Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 45

Sentence

Dana Osgood called the Bench at ten past six on Tuesday morning, on the jail’s one pay line, and Tess took it in the pantry with the door shut and a cold biscuit in her free hand because she had not been able to make herself eat anything else.

“Gil told me,” said Dana. “All of it. He read it to me from his notes, in order, like a man doing the weather.”

“I let him go.”

“I know you did.”

“I want you to say what you think.”

“I think I’d have done the same, and I think I’ll never forgive you.” The little gray voice was perfectly even. “Both. Together. In the same breath. I’d like you to know that’s possible, because I’ve only just found out myself. Peter chose to get back in that car. It’s the most infuriating quality in a husband.” A pause. “Did he look well?”

“He looked like himself. For about four minutes.”

“Four minutes.” Dana drew a long breath through her nose. “Then it was a good day. I’ll take it. Tess, he said he’s protecting someone in Pocatello?”

“Ruth Ansley.”

“I’ve never heard the name.” The even voice cracked down the middle, once, and mended. “Fifteen years. Fifteen years I’ve sat by that man, and a woman I’ve never met has been sitting by him four. I’d like very much to know whether I’m angry at her.”

“So would I.”

“Find out. And bring me my coat when you do. The real one.” There was something very close to a laugh. “I’d like to see how it hangs on a person who isn’t pretending.”

The line clicked. Of all the people who had been kind to her that week, Tess thought, the sharpest had been the kindest, and she did not know where to put that.

---

The Larch County courthouse had been built in 1911 by a county that believed in the future, and had been losing faith in it ever since. It stood in the middle of the town square with a clock that told the wrong hour and a flagpole that leaned, and at ten minutes to nine on the fifteenth of December it held, in a courtroom designed for forty, a hundred and twelve people standing against the walls.

She came in through the side door behind Gil, in her cleaned flannel and her father’s overcoat, and stopped on the threshold. The Bench had come in its trucks. The Voyles family sat in the third row in a block, Harlan with his bandaged hand across his knee and Nell beside him.

Odell Pruden had been brought in a folding chair. Even Mabel Tarkington had come, in her good hat, and sat in the front row with her cane across her lap and her chin up, like a woman at a christening she had decided to disapprove of.

On the other side of the aisle, alone, in a row of oak, sat nobody.

“That’s Dolores’s side,” said Gil, very low. “Wade said nobody was to sit there. It’s for her.”

Judge Walter Ferris was seventy-one and had been on the bench thirty-eight years. He came in with his robe unbuttoned and a plain brown cardigan beneath it, and he looked at the crowded room with weary affection, as a man looks at a dog that has got on the sofa.

“Sit down, all of you, the ones who can. The rest of you may lean. I don’t want anyone in the aisle.” He eased himself into his chair. “This is the sentencing of Emmett Louis Reyes, nineteen (the file said Raymer until Friday, which was his stepfather’s name, and the clerk has corrected it), on his plea of guilty to conspiracy to unlawfully take game by prohibited means, to accessory after the fact in the death of Perry Olsen, and to aiding and abetting the unlawful taking of persons. Counsel?”

---

Emmett stood very straight at the defense table, in a borrowed brown jacket whose sleeves came halfway down his forearms. His right hand was in a plaster splint to the elbow. Tess had last seen it laid open on the edge of a zinc lid, and she looked away from it, quickly, as one looks away from a stranger’s tears.

The public defender spoke for twelve minutes, ably, and with a tact so heavy it seemed to bow her shoulders. She said that the defendant was nineteen. She said that he had been used by an older man, a man of wealth and ease, who had given him a transmission and a promise.

She said that the defendant had, within a day of being asked, signed a full statement, worn a wire, been bound to a post by silver wire in the snow, and been the only person on that mountain who walked off it with his teeth in his head by reason of his own honesty.

She said that Emmett Reyes had given testimony that closed a case the county had thought unsolvable, and that he had dug, within the last two weeks, with a broken hand, the hole that held the founding records of an entire people.

“He did that in front of me,” said Judge Ferris mildly. “I was there, counsel. I was in a Bronco at the edge of the meadow with a thermos. I saw the hand.”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“I’d like to hear from the family of the deceased. Is anyone here for Mrs. Aarons?”

Nobody moved.

Then Wade rose.

He had been in the second row, between Birdie and the aisle, in a gray wool suit that did not fit him across the shoulders and that he must have worn to a funeral. He came forward slowly. He stopped at the rail with his hands at his sides, a square, slow man with sawdust still in the seam of his collar, and he did not look at the judge. He looked at Emmett.

“I’ve got a statement,” he said. “It’s short.”

“Take your time, Mr. Aarons.”

“I’ve said nothing about my mother for three months. I made a rule. I told the boy and I told the Warden. I said nobody talks about Dolores when we’re on the mountain.” His voice was low and even. “I thought if I didn’t say her name I could keep standing up. It worked, mostly. It worked on a hill.”

There was no sound in the courtroom at all. The radiator ticked.

“Her name was Dolores Rae Aarons. She was seventy-three. She was a seamstress. She could take in a coat in the time it takes you to drink your coffee and you’d never find the seam. She hated cats and fed every one in the county. She sang off-key in the kitchen to a station that had gone off the air in nineteen ninety-four, because she said it was company.” He swallowed.

“On the fourth of September a boy sold her run night to a man for a transmission, and a man with a rifle waited at the gate, and I found her behind the orchard at eleven o’clock the next morning. I’d like it on the record that I knew the boy. I taught him to drive a log truck. I thought he was a good boy. I still think he’s a good boy who did a very bad thing.”

Emmett had not moved. His face was the color of paper. He stared straight in front of him with his jaw locked, like a soldier in a wind.

“I’m not asking you to put him in a cell, Your Honor,” said Wade Aarons. “I voted in August to keep him inside the fence and I’d vote it again. Cells are for men we’ve stopped believing in. I haven’t stopped. But I don’t want him to get away with *easy.* I want him to carry something.”

He turned his head at last, and looked at the sentencing judge. “I want him to carry the name. Every Sunday, till he’s thirty. I want him to go up the orchard row, in whatever weather, and stand at her stone for an hour, and say *Dolores Rae Aarons* out loud. Not me. Him. Nobody else has to listen.”

“That’s an unusual request.”

“It’s an unusual place, Your Honor.”

“It is.” Ferris looked at him over his glasses. “Mr. Aarons, in thirty-eight years I have heard perhaps four victim statements I would call generous. I think that was the fifth. You’ve done a hard thing.”

Wade did not sit. He stood with his hands at his sides, and then, to everybody’s surprise, he turned and looked at the empty row of oak on the other side of the aisle, and said in an odd, thick, tender voice, to the place where she would have been, “There, Ma. I said it.”

Tess found that she could not see. She had her knuckles against her mouth. Beside her Gil took off his hat and held it on his knee. In the third row, Harlan Voyles put his good hand over his eyes.

---

Ferris read the sentence in the plain flat voice of a judge whose doctor had told him to avoid emotion.

Two years in the county facility, suspended. Five years of probation, supervised by the sheriff. Two hundred and forty hours of labor on county and Closure lands, to include, “when the ground allows and the Warden of the Fourteen so directs,” the setting of two memorial stones at the Long Meadow, numbered 99-001 and 99-002, in a place chosen by the Long Table. Restitution in a sum to be fixed by the clerk against the amount of the transmission.

No contact with Mr. Daniel Kessler, or with any employee or agent of Corvane Biosciences, “by any means, including a very polite letter.” And, on the motion of the victim’s son, which the court was unable to find a precedent for and could not bring itself to refuse, attendance each Sunday at the grave of Dolores Rae Aarons for one hour, through the thirtieth of November in the year the defendant turned thirty.

“Mr. Reyes,” said Ferris. “Do you understand each of those terms?”

“Yes, sir.” It came out very small.

“Say the name for me.”

Emmett’s mouth opened. For a moment there was nothing in it. His throat worked. He drew a breath that Tess heard from the back of the room.

“Dolores Rae Aarons,” said Emmett Reyes. His voice broke in the middle and he pushed it through. “Dolores Rae Aarons. Ma’am. I’m sorry. I’m *so* sorry.”

“That’s good,” said Ferris gently. “That’s very good. That’ll do for today. You will have eleven years to improve it.” He glanced at the clock, which said ten past four, and at his own watch, which said ten past nine, and sighed. “This court is adjourned. Warden Okafor, if you’d stay a moment. I’d like to talk about your bond.”

---

He did it in chambers, with the door shut, in a small dusty room full of bound volumes and a stuffed trout. Ferris poured two glasses of something brown from a drawer and did not offer one to Gil, who took the refusal with an air of habit.

“The Friday order is exhausted,” said Ferris. “It lapsed at sunset. Emmett’s labor was within it, nobody ran, and your bond is discharged on that part. I’ve signed the release. I wanted you to hear it from me, not the clerk.”

“Thank you, Judge.”

“The part I didn’t want to say in open court.” He turned the glass in his fingers. “A letter arrived at my house on Saturday, by courier, in a very good envelope. It was unsigned. It said that a county judge’s rulings in the Closure matter might, if appealed, be thought to rest on a private arrangement among old families. It named four.” He looked at Tess. “Mine was one. My wife’s grandmother is buried at the Bench.”

“They’re asking you to recuse.”

“They’re not *asking.* That’s the beauty of it.” He smiled. “I know a letter. It’s a polite way of saying *we’ll make a record.* I won’t recuse. Tell Ms. Feld, because if the Department means to attack me for my wife’s grandmother, they’d better do it while I’m in a mood to enjoy it.”

“Yes, sir.”

“One more thing.” He set the glass down. “Boise called. Voigt’s very short-tempered. She has Kessler in custody on the material-witness paper and a lawyer from Washington who’ll have him out by Wednesday. Kessler has told her one thing, in forty minutes. He says it’s his whole statement.”

“What?”

“That he was never told the Roll was in the ground,” said Ferris. “That nobody told him until the eleventh of December. That when the Board talked about *the book,* it was a different book, and a different hole.” He put his fingers together. “He says there’s a second case. Somewhere in the county. He says he was told to look for it in August.”

The stuffed trout gazed at them with a glass and furious eye.

“August,” said Tess.

“That’s what he said.”

“The sixth?”

“He didn’t give a date. But I thought you’d like to hear it.”

---

It was dusk before she was home. She had stopped at the Two Spoons to eat a slice of Gil’s pie at the counter while the waitress watched her the way one watches a horse that might bolt. She had gone through her notebook twice. *Saw. Know. Guess.* In the third column, for the first time in her life, she had begun to write things down.

*Guess: someone told both Walt and Weir in August. Guess: the same someone made the hotline call. Guess: there is a second case.*

It was not a method. It was a confession. She left the page in.

Burt Haskell had the pipe gate. She could see him from the lane, a large uncertain shape in a deputy’s coat, with a thermos at his feet and a flashlight under his arm, and she knew him only by his boots and the way he stood with his weight on the left leg. She had practiced all day. She had said *Burt, Burt, Burt* to herself in the cab, as one says a phone number.

“Evening, Warden,” he said. He said it with great cheerfulness. “Anything?”

“A little. Your boots.”

“That’s a start.”

“And the way you say *anything.*” She stopped the truck. “Is it quiet?”

“Dogs are in. It’s been quiet since noon.” He hesitated. “Except. It’s nothing. You’ll think I’m jumpy. At about half past four a woman came to the gate. She didn’t come up the lane.

She stood across the road, on the shoulder, by the culvert, and she looked at the house a long while with her hands on a stick. And then she went away.” Burt scratched his ear. “I’d have gone after her. I’d have asked. But I didn’t want to leave the gate, on account of the hotline business.”

“What did she look like?”

“Small.” He frowned. “Tidy. Gray hair, short, like a little boy’s. A green coat.”

*Green,* thought Tess. *Not camel.* And knew, at once, with a sudden clear drop in her stomach, that it did not mean what she had hoped.

“Did you see her face?”

“Not well. She was a long way. But Tess—” Burt looked at the ground. “She looked at me. I mean she looked straight at me, and she raised her stick. Like a person saying hello. And then she did a funny thing. She laid two fingers on her mouth. Like you’d do in church.”

“Burt,” said Tess. “Where’s the gate latch?”

“What?”

“The pipe gate. The one that creaks. On Sunday night, at about nine, it opened and shut on no wind. Ansel said it was you.”

“It wasn’t me. I wasn’t on till Monday.” He looked at her. “I thought it was Ansel.”

The wind rose in the spruce.

She felt it with the whole of her skin, a small cold quiver of attention at the back of her neck. The pipe gate across the lane stood open an exact two feet. It was the gap that a tidy small woman with a stick might choose to go through.

She was standing in the barn door, a hundred feet up the lane.

Tess had not heard her cross the yard. She stood in the long yellow light from the barn lamp with her back to the wall and her stick planted in front of her in both hands, as a woman stands in a church porch. She was very small. She was tidy. She had pewter hair cut short like a boy’s, and a plain wool coat the color of a spruce bough, buttoned to the throat, and a face like a winter apple, lined and brown and entirely composed.

She smelled of lavender soap and woodsmoke and something dry and green, like the inside of a tin.

“Warden,” said Ruth Ansley. She had a voice like a bell wrapped in flannel, low, courteous and tired. “I’d have come on Sunday. I lost my nerve at the gate.”

“You called the care home.”

“I did. I wanted to hear if he was still in his room.” Her eyes were gray and very clear, and the lines around them were a lifetime of care. “He wasn’t, of course. I knew that. It’s only a thing one does.”

“You wrote the note in the ceiling.”

“I wrote the note. I wrote the *14* on the back of the photograph, in my own hand so you could compare it, and I’m sorry, my dear, it was theatrical. I’d been taking it down the corridor in my head for forty years and I wanted the last page to have a flourish.” She smiled faintly.

“I did not wear Dana Osgood’s coat. I want that said first, before anything. I bought a coat to match it. I wore it exactly once, on the twenty-fourth of November, to be photographed beside a bed. I never in my life waved at a child from a porch.”

“Then who did?”

“A girl.” Ruth looked at the lit window of the Bench kitchen, where a small figure was drawing at the long table with a green pencil. “I never wore her coat, Warden. I taught the girl who does to stand like her.”

Burt had put his hand on his belt. Tess raised her own, quietly, and he lowered it.

“What girl?”

“She’d tell you she has no name. That’s the one thing she was taught, and it’s the one thing I’m sorry for.” Ruth took a step into the light. The stick did not tremble. “I’ll tell you the rest.

But you’ll want to be sitting, and I’d like to do it in a room with a stove, because I’m eighty-three and I’ve driven from Pocatello without eating. And before I start, there’s a thing I’d like to see. Peter said you had it. Peter, on the twenty-fourth, told me you’d be the one to carry it.”

“What?”

“The pencil,” said Ruth Ansley. “The T. In Margit’s book. I’ve waited most of my life to be shown it.”

---

They gave her Chukwuma’s own chair by the range and a bowl of pepper soup, which she ate in small even spoonfuls, like a woman performing a ceremony.

Ansel stood at the back wall with his arms folded. Greta, who did not know any of them that night, was brought down in a shawl by Birdie and sat by the stove and said, with great graciousness, that it was a pity about the weather.

Tess fetched the ledger. Gil brought the sealed case from the sheriff’s safe, under the orange tape, and cut it with a penknife at four minutes past seven, in the presence of Nora Feld on speakerphone and Moreau the stenographer, who said sleepily from Boise that she had begun to look forward to these. They opened the great flat book to the page of the ninth of November, 1962, and laid it under the lamp.

Ruth Ansley took out a pair of spectacles from her coat, and put them on, and bent over the page.

She looked at it for a long time. She did not touch it. She looked at Margit Haugen’s firm black handwriting, and at the faint gray groove of the pencil beneath, the small round T and O, the T with its little foot to the stem. Her hands were folded on the head of her stick. Her face did not alter, and somehow it grew older.

“Well,” she said at last, very softly. “I’d hoped it was only since August.”

“What do you mean?”

“The girl, Warden. The one who writes in pencil.” She took off the spectacles. “I taught her to write that T. I thought it her own doing, this month, a bit of malice or a bit of grief, and I’d have forgiven it.” Her gray eyes came up, wet and very steady.

“But I was nineteen in 1962. I learned that T from a copybook, from the woman who taught me, and I taught it to the girl from the same copybook, so that her hand would be the old hand. That letter in Margit’s book is older than anything I know. Someone has been writing a T in this county for sixty-four years, Warden, and it was never the girl. I only taught her to look as though it was.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!