Calder Voss was not what Leda had prepared for.
She had prepared for a hard man in a gray coat, a man who would lean on the rail of the *Gannet* and say *I’m sorry, Ms. Vale, we have a contract.* She had rehearsed her reply on the row across the harbor, with Ro sculling and Pike left behind on the *Marten* in the dusk. She had even rehearsed her tone.
The man who put a hand out to steady her skiff against the survey boat’s hull was perhaps thirty-five, thin, sunburned in winter, with ink to the wrist and the harried look of someone who had been asked to do something he did not like for a reason he had not been given.
“Leda Vale,” he said, before she could speak. “Yes. Pike’s letter described you. It was waiting for me off the Orra packet this noon. It said you’d arrive angry and be right.”
“Pike wrote to you?”
“Pike wrote to everyone, the day he left.” He smiled without much humor. “I’m Voss. Please come up. I’d like you to see what my diver’s doing before you decide what to call it.”
He took a single folded sheet from his breast pocket as they walked aft and held it out, not quite offering it. Leda saw four lines in a hand that leaned forward, as if hurrying a thought along.
“He didn’t ask me to stop,” Voss said. “He didn’t ask me for anything, which was the unsettling part. He wrote that he had no standing to instruct me, that he was bringing a diver who would not lie, and that he would consider it a favor if I counted the fringe before I decided what it was worth. Counted, not cored. I’ve been thinking about that word all afternoon.”
She climbed over the rail. The deck was spotless. A camera on a tripod stood by the stern with a canvas hood over its lens; its operator, a bored young man in an oilskin, was eating a sandwich. At the side, a winch held a taut line, and a woman in a drysuit sat on the gunwale with her legs over the water, speaking into a tube.
“Four minutes,” the woman said, cheerfully. “Plate two. Nothing unusual. Fringe is healthy.”
“It flinched,” said Leda.
Voss turned. “I’m sorry?”
“Two minutes ago. The fringe along plate two. It flinched. From here I saw it ripple. Is your diver touching it?”
“She’s not supposed to.” Voss spoke into the tube. “Nina, are you in contact with the root?”
“No contact,” said the tube. “Two meters off. I’m taking water samples and photographing. There’s a slight current.”
“Is there a core tool in her kit?”
There was a pause that went on long enough for the woman on the gunwale to look up.
“Yes,” said Voss at last. “It’s in the standard kit. It hasn’t been used. I’d have to authorize it.” He rubbed his face. “I haven’t. I was thinking about it.”
“Don’t.”
“I beg your pardon?”
“Do not core that root, Mr. Voss.” She kept her voice low and level. “It’s alive. It answers when it’s hurt. If your diver puts a steel tube through the fringe at plate two, you will have a sample, and a root that bleeds for a year.”
“That’s an extraordinary claim.”
“I know.” She looked at him. “I also know the lead engineer of a survey boat doesn’t stand on his own deck telling a stranger he hasn’t authorized the thing he was thinking about unless he’s looking for a reason not to.”
For a moment he said nothing. The wind fluttered the hood on the camera.
“My instructions,” said Voss slowly, “were to bring back evidence of a defect. I was told this was a liability exercise.” He looked at the ink on his thumb. “I’m an engineer, Ms. Vale. I didn’t study for twelve years to be a witness for the prosecution. But I also don’t get to ignore a client.”
“Which client?”
“Dunmore Coastal.”
“The plates are Harrow & Pike’s.”
“The plates are Dunmore’s,” said Voss. “Look underneath.”
She had seen the tag already, in the lamplight, from across the harbor. She asked anyway. “What does it mean?”
“Asset 0117.” He lowered his voice. “Dunmore financed the installation. The outlets aren’t Pike’s property. They’re leased back to the harbor boards and owned, on paper, by Dunmore. If those outlets damage the root, Dunmore is on the hook as owner. If they don’t, Dunmore collects rent.” His mouth twisted. “Either way I work for people who need to know which it is, and I would have liked to know that three weeks ago.”
Leda stood very still.
What crossed her face was not outrage. It was arithmetic. *Pike was only the manufacturer.* The man in her kitchen had been right to say he was ruined, and wrong about who held the knife. The debts were Pike’s. The liability, if it came, would follow the plates. And whoever owned the plates would decide what the survey meant.
“Mr. Voss,” she said. “I’m going to ask for something unreasonable.”
“I rather thought so.”
“A survey. Joint. My divers and yours, together, with a holder at the branch. No coring. We take photographs, measurements, water, nothing that touches root. We share everything we find, the same day, in writing, to the Orra committee and the harbor board. Your report and ours say the same thing or they say why not.”
“Dunmore won’t like it.”
“Dunmore isn’t diving.”
He almost laughed. “That’s a very Saltwake sentence.”
“I’m told I’m getting better at them.”
Voss was silent for a long time. Down in the water, the diver’s bubbles rose and broke in silver rings. On the quay, the lamps swung. Far off, someone laughed on a deck.
“Tomorrow,” he said finally. “Dawn, slack tide. Your party and mine. I’ll tell Nina to stay off the root.” He rubbed at the ink on his thumb. “I’ll tell head office it’s a standard dual-party inspection. It isn’t, but that’s what I’ll call it.”
“Thank you.”
“Don’t thank me yet. I haven’t decided if I’m being brave or stupid.”
“Usually both,” said Leda. “It’s the same muscle.”
---
They went down at slack water, in the cold gray quiet before the sun cleared the east quay.
Leda had briefed it the night before, standing at Fenn’s mother’s kitchen table with chalk on a slate and Ro, Bram, Voss, the diver Nina and a small ring of Orra folk watching in silence. *Two divers. Two divers. Tender. Holder.* She had said the four words aloud and watched Bram’s lips move with them.
Fenn’s mother had put tea in front of each of them without being asked, a stout, quiet woman with her son’s frown, and had waited until the briefing ended and the others were pulling on boots. Then she had caught Leda’s sleeve at the door.
“Will it die?” she said. “The root. You can tell me plain. I fished off those steps thirty years.”
“I don’t know yet,” Leda said. “I won’t tell you it’ll be fine. I’ll tell you what I see when I come up, whatever it is.”
“That’s all I wanted.” The woman let go of her sleeve and smoothed it, as if she had creased something precious. “People keep saying it’ll be fine. It makes me want to hit them.”
Leda found that she liked her very much.
The holder was Fenn.
It had not been her choice. It had been Marra’s, relayed in a note from Bellwether, written in a shaky hand and put into the boy’s pocket on the dock: *He’s ready. He holds the best of any of us. Ask him.* And Leda, who had not wanted to put a fifteen-year-old on the end of a living root while she dived beneath it, had looked at the note, and at Fenn, and at the open palm he held out to her without being asked.
“I’ll tell the tender at the first flinch,” he had said. “I’ll tell you to come up. I won’t wait to be sure.”
“You must not wait to be sure.”
“I know.”
Now he knelt on the east steps with his right hand flat on the old pier-post that Orra’s holders called the Anchor Branch, and his left on his own knee, and his face turned slightly to the sea. Quill, the young tender she had brought from the Saltwake quay, sat behind him with a pocket watch.
Bram sat at the water’s edge on a high stool with a back, as the conditions required, with the rope across his lap. Sera had not come. Leda had told him that if he hit the limit, she would say it.
She did not intend to have to.
She went into the water.
---
It was cold in a way that did not frighten her now. It was clear, enormous, quiet cold, the cold of a cellar in the earth, and as she followed the buddy line down along the face of the ledge with Ro a body-length behind her, she felt the stone slide under her hands like a cheek.
The ledge dropped sharply for four meters and then leveled. At the lip, three meters below the surface, the first plate came into view.
It was bigger than she had imagined. A bolted square of black iron, three feet across, set into the stone with a collar of cement. The outlet itself pointed seaward. Where the jet had struck, over a year of tides, the stone below it was scoured pale and smooth. And at its foot, in a long, trailing, delicate band, hung the root.
She had seen the fringe at night once. Now she saw it in daylight, and her breath caught in the mask.
It was lovely. A thousand pale green filaments, fine as hair, streaming in the current, each one tipped with a tiny cup of silver. They lay in long swaying lines along the shelf, tens of thousands of them, like a field of grass seen from above on a windy day.
Near the plate, they were white.
Not dead. She knew the difference now, as she knew the differences between her own pulse and the sea’s. The white fringe still moved. It still caught the tide. But it moved wrong, curled, held tight against itself like the fingers of a hand held in a fist. Around the jet’s strike zone the pale band was perhaps a meter wide. Beyond it the green began, sharp as the edge of a stain.
She put out a hand and stopped herself an inch away.
Not touching. That was the rule.
Ro’s hand tapped her shoulder. Two taps. *Plate one measured.* She took the slate from her thigh and wrote: *Bleach 1.1m. Jet 3 o’clock. Fringe curled but responds.* She wrote *responds* twice, to be sure, and then showed it to Ro, who read it and flashed an *okay* sign with her free hand.
They worked down the line. Plate two had a bleached band of eight tenths; the jet was weaker there. Plate three was worse, a broad bar of white nearly two meters across, and the fringe was thin, ragged, as though somebody had been combing it backward. She wrote *thin* and underlined it. Beneath the plate, half-hidden by the curl of dead silt, a stamp caught her eye: not the Harrow & Pike mark, and not a *Type C.* A different batch, *R-14*. A different lot.
She noted it and swam on.
Plate four was the last. It sat at the far end of the ledge, close to the east steps, where Fenn’s mother had fished. The water was shallow there and bright, and the sunlight, now clearing the quay, fell through it in long gold bars.
The fringe at plate four was the worst. And the bronze tag under the plate was the same: *Dunmore Coastal. Asset 0117.* But beside it, scratched into the cement collar by someone with a nail, was a line of numerals she could not read. A date, perhaps. Or a count.
She leaned in.
The line went taut at her waist.
It was not a pull. It was a tug, three short. *Come up.* She knew it before she thought about it. Her body knew it. Her hand moved to the slate, and her eyes went to the gauge, and she saw that her reserve had fallen to the line.
*Abort.*
It had not been twenty minutes. She had not finished. She had not read the numerals, or measured the last fringe, or even touched the camera clip at her chest. A cold, bright, furious reluctance went through her like a spasm.
*Fenn,* she thought. *He’s on the surface. He’s felt something.*
She looked down at the fringe. It was lying quiet. Not flinching. Only, at its very edge, a single filament of white lifted, and curled, and lay against the stone like a finger laid across lips.
And in the quiet she heard, not a voice, not a sound, only a pressure at the back of her skull, the plain unmistakable sense of the whole root listening.
She turned and swam.
---
Bram’s hands were shaking when she broke the surface.
She saw it before she was out of the water. He sat on the stool with the rope in both fists and his face the color of putty, and Ro, who had surfaced a moment before, was already on the step with her hand over his, taking up the slack.
“It’s all right,” said Fenn, his own voice high and thin. He knelt on the steps with his palm still flat on the post. “It’s all right. The root jumped. It wasn’t big. I told the tender. It’s gone still again.”
“I pulled you,” Bram said. “Fenn called, and I pulled.”
“You did right.”
“I almost didn’t.”
“Bram.”
“My hands wouldn’t close.” He spoke very quickly. “For a moment. They just wouldn’t. The rope started to go and I thought, if she’s on the end of it, if I lose her...”
“You didn’t lose me.”
“I almost did.”
She pulled herself out of the water. Her legs were weak. She went to him across the wet stone, ignoring the cold and the camera on the *Gannet’s* deck and the small crowd of Orra folk, and she knelt at his stool and put both her hands over both of his. His were ice.
“I said I would tell you,” she said. “If I saw it. I’m telling you.”
His eyes came up. They were wet.
“You’re off the line,” said Leda.
He closed them. A long breath went out of him, shuddering. “Yes,” he said. “All right.”
“It isn’t failure.”
“I know.”
“It’s information.”
“Like the weather.” He laughed, wetly, a cracked, helpless sound. “I’ll hold the slate, if you’ll let me. I can hold a slate.”
“You can hold anything I give you,” said Leda, and got up, and found that her own hands were not quite steady either.
At the foot of the steps, Voss stood alone with his notebook, ignoring his own diver, who was climbing out of the water beside him. He was staring at the ledge. At the white band. At the plates in the shallows, which were, in the plain light of the morning, starkly, shamefully visible.
“Ms. Vale,” he said. His voice was strange. “I need to show you something in my cores. The ones I did not take.” He swallowed. “The ones Dunmore has already taken. Last year, at three other harbors. I wasn’t meant to see the lab report. I saw it.”
“What does it say?”
“That their root dies at the jet in nineteen months.” He lifted his eyes to hers. “And that Orra has had its plates for fourteen.”

