Judge Imogen Pruitt had a reputation for eating lawyers, and a lunch of cottage cheese at her desk.
The Carl B. Stokes courthouse in Cleveland rose over the lake in a sheet of gray limestone, with a lobby like a train station and a security line like a very long wait for a very small prize. Dee stood in it at eight-forty on Tuesday morning, in her good black suit, with her shoes in a plastic tray and her hands held out for the wand. Ines was ahead of her. Mattias, who had not been permitted past the lobby, was behind a rope, where he stood with his hands in his coat and the immovable expression of a man who has decided not to be a problem.
"It's a motion for return of property," said Ines in the elevator. "In the ordinary run it takes six weeks. We are asking for six days. I have filed an affidavit from Sister Perpetua, a declaration from Mr. Brannigan, the heron ring, the Heron Memorial Society's articles, and a very long letter. If she asks anything, you answer yes ma'am and no ma'am. You do not make speeches. You are a funeral director. They find us reassuring."
"Do they?"
"No. But they expect to." Ines checked her watch. "Theo Merrow texted me at seven. Anselm Pyke did not come to work on Monday and has not been seen since. Theo says his mother has not slept."
Courtroom 17A was paneled in pale ash, with a high bench and a flag. At the government's table sat AUSA Carrow, a stout, ruffled man in his forties with an expression of permanent apology, and beside him, in a navy suit, a thin young lawyer with a briefcase that had been chosen to look expensive. Behind them, in the first row of the gallery, in a charcoal overcoat, sat Special Agent in Charge Calder.
He did not look at Dee. He was a lean, tidy, ordinary man, fifty or so, with sandy hair going gray at the temples, and the smooth neutral face of a man who has been told, all his life, that he looks trustworthy. Beside him sat Priya Lund, in the second row, deliberately a seat away, with her hands in her lap.
"All rise," said the bailiff.
Judge Pruitt entered fast, in a black robe worn like a coat, and took the bench before anyone had finished rising. She was sixty, white-haired, with half-moon glasses, and she did not say good morning. "Ms. Okafor. Mr. Carrow. I have read your papers. I would like to know why I should believe that a steamer trunk is a matter of urgency."
"Your Honor," said Ines, "the movant is the daughter and sole heir of the trunk's owner, Margaret Heron Halloran, who died in 2004. The trunk contains personal effects. It was taken from a sealed room that the movant had a lawful right to enter, under a covenant, by a federal agent who had no warrant for the room itself. The warrant described Lots 0 and 00. The Dry Room is a chamber in Lot 00 connected only by a Swiss lock."
"Mr. Carrow?"
Carrow rose and stuffed one hand in his pocket. "Your Honor, the government's position is that the trunk is potential evidence in an ongoing investigation. The affidavit in support of the warrant describes it as such."
"The affidavit describes a trunk?"
"The affidavit describes, ah, a chamber and its contents."
"Which the affiant had not seen."
"Your Honor." Carrow glanced at the young lawyer, who did not glance back. "The affiant had information from a source."
"Sit down, Mr. Carrow." She turned her glasses on Dee. "Miss Halloran. Is that a trunk with a brass plate?"
Dee rose. "Yes, Your Honor. M. A. H. My mother's initials."
"What is in it?"
"I do not know, ma'am. I was not able to open it. My mother died when I was nine. It has been in that room since April of 2004, and I learned it was there on December thirteenth." She heard her own voice, level, procedural, a little hoarse. "I would like to see my mother's things."
The courtroom was very quiet. Pruitt took off her glasses and rubbed the bridge of her nose.
"Agent Lund," she said. "I see you are on the witness list for the movant. Are you here for the property, or for the government?"
"For the property, Your Honor," said Lund, rising. "With respect."
It took eleven minutes. Lund described, without ornament, the opening of the Dry Room at five-forty p.m. on December eighteenth, the presence of Calder and two agents, the photography of the top drawer and only the top drawer, and the sealing of the trunk with evidence tape that had been applied, she said, before the lid was lifted. "Which is irregular," she said. "Evidence is usually inventoried by the chain. The trunk was sealed before it was inventoried. I do not know why. I was not asked."
Carrow rose, sat, rose again. Calder, in the first row, did not move.
"I find," said Judge Pruitt, writing, "that the government has not shown a need to withhold a decedent's personal effects from her heir. I find that the warrant did not particularly describe the Dry Room. I will grant the motion in part. The trunk and the cabinet will be opened Wednesday, at ten a.m., in the clerk's office, in the presence of the movant, her counsel, a representative of the government, and Agent Lund as an independent witness. The items will be photographed and returned to the movant, with the exception of any item that the government can show, under seal, to be contraband."
"Your Honor," said the thin young lawyer, rising for the first time, "the cabinet is not a personal effect. It is, as we understand, a commercial filing cabinet."
"Then it is a cabinet of her mother's, young man, or it is a cabinet of nobody's, and I will look at its contents either way." Pruitt looked down at him. "Has the government inventoried the cabinet?"
"The top drawer, Your Honor. The other three drawers were found empty."
There was a small silence. Lund, in the gallery, had gone entirely still.
"Found empty," said Pruitt. "On Friday night."
"On Friday, yes. In the, ah, the room."
Ines rose very slowly. "Your Honor, may I note for the record that the government's own photographic log contains no images of drawers two through four? If the drawers had been opened and found empty, I would expect a photograph of an empty drawer. It is, I would have thought, an interesting thing to photograph."
"Mr. Carrow?"
Carrow looked at the table. The young lawyer looked at the ceiling. In the gallery, Calder uncrossed his legs, and for the first time looked straight at Dee, and she saw with perfect clarity that he was not worried.
"Wednesday, ten o'clock," said Pruitt. "Mr. Carrow, you will bring the cabinet with its keys. If there is no key, bring a locksmith. If there are no drawers, bring a very good explanation." She rapped the gavel once. "Adjourned."
In the corridor, as the doors swung, Ines caught Dee's sleeve. "Three drawers," she said, low and fast. "Locked on Sunday night, when you left. Dee, the Dry Room has a Swiss lock. How many keys?"
"One," said Dee. "Sister Perpetua kept it in the bread safe for twenty-two years. I took it. It has been in my purse for nine days."
She reached into her coat, found the key, and held it up between them, a small flat steel thing the length of a finger. It was in perfect order.
"Then somebody emptied three drawers in a sealed room before the Marshal arrived," said Ines softly, "with a key that does not exist."

