Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 53

The Eleventh Hand

He would not come into the kitchen until she had put out the salt.

Tess understood why, when she saw how he looked at it. Tobias Tull stood in the doorway with his white head bare and his hat held against his chest in both hands, and his eyes went to the little saucer on the long table before they went to her face. It was the glance of someone who has been told, in childhood, that certain doors had a price and has spent sixty years not testing it.

“It’s only bread and salt,” said Tess. “Sit, Mr. Tull.”

“It’s guest-right.”

“It’s a chair. The right is the other thing.”

“Ma’am,” said the old man, “I’ve not been a guest in a house like this since I was six.” He crossed the room. He moved as tall old men do, a little stiffly, as if each joint had been checked at the door and handed back on the way out. When he reached the table he took a pinch of salt between thumb and finger and laid it on his tongue, and closed his eyes.

She waited. The clock over the range ticked. Outside the wind had come up, and had a thin snow in it that ticked on the glass.

“Thank you,” he said, in a voice that had gone rough. “I didn’t think the gate would open.”

“It didn’t for me.”

“No. It’s for Eleven.” He opened his eyes. They were pale, a washed-out blue, red at the rims, and perfectly steady. “I came to give back something. And to say I’m sorry. I don’t know which should come first. I’ve been up all night working it out in a state car, and I got no further than the cattle guard.”

“Say whichever’s harder.”

“Then I’ll start with my name.” He sat. He put the hat on the table, brim down, with a care that was almost tender. “Tobias Tull. Born in Closure Eleven, eighteenth of March, nineteen fifty-six. My aunt was Lena Tull, who taught the school. I’m the one she put in the truck.”

---

It was not a long story, but it took him a long time to tell it, because he kept stopping to lay his hand flat on the table, as though it might lift.

Eleven, he said, had been thirty-one souls and a handful of children on a land trust in the high desert, a little place of dry fields and one-room buildings, with a school and a church that was also a granary. The Quiet Ones: that was the Department’s name, and the Closure’s own name for itself was only *the Table.* Nobody there spoke much.

They had a way of keeping faces, a way of keeping each other, and it was done in the evenings with bread, and a ring of hands, and the children sitting up to see.

“Then the Department wrote,” he said. “In October. They said Eleven was *decayed,* that the Compact had lapsed there, that the land would revert. They said the children would be taken into care. They sent a man with a very nice voice.”

“F. Weir.”

“Franklin Weir, assistant to the Commissioner. He came in a black car with a doctor in the passenger seat.” He swallowed. “Leland Ames. The elder. He had a bag. He examined each of the children on the school steps in front of the others. He wrote something on a pad.”

“Thirty-one,” said Tess, because it was the number she knew.

“Thirty-one on the Table, not counting the seven of us they thought too small to count.” He gave a rough, ashamed little laugh.

“My aunt had a plan. I can see that now. She’d have had it in a week if they’d given her a week. They gave her a night. Anna Redbird walked the thirty-one through the dark to the Bench, because Margit Haugen had written to say, *the gate will open.* That was the walk, the one you’ve heard about. They went in on foot, with the lamps out.”

“And you?”

“I went in the truck.”

He looked at his hand.

“Seven of us. The youngest, the ones who couldn’t walk that far in the cold. And my aunt driving a hay truck with a false floor, along the county road, at four in the morning, with a Department car behind us. She stopped it at the Cascade junction.”

He paused. “I know about that now. They arrested the lot of us. The Department took us in, as *wards,* seven children and one woman who’d stolen a truck. They said there’d be a hearing. There was never a hearing. Aunt Lena they sent east. I never saw her again.”

Tess said nothing. She had a pencil in her fist, and she had broken it, quite quietly, without noticing.

“Margit Haugen came to the car,” said Tobias. “The same morning. I remember because it was getting light, and she stood on the gravel by the black car, a very small woman in a man’s coat, and she talked to Weir for a quarter of an hour. And then she took me by the hand and put me in the front seat. I was six. She knelt down and said, *Tobias, this afternoon you’re going to be very brave and carry something for me.*”

“Carry what?”

“A book.” He closed his eyes. “She had found a school satchel for it. I didn’t know yet how heavy it would be. I sat in that front seat all the way back up the county road with my hands in my lap, and nobody spoke.”

“A book,” said Tess. “Closure Eleven’s ledger. The one the card in the case says F. Weir received.”

“I suppose. I never opened it. I thought it was a Bible.”

---

It was ten past one in the morning, and by then there were five of them in the kitchen.

Gil had come in from the barn, ponderous and gray, and stood by the range with a mug of coffee he had not touched. Ansel had come down the stairs in his socks, with both feet wrapped in clean cotton, and settled against the wall. Ruth Ansley sat in her chair with her stick across her knees and her face turned toward the old man, and she had not spoken once. And Wynne stood in the pantry doorway in her overlong gray coat, with her arms wrapped around herself.

She had come down without being called. She had not come any further. It was, Tess saw, quite beyond her.

“I know you,” said Wynne.

Tobias looked up. For a moment she thought he would rise.

“I know you,” the girl said again. Her voice was low and hoarse. “You were one of the seven. You’re Tobias, Lena’s sister’s boy. There’s a picture of you in the ledger. It’s in the back, behind a flap, a little boy in a coat that’s too big. I’ve kept your face since I was twelve.” She drew a breath. “I thought you were dead.”

“I’m sorry,” said Tobias Tull.

“You rode in with them.”

“Yes.”

“You rode in the car. You *drove* the car. I saw you at the gate.”

“I’ve been the Department’s man for eighteen years, miss.” He said it simply, with his washed-out eyes on hers. “Idaho State Police first, thirty years, and I retired a major. Then a state liaison to the Interior Office, which was Mr. Weir’s idea. Franklin’s son. He remembered a boy the Department once raised, with no kin, and when Anita fell ill he said, *Tobias, you’ve been a good boy all your life, and there’s a very nice place in Boise for your wife.*”

“Your wife.”

“Anita. She’s seventy-one. She’s had the forgetting since ‘nineteen.” He turned his hat over, once, on the table. “She’s in a place called Corvane Care. A very good place. They look after her for nothing, as long as I do what’s asked. I’ve driven that car for them for eight years, on top of the rest.”

It was so quiet that Tess heard the snow.

“What did they ask?” said Gil, very low.

“Nothing that was ever wicked, Sheriff. That’s how they do it.” Tobias’s lip trembled.

“To drive. To sit in a car. To say, if an officer asks, that I was there on the Department’s business. I never touched a child. I never took a book.” He swallowed. “Then three months ago Mr. Weir said they’d be needing someone who knew the Bench. And I thought, they’ve found it. I thought, the girl’s the last of us, and they’ve found her, and I’ll be in the car when they take her. And I couldn’t.”

“So you came.”

“I came at midnight, because I’d been told you’d bar the door, and I didn’t want to be shot at the cattle guard by a man called Burt.” He gave a ghost of a smile. “And because I remembered the gate. I’ve dreamed of it every winter of my life. The little iron one with the two bars. I never knew if I’d made it up.”

“You didn’t,” said Wynne.

---

“There’s a thing in the record that doesn’t add up,” said Tess.

She had not meant to say it yet. But the old man had been looking at his hands for so long that she found she could not wait, and so she laid it out, as plainly as she could, in the lamplight. Walt’s card. The zinc lid. A ring of fourteen, with thirteen ledgers and one empty slot, and a note in the slot, *received for the Department, one ledger, nine November,* signed F. Weir, assistant.

And a lid that, in the autumn of 1962, nobody on this earth had opened without fourteen palms. “I’ve been through the Bench’s own papers. Margit swore she’d never leave that lid unlocked. There was no ring written down. How did he get Eleven’s book out?”

Tobias looked at her.

“He didn’t,” he said. “I did.”

“You.”

“Margit didn’t tell me that part. She told me afterward, in a letter, when I was twelve and in a boys’ home in Pocatello and she had found out where. I’ve kept it for fifty-eight years.” He put his hand into his coat and brought out a flat envelope, soft with age, and laid it on the table. “She wrote that the lid was made to be opened by its own. That’s why there are fourteen hollows.

“Each Closure’s hand, one hollow. If a Closure *chose* to be released, it could open its own slot alone. That was the clause. *A Closure released by its own hand may be taken back by its own hand.*”

Ruth Ansley drew a sharp breath. “She wrote that into the Compact.”

“She wrote it into the lid, ma’am. It’s in the hinge.”

He turned to Tess. “They drove me out to the Long Meadow that same afternoon, in the black car, with Margit and Mr. Weir and the doctor. They dug up the case. I stood in a hole with a man with a very nice voice, and he put my hand in a hollow, the eleventh, and said, *Say yes, Tobias.* And I said yes.

“And it opened, only the one slot. I took out the ledger of Eleven, because it was mine, and put it in the satchel, and carried it to the car in both arms with my chin on top. It was the heaviest thing I’d ever held. I thought if I put it down it would be the end of the world. Then I handed it to him.”

*It was heavier than he was.*

“Wait,” said Tess. “Wait. That’s a release.”

“Yes.”

“A closure *given* by its own hand. That’s what he wanted. A paper showing that Eleven was never seized. It *gave itself.*” She had gone cold from the scalp down. “And the hand that gave it was a six-year-old child’s.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“Which means it was never lawful.”

“I don’t know what it means,” said Tobias Tull, wearily. “I only know I said yes in a hole in the ground to a man who held my wrist. And that for sixty-four years it was the thing in my life I couldn’t put down.”

The pencil, in two halves, lay at Tess’s elbow. She looked at it, and then at Wynne, in the pantry door, who had not moved. And she saw the girl’s face go, slowly, from stunned to still to something else, a hard, bright, dawning look that Tess had last seen on Ruth at the Bench gate when she said *I taught it to her myself.*

“*May be taken back by its own hand,*” said Wynne.

“That’s what she wrote.”

“Eleven has a hand.” The tawny eyes lifted. “Eleven has a hand, and it’s *mine.*”

---

The thing that came out of the old man’s coat was a card.

It was an index card, soft and brown, with a typed head and a sheet of pink carbon clipped behind it, and he had carried it, he said, since March. A clerk in the Receiving building had let it fall on the floor and he had stepped on it and, being a policeman, had not been able to resist picking it up. He had put it in his shoe. He had gone on putting it in his shoe for nine months, as if the thing might one day be spent.

*RECEIVING AUTHORITY. Intake of ward. Ward 7-19.* The date, in neat type, *9 Mar. 2015.* A line of numbers, then *Sex: F. Approx. age: 8 yrs. Retains: YES (marked). Source: Spokane, voluntary guardian.* Under that, in a quick, looped hand, a signature. *L. M. Ames, M.D.*

And every o on the card sat a thousandth of an inch too high.

Tess did not say anything. She turned it so that Wynne could see, and Wynne came across the kitchen and bent over it. And from across the room Gil said, in a gray, unsteady voice, “March of ‘fifteen. Eight years old. That’s nineteen now, near enough.”

“It’s the same machine,” said Wynne.

“It’s in a clinic in Boise,” said Tess. “And the man who owns it signed the birth record that says she’s seventeen.”

“That’s perjury, if it’s sworn,” said Gil. “That’s the whole of the petition. That’s a forged certificate in front of a judge.”

“If we can get it in front of a judge.” She laid a hand flat on the card. “Mr. Tull. You’ll swear to where this came from.”

“I’ll swear.”

“It will cost you.”

“Ma’am,” said Tobias Tull, with great dignity, “I know the price. I’ve been paying it for sixty-four years in a very much worse coin.”

---

The phone rang at seven minutes past two.

It was not Tess’s. It was in the old man’s coat. It buzzed, in the stillness, with a flat, dry insect sound, and every head in the kitchen turned. He took it out and looked at the screen. His face, which had been gray and steady, lost something. A little color went out of it, then the rest.

“It’s the home,” he said. “It’s Anita’s.”

“Don’t,” said Ansel.

“I have to.”

He answered it. It was a very short conversation, on his side only a few words, *yes,* and *I see,* and *where,* and at the end, quite softly, *please don’t hurt her, she’s afraid of stairs.* When he put the phone down he laid it very carefully on the table, face-up, as though it might still be breathing.

“They’ve moved her,” said Tobias. “Two a.m. A transfer to a facility they call the Annex. In Boise. It’s a *clinical placement.* They say they’ll look after her very well.” He laughed, one cracked syllable. “They said they were sorry to wake me.”

“Then they know you’re here.”

“They know I’m *not* in the car. It’s the same thing.”

“Mr. Tull.” Tess had risen. “I’ll get her out. Gil knows a judge. Nora Feld will file tonight.”

“You can’t, Warden. It’s their building.”

He rose, too, slowly, with both hands on the table. He took the badge out of his breast pocket, an old brass shield on a leather folder, with the state seal on it and a number, and laid it beside the hat. “And now it’s not a thing I can do anything about. I’m done. They’ll take the pension by morning and the pension is the care. I knew they would.” He bowed his head. “I didn’t think they’d be quite so quick. I think that’s the thing I mind.”

“We’ll find her.”

“I know you’ll try.” He looked across the table at Wynne with his pale, ruined, absolutely clear eyes. “Miss. I’m a poor sort of witness. But I’ve put the thing down. I carried it for sixty-four years and it was never mine. It’s yours now. Whatever it opens.”

Wynne did not answer. She had put out her hand and laid two fingers, very lightly, to his sleeve.

---

They put him to bed in the room off the kitchen at three, with Gil’s blanket and a mug of something hot. He fell asleep sitting up, with his hand on his badge. Ruth had gone to bed. Ansel, who had said four words in the last hour, had said a fifth, *Rest,* and had gone to sit on the stair outside the girl’s room with his feet in their cotton wrappings and his chin on his knees.

Tess did not rest. She had the card, and the letter, and the notebook, and she spent the dead hours of the night at the long table making them into a thing Nora Feld could carry into a courtroom. *Exhibit. Exhibit. Declaration of T. Tull.* She wrote it all out in her tidy upright hand, and what it came to, at last, was a shape.

A birth record typed on a broken machine. An intake card typed on the same one. A release of a Closure signed by a child. A ledger that was a fair copy, so a bad book had been given away for a good one. And a lid that Margit Haugen had built, in 1938, with a door in it that only the owner could open.

*Taken back by its own hand.*

She had been thinking for a month that the Roll was a thing to be found. It had not occurred to her that it might be a thing to be *used.*

At twenty minutes to six, with the window going from black to gray, she went up the stair.

Ansel was asleep against the wall, in a heap, his bandaged feet stuck out on the landing like a boy’s. Joss’s door was shut. The little room at the end, the one with the iron bed and the quilt that Birdie had put on it with a small, grim sniff, stood open an inch.

She pushed it.

The bed was made. The quilt had been smoothed and the corners tucked, neatly, like a bed in a school. On the pillow lay the long gray overcoat, folded, with its sleeves crossed, and on top of that lay a piece of the brown wrapping paper from the pantry, in pencil, in a small clear upright hand.

*I am not leaving. I am being walked out. Nobody searches a house for a person who has already gone.*

*Do not follow me to the gate. I will go through it myself.*

*The man in the car was right about one thing. It is heavy. W.*

Tess read it twice. Then she crossed the room to the window and looked down.

The pole light was still off. In the gray the orchard wall was a long dim line, and the pipe gate in the corner of it stood wide open, in perfect silence, and the snow beyond it was already full of small, even, deliberate footprints, going away toward the county road and the nine dark cars.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!