My run of show for Monday the fifteenth of December has two lines at the top, and for the first time in my career I have written them in the same color of ink.
*9:00 Knox County Superior Court, Rockland. Kittiwake v. everyone.*
*10:00 Augusta, Office of the Treasurer. Marnie under oath.*
They are forty-seven minutes apart by road. Over the weekend, on a long call, with a map open on Priscilla’s laptop and Ines drawing arrows on a napkin beside me, it was decided that Augusta would not be moved. The deputy treasurer had already moved it once.
But Pell’s office allows a witness to testify by video, and a clerk in Rockland owes the court a favor, and so at 9:49 I am going to slide out of a courtroom and into a windowless room with a laptop and a very patient bailiff, and I am going to say, to a screen, whether I lied.
I have been practicing the answer for six weeks. I know it by heart. I’m still not sure I can say it without my voice doing something.
---
The weekend, in short, went like this.
Beckett read the receipt on Saturday morning at Rosa’s table, with his mother across from him and the coffee going cold, and then he read it again, and then he put it down and asked my grandmother what the blank was for.
Rosa dried her hands. She sat. She looked at the paper for a long time without touching it.
“I do not know,” she said. “I would like to say that I do. In April of 2009, when Ambrose gave me the list of names, he said a thing I did not understand. He said, *I’ve left a blank, Rosa. The one who comes after writes in it.* I thought he meant the line for the last name. The one he couldn’t say.”
She turned the receipt over, as if there might be something on the back. “The hundred and eleventh. Winnie’s grandmother. But maybe I was only hearing what I wanted. Maybe he meant more.”
“Maybe he meant the lease,” said Beckett.
“Maybe he meant both.” She pushed the strip back across the cloth. “It is a terrible thing, flaco, when dead men leave sentences and no footnotes.”
Vivian stayed through Sunday. She did not leave on the Saturday boat, as she’d said she would, or on the Sunday. When I asked Beckett on the pier whether he’d asked her to stay, he said, “I asked her what she wanted for breakfast. She said eggs. It’s a start.”
---
The Knox County courthouse is a brown brick building with a flagpole, a granite step worn into a shallow dish, and a metal detector that beeps at my tote bag every time, as though it has a grudge against Greg.
It’s 8:41. Priscilla Amadi is in the lobby in a charcoal suit with her hair pulled back so tightly she looks six inches taller. She hands me a coffee and a stapled sheet.
“Three things,” she says. “One. In Rockland you say nothing. If Justice Calloran looks at you, you look at me. Two. At 9:49 you walk, you don’t run, and Ines goes with you to the witness room. Three.” She lowers her voice. “In Augusta they will ask about Greg, and they will ask about Mr. Whitfield. Both. I want you to answer the second one before they finish the question.”
“I’m going to say yes.”
“I know. Say it fast.”
“Is it a problem? The two of us.”
“It’s a fact,” says Priscilla, “and a fact is only a problem when someone else gets to announce it.” She nods at the door. “Come on. Delphine Rourke is on the left, and she brought a very good suit.”
---
Justice Calloran is a thin, quick woman in her sixties with reading glasses on a beaded chain, and a way of holding a pen that suggests she has been waiting for someone to use a long word wrongly.
Delphine Rourke speaks first. She has the whole of her argument in a single binder with colored tabs, and she doesn’t open it.
She tells the court, in a low and courteous voice, that Kittiwake Harbor Homes LLC holds nine written assignment agreements with leaseholders on Pemberton Island; that the master lease, Section Nine, provides that the lessor’s consent to an assignment *shall not be unreasonably withheld*; that six refusals were delivered on the twelfth, each on Trust letterhead, each over the signature of a trustee who, she is careful to add, is also a party to a pending purchase of the same ground by the Trust’s own beneficiaries.
“We ask for declaratory relief, Your Honor. We ask the court to say what *unreasonable* means. In a world where a landlord may refuse consent in order to preserve a lever for his own sale, the leaseholders are not holders. They are hostages.”
It is a good speech. It is, I realize, exactly what I’d have said, in her chair, with her client.
---
Priscilla rises. She does not use the binder either.
“Your Honor,” she says, “my client’s refusals are reasons, and the reasons are in the record. Four of the six leaseholders are over seventy. Each was approached by a vendor who had access to a list assembled by a family member. Each was told that closing would occur in five days. Two of them were told they would forfeit a deposit they had already spent if they changed their minds. One was told, in writing, that her cooperation was *confidential.*”
“Kittiwake’s own agreement says that?” says Justice Calloran.
“Paragraph nine, Your Honor. I have a copy.” Priscilla hands it up. “The question isn’t what *unreasonable* means in the abstract. It’s whether a trustee acts unreasonably when he declines to approve a transaction that the seller herself, on being told the full story, is trying to unwind.”
The judge reads. The room gets very quiet. In the second row, I see Carmen, who has taken the day off and driven up from Worcester in the camel coat, sitting with her hands clasped around the strap of her purse. She’s looking straight ahead. She does not look at me, and I love her, and I have to look at the floor.
“Ms. Rourke,” says the judge, not looking up. “Is it your contention that Mrs. Ortiz was misled?”
“It’s my contention, Your Honor, that Mrs. Ortiz was offered a price.”
“That’s not what I asked.”
A pause. “No, Your Honor,” says Delphine Rourke. “It isn’t.”
---
Justice Calloran rules at 9:44. She does it from the bench, without an adjournment, in four sentences. She declines to grant expedited declaratory relief. She orders that the status quo be maintained on all nine lots until a full hearing on the eighth of January.
She orders that Kittiwake not communicate further with any of the six refusing leaseholders, directly or through a vendor, about assignment, forfeiture, or the existence of this action. She adds, to the room generally, that she is not in a position to say whether anyone behaved *well,* only whether the court should move quickly, and that it should not.
“Ms. Rourke,” she says. “Anything?”
Rourke has risen. She stands for a moment with one hand flat on the binder.
“Only that I’m obliged, Your Honor,” she says. “I’d like the record to note that I’ll lose well.”
“I’ll make a note.”
Someone, behind me, laughs, once, and stops. And Priscilla puts a hand on my sleeve, and says without moving her lips, “Nine forty-four. Go.”
---
The witness room is a windowless box with a laptop, a speakerphone, a ficus that has given up, and a bailiff named Mr. Ferreira who tells me he has sat in this chair for nineteen years and has never once seen the ficus die or recover.
Ines sits at my elbow with a legal pad. She has not said a word since we left the courtroom. She’s a quiet woman, with a long gray braid and a habit of turning her pen over and over like a worry bead. Now she slides a single sheet in front of me. It says, in her small clear hand: *Short. True. First.*
At 10:02 the screen comes to life. A conference room in Augusta. Deputy Treasurer Gail Pell at the head of a long table, with a stenographer and a cup of tea. Beside her, a man I don’t know: Holdings’ counsel, I’m told, a colleague of Marsh, because Marsh himself has been, in the phrase the firm used, *reassigned to other matters.* At the foot of the table, alone, a young lawyer in a blue suit named Lombard, who represents Dalton, who is not in the room.
“Ms. Delgado,” says Pell. “You’ve been sworn?”
“Yes.”
“Then let’s begin.”
---
It takes forty minutes. For thirty-five of them it is dull. They go through the reading of the Schedule, who held the notary stamp, who stood where, the order of names. I answer in short sentences. I remember Ines’s note.
At 10:41 the man from Holdings stands up.
“Ms. Delgado, I’d like to speak briefly about your credibility as a witness to the reading.” He is perhaps forty, careful, with the manner of a person who has been told to be fair and doesn’t enjoy it. “Is it true that, until November of this year, you told your family that you had a boyfriend named Greg?”
“Yes.”
“And that Greg did not exist?”
“He didn’t,” I say. “I invented him last November so my aunt would stop introducing me to men at funerals. I carried a binder about him. I lied to my grandmother for eleven months, and then I stopped.”
“And do you now, as you sit here, have a romantic relationship with Beckett Whitfield, the trustee?”
“Yes.” I say it before the end of the question, the way I was told to. “Since November. He’s the man who stepped off the ferry in place of an actor I’d hired. I’ve told every party to these proceedings, in writing, on the twelfth of December. I’m telling you again.”
There’s a very small silence. I can see Pell’s pen stop. I can see Lombard, at the end of the table, stare at the ceiling in what I think is admiration.
“Thank you,” says the man from Holdings. He looks down at his notes and I realize that he had a third question and that it was a good one, and that I’ve just taken it away from him. “No further questions.”
---
Pell rules at 11:20. It’s a short statement, delivered in the voice of a woman who has had to decide between two things she would rather not decide.
She finds that the Declaration of Trust, typed on a machine that Charles Whitfield happens to own and Ambrose Whitfield owned before him, speaks in plain terms. Payment was due on the reading of the Schedule *aloud, in full, in public, in Pemberton, by a family member, before a notary.* The Schedule was read aloud on the twelfth of November. In full, by the testimony of four hundred and six names and a notary’s jurat.
In public, in a hall of the Pemberton Grange with the doors open. By a member of the family, who is Beckett Whitfield’s family by birth and the workers’ by courtesy. Before a notary whose new commission began at midnight and whose seal is dated one minute later, and the office does not find that one minute is a defect.
“Mrs. Bray’s jurat stands,” says Pell. “The second seal, which I gather was offered by a Massachusetts notary as a precaution, adds nothing and subtracts nothing. As to the question of reversion, the Declaration provides that the fund reverts to Holdings only if neither of the two signers survives to see the Schedule read. Mr. Lund is alive and, I am told, delighted about it.”
A pause. “The claim of Whitfield Holdings is denied. The award of two million, forty-six thousand, one hundred and eighteen dollars and forty cents is released to the Summer Floor Fund, to be held by its trustee and disbursed according to the Declaration. Payment issues within thirty days.”
I realize I’m gripping the table. Ines has taken my hand under it, without looking at me, and I hold on like the child I apparently still am.
“Ms. Delgado,” says Pell, as the stenographer closes her machine. “One more thing, off the record.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“In thirty years, I’ve had a number of witnesses say they lied. Most of them said it last.” The faintest edge of a smile. “Go home.”
---
The clock in the Rockland lobby says 11:41, and I’m standing on the granite step with my face turned into the cold, when Beckett comes out of the courthouse with his hands in his pockets and stops beside me.
“Two million dollars,” he says.
“Two million forty-six.”
“I’m trying to say a sentence with a number in it, and I can’t.”
“Then don’t.” I lean against him. He puts an arm around my shoulders, openly, in front of the flagpole, and we stand for a minute and let the cold work on us. “It’s not the whole sum. It’s two-thirds of it. We still have Aldous. We still have the summer names. It’s not over.”
“I know.” He looks down at the red jacket, which is mine again and fits me, and says nothing about the cuffs. “How did it feel? Saying it?”
“I said *yes* about you before he finished the question. I think I broke the poor man.”
“You did.”
“I’m not sorry.” I look at him. “It’s going to be in the Courier, Beckett. All of it. The boyfriend who wasn’t. The boyfriend who was. They’ll put it on the front page with a picture.”
“Probably.”
“Does that bother you?”
He considers. “It bothers me that Greg got a better headline than I did,” he says, and I laugh so hard that the bailiff looks out of the lobby doors to check on us.
---
Carmen is waiting at the bottom of the step with her purse held in front of her in both hands. She has been crying, neatly, in the manner of a woman who has had a great deal of practice doing it without disturbing her mascara.
“You were very good,” she says to Priscilla, who has come out behind us. “Both of you. All of you. I don’t know what the word is for what I want to say.”
“You don’t have to say anything,” says Priscilla.
“I do. I’m the one on the list.” She turns to me. “Marnie. The judge said the six can’t be called. I’m one of the six. I wanted you to know that I’m not going to call them, either, the sixteen. I’m going to wait for them to call me, and I’m going to say whatever it is they want to hear, which is probably *I’m sorry,* and then I’m going to hang up and make a casserole.”
“That seems like a plan.”
“It’s the only one I’ve ever had,” says my aunt. She straightens my collar, the way she’s done since I was nine. “I’m just asking. Did you eat?”
“I had a coffee.”
“That is not a meal,” says Carmen, and takes my arm, and walks me toward the car.
---
It lands at 12:30, in the car, on the way to the Rockland ferry terminal. A text from Cass Dunleavy at the Courier, not a call, which I understand to be a courtesy.
*Hi Marnie. Story posts at 4. It’s straight. I have your testimony and Justice Calloran’s order. One more thing: I got a PDF this morning from a Halvorsen address, sent to what I think is every holder of Whitfield Holdings stock outside the family. Thirty-one people. It’s a tender offer. Twenty-five percent over the price on the table in November. Open until Jan 5. It’s two pages. Page two is about you.*
I hold the phone out to Beckett. He takes it at a red light on Main Street, and I watch him read page one with a face that gives away nothing, and then I watch him read what Cass has pasted of page two.
*Participating holders should consider the conflicts of interest raised by the sworn admission, on December 15, of the operating partner for the Island Transition Program, a sole proprietor with a personal relationship to the sitting trustee, who has previously admitted to the fabrication of a relationship in a matter before this family.*
The light turns green. Behind us someone taps a horn, politely, the way they do in Maine. Beckett doesn’t move.
“They had that this morning,” he says slowly. “Before you testified.”
“They knew what I’d say.”
“They knew you’d tell the truth.” He looks at me. And then, for the first time in the six weeks I’ve known him, I watch Beckett Whitfield’s expression go from stillness to something so cold and so clean that I understand why a room full of men with margin calls once stood when he came in. “Thirty-one cousins,” he says. “Thirty-one letters. Marnie, I think we’ve been fighting over a house, and they’ve been counting a company.”
The horn behind us goes again. I put my hand over his on the wheel, and he drives.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!