The roster took forty minutes to decide what to do with Corwin Pike, and thirty-five of them were spent on the question of whether he should be allowed to speak.
“He sat in my kitchen,” Leda said, “and said it all once. I’d like him to say it again, where you can see his face.”
That was how Corwin Pike came to stand in the old net loft at seven in the morning, in a borrowed oilskin that did not fit, with fifty-odd people looking at him the way you look at a wave you have decided to respect. He did not use notes.
He said the number forty-one. He said the number eleven. He said Dunmore Coastal and the first of the month, and when somebody at the back called out “And what about the ones you can’t pay for?” he said, “Then I can’t, and I’d rather you heard it from me than from a lawyer.”
Nobody clapped. Nobody shouted either. Leda counted that as a start.
Della asked the first real question. She asked it gently, with her cardigan still buttoned wrong. “If we supervise, and our report says a repair is bad, will you pay for the next one anyway?”
“I will pay in the order your report sets,” said Pike. “Until I can’t. When I can’t, you’ll be told the day I know.”
“In writing?”
“In writing, and a copy to every board.”
Nessa asked what happened if Dunmore bought him out. Pike said the offer was open for six days, and that he would not accept anything that voided a survey the cooperative had already done. Hobb’s cousin asked if that was a promise or a hope. Pike took a moment.
“A hope with my signature under it,” he said. “I know that’s thin. It’s what I have.”
They sent him out of the room to vote. It was the first thing Leda had seen the cooperative do that felt entirely like itself: a long, tired, unglamorous argument held in a room that smelled of fish, and settled by people raising their hands.
The motion that carried was Nessa’s, and Della read it aloud for the record. *The roster will supervise outlet surveys and repairs on request, at the order we set. No release is given or implied. Every finding is published. The firm pays what it can, as it can, and tells us the day it cannot. Any member may refuse a dive, and no refusal is held against them.*
It passed by thirty-one to nine, with eleven people looking at their boots.
“I voted against,” Ro said, from the wall, once the hands were down. “Not because he’s lying. Because I think he’s honest, and I think that’s more dangerous.”
“Why?”
“An honest man who’s frightened will do the right thing until he can’t.” She shrugged. “I’d like to be standing somewhere solid when that day comes.”
Leda thought about that all the way to the quay.
---
Bram’s answer was waiting for her there.
He sat on an upturned crate by the *Marten’s* gangplank with Sera beside him, her arms crossed in the stern posture of a woman who has been argued with for a night. Della stood at the other side, looking at the sky.
“We’ve both said yes,” Sera said at once, before Leda could ask. “With conditions.”
“They’re not conditions,” said Bram. “They’re a list.”
“They’re conditions.” Sera held up one finger. “He ties on. He does not stand on the ladder. He sits on a stool with a back, and Ro takes the rope if his hands go.” Another finger. “If he says he’s tired once, he’s off the line. No argument. No *I just need a minute*.”
“I’ll say it,” said Bram.
“You won’t. You’ve never said it once in your life.” Sera’s mouth softened, just a little. “So Leda says it for you. If she sees your hands shaking, you’re off, and you don’t ask why.”
Leda looked at him.
He was looking at his own hands, folded on the stick. His chin had a stubborn tilt she had last seen when he was fourteen and had been told, kindly, that he could not follow Perrin out to the reef.
“Can you accept that?” she said.
“I’d rather not.”
“That’s not what I asked.”
He let out a breath. It took him a moment. “Yes,” he said. “I can accept that. If you do too. If it’s you who says it. Not Ro. Not the doctor. You.”
It was a trade. She understood it exactly. She was being asked to be the person who said *stop* to her brother, which she had spent her whole life not saying, and he was being asked to hear it.
“All right,” she said. “Then you’re on my list.”
He nodded once more. He did not smile, but the line of his shoulders came down half an inch.
Pike came down to the quay with a folded paper in his hand, and for a moment Leda thought he was going to give it to her. Instead he went to the two packet boats tied behind the *Marten*, the Bellwether boat and its sister bound for Orra, and spoke to each master in a low voice. He handed over one paper to the first and a second, thinner one to the other. Each master tucked his in his coat, touched his cap, and began to cast off.
“What’s that?” Leda said.
“An order, and a letter.” Pike’s voice was dry. “To my foreman at Bellwether. Dated, signed, witnessed by Della and a clerk from the harbor office, who happened to be passing.
It tells him to open the stone stub on the yard bank and take his men’s instructions from the surveyor on site. Not from me. I’ll be at sea, and nobody can reach a ship once it has sailed. The letter is for the Dunmore engineer I expect to find at Orra. I won’t call it a courtesy. I’d like him to know what I’m asking before he’s told what I’ve done.”
“Nobody can.”
“There never was a way,” said Pike. “So I wrote orders loosely and trusted people to guess. It’s an old habit. I’d like to retire it.”
He took a breath, and did what she had not expected: he looked at the *Marten*, at its plain brown sail and its small cabin, and asked, with real humility, “May I come?”
“As what?”
“As a passenger. As a witness. I’ll carry nothing, touch nothing, and say nothing unless I’m asked.” He swallowed. “If Dunmore’s people are at Orra, I’d rather they saw me standing next to you than behind a desk.”
Leda looked at Della. Della looked at the sky again, in the way she had when she wanted somebody else to make a decision and take the credit for being wrong.
“You’ll bunk forward,” said Leda. “You’ll take your share of watches. You do not speak to Dunmore until I say.”
“Understood.”
“And if you’re sick over the rail, you clean it.”
“I’ve no doubt,” said Pike, and she thought she saw something almost like gratitude cross his face. “I’ve been sick over worse.”
---
The crossing took three days. Quill, nineteen and unwilling to be left behind, had begged a berth and stowed himself forward with his clipboard.
For the first of the days nobody said anything to anybody that was not strictly necessary.
The sea was dark and cold, with a long, flat swell out of the north. Ro had the helm in the mornings, and Leda in the afternoons, and Bram sat in the cockpit on his stool with a blanket over his knees and a coil of line in his lap, tying and untying the same bowline until she had begun to think it was a kind of prayer.
She watched him. She watched him the way she had once been watched, and she hated every minute of it.
On the second evening she sat down beside him with two mugs.
“You’re staring,” he said.
“I’m checking.”
“You’re staring.” He took the mug. “It’s all right. I’d do the same.”
“I keep thinking you’re going to fall over.”
“I’ve kept thinking it too.” He looked at the water. “Thing is, Leda, when you’ve nearly been dead, every day’s a kind of cheat. I’m not scared of falling. I’m scared of being the reason somebody else has to catch me.”
She thought of Perrin. She did not say it. She did not need to.
“Then let me tell you what I tell my divers,” she said. “If you can’t do the job, it isn’t the same as if you can’t be trusted. It’s information. It’s like the weather.”
He barked a laugh. “That’s the nicest thing you’ve ever said to me.”
“I’ve said nicer.”
“When?”
“I haven’t yet.”
They both smiled, and for a while there was nothing but the wind in the sail and Pike, on the foredeck, being industriously and silently ill.
By the afternoon of the second day the rope drill had become a habit. Leda ran it on the cockpit sole, two tugs for *all well*, three for *come up*, a long continuous pull that no one was ever to use except once. Ro lay on her back with the line looped round her wrist and played the diver.
Bram held the other end and answered each signal a half-second before it finished, which meant he had been waiting for it, which meant he had been hearing it in his sleep.
“You’re early,” Leda said, the fourth time.
“I’m ready.”
“Early isn’t ready. If I give two and you answer before I finish, I can’t tell whether you felt me or guessed me.”
He scowled, then nodded, and the fifth answer came late enough to be honest. Ro, on her back, gave a small thumbs-up with the hand that held the line.
Pike had been pretending to coil a halyard. When the drill stopped he said, rather stiffly, “May I ask what the long pull means?”
“It means I’m in trouble and can’t talk,” Leda said. “It’s the only signal the tender doesn’t have to wonder about. Everything else, you check. That one, you haul.”
“And has it ever been used?”
She did not answer at once. Bram looked at his hands.
“Once,” said Leda. “It was answered.”
Pike nodded slowly, and went back to the halyard, and did not say another word until supper.
---
On the third night Pike took the middle watch, because nobody else wanted it and because Leda wanted to see what he did when he thought no one was looking.
He did nothing. That was the surprise. He sat at the stern with the tiller under his arm and his eyes on the compass lamp, and he did not fidget, did not pace, did not take out a notebook or a pocket watch. When she came up at two to relieve him he was exactly where she had left him, rigid with cold, steering a straight course with the patience of a man doing penance.
“You can sleep,” she said.
“I’d rather not. I dream about plates.”
She sat down beside him. The sea was black and the stars were sharp, and far off to the south a single light moved on the horizon, a coastal steamer, perhaps, or a trick of the eye.
“Tell me something,” she said. “The restriction Hale wanted printed beside Type C. Why did you say no?”
He was silent a while. “I’d like to say it was money.”
“Was it?”
“Partly. The catalogue was already printed. A reprint was nine thousand.” He moved his jaw. “But I’ve had two years to be honest with myself, and the truth is I thought printing it would make it true. If Type C was listed as unsuitable for live root, then somebody, someday, would have to ask which harbors had live root. And I didn’t want to know.”
“That’s not money. That’s fear.”
“They’re cousins.” He laughed, thinly. “I’ve found they usually are.”
She thought of the flow table stapled to Iven’s drawing, its clean columns. She thought of the pencil ghost beneath the guillotine, a footnote that had survived its own execution because somebody had pressed hard enough when they wrote it.
“Hale pressed hard,” she said.
“She always did. It’s why her handwriting is legible through three layers of carbon.” His voice caught. “I wish I’d listened to the pencil.”
Leda did not forgive him. It was not hers to do. But she put her own spare blanket across his knees, which was not the same as forgiveness, and went forward to wake Ro for the dawn.
---
They raised Orra at dusk on the twenty-ninth.
It came up out of the sea the way it always did, a loose raft of old hulls and new timber, lamps coming on in the cold. Leda had come to this place for the first time with Perrin’s death sitting in her chest like a stone and a plan in her pocket. Now she came to it with the plan in her bones and a company at her back, and it looked, in the long blue light, like a place that had been waiting.
The ledge was on the east side, under the quay. She could see it before she could see the quay: a pale shelf of stone in the shallows, with the long fringe of root trailing off its edge. In daylight it would be green. At dusk it was the color of old silver.
And on the water above it, just off the lip, a boat lay at anchor.
It was not an Orra boat. It was long and low and painted a flat, expensive gray, with a brass rail and a name on the stern that she read twice before it made sense. *Gannet.* Under it, in smaller letters: *Dunmore Coastal Holdings, Survey Service.*
“That’s them,” said Pike quietly. He had come aft to stand beside her. His face was the color of the sky. “That’s the boat.”
“It’s early,” said Ro.
“They’ve a bigger engine. I should have said.” He did not look at her. “I’m sorry.”
“Don’t be sorry yet,” said Leda. “Be useful. What’s the usual crew?”
“Two engineers, one camera operator, one diver. The engineer is Calder Voss. He’s good. He’s honest, as far as I know. I don’t know who he reports to.”
“What’s he going to do?”
“Test,” said Pike. “That’s what a courtesy inspection is. They take core samples of whatever’s near the outlets, and they photograph what the cores look like, and they write a report. If there’s a lawsuit later, the report is evidence.”
“Core samples of what?”
Pike did not answer. He did not have to.
She looked at the ledge again. She looked at the lamp on the *Gannet’s* deck, and at the small figure leaning over the side with a rod in his hands, and at the line that ran from the rod into the water.
And she saw the fringe move.
It was a small thing, a ripple across the silver, as if a breath had passed over a field. It started near the second plate and spread outward, a flinch, a shiver, a long indrawn gasp. Then it settled. Then, a moment later, it did it again.
Her whole body went cold.
“Ro,” she said. “Take the helm.”
“What are you going to do?”
“I’m going to row across and ask them what they’re testing.”
“You said you’d wait for the roster.”
“I said I’d ask first.” Leda was already pulling off her coat. “I’m asking.”
On the shore, a lamp was bobbing down the quay steps: one lamp, then another, a small knot of Orra folk hurrying. In the front, a figure in a green coat was running as if the stone were hot under him. Even at that distance she knew the stride.
Fenn had gotten there first, and he was shouting something she could not hear.
And on the underside of the nearest plate, as the *Gannet’s* lamp swung across it, a small bronze tag caught the light. She had to read it twice. It did not say *Harrow & Pike.*
It said *Dunmore Coastal. Asset 0117.*

