By first light the whole town was on the north arm, and the Gannet lay in her black lane of water two hundred yards off the leaves, with steam coming off her funnel and a plank run out across the ice.
Leda stood at the parapet with her collar up and watched the plank. It was a plain deal board, six feet long, laid from the launch’s rail to the edge of the pack, and on either side of it the ice lay in gray broken plates, heaving very slightly with the swell under it. Nobody had crossed yet. A man in a blue coat stood at the rail with his hands behind him, and a second figure, taller, stood a little apart.
“They’re waiting to be asked,” said Iven, beside her.
“Politely.”
“Dunmore is always polite. It’s the one thing they’ve never been short of.” He shifted the log under his good arm. He had slept three hours and shaved with his wrong hand, and there was a small cut at the corner of his jaw. “Marden’s agreed to meet them at the gate-head. Six councillors, Della, Frost for the bell. They don’t come through the gate. We go out to them.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s ours.” He said it simply. “If we let them in, they’re guests. If we meet them on the ice, it’s a place nobody owns. I’d sooner be on the stone.”
She would have liked to say something clever. She had a feeling about the whole business, a cold small watchful feeling like a fish under a boat, and clever things would not come. She put her glove over his on the parapet instead, and they stood a moment, two people on a wall, with the sun coming up red behind the pack.
“Mr. Wren’s the tall one,” she said.
“I thought so.”
“He’s thinner.”
“It’s a hard season for assessors.”
---
The man in the blue coat crossed the plank first, with a walking cane in one hand and the other held out for balance, and he did it with the cheerful, slightly theatrical care of someone who had been told the ice was thin and meant to show he did not mind.
He was perhaps fifty-five, rosy and round, with a silver mustache waxed at the ends and a pair of pince-nez on a ribbon. His coat was cut as nothing in Saltwake had ever been cut. He reached the stone steps of the gate-head, took off his hat to Marden, and said, in a warm, easy, carrying voice, “Mr. Chairman. Lucian Sallow, of the Directors of Dunmore Marine Assurance. I cannot tell you what a pleasure it is.”
“It’s six degrees below,” said Marden.
“Then I am doubly obliged that you rose.” He bowed, left and right. “Councillors. Keeper Della, I believe? We have not met, but I have admired your work for years. I have read your roster’s logs. Very fine hands. Very fine.”
Della said nothing at all. She stood on the top step with her stick planted and her face like a shut hatch, and Leda saw her take the measure of the man in the time it took him to finish bowing.
“You’ll come in out of the wind,” said Marden grudgingly.
“I should be delighted. But first, if I may, a small courtesy.” Sallow turned, and lifted a hand, and the second figure came across the plank.
It was Tobias Wren. He was thinner, as she had said, a gray stooped man in a gray coat with a gray beard trimmed close, and he crossed the ice with his eyes on his boots. When he reached the steps he stopped, and raised his head, and for an instant his eyes met Leda’s across the heads of the councillors. They were tired and rather bloodshot, and quite steady.
“Mr. Wren will be known to some of you,” said Sallow. “He was our field assessor on the Bellwether matter. He has been of the greatest assistance in my enquiries.”
Wren did not smile. He did not look at the Director. He said, in a dry level voice, “Miss Vale. Mr. Sayer.”
“Mr. Wren,” said Iven.
“I hoped we might meet again. Under better skies.”
“The sky’s very clear.”
“So it is.” The corner of the assessor’s mouth twitched. It was the smallest thing, and Leda was suddenly, entirely sure he had not come as a friend of the Directors.
---
They talked in the customs house, with the stove going and the door shut, and Sallow talked for an hour.
It was an impressive performance. He sat at the head of the long table, where Marden had put him, with his hat on his knee and his pince-nez swinging, and spoke without notes. He praised the town. He praised the roster. He expressed the Directors’ deepest concern for a community that had faced, in the course of a single season, an extraordinary hazard, and he said, with a catch in his voice, that nobody could have blamed the council for refusing to speak to a firm of underwriters on such a day.
“We are not here to buy anything,” he said. “We are here to help. May I be frank?”
“It’s customary,” said Marden.
“The Directors have an interest in the Harbour Reversion Trust. A considerable interest. You will understand that Dunmore, as a marine insurer, has for three generations lent upon the security of quays, and a great many of those quays carried, in one form or another, the Trust’s seats.” He opened his hands. “We did not install them. We did not design them. We inherited a portfolio. And we discovered, in the last year, that a number of those seats were, shall I say, imperfectly maintained.”
“By whom?” said Iven.
“By the Trust. By the family at its head. A most estimable gentleman, Mr. Hollis Vane, whom I have the honor to count a friend.” Sallow smiled blandly. “He has, I understand, lately become troubled in conscience. He has been sending out letters. It is no secret that he proposes to wind up the Trust, and to extinguish its reversion rights, at the Court of Leases at Ashlen.”
“We know,” said Leda.
“Of course you do. You are the instrument.” The pince-nez swung. “But I am afraid, Miss Vale, that it is not as simple as Mr. Vane supposes. Dunmore holds the Trust’s bonds. Forty harbors, three hundred seats, a hundred years of paper. If the Trust is wound up, the bonds go with it. And a great many honest policy-holders, widows and net-menders and small lenders, will lose their savings.”
It was cleverly done. It was so cleverly done that Leda felt her mouth go dry, and thought, with a cold clear flash, *he’s right, and he knows it, and it’s still a lie.*
“What do you propose?” said Della.
It was the first thing she had said. Sallow turned to her with every sign of pleasure.
“A mechanical solution, Keeper. We have been working for some years on a device. We call it the Dunmore Jack. It is a hydraulic piston, fitted into the seat, which holds the pawl against the root at any tide. It needs no keeper. It needs no ring. It needs no answering at all.” He leaned forward. “It could be fitted to your tenth seat, under your roster hall, in a week. It would hold at the thaw. It would hold for thirty years. And Saltwake would never again be at the mercy of a root’s mood.”
Nobody spoke. The stove ticked.
“In return,” said Sallow, “all we should ask is the supervision of the roster that I mentioned in my letter. A trivial formality. A seat for a Dunmore engineer on your council, and the right to inspect.”
---
Della was waiting in the passage when the meeting broke, with one hand on the wall and her stick tucked under her arm, and Leda knew by her face what she was going to say before she said it.
“It’s a very good offer,” said the old woman.
“Della.”
“I don’t say I’ll take it. I say it’s good.” Her voice was low and rough. “I’ve sat in that chair thirty-one years, Leda. I have never once gone to bed without a corner of my mind on the root. And that man has just told me that I might, in a week, put it all down. A piston. Thirty years. No ring, no counting, no fainting girls on the floor.” She laughed shortly. “I am sixty-eight. Do you know what I would give to sleep through the closing turn?”
“I know.”
“Do you?”
“I know what I’d give to sleep through the one at the pier.” She meant it. She felt it in her chest like a stone. “But Della, listen. He didn’t say what it does to the root.”
“He said it holds.”
“He said it holds. He didn’t say what for.” She took the old woman’s hand, which was cold and square and unexpectedly small. “A root that nobody answers is a root that nobody listens to. You taught me that. You said it was the first thing. *The listening’s the thing, child. The rest is hands.*”
Della said nothing. Her fingers tightened for a moment on Leda’s, and then loosened.
“I know I said it,” she said at last. “I was younger. I had more patience.” She drew a long breath. “I shall not take it. Not on that man’s word. But do not tell me I did not want to.”
“I won’t.”
“Good.” She straightened. “Because I’ll hear it said in my sleep, I think, for a year.”
---
Wren caught her at the door when the meeting broke up, in the confusion of chairs and coats, with his gray cap in his hand and his face turned away.
“Miss Vale. A moment.”
She followed him round the corner of the customs house, to the lee of the wall where the wind did not reach, and he stopped there with his back against the stone and looked at her for a while without speaking.
“I should tell you first that I am no longer in Dunmore’s employ,” he said.
“You came on their boat.”
“I came on it because it was the only way across. I was dismissed on the eightieth day. Quite correctly. I have, in my time, written seven reports that the Directors found inconvenient, and the seventh was the one about Bellwether.” His voice was dry. “Mr. Sallow offered to take me to Saltwake as a courtesy, so that I might serve as a guide. I think he supposed I would be grateful.”
“Aren’t you?”
“I am here, Miss Vale. That is the nearest I can get.” He rubbed his beard. “I will say what I can say in five minutes. The Jack does hold. I have seen it tested. In the first year it holds like a rock. In the third, the root begins to die around it, because it cannot be answered, and a root that cannot be answered stops growing. In the fifth it is dead wood. I have the figures in my bag, from nine installations.”
She felt the cold go through her.
“Dunmore fitted nine.”
“At nine harbors. Under the Trust’s name. They did not call it a hazard.” Wren’s eyes, bloodshot and gray, did not leave hers. “That is what they are for. If the root dies, the quay is no longer a living quay. It may be re-let. It may be rebuilt in iron. It is, in the Directors’ phrase, a *performing asset.*”
“They want the harbors.”
“They want the *reversion.* The Trust is a great machine for making living quays fail. Mr. Vane’s family built it. Dunmore bought the parts.” He drew a long breath. “And Mr. Vane has been going about the coast for eleven years, I believe, trying to take it to pieces, and the Directors have been very patient. They have let him. They have waited for him to do the work, because it is cheaper.”
“He’s not going to wind it up.”
“No. They will not allow it. Not while the bonds are theirs.” He fastened his coat. “And that, Miss Vale, is why I am afraid. Mr. Sallow did not come to Saltwake to sell you a piston. He came because Mr. Vane is aboard the Gannet.”
The wind dropped. She stood very still.
“He’s what?”
“He came by the Court’s leave, under seal. Justice Aldane released him on the ninety-first, into the custody of Warden Thale’s own deputy, to present himself to the roster in person.” Wren’s mouth twisted. “He believed that no one else could tell you how to answer the seat. He is right. I think Mr. Sallow believes he can make him change his mind.”
---
They brought him across the plank at noon.
Leda watched from the gate-head with her hands clenched in her pockets. It was a long slow business. The sun was high and the ice glared, and the figures came over it one at a time, small and black against the white. First a big young warden in a blue coat, with a warden’s short baton he had plainly never used. Then, a pace behind him, a thin man in a gray overcoat with a violet scarf, walking carefully, with his hat in his left hand.
He stopped at the foot of the steps. He looked up, past Marden, past Della, to where she stood at the top by the parapet, and for a moment the soft tired handsome face did something she had not seen it do at Ashlen. It looked relieved.
“Miss Vale,” said Hollis Vane. “I am sorry to come uninvited. The tide, as you say, is not mine to choose.”
“What are you doing here?”
“I have come to ask you for a favor.” He lowered his hat. “I have a daughter, you see. Esme. She is twenty-two, and she lives in Ashlen, and she has an ear.”
Nobody moved. Behind her she heard Iven draw a long breath.
“She is the reason I could not tell you the whole of it,” said Vane. “She is the one the Trust has always wanted, and the one the Directors know about. It is not the seats I cannot stand to keep, Miss Vale. It is her name on the roll.”

