Hale checked the ledger against the Court’s own lease books by candlelight, and by ten that night she had found nothing wrong with it, and was more frightened than she had been all week.
“It is exact,” she said. She sat in the records room of the Court of Leases with the cream pages spread across a table and four heavy lease books propped open round her, like a general among her maps. “Every harbor. Every date. I have checked eleven of them against the Court’s copies of the surveys, and there is not one figure out of place. He has given us what he said he would.”
“Isn’t that good?” said Leda.
“It is *suspicious.* A man who tells you the whole truth in order, with no weak places, has had a good deal of practice arranging it.” Hale rubbed her eyes with the heels of both hands. “I have been a lawyer for twenty-six years. The honest ones leave a seam. They forget a date, they misplace a name, they contradict themselves in a way you can use. This has no seams.”
“Then you think he’s lying.”
“I think he is *telling the truth in a form that serves him.* It is not the same.” Hale lowered her hands. “I will tell you what I do not doubt. The seats are real. The Trust is real. The seat under Saltwake’s pier is real, and it is set to trip on the ninetieth. I should stake the Court’s whole docket on that. The rest, the grandfather and the safety valve and the sorrow, is a story. It may be a true story. It is also a very good one.”
Leda sat on the edge of a stool with the plate in her lap and said nothing. She had been thinking about the thumb-print in the wax, left-handed, pressed down hard, and about a man holding his hat in the hand he wrote with.
“Does it matter?” she said at last. “If the story’s good? If the seat’s real?”
“It matters to the charter.” Hale took up a pen. “I shall draft the commission tonight. You will have it by dawn, and you will read every word on the Pell, and you will not sign any part of it until I have seen your reservations. I intend three conditions. No secrecy clause, the list is published to every harbor on it within thirty days. The Court’s seal on the Trust’s winding-up before the cooperative is paid. And Vane’s sworn statement of what he has done, in his own hand, before Justice Aldane.”
“He’ll agree?”
“He will agree to all three at once. I am certain of it.” Hale dipped the pen. “That, Miss Vale, is the part that troubles me.”
---
He came to the Court at eleven, in the rain, and he agreed to every condition before Hale had finished reading them.
Justice Aldane received him in her private chamber, a small paneled room with a coal fire and a long table, and she did not rise. Thale stood at the door. Hale sat at her right hand with the three conditions on a single sheet, and Leda was allowed a chair by the wall because the Justice had looked at her over her spectacles and said, “The witness may stay if she keeps her face still.”
“It does a thing at the eyebrows,” said Hale, without turning.
“Then she may keep it where it is.”
Hollis Vane stood in the lamplight with his wet hat in his left hand and did not seem to notice it was dripping. He heard the conditions through once. He nodded after the first. He nodded after the second. At the third, the sworn statement in his own hand, he said, “Of course,” so mildly that Aldane’s eyebrows rose.
“You understand, Mr. Vane, that what you write may be used against you.”
“I should be surprised if it were not.”
“You may take advice.”
“I took it this morning. Miss Hale’s colleague, Mr. Orlo, in Fish Lane, was very patient with me.” He set the hat on a chair. “I have already written it. I hoped you would not mind.”
He took from his coat a folded sheet and laid it on the table. It ran to eleven pages, in the small upright violet hand, and Aldane read the first page standing, and the second sitting, and the third with her lips pressed together. It named the Registry deputy and the Registrar and the retired grain factor. It named Gill, and the carter, and the bursary. It said, in plain words, that the writer had known what the first crate was and had let it be set. It did not say he was sorry. It said he had been wrong.
“This is a confession,” said the Justice.
“It is a statement of fact.”
“The two are very close in law.”
“Then I shall be glad of the Court’s discretion.” He took the pen she held out, left-handed, and wrote his name at the foot of the eleventh page, quite slowly, as a man writes who has been taught to do it correctly. *Hollis Aldous Vane.* “I do not ask for mercy. I ask only that the cooperative be given the time to do the work first.”
Aldane looked at him for a long time. In the grate a lump of coal collapsed with a small soft sound.
“The Court will consider it,” she said. “You will present yourself here each morning at nine until further notice. Warden Thale will have a man on your lodging.”
“That is entirely proper.”
He bowed, picked up his hat, and, as he passed Leda’s chair, stopped. It was a thing she would think about for some time afterward. He did not look at her face. He looked at her hand, the right one, lying on her knee.
“Miss Vale. May I ask you one thing, which has nothing to do with the law?”
She said nothing. Hale’s heel pressed her ankle.
“At the seat. At Berth Nine, on the eighty-fourth. Was it warm?”
For a moment she could not speak. It had not been in the log. She had told no one but Orne and Iven, and neither of them had said a word to anybody who could carry it.
“How do you know?” she said.
“I don’t.” He smiled, faintly, almost shyly. “I was told once, as a boy, that the first shoot after a long silence is warm. By my grandfather. I never found out if he was right.”
“He was,” said Leda.
“Thank you,” said Hollis Vane. He bowed again, and went out into the rain, and she sat with her hand where he had looked, and found that it was trembling very slightly.
---
Dray was awake when she got back to the Infirmary, propped against his pillows with the lamp turned low and a primer open on his chest.
It was a child’s reading book, with a blue paper cover and a picture of a duck. A nurse had left it with him that morning, he said, because the ward had no other books, and he had found he did not mind. He had got to the page about the pond.
“They say he’s come,” said Dray. “The man. In the scarf.”
“He came.”
“I’ve met him.” The old surveyor said it flatly. “Not as I’ve told it. Not at an inspectors’ dinner. The first time I saw him he was by my bed, at Marren Ford, the night before they moved me, with a book of his own. He sat there a quarter of an hour in the lamplight, quite still, and I took him for a doctor. He asked how my girl’s sums were.”
Leda did not move.
“I said, she’s a hand at them. He said, *I’m glad.* He said, *Please tell her not to stop.*” Dray’s mouth worked. “And then he got up and went, and I never saw him again, and in the morning there was a purse on the blanket and a violet receipt for the fees. I never thought. I told myself he was a kind man who didn’t want thanking.”
“He was both.”
“Aye. That’s what I can’t get past.” He looked at her. “It’s not that I think he’s lying. It’s that I think he means every word and he’s *still* using me.”
It was the most exact thing anyone had said about Hollis Vane in two days. She sat on the foot of the bed, and Dray, after a moment, passed her the duck.
---
The night was a long one, and for a while it did not feel as if they were doing anything at all.
Packing went on in the back ward in odd bursts, between Sera giving orders and the nurses finding Bram’s other boot. Ro stood by the door with her bandaged shoulder and a canvas bag and said she would not go to Saltwake, not this time, and nobody argued with her.
“Somebody has to hold the yard,” said Ro. “Pike’s got three apprentices and a wife and a licence he can’t read the small print on. And somebody has to take the list round.”
“Forty harbors,” said Pike. “I make it a year.”
“A year and a bit.” Ro shrugged her good shoulder. “It’s a good year. I’d rather it was spent doing than waiting.”
“We’ll need a roster,” said Leda. “Real divers. Not you alone.”
“Miss Orne and I. Dunn, if the Fish Quay will spare him. Two of Pike’s yard men who’ve sat on a line with me before.” Ro counted them on her fingers. “It’s thin. It’s not nothing.”
Leda looked round the room. It was the oddest company she had ever put together. A boat builder, a suspended port diver, a woman with a broken shoulder, and a lawyer with a spare pencil. It was nothing like Saltwake’s long gray roster, with its forty years of habit.
*And it will do,* she thought. *It will do very well.*
It was nearly midnight when Orne came, with her hat in her hand.
“I had it out of Cooper’s Row at six,” she said. “The pawn broker was very good about it. He said he’d not seen a woman redeem a watch in a month.” She held out something small wrapped in a handkerchief. “You’ll have to wind it. It stopped.”
Leda unwrapped the cloth. The brass tide watch lay in her palm, scratched and warm, with its little tide-dial still set to the hour she had given it up.
“Orne. That’s ten crowns.”
“Eleven, with the interest. It’s from the post. They paid me out.” Orne’s voice was gruff. “It’s not a gift. I’ll want it in the roster accounts. Item, one watch, cost to be repaid by the cooperative.”
“I’ll put it in the log.”
“See you do.” Orne turned to go, then stopped. “My mother used to say there are people you want to owe, and people you don’t. I never owed a person anything I wanted to repay before.” She did not turn her head. “I’ll tend for you any day, Miss Vale. In any water.”
---
Iven was waiting for her in the yard, which was empty and silver with frost, and he had not been to bed.
She had known he would be there. He sat on an upturned bucket by the water pump with his coat buttoned to the chin, and his left arm bound across his chest, and he looked as she had never seen him, not tired but quiet, like a house with all its lamps out and a single candle in the back.
“I want to say something,” he said, “and I need you to let me finish.”
“All right.”
“I think we should go. Not for Vane. For the gate.” He did not look at her. “I’ll go anywhere you go. But I’ve been thinking about Saltwake for a day and a half, and I find I’m frightened in a way I haven’t been, not since the winter before Perrin. It’s four hundred people. It’s the Orra children, and Della’s whole street, and the boy who sweeps the roster hall.” He stopped. “And I want to say I’m frightened of the man, too. I can’t help it. I believe him, and I’m frightened.”
“So am I.”
“I know. I saw you with the plate.” He smiled, very slightly. “You’ve been rubbing the number off with your thumb.”
She looked down. She had.
“I need to know something,” she said. “If it comes to the pier. If the root goes, and I have to be in the water, and there’s ice, and the gate’s shut, and the thing is about to trip. Will you hold the line?”
“I can’t.”
“Iven.”
“I can’t hold it,” he said. “My arm’s gone for the winter, Leda. I can read the pier and I can read the log and I can tell you which way the ice is going to lean. But I can’t take your weight.” He drew a breath. “Somebody else will have to. Bram, under the rule. Fenn. Ro, if she’d come. Not me.”
It was the plainest thing he had ever said to her. It sat on the cold air between them, and she felt it settle, as one feels a tide turn without seeing it.
“Then you tell them what to do,” she said. “From the pier. You tell me when to come up.”
“That I can do.”
“And I’ll come.”
“I know.” He got up from the bucket. It cost him something, and she did not help. He crossed the yard, and put his good arm round her, awkwardly, over the sling, and she held on to his coat with both hands and thought of nothing for a little while at all.
---
The Patience Pell was riding at Berth Three in the first gray of the eighty-seventh morning, and on the quay beside her stood Hale with a flat canvas case and her pencil behind her ear.
“The commission,” she said. “Three copies. Read it on the passage. And one more thing.”
She drew Leda aside, to the edge of the coping, where the water slapped and the wardens could not hear. The lawyer’s face was gray and fixed.
“I counted the ledger twice,” she said. “Three hundred and eleven seats. That is what he told us. And the last number on the last page is three hundred and nineteen.”
“I don’t follow.”
“The seats are numbered from zero zero zero one. If there are three hundred and eleven, the last should be zero three one one. It is zero three one nine.” Hale lowered her voice. “Eight numbers are not in the book. I went through it five times. Zero zero zero three to zero zero one zero. They are simply, not there.”
“A mistake.”
“I told you. There are no seams.” She held Leda’s eyes. “Somebody tore them out. And the pages on either side are the Saltwake pages.”
Behind them the Pell’s master was calling the tide. The gray water moved against the stone. Leda stood with the cold coming up through her boots, and the brass watch ticking at last in her pocket, because Orne had wound it, and thought of eight seats she could not see, in a place she had thought she knew, and a man who had told her everything except where they were.

