They argued about it for six hours, in the Infirmary’s back ward, round a table made of two doors laid across trestles.
Leda had never seen so many people try so hard to be reasonable. Hale sat at the head with a legal pad and three pencils. Thale had come in his blue coat and taken the chair nearest the stove, where he sat with his cap on his knee and said little. Sera, Bram, Ro, Pike and Orne filled the benches along the wall, and Iven stood at the window with his back to the room, because he could not sit still and could not walk, and the window was the only compromise.
The letter lay in the middle of the table, under a pewter mug.
“Noon, on the ninetieth,” said Hale. “Berth Nine. Alone if you like, with the boy if he is willing. I will not be armed. It is a courteous letter.”
“It’s a courteous noose,” said Pike.
“It is a courteous letter written by a man who has had four people read his mail and one clerk flood a cellar.” She tapped the pad. “I want us to be clear what we think he is doing. Not what we fear. What we can show.”
“He’s naming the day,” said Leda.
“Yes. He has seen Della’s letter, or someone has, and he has put the Saltwake gate on the same morning as his noon. If we go, we miss the gate and the Pell winters here. If we sail, we refuse him.”
“Then we refuse him.”
“Do we?” said Sera, from the bench.
It was said quietly, and everybody turned. Sera had a way of speaking that made the room lean. She sat with her black skirts spread and her stick across her knees, and she looked at no one.
“I have been a physician for thirty years. I have buried a number of patients who refused to speak to the man who wished to cure them, because they did not like his manner.” She lifted one shoulder. “I do not say we trust him. I say that a man who sends a note with a fixed hour and a fixed place and says *I shall not be armed* is, among other things, a man who wants an answer. He has had everything else from us except that.”
“He had Dray,” said Ro.
“He had a clerk and a surveyor and a watchman. He has never had a conversation.” Sera tilted her head. “I find that interesting. So does Miss Hale.”
“I find it dangerous,” said Hale. “But I find it interesting.”
---
At the third hour Thale laid his own cards on the table.
“I’ll say what I can do and what I can’t. I can have a dozen wardens within sight of Berth Nine at any hour of any day, and no gentleman in a scarf will see them, because that’s my trade. I can’t put a man inside the meeting. If there’s a conversation, it’s yours.” He turned the cap in his hands. “And I’ll tell you what I would do, if I were you.”
“Tell us,” said Iven, to the window.
“I’d not go on his day. A man who picks the hour picks the ground. I’d go on mine.”
Leda looked up. For a moment nobody breathed.
“Write him a letter,” said Thale. “Say you’ll meet. Say it’s the eighty-sixth, noon, at Berth Nine, in the open, with the Court’s leave and the warden’s men on the quay. If he’s a man of his word he’ll come. If he isn’t, you have lost nothing and the gate stays open for you an extra four days.”
“Four days,” said Bram.
“You’d sail on the eighty-seventh. the Pell can do the passage in three. She’s quicker than the Heron, under a root.”
“And if he says no?”
“Then he’s a man who needs the ninetieth for something,” said Hale. “Which I should like very much to know.”
It was a good plan. It was so clearly a good plan that Leda felt a small cold stir in her stomach, and examined it, and could not say why. It was only that nothing in the last two months had gone to plan, and she had grown wary of the plan that did.
“I’ll carry it,” said Orne.
Everybody looked at her. She had not spoken since noon. She sat at the end of the bench with a stiff gray look, her hands folded, and something in her face that Leda knew from the mirror.
“The letter. To the carter. I’ll give it to Brindle myself.” She swallowed. “I want to see his face when he takes it.”
“Thale’s looking for him,” said Pike.
“Thale is looking for a man who is sitting at the Infirmary gate with a whittling knife,” said Orne. “I walked past him this morning.”
Thale said something short under his breath and stood.
“Let him be,” said Leda. “Please. Let her. If he runs we’ll learn something. If he doesn’t, we’ve got a messenger.”
It was an odd thing to ask of a warden, and a stranger thing for him to give. He sat down again. He did not say yes. He took out his pipe, and looked at it, and put it away.
---
Hale wrote the letter in forty minutes, with Leda standing at her shoulder and Iven, from the window, saying *shorter.*
*To H.V., in answer to your note of the eighty-fifth.*
*The cooperative will meet you. Not on the ninetieth, which we are obliged to keep for a prior duty. On the eighty-sixth day, at noon, at Berth Nine, in the open, with the Court’s leave and the acting warden’s men on the quay. We bring a lawyer. You are welcome to the same. If your request is as you describe it, a commission in proper form, there is nothing in it that cannot be said in daylight.*
*We have kept the plate.*
*Leda Vale, Iven Sayer, for the Cooperative.*
“The last line,” said Pike. “Do we need it?”
“Yes,” said Leda, who had written it.
“It says we found the first one.”
“I want him to know. I want him to wonder what we think it means.” She took the pen from Hale, dipped it, and put her name beneath the other, in square plain letters. “He’s been giving us riddles for two months. It’s time he had one.”
She blotted it. Iven came away from the window at last, and stood behind her, and put his good hand on the back of her chair, not quite touching.
“It’s good,” he said.
“You said shorter.”
“It was. You made it longer. It’s better.” He drew a breath. “It’s got you in it.”
---
Sera caught her in the passage, where the lamp was low and the smell of carbolic thickest.
“A word, child.”
Leda stopped. Sera was the only person alive who could call her that without it sounding like an insult, and she did it rarely, and always when something had to be said that would not wait for a better room.
“You wrote that last line to provoke him,” said the old woman.
“Yes.”
“It was well done. I should like you to be aware that it is also the sort of thing Perrin would have done, and I watched where that led.”
It was a very quiet blow, and Leda felt it land under the ribs. She did not flinch. She had learned long ago that Sera aimed to hit, and that the kindest thing to do was to stand still.
“Perrin took chances on the water,” she said.
“Perrin took chances on people. It is a different sort.” Sera shifted her stick. “Do not mistake me. I am not asking you to be careful, you are far too careful already. I am asking you to remember that the man in the scarf has been three steps ahead since the first day, and that when you provoke a man like that, you give him something to do.”
“I know.”
“Do you?” The pale eyes held hers. “He has not hurt anyone. Have you noticed? Dray’s foot was an accident of the coffer. The cellars were Iven’s own doing. Orne’s post was a cost of her own choosing. In two months, and a dozen devices, I can find no one who was hurt by what he *did.* Only by what we did to answer.”
Leda said nothing. She had thought of it, once or twice, at three in the morning, and put it away.
“That is not an excuse for him,” said Sera. “It is a description. I should like you to carry it into the meeting. Carry it, mind. Not believe it.”
“I will.”
“Good.” She turned, then paused, and glanced back. “And Leda. When Iven says *it’s got you in it,* he is not being kind. He is telling you what he fears. Listen to that, too.”
She went away down the passage, tapping, and the lamp swung a little in the draft behind her.
---
Bram was in the kitchen with the claims register open and a lamp pulled close.
He had finished it. All eleven names, all the sums, copied fair in a clear round hand, with a neat line ruled under each total. He sat with the pen across the page and his bad leg stretched on a second stool, and when she came in he did not look up.
“Fifty-two struck off. Seventy-four paid in coin. Eleven receipts.” He tapped the page. “It balances.”
“It’s beautiful.”
“It’s a ledger.” But he looked pleased. He put the pen down. “I heard you in the passage. Not the words. Sera’s got a voice that goes through a wall.”
“She was telling me I’m like Perrin.”
“Aye.” He said it simply. “You are, a bit. The best bits and the worst, the same as anyone.”
She sat down across from him. The kitchen was warm, and the kettle was talking to itself on the hob, and for a moment she let herself be a person who had come in out of the cold.
“I’m sailing on the eighty-seventh,” she said. “If he comes on the eighty-sixth, and if it goes the way it might. You’ll be on the Pell, Bram. Under Della’s rule, with a second holder at your shoulder. I don’t know yet who.”
“You,” he said.
“Me, if my ear holds. Or Fenn.”
“Fenn’s at Saltwake.”
“Then Ro. She’ll want to stay here, but she’ll go if I ask.” She hesitated. “Would you mind? Having someone watch?”
He considered it with the grave air he brought to everything now, since the Infirmary. He turned the pen over, and set it down, and lined it with the edge of the book.
“I’d mind it if it was a punishment,” he said. “It isn’t. It’s a rule that’s got my name on it.” A flash of the grin. “It’s the first one that has.”
She laughed, and was surprised by how much it loosened. It was a small thing, and he gave it to her without effort, and she thought how strange it was that the people she had been most afraid for were the ones who steadied her.
“Go to bed,” she said. “You’re a patient.”
“I’m a *cleared* patient. Sera says it’s a difference.”
“It’s a difference of about an inch.”
“An inch is plenty,” said Bram. “Ask Iven.”
---
After the others had gone she went out to the Infirmary yard, where Orne was waiting by the gate with the letter inside her coat.
It was cold, and the lamps along Wharf Road made yellow rings on the wet cobbles. At the corner, quite visibly, with its canvas hood and its gray horse and a man on the box whittling a small piece of birch, stood the green cart.
“You don’t have to,” said Leda.
“I do.” Orne’s voice was flat. “I lost the post on the seventy-eighth, Miss Vale. I knew I would. I’d have done it a hundred times over. But I’ve had four days with nothing to do, and I’ve found that what I want is to be asked to do something. And nobody’s asked.” She gave a small stiff laugh. “It’s not as though I could have said no.”
“The cooperative’s asking.”
“Is it?”
“I’m asking. I don’t have the standing yet. I’ll have it by morning.” Leda stopped, and tried again. “We don’t have a roster at Ashlen. We have Pike’s yard and a lawyer and your name. If the work is to be done here after we’ve gone, somebody has to hold it. I’d want it to be you. As a member, not a favor.”
Orne said nothing for a long moment. The wind pulled a strand of her gray-streaked hair across her face, and she did not put it back.
“I’m forty-four,” she said at last. “I’ve never been a member of anything.”
“Neither had I, at your age.”
“That’s not true. You’ve been in Saltwake since you were a girl.”
“I was a *tender.* It’s not the same.” Leda smiled, rather crookedly. “I’ll tell Della by the next ship. She’ll say it’s irregular. She’ll vote yes.”
Orne nodded. She did not say thank you. She went down the steps and crossed the cobbles, a square dark figure with her head up, and Leda watched her go up to the cart. The carter looked down. Orne held up the letter. And Brindle, with a sort of slow ceremony, closed his penknife, put it in his pocket, and took the envelope between two fingers like a man receiving something from a priest.
He read the direction. He looked across the yard at Leda, and tipped his cap.
---
Leda did not go back inside. She walked, instead, along Wharf Road to the end, where it met the harbor wall and the first stair went down to the water, and sat on the cold step with her hands between her knees.
She took out the plate.
She had not looked at the back. In all the confusion of the court, the reports, the arrest, the card, she had put it in her pocket wet and gone to bed with it under her pillow like a child, and had not once turned it over. She did so now, under the weak yellow light of the lamp at the top of the stair.
The back was rough, a casting seam, brass with the flash still on it. And there, scratched with a nail or a needle, very small, in a different hand from the punched numbers, were four letters.
*A.M.V.*
Under them, a line of tiny script, hardly readable. She tilted the brass until the lamp caught each stroke.
*For the one who answers.*
She sat with it a long time. The water slapped at the stair. Out in the roads a ship’s bell rang the hour, and somewhere behind her, along the quay, a door shut.
*Not H.V.* A.M.V. Someone before him. A grandfather, a founder, a man whose initials had been scratched into the back of a plate with a needle by a hand that was careful, almost loving, and had wanted whoever found it to understand.
*For the one who answers.*
She thought of the letter in the carter’s pocket, and of the sentence she had written. *We have kept the plate.* She had meant it as a challenge, a thing to make him wonder.
She felt, quite suddenly and quite coldly, that she had been answering all along.

