At 9:12 on Monday morning, in a corridor of the Cumberland County courthouse that smells of floor wax and wet wool, Dalton Pruitt looks at me over the rim of a paper cup and says, “Ms. Delgado. You look rested.”
“I look like I took three ferries and a bus.”
“Rested is what I said.” He is thinner than he was a fortnight ago, and better dressed, in a navy suit with the faintest pinstripe and a tie the color of a lifeboat. He smiles with the lower half of his face. “There’s nothing personal in it. I’d say so, but you’ve read my texts.”
“You’ll see them in evidence on the third.”
“Am I?” He drinks. “I’d be careful about that, if I were you. A boy of nineteen with a grudge and a phone is not a witness. He’s a liability for the man who hired him.” He tips the cup toward me, a toast. “Good luck with Judge Ouellette. She’s very fond of paper.”
He walks away down the corridor. I watch the back of the lifeboat tie until the doors take it.
“Don’t,” says Ines, at my shoulder.
“I wasn’t going to.”
“You were composing a sentence. I could hear the commas.” She hands me a coffee that tastes of cardboard. “It’s a hearing about a restraining order, not about Dalton. Judges are allergic to being told what a case is about. We do it by a small, boring route, one fact at a time, and we let her get there first.”
Behind her, on a bench under a portrait of a judge who died in 1911, Beckett is sitting with his hands loosely clasped and his eyes closed, and Charles, beside him, is not holding a cello case. He is holding his hat. It is the first time in a month I’ve seen him with his hands full of nothing.
---
At 9:34 the courtroom is much smaller than I want it to be, and the judge much larger.
Justice Thelma Ouellette is a broad, gray, unhurried woman in her sixties, with half-moon glasses and a voice that has the dry patience of a person who has heard every explanation for lateness invented by man. She sits under the seal of the State of Maine, with a stack of paper at her left hand as high as a loaf of bread, and she says, “I’ve read everything. I read it twice. I’d like counsel to understand I do not need it read to me a third time.”
Across the aisle, at the plaintiff’s table, sits Calvin Marsh, for Halvorsen: fifty, silver, in a charcoal suit that costs more than my first car, with a younger associate on either side of him like bookends. Simone is not at that table. She is in the gallery, at the far end of the third row, in a plain gray coat, with her hands in her lap. She does not look at me. She does not look at anything.
At the end of the other table, Dalton has taken a chair as Holdings’ designee. He has taken it so easily that I almost think he belongs in it.
“Mr. Marsh,” says the judge. “Your motion.”
Marsh rises. He is beautiful at it. He speaks for eleven minutes in a low, even, reasonable voice, and by the end of the eleventh I’d have sworn that the entire dispute was an act of unreasonable persistence by a man who failed to deliver a piece of paper to a porch on time. The clause required personal delivery. Personal delivery occurred at 4:58.
The closing occurred at 4:30. Between the two is a gap of twenty-eight minutes, he says, in which a purchaser acted in perfect good faith on a waiver executed by the holders of record. “My client paid thirty-eight million six hundred thousand dollars,” he says. “It is entitled to the shares.”
“The waiver,” says the judge.
“Executed electronically on the nineteenth, Your Honor. Exhibit D.”
“I’ve seen Exhibit D.” She looks over her glasses. “Ms. Barlow.”
Ines stands. She doesn’t pick up a single paper. This is, I have come to understand, her loudest possible gesture.
“Your Honor, I’ll be brief, because the Court has read it. The waiver is a forgery. Not a disputed signature. A forgery, by a person who was not Mr. Whitfield, who typed his name into a box at 11:46 on the nineteenth of November, on a laptop connected to a router at the Pemberton Mercantile, at the instruction of an individual sitting at the Holdings table.
“And the same name was typed a second time for the Whitfield Family Trust, on the claim that one trustee can sign alone.” She doesn’t turn around.
“I have the instruction in writing. I have the person who followed it, who’s cooperating. And I have the platform’s own audit log, which Halvorsen’s own deal lead was good enough to retrieve.”
“Objection,” says Marsh. “That’s a characterization.”
“It’s a log,” says the judge. “Sit down, Mr. Marsh. I’ll tell you when it’s a characterization.”
He sits. In the third row, Simone does not move.
---
At 10:41 I am sworn, and a thing happens to my hands that has never happened before in my entire career: they decide they don’t belong to me.
I have stood up in front of ballrooms. I have walked a bride and a groom and three hundred guests through a catastrophic power cut with a flashlight and a joke. I know what to do with an audience. This is not an audience. This is a woman in half-moon glasses who has asked me, in a level voice, to state my name and my occupation and who says, when I’ve done it, “You may sit, Ms. Delgado. You’re not in trouble. You’ll be asked about a Friday.”
Ines walks me through it. The porch, the clipboard, Margaret writing the time on the back of the page. Four fifty-eight. It takes four minutes, and the judge writes through all of it, and when Ines says, “No further questions,” I think for one brief and stupid second that it’s over.
Marsh stands. He buttons his jacket.
“Ms. Delgado,” he says, pleasantly. “Good morning. You’re a wedding planner.”
“I’m the principal of Delgado & Company. Yes.”
“You have a financial relationship with Mr. Whitfield.”
“I have a promissory note. Four percent, simple. It was disclosed on Friday.”
“By the Courier. After a reporter found it.”
“By the Courier. After I asked her to print it, at 7:30 that morning.” I keep my hands flat. “I’d rather you hear it from me.”
“I’m sure you would.” He smiles. “You also have a personal relationship with Mr. Whitfield. That’s been described in print, I believe, as ‘in love.’”
“That’s my phrase.”
“You’re a party with an interest.”
“I’m a party with an interest,” I say. “I’m in love with him. I’d say so under oath, and I just have.”
There’s a small, bright sound in the room. It takes me a moment to place it. It’s someone in the gallery, in the last row, trying very hard not to laugh. It’s a laugh I know. It’s Dale Cobb, who has come to Portland on a Monday in a clean flannel shirt to sit at the back, and is now covering his entire face with a hat.
“I’d also like to ask,” says Marsh, with the faintest chill, “about the nature of the relationship’s origin.”
“Go ahead.”
“You hired Mr. Whitfield. Under an assumed name. To pose as your boyfriend, at a family reunion, for the purpose of deceiving your grandmother and a hundred others.”
“I hired a man for a weekend,” I say. “I told him to say his name was Greg. I told my family and my town that he was mine, and I let it run for longer than I should have, because I was afraid of being the one who needed anyone. That’s what I did. It was the worst-judged contract of my career. It’s also the only one I’ve never once regretted.”
“So you’re a person who lies to people she loves.”
“I was. I told every one of them when I stopped.” I turn my head slightly. “I’d be glad to supply the recording.”
Marsh pauses. He had not expected the recording. In the front row, Ines’s pencil moves, once, a quarter-inch.
“Your Honor,” Marsh says, “I’ll withdraw the question.”
“I thought you might,” says the judge. “Mr. Marsh, sit down. Ms. Delgado, you’re excused. That is the first time this morning I have not wanted a witness to stop talking.”
---
At 12:03 Justice Ouellette reads the order from the bench, without once looking down.
It is shorter than anyone would have predicted. The motion for a declaration is denied without prejudice, pending evidence. The shares of the Aldous block are to remain registered in the name of Margaret Aldous, and neither party may vote, pledge or transfer them, and Mr. Hurley is to hold the purchase proceeds in escrow in his firm’s account, in a pot that nobody is to touch, until the Court has heard evidence.
A neutral, a special master, a retired justice named Alden Frye, is appointed to inspect the records of Whitfield Holdings, including its minute book, its signing-platform account, its president’s office and its safe, on Wednesday, the twenty-sixth of November, at ten o’clock in the morning, with every party entitled to attend.
“An evidentiary hearing on the validity of the waiver and the notice will be held on Wednesday the third of December,” she says. “Ms. Barlow.”
“Your Honor.”
“Mr. Whitfield asked for relief. It’s not free. A bond in the sum of four hundred thousand dollars, filed within forty-eight hours, to cover the harm to the plaintiff if I’m wrong.”
“Understood.”
“Mr. Marsh. You’ll have your day.” She takes her glasses off. “For the benefit of the corporate designee at the end of the defendant’s table: I will be reading very carefully, this week and next, who in this case has been prepared to sign things for someone else.”
At the end of the table, Dalton’s smile develops, around the edges, a faint and fascinating crack.
---
At 12:41, on the courthouse steps, in a gust that tries to take the papers from our hands, Simone Achterberg catches up with us with her coat unbuttoned and a phone in her fist.
“Halvorsen’s general counsel,” she says. “A text. Four minutes ago.” She reads it in a very even voice. “’Effective immediately you are removed from the Whitfield matter and placed on administrative leave pending review of your communications with opposing parties.’”
“Simone.”
“I expected it. I walked into a room full of lawyers with a folder in my arms and then I stood in the back of a courtroom for three hours, wearing my own face.” She folds the phone away. “I’ve been with that firm eleven years. I was going to be a partner in the spring.”
“You can’t be put on leave for telling the truth.”
“I can be put on leave for how I told it, to whom, and in what order. That’s the part nobody warns you about.” She looks, for a moment, almost young. “I want to testify on the third. I’ll need a lawyer who isn’t theirs.”
“Ines,” I say.
“I’d be delighted to be your lawyer’s lawyer,” says Ines, who has materialized at my elbow. “It makes a very small conflict. I’ll see that it’s well documented.”
“Thank you.” Simone pulls her coat tight. “I said I had two prices on Friday. I find there’s a third.”
“What is it?”
“I’d like to learn what it feels like to have nobody expect anything of me for a month.” She laughs, once, a startled, unprofessional sound. “I’ve been told it’s restful.”
Beckett, who has been silent the whole time, takes a step forward and says, in his careful way, “Ms. Achterberg. May I offer you something, if you’d like it, and say no if you don’t?”
“That depends on the something.”
“A room at Rosa’s. For as long as the month takes. Not on my money. On hers. She’s already made up the bed.”
Simone looks from him to me, and then, past us, at the long gray harbor of Portland, where a ferry is pulling out toward some other island with its lights on in the noon. She opens her mouth and, for the first time since I’ve known her, doesn’t know what a professional would say.
“I’ll bring my own coffee,” she says.
---
At 2:20, in an office with a framed bond rating on the wall, the Pleiades Surety Company’s regional manager, a gentle bald man named Mr. Lyman, explains to us that a four hundred thousand dollar court bond in forty-eight hours requires collateral he can touch.
“Cash, or a lien on something with a verified value. A security. A deed.” He spreads his hands. “Mr. Whitfield, your assets are rather heavily pledged. I’ve looked.”
“They are,” says Beckett. He has the look of a man who’s already done the arithmetic and doesn’t want to hear it in company.
“I’d pledge my house,” I say.
“You rent your house,” says Tomás, on the speaker, from the Mercantile. “I’ve seen the lease.”
“I’d pledge the business.”
“You owe forty-one thousand three hundred on the business, Marnie, and the lender is the man sitting in the room. The bank has the rest.”
“Then someone give me a better idea.”
Nobody speaks. And then Charles Whitfield, who has spent the whole meeting sitting on a leather chair too low for him, with his hands in his lap and his hat on his knee, says: “Mr. Lyman, do you accept instruments?”
“Instruments?”
“A violin, say. A cello. There are certain standard forms of insurance on antique instruments, are there not? I understand a gentleman in your trade will take a Stradivari for a vault.”
I understand what he’s saying a half second before anyone else, and I feel it in my own stomach, like a floor dropping out of a ferry.
“Dad,” says Beckett. “No.”
“It’s a Bavarian cello, made in Mittenwald, about 1790. It was appraised in 2019 at four hundred and ten thousand dollars.” Charles says it as though he were reading the weather. “It’s the only thing I own outright, my son. It was never in the company, never in the Trust, never pledged. I bought it with the first money I earned outside my father’s office. I’ve played it every day for thirty-four years except one, a Tuesday in 2011, when I couldn’t.”
“You’ll have to hand it over.”
“For thirty days. That covers the hearing.”
“It would live in a vault. Climate-controlled. You couldn’t touch it.”
“I understand what that means, Mr. Lyman,” says Charles.
He doesn’t look at his son. He doesn’t look at me. He looks at the case at his feet, which has been, I now remember, at his feet or in his arms or on his knees in every room I’ve seen him in for twenty-two days, a dark and scuffed and patient thing like a dog that has never once been asked to leave. He puts a hand on the handle.
“I asked first,” he says, softly. “Note that this time I did.”
---
At 3:55 on the pavement outside the Pleiades Surety Company, with an empty hand and a damp wind blowing newspapers down Congress Street, Charles Whitfield stands for a long time, and then says, almost to himself, “I’ve never been without it in a train station.”
Nobody says anything. There’s nothing to say. Ines finds something to do with her phone. Beckett stands beside his father with his shoulders square and his hands, for once, entirely at his sides, because he knows better than to take hold of him. It is the oldest rule in the family: the only thing worse than help is help that arrives before it’s been asked.
My phone buzzes. A number I don’t know.
It’s a woman’s voice, low and quick, from a hospital corridor or a stairwell, with an echo behind it. “Ms. Delgado. You’ve only heard me say ‘present.’ I was at the back of the courtroom.”
“Lorna Veit?”
“I haven’t got long. My sister’s in the next room with a hip.” A breath. “That waiver. It had a little line at the bottom. ‘Acknowledged by Corporate Secretary L. Veit.’ I read it over Mr. Marsh’s shoulder in the corridor this morning.”
“Yes.”
“I never acknowledged it. I didn’t know it existed. And I’m Secretary of that company, and I always have been, and for the first time since 1999 I’d very much like someone to ask me what’s in my minute book.”
I look at Beckett. He is already looking at me, with his eyebrows raised, and I put the phone on speaker without being asked, which is something I’ve learned from him.
“Mrs. Veit,” says Beckett. His voice is entirely level. “May I ask you something? And please say no if you’d like.”
“You asked me for nothing once, Mr. Whitfield, except to listen to a recording,” says Lorna Veit. “I listened. I voted against your father anyway. I think it was the worst day of my life, and I’ve been to funerals.” A pause, and her voice turns small and dry and almost amused. “Come tonight. Bring crackers and no lawyers. I’ll make tea. I keep the book on paper.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!