The trapdoor under the keeper’s chair had not been opened in forty years, and somebody had opened it that afternoon without leaving a mark on the dust.
Leda saw that first, kneeling at midnight on the oak dais with a shuttered lantern at her knee, and the sight went through her like cold water. The boards round the hatch were gray with a generation of lamp-black. The hatch itself, a square of black oak with an iron ring, had a clean bright crescent on the rim where a lever had been set. And on the floor beside it, quite distinct, lay a small bright curl of brass shaving, like a ribbon of butter.
“There,” said Bram.
He crouched on the other side with his stick across his knees and his hand flat on the planks. He had not slept. His face in the lantern light was drawn and old, and his voice was a thread. “It was a small tool. A wrench, or a gouge. They were quick. But they weren’t careful.”
“Who had the keys to the hall?”
“Della. Marden. Tove for the council.” He swallowed. “The council voted at four on the hundred-and-first to let the Dunmore engineer look at the hall. For the report. Mr. Sallow asked it as a courtesy, and nobody could think of a reason to say no.”
“The engineer. A man named Pritchard.”
“Aye. I saw him go in with the council clerk. He had a bag. He was in a quarter of an hour.” Bram’s hand tightened on the stick. “I didn’t think anything. I’d been in the ring since noon.”
“Neither did I,” said Leda.
It was true. She had stood at the door of the hall that very afternoon with a mug of tea, and seen a polite young man in a blue coat go in with a leather bag, and had thought, *there goes another man to measure us.* She had gone back to the circle. She felt it now as a small cold stain, the sort of mistake one remembers.
Wren knelt beside her. He had come without being sent for, in the gray overcoat Dunmore had dismissed him in, with a tin lamp and a small canvas tool-roll. He put his gloved hand on the ring and lifted the hatch.
---
It opened on a shaft no wider than a chimney, with iron rungs, and the smell that rose from it was cold stone and wet weed and, very faintly, brass oil.
She went down first. It was fourteen feet, and the rungs were dry. Iven had come in at the door behind them with Tove, silent, and now stood at the top of the shaft with his back against the chair’s pedestal, holding the lamp one-handed, with the log on the boards at his feet.
He had not said a word. She did not need him to. In the little round of light above her head she could see the shape of his sling, and his chin, and that he was counting.
At the bottom the shaft opened into a cell no larger than a cupboard.
The seat was smaller than the pier’s. She had expected a giant, a grandfather of brass. It was a plain gray cylinder the height of her waist, bolted to the rock, with a single heavy pawl on one side and a cracked dial on the other. The needle shivered at the red line. And under the dial, on the lowest curve of the housing, where no one would have looked who was not looking, a short bright stud of brass had been screwed into the metal.
She put her lamp to it. It was no longer than her thumb, with a little wheel for a head and a thread of clear fluid weeping from its tip. A drip. A drop, a pause, a drop. Under it, on the rock, a small bright pool.
“A bleed valve,” said Wren.
He had come down the shaft behind her. He crouched, with the knees of his gray trousers on the wet stone, and looked at the thing without touching it for a very long time.
“I know it. It’s a Dunmore pattern. A tap-valve, with a wheel. It’s fitted to a seat’s sleeve to relieve pressure.” His voice was perfectly flat. “That is to say, to ease it. Turned a quarter, it slows a trip. Turned the other way,” he stopped.
“It hastens it.”
“It draws off the fluid that damps the pawl. The less there is, the faster it counts.” He lifted his lamp, and she saw that his face had gone the color of old paper. “It is a thing I have seen done in a drawing. I did not think anyone would be so foolish as to do it in a living root.”
Leda looked at the thread of fluid. It was running steadily, a drop to every beat of the tick, down the curve of the metal and into the pool, and in the dim wet light it was the exact color of tea.
*Tick.*
She felt, in her own palm, the long stubborn shudder of the root round the seat. It was in pain. It had been, she understood, in a small quiet continuous way, for a day and a night.
---
It took the three of them an hour to stop it.
It could not be simply unscrewed. The valve had been turned wide open and the thread was cut cleanly, and if it were drawn out in one pull the sleeve would give, the damping fluid would run out all at once, and the pawl would release against a root that was not ready. Wren said it in a low voice, with great care, while the lamp hissed. He had seen it tried once, on a quay in the north, and it had cost a man his hand.
So they did it as Perrin would have. Slowly, in order, with a hand on the root.
Bram came down at one o’clock, grim and white, with Fenn at his shoulder, and Leda put them on either side of her with their palms flat on the rock. She did not say what she wanted. She had not words for it. She only said, *hold,* and they held, and the root in the dark under the hall leaned very slightly into the three of them, like a dog against a leg.
“Now,” she said.
Wren turned the wheel a quarter-turn. It was stiff. It fought his fingers, and a bead of sweat ran down the side of his face and fell on the brass. He turned it again. The thread of fluid slowed. A second quarter, and it was a bead every five beats. A third, and it stood quivering on the tip, and did not fall.
“Closed,” he whispered.
“Hold her,” said Leda.
She laid her hand on the seat. It was cold, and wet, and sticky with the stuff, and the root beneath answered at once, with a shudder, a long slow involuntary relief, like a held breath going out of a lung. And under it, so quietly she thought she imagined it, the tick.
She counted. She counted twenty-one.
“Twenty-one seconds,” said Iven, from the top of the shaft. His voice came down very small. “It’s coming back. Twenty-two. Twenty-three.”
Nobody moved. They stayed where they were, three hands on the stone and a man with a wrench, in a cupboard of rock under a chair, for another quarter of an hour. At the end of it the tick had settled at twenty-six. It was not the old pace. They could not undo what the drip had taken. But it was a number a person could breathe on.
Fenn was crying, soundlessly, with his hand on the rock. He did not seem to notice. Bram had shut his eyes, and his lips were moving.
“What are you saying?” whispered Leda.
“*Here,*” said Bram. “That’s all. *Here. We hold. Stand down.*”
---
Marden dealt with it at nine the next morning, in the customs house, with the door shut, in a manner that Leda thought would be remembered for years.
He did not shout. He had the valve on the table before him, in a clean white cloth, with the damp still on it. Beside it lay Wren’s sworn account in three plain pages, and the council clerk’s record of who had entered the hall on the hundred-and-first, and the sealed pail of fluid the three of them had drained.
He sat behind them in the chairman’s seat, with his scarred jaw set and his big hands folded, and he waited until the Director of Dunmore had been fetched from the gate-house and given a chair.
“Mr. Sallow. Does this belong to your firm?”
Sallow put on his pince-nez. He looked at the little brass stud for a long moment with an expression of the deepest interest.
“It is certainly a Dunmore pattern. I recognise the stamp.” He lifted his eyes. “May I ask where it was found?”
“On the seat under the roster hall. Fitted yesterday afternoon, between the hours of four and five, by a man who entered with the council’s leave.” Marden did not blink. “Your engineer, Pritchard.”
“Mr. Pritchard is a competent young man. He was instructed to take readings.”
“With a bleed valve.”
“I cannot think he would have.” Sallow’s voice was still easy, still warm. “It must be some mistake. A misunderstanding of the pattern. I shall of course look into it myself.”
“You will not need to,” said Marden. “I’ve had him sent for.”
There was a pause. The door opened. A council officer came in, and behind him, between two wardens of the town, a young man in a blue coat with a leather bag, and a face as white as milk.
He lasted about a minute. He was perhaps twenty-six, plump, anxious, and he had very plainly been up all night. He said that he had been told it was a sensor. He said that Mr. Sallow had given it to him on the Gannet, in a small box, with a note, and had said it would help to take a reading and that it must go in on the quiet.
He said he had not thought it would do any harm. He said that when he heard the hall was a *real* root he had tried to go back, and been too afraid.
“Where is the note?” said Marden.
“I burned it.”
“That was foolish.”
“I know, sir.” The young man’s chin trembled. “I’m very sorry.”
Sallow had not moved. He sat with his hands folded on his hat and his head a little on one side, and when Marden looked at him he gave a small, regretful, perfectly charming shrug.
“Poor Pritchard,” he said. “He is young. The Directors, I fear, will be very much distressed.” He rose, with a slight bow. “I shall of course withdraw the offer of the Jack, in the circumstances. And I shall take Mr. Pritchard back with me, to answer for it at the proper place.”
“You’ll go,” said Marden. “Both of you. By noon.”
“As the council wishes.” Sallow picked up his hat. At the door he paused, and turned, and said in a conversational tone, as one remarks on the weather: “The thaw, Mr. Chairman, is on the hundred-and-ninetieth day or thereabouts. I think you will find us waiting at the gate, with a writ from the Court of Leases, and a little more than a piston.”
---
It was Vane who taught them the words.
He came into the roster hall at dusk, in his shirt-sleeves, with his scarf round his neck and his hat in his left hand, and stood in the doorway until Della looked up and nodded. The sixteen were already in their ring on the boards. The stoves had been banked. Tove stood at the east end with his watch and his log, and Iven at the west, and between them the hall was very still.
“I have been thinking about what went wrong on the ninety-seventh,” said Vane. “The fear that ran round. I think I know why.”
“Go on,” said Della.
“My grandfather’s notes. I have the answerers’ book by heart. He wrote that the old keepers did not answer in silence. They answered in *time.*” He set his hat down on a bench. “All together. A single line, said aloud, over and over, at the same pace, so that a ring should move as a single body. The fear could not run round, because there was nowhere for it to go, no gap between one voice and the next. It was not a charm. It was a drum.”
“Here,” said Della slowly. “We hold. Stand down.”
“The very words. But said in a beat.” He lifted his left hand, and brought it down, softly, on the arm of a bench. “Like rowers.”
Leda looked across the ring at Ysolde. The old net-woman sat with her gray head bent and her hands flat, and for a long moment she did not move. Then, quite suddenly, she began to hum.
It was not the old words. It was a net-song, a dull little tune of three notes that every child of Saltwake had been sung to sleep with, and she hummed it under her breath in the rhythm of a needle through a mesh. *Over and under and through.* It was Nettie’s song. She had heard the child singing it on the roster floor, week upon week, in an absent sweet voice, while she swept.
The three notes ran round the ring. First Tali took them, then the baker, then Marden’s daughter. And over them, to the tune, in a murmur that was half chant and half prayer, Leda heard her own voice say it.
*Here. We hold. Stand down.*
*Over and under and through.*
---
They held for forty minutes.
It was the longest they had done. It was also the quietest, in a way that she could not afterward explain. The chant lay over the ring like a net over a boat, a faint steady throb that carried them from one breath to the next, and when the fear came, as it came in Fenn at the twenty-fifth minute and in the baker at the thirty-second, it did not run.
It reached the edge of a voice, and found the next voice waiting, and stopped, like a ripple against a wall.
Tove called the minutes. Iven called the faces. And at forty minutes, by Tove’s watch, Della said *let go,* and sixteen hands came off the boards with a sound like a long sigh.
Nobody spoke. Ysolde was weeping, quietly, without any shame. Fenn had his head on his knees. Under the boards the Kindly lay very quiet, and the tick, which had been twenty-six, was twenty-eight.
Vane stood in the doorway with his hand pressed flat against the frame. He had not come into the ring, or sat, or touched the floor. But there was an odd look on his face that Leda did not at first understand, a strained inward listening, such as she had seen on Bram’s.
“Mr. Vane,” she said.
He did not seem to hear.
“Mr. Vane. Are you all right?”
“I heard it,” said Hollis Vane.
He said it very softly. He took his hand from the frame, and looked at the palm, as though it belonged to someone else.
“I told you at Berth Nine that I had no ear. I told the Court. I told my own daughter, when she was small, that I could not hear what she heard.” His voice shook. “It was not true. I have heard it all my life. Since I was a boy. I have heard every seat my father ever set, humming and ticking in the dark, on every quay I ever walked. And I have never told a soul.”
Nobody breathed.
“I thought if I said I could not hear it,” said Vane, “they would never ask me to answer.”

