vivid. This was before I remembered what people eat on an island.
“Greg can’t have lobster,” I say.
His eyes meet mine. I can see him locating page five in his memory.
“I’m very happy with the pork.”
“Does it swell your throat?” Carmen asks. “My friend Estelle’s nephew carries an injector.”
“We keep a protocol,” Greg says.
“Separate serving utensils,” I supply, taking the lobster spoon away from the rice.
Rosa watches this procedure without expression. Then she gives him another spoonful of pernil large enough to constitute a promise.
“Tell us about the music,” Carmen says. “Marisol says you play.”
“Cello,” he answers.
“That thing’s bigger than my first apartment,” Rafa says.
“Mine too,” Greg says.
His timing is excellent. Rafa laughs. Even I laugh, and I am privately trying to determine whether he has memorized the entire binder on a twelve-minute walk.
“Where did you learn?” I ask.
“School. An enthusiastic teacher. A lack of athletic promise.”
“You should hear our Marnie with a microphone,” Rosa says. “She can make a room behave.”
“I believe that.”
The look he gives me is entirely unnecessary for a dinner scene. I drink water and rearrange my napkin.
Rafa asks about my business. I give the answer I give prospective clients: busy, exciting, selective about new work. It is technically true if you define selective as nobody currently selecting me.
“She paid for all this,” Carmen says, waving at the family. “Rooms, tent, food. I told her we can contribute.”
“It’s Abuela’s eightieth.”
“And I told you eighty is a birthday, not a ransom,” Rosa says.
Greg’s fork pauses. He looks at me, and for the first time all evening I don’t want him paying such close attention.
I ask Tomás about the kayak season. He launches gratefully into a description of two mainland visitors who believed paddles were included only at an extra charge. By the time he finishes, Carmen is laughing hard enough to need a napkin, and I have escaped a financial disclosure.
Then Rafa takes an envelope from his back pocket.
“Speaking of charges.”
The table quiets.
It is the Trust letter. Sixty-one families own their houses on land they do not own. Their ground leases expire December thirty-first. The letter says the future terms are under review. It does not say whether Rosa will be allowed to stay in the kitchen where she is currently feeding all of us.
“I wrote again,” Rafa says. “Got a lawyer back. Not a person. A lawyer.”
“Rafa,” Rosa says.
“Mira. It’s her birthday. Where do they think she’s supposed to go?”
Greg’s hand tightens around his water glass. A pale strip appears across his knuckles.
“Who handles the letters?” he asks.
“Boy named Whitfield, somewhere in a city. He’s never hungry. Those boys never are.”
“He might not know what the letters say,” I offer, because I plan events and therefore have a pathological attachment to salvage.
“His name’s on them.” Rafa taps the envelope. “Good enough for me.”
Greg looks down at the table. Rosa puts food on his plate as though the conversation has made him thinner.
I should be relieved. The family adores him. He handles Carmen, listens to Rafa, and has not once checked the time. He is better at being Greg than the man I designed.
When Rosa drops her napkin, he retrieves it before anybody notices. There is nobody watching for whom he needs to do that.
Instead, I notice how carefully he sets his glass back in its damp ring.
Rafa lifts his drink.
“To the Whitfields. May the tide take them.”
Greg raises his water and says, “Salud.”

