The Chair of the Priority Board poured two cups of tea and did not drink either one.
Thea Rosskamp did this every time, and every clerk in the courthouse knew it. She poured, she set one cup in front of her guest, she folded her hands around the other, and she let it go cold while she talked. Odile had once watched her do it through an entire disciplinary hearing. Nobody had worked out whether it was a courtesy or a tactic. Odile had her money on tactic.
“Thank you for coming up so early, Ms. Branagh,” Rosskamp said.
“You sent a runner at seven-fifteen. He was holding a card with my name on it and he looked like he might cry.”
“That’s Dennis. He looks like that at funerals, too.”
The Board Chamber was on the second floor of the courthouse, under a ceiling of pressed tin that had been painted green in some decade nobody could name. A long table of dark oak ran down the middle, with five high-backed chairs on one side and a single wooden stool on the other, for petitioners.
Odile had not been given the stool. She had been given an armchair with a cushion in the corner, beside a window that looked out on the dead lawn. She knew exactly what that meant, which was that she was being treated gently, and being treated gently by the Priority Board was the most frightening thing that had happened to her all week.
Rosskamp was sixty-one, small and straight-backed, with iron-colored hair pinned up in a style that had not changed since she took the chair. She was a Well, one of the eleven. She had a Priority Date older than the courthouse bell. When she talked, she had a way of looking slightly past your shoulder, as though she were speaking to someone standing behind you who was more important than you were.
“I would have liked to tell you before the notice went up,” she said. “Harlan tells me it went up yesterday afternoon. That was a mistake. I’m sorry for it.”
“It was a straight notice.”
“I understand you pinned it yourself.”
“I’m good at straight.”
Something crossed Rosskamp’s face that might have been humor. It was gone quickly. “Let me explain what this is, and then you can tell me what you think of it. Is that fair?”
“I think I know what it is. It’s a resolution to seal my Bore.”
“It is a resolution to seal twenty-two Bores that have not produced Draw in at least ten years. Yes.” She turned the cup a quarter turn. “Do you know how a Bore works, Ms. Branagh? In practice, I mean, not in the Water Office pamphlets.”
“A person has a channel. They sink it. It pulls from the aquifer.”
“And a Dry?”
“A Dry has a channel that doesn’t go anywhere.”
“That is what we all assumed, for a long time.” Rosskamp slid a thin folder across the oak. “Four years ago, when the drought turned, this Board commissioned a study of the aquifer’s decline. It was an ugly, inconvenient study. It concluded that the Draw we measure at the Meter on Audit Day accounts for less than all of the water that is leaving the ground. There is a residual. Something is taking water that nobody has put a name against.”
Odile did not open the folder. “And you think it’s us.”
“We think it may be you. We think a Dry Bore may not be empty. We think it may be open.” Rosskamp’s voice was quiet. “An open channel with nobody holding it, in a county with a falling table, is a leak. Every foot we lose is a well that goes dry in this town. People have started to haul water for their children, Ms. Branagh. I have a sister-in-law who bathes her grandchild in a dishpan.”
The argument was reasonable, which was the worst thing about it. Odile had been prepared for villains. She had walked up the stairs planning her expression for villains. She sat in the armchair with a hundred and fifty pounds of embarrassment sitting on her chest and could not find one thing wrong with what the woman had said.
“What does Capping do, exactly?” she said. “To the person.”
“It seals the Bore. Permanently. Nothing leaves, nothing enters.” Rosskamp paused. “Most people describe a quiet. They say they did not know they could hear until it stopped. It is not painful. It is a loss all the same, and I will not pretend to you otherwise.”
“But I’m Dry. I’ve never had anything to lose.”
“Then you have nothing to lose by letting us do it.”
Odile opened her mouth, and for a second nothing came out. The line was a good one. She was nearly certain Rosskamp had practiced it.
“There is an alternative,” Rosskamp said, and reached into the folder again. “A voluntary Capping. You would sign a consent before the Hearing, and the Board would grant a Quiet Bonus of twelve hundred dollars, paid from the county contingency fund. Your position at the Water Office would be guaranteed for life. I have already spoken to Harlan.” She laid a printed form on the table. It was one page. “It would spare you a public vote. People tend to find those unpleasant.”
Twelve hundred dollars. Odile thought of the Rennick Water Hauling tab, which stood at two thousand one hundred and forty. She thought of it the way you look at a hole in the road, from a safe distance, with an awareness of your tires.
“May I think about it?”
“Of course. You have ninety days.” Rosskamp slid the folder one inch closer. “I would prefer you did not wait until the eighty-ninth.”
“Does the Board have to Cap me?”
“The Board has to vote.”
“That’s not what I asked.”
For the first time, Rosskamp looked directly at her instead of at the space behind her. It was an uncomfortable thing to be looked at by. It was like being measured by a person who had measured a great many things and had not yet been surprised.
“Three of the five seats on this Board are held by families whose Priority Dates predate the county,” she said. “I am the Chair. I have one vote. I would like to be generous, Ms. Branagh, and the arithmetic does not always let me.”
She poured more tea into the cup she was not drinking, and Odile understood that she had been dismissed.
The Records Room was in the back of the Water Office, down a corridor lined with filing cabinets that had been painted the color of mustard. It smelled of paper, dust and old pennies. Odile came in through the side door at a quarter to nine, with the folder under her arm, and discovered that somebody was already inside.
A man in a rumpled tan shirt was kneeling on the floor in the middle of the room, surrounded by fourteen open cardboard boxes. Each box was full of folded charts. He had spread several of the charts on the floor and weighted the corners with a plumb bob, a tape measure and a sandwich. He looked up as she came in and his face assembled a sequence of apologies.
“Oh. I’m so sorry. I’m in your room. I’m not supposed to be. I have a letter. Somewhere.”
“You’re in the Records Room.”
“Yes. It’s bad of me. Truly bad. Harlan said it would be fine, but Harlan says everything is fine, so I wasn’t sure it was a fact.” He scrambled up and wiped his hand on his trousers before holding it out. “Navid Lakhani. I’m the State Extension hydrologist. For the county. On contract. They send me every few years to look at the table and write something unsettling.”
“Odile Branagh. I stamp things.”
“I’ve seen you stamp things. You’re remarkably fast.” He seemed to hear himself and added, “That is a compliment. I apologize if it didn’t sound like one.”
Navid Lakhani was thirty-six or thirty-seven, thin, with gold-rimmed glasses and a pencil behind each ear, as if one had been deemed insufficient. He carried a canvas bag with a state seal on it, and a metal lunchbox, which he set down on a stack of boxes with a degree of tenderness that Odile found strange until she noticed that the lunchbox had a small antenna and a dial.
“What’s in the lunchbox?”
“A logger. For well levels. It’s not a sandwich.” He glanced at the sandwich on the floor. “That’s a sandwich.”
“I wouldn’t have guessed.”
“What are you reading, if I may ask? I can see the Board’s folder. I don’t want to pry.”
“It’s the study,” said Odile. “The one about the residual.”
“Ah.” His whole expression changed. The apologies slid off his face and something sharper and more tired took their place. “Yes. That study. I’m afraid I reviewed the draft. I told them it was not a study. It was a rumor in a binder.”
She looked down at the folder. She had not opened it. She opened it now, and the first page was a table of numbers, and the second page was a map of the county with small red dots on it, and the third page was a conclusion that ran to exactly two sentences.
“They measured wells,” said Navid. “And they measured Draw on Audit Day. And the sums did not agree, and rather than say we don’t know, they said it must be the Dry Bores. Because the Dry Bores are the only Bores nobody can see. I told them that is not evidence. That is an absence of evidence with a plan attached.”
He caught himself. “I’m sorry. I get worked up. I call the residual the unexplained residual, which is as far as I’m allowed to go.”
“You think it isn’t us.”
“I think I don’t have enough data to blame anyone. I’d love to find out. That’s why I’m in your Records Room, surrounded by boxes, eating a sandwich from last Tuesday, trying to find any well log from before the Board took over the Ledger.”
He knelt and tapped the nearest chart. “Everything we have is a hundred years of the same story. Table goes down, table goes down. I want to find a log where it went up. Something to compare with. Any decade at all.”
“Why would it have gone up?”
“Because the old code had a provision for it, and I cannot imagine why a provision would exist if it had never been used.” He fished through the box and held up a bound volume the color of dried tea. “County Code. The first edition. I read it for relaxation, which is why I have so few friends. There’s a section in here, about recharge, that is quite the most sensible paragraph in the entire book.”
He opened it. The pages were soft as cloth. He ran a finger down the margin, found a line, and then frowned at the page.
“I’ve forgotten the number. It’s fourteen, something.”
“Let me.”
She took the book from him. It was a little rude. He did not seem to mind. She turned pages at the speed she turned pages at work, skimming for the shape of the type, until the section number caught her eye. It was short, and it sat on the page alone, as though the typesetter had understood it was out of place.
14-9. RECHARGE WORKS.
Any Bore which shall be shown, by not fewer than two witness wells observed for not fewer than sixty consecutive days, to return to the aquifer a greater quantity than it takes from it, shall be deemed a Recharge Works for the common benefit of the county; and no such Bore shall be capped, limited, or Called upon by any Priority whatsoever.
She read it once with her lips moving. She read it a second time without.
Her heart did something slow and heavy and strange.
“It’s never been used,” Navid was saying. “Not that I can find. The last petition was ninety-five years ago. After that the Board stopped granting hearings under it, and then it just sort of went quiet, the way a clause does. I’ve always wondered why. It’s a perfectly good rule. A person could, in principle, sink a Bore that put water back.”
“That would be insane.”
“It would be extraordinarily rare. The Draw goes one way. Everybody says so. It comes up, and you spend it, and it’s gone. You’d need a Bore that ran backward.” He stopped. “Sorry. You’ve gone pale. Are you all right? Did I say something? It’s the sandwich, isn’t it.”
“It’s not the sandwich.”
“I could open a window.”
“Dr. Lakhani,” said Odile. “How long does it take to put in two witness wells?”
He blinked at her. It took him a second to rebuild the room around the question. “To install? A day. Perhaps two, for the casing. The code requires sixty days of continuous data. So if I’m counting properly, and one should never trust me to count properly, anyone who wished to petition would need to have the wells in place and logging by, oh, day thirty at the latest. For the Hearing. That is if someone wished to. Which, I take it, you do not.”
His eyes went to the folder, to the notice, to her face, and she watched him arrive at something. His voice changed. “Oh. Oh, you’re on the list.”
“Number fourteen.”
“I’m so sorry. That’s a terrible thing.”
“It’s a straight notice,” Odile said. She had said it twice now and it was starting to sound like a joke she could not get out of. She closed the book. She did not hand it back. “How much does a witness well cost?”
“Well. The state would cover the casing, technically, if it were a research installation. I could make that argument. I have a talent for forms.” He brightened, in spite of himself. “Do you have a reason to think you might return water, Ms. Branagh?”
“No,” she said. “I don’t know.”
He waited, polite, with his pencils.
“I have a geranium,” said Odile.
“I beg your pardon?”
“Nothing. I’ll find you after work. Is there anywhere you’re staying?”
“The Cattleman’s Rest. Room six. The bed has a slope.” He offered a card out of his lunchbox with an air of discovering that he was somehow more willing to be useful than he had been that morning. “And I would, if it’s not an imposition, like to know what the geranium does.”
She took the card. It said IDRIS LAKHANI, PH.D., HYDROLOGY, and under it, in his own handwriting, in pencil, SORRY IN ADVANCE.
That evening, in the kitchen on Tin Street, Odile sat at the table with a notebook and two cups.
One cup was empty. One was full. The geranium watched from the sill with its usual air of smug indifference. In the hallway the old clock ticked over, and in the cistern in the back, under its wooden lid, forty-one gallons of water sat in the dark and did not go up or down.
She wrote the numbers in a column, because writing them gave her something to hold.
Ninety days to the Hearing. Sixty days of witness-well data required. Wells in the ground by day thirty at the latest, and she had spent two of them. She had forty-one gallons in a cistern, a debt of two thousand one hundred and forty dollars at nine cents a gallon of hauled water, and a pot of dirt that drank a cup in two seconds.
She had no idea what it meant. She had a clause in a book a century old and a hydrologist who apologized for sandwiches.
She looked at it for a long time.
Then she wrote at the bottom of the page, in letters small and neat as stamps, the only sum that mattered.
Ninety days. Forty-one gallons. She had done worse math on better days.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!