Imogen Strand had a way of reading a document that made the document feel it had been caught.
She did it now, at nine o’clock on Friday morning, in Courtroom 4B, with the radiator ticking under the windows and a thin gray light on the polished rail. She turned the pages of the guardian ad litem’s report one at a time, without hurry, and when she reached the end she laid it flat and looked over her rimless glasses at the man who had written it.
“Mr. Penrose. Summarize.”
Ellis Penrose rose from the third row. He was a long, stooped lawyer of sixty, from Twin Falls, in a corduroy jacket gone shiny at the elbows, with a face like a sympathetic horse and a voice that had been trained out of every inflection. He had spent four hours the night before in the kitchen of the Bench, with Wynne across the table from him and Birdie at the range pretending not to listen.
“Your Honor, I interviewed the respondent for four hours and ten minutes. I examined the 2009 birth record, the 2015 intake card, the 2019 certificate with the altered age, and the so-called Letter of Recovery. I spoke with Mr. Sorrell by telephone. I have three findings.”
“Go on.”
“One. The respondent states that she is nineteen. Her account of her own age is consistent across the interview and with the 2015 card, which says *approximately eight*. The only document that says seventeen is a certificate in which the figure has been struck over by a typewriter. I find no reliable evidence that she is a minor.”
“Two.”
“There has never been a court committal. No order of any court places her in the Department’s custody, or in Corvane’s. I looked. I asked Mr. Pickering’s office on Tuesday, and again yesterday. I’m told the order is ‘in process.’” Penrose permitted himself a very small cough. “It has been in process, by my arithmetic, for eleven years.”
A sound went through the benches, not quite a laugh. Tess, in the first row with her hands between her knees, did not turn her head. She could feel Alan Pickering two seats along, perfectly still, in his gray overcoat, with the air of someone waiting for a train he already knew was late.
“Three,” said Penrose. “I asked the respondent whether she wished to remain in the Department’s care. She said, and I quote, ‘I’d rather be wrong on my own.’ I recommend that the temporary custody order lapse, that the bond be released, and that the petition be dismissed.”
“Mr. Pickering?”
Pickering rose, buttoning his coat. “The Department takes no position on the guardian’s findings, Your Honor. The Department’s interest in the respondent has always been protective.”
“Has it.”
“We’ll withdraw the application for recovery without prejudice.”
“Without prejudice,” said Strand, in the voice of a woman handling something with tongs. “I’ll allow it. I’ll also order, Mr. Pickering, that the file stay in this court under seal, and that anyone who wishes to approach this young woman with a paper do so through counsel, in this room, in daylight. Is that understood?”
“Perfectly.”
“Then the bond is released. Mrs. Haugen, you may have your pasture back. Ms. Okafor, you’re relieved.” She tapped the page. “Ms. Wynne, you may stand.”
Wynne stood in the second row, in Chukwuma’s gray overcoat, with her cuffs turned back and her hands at her sides. She looked suddenly very young, and very alert.
“You’re not anyone’s ward in this courtroom,” said Strand. “Do you understand what that means?”
“It means I can leave.”
“It means that if you stay anywhere, you stay because you chose it. Go and eat something.”
---
The second matter began at ten past ten, and for the first quarter hour it was a masterpiece of calm.
Dr. Leland Ames Jr. took the stand in a gray three-piece suit and was sworn, and looked at the room with a mild patient frown, as if delayed at a dinner. Pickering’s associate, a young woman with a fountain pen, walked him through his letter. Greta Haugen, seventy-five, had shown significant cognitive decline. She had been unable to identify a clock. She had misidentified her visitors, and in the presence of a caregiver had declared herself to be a child.
“In your professional opinion, Doctor, is she capable of managing her affairs?”
“No.”
“And is she capable of managing those of the household that depends on her?”
“I believe the household would be better served by a disinterested friend,” said Ames. “Someone with no stake. A person of long standing.”
“Such as Mrs. Ruth Ansley?”
“Such as Mrs. Ansley.”
Nora Feld rose to cross-examine, and Tess, who had watched her do it at five in the morning with a mouthful of cold toast, saw the little round woman in the rumpled navy suit become something rather different. She took a single sheet of paper and held it down at her side.
“Dr. Ames. Your letter says Mrs. Haugen could not identify a clock.”
“Correct.”
“When did you examine her?”
“Wednesday evening, the sixteenth.”
“At the Bench kitchen, in the presence of twenty-nine people, with a wall clock above the range?”
“I believe there was one.”
“There was. She told you the time, and that your watch was four minutes fast, and that it was the habit of your father to wear it so.” Nora waited. “Did you record that?”
Ames adjusted his cuff. “I recorded the pattern of decline.”
“The letter is dated Monday the fourteenth, Doctor. Two days before the examination.”
It was very quiet. The radiator ticked. Ames sat with his hands on his knees, and a muscle in his jaw moved once, as if to a metronome.
“I prepared a preliminary,” he said. “I updated.”
“Where is the update?”
“I have it in my files.”
“Thank you.” Nora walked back to the table, and set down her sheet. “Your Honor, I’d like to call a witness whom Mr. Pickering has not met. I ask leave to take her out of order. She is in poor health.”
---
Doreen Lisk had come to the courthouse in a wheelchair pushed by Deputy Rojas, with her green oxygen cart at her side and her lilac cardigan buttoned wrong. She had slept in a county infirmary bed under guard and had been given, at six, a bowl of oatmeal and a doctor’s lecture.
She had been sworn at a quarter to eleven. She sat, now, in the witness box, very small, with her hands on her handbag and a plastic tube across her cheeks, and for a moment it seemed to Tess that nobody in the room could look at her at once.
Nora’s questions were quiet and brief. She asked the old woman her name, her work, her years. She asked about the Selectric. She asked what she had typed, and when, and for whom.
“I typed the petition’s second page,” said Doreen Lisk. “The recital and the nomination. On Monday the fourteenth, at the clinic, at about four. I was given a sheet of tracing paper with the signature already on it. I put it under the form and ran it through the machine so that the ink would settle. I was told it was an authorization the lady had given by telephone.”
“Who gave you the tracing paper?”
“A woman in the Receiving office. She does the calligraphy.” Doreen coughed. They waited. “Mrs. Ansley’s hand is very good. It took four attempts. I know, because I threw out three.”
Strand lifted her head. “Mrs. Lisk. You understand that you are saying you assisted in preparing a forged signature.”
“I do, Your Honor.”
“You understand what that means for you.”
“Yes.” The old woman looked at the magistrate directly. “I’m seventy-four. I’ve been an honest typist for fifty years, and I did a dishonest thing on the fourteenth of December because I was told it was a kindness. I’d like it written down that I stopped.”
“It will be written down,” said Strand.
And she was as good as her word. She heard from Baines, in his cardigan, with a laminated chart of the film ribbon. She heard Ruth, who walked up to the box with her stick and her green coat and swore in a voice that rang off the paneling, and said she had never in her life consented to be anyone’s guardian, and that her signature, in her present hand, wouldn’t have passed a bank.
She heard, last, an old, deaf, huge, genial man in a tweed suit with a hearing horn, who had been the county doctor for fifty-three years and was brought into the box on Birdie’s arm.
“Dr. Halloran,” said Nora, raising her voice to a clean projecting shout. “Do you know Mrs. Haugen?”
“I’ve delivered two of her grandchildren!” said Dr. Halloran. “And patched her husband!”
“Have you examined her recently?”
“Tuesday! At her own table!” He tapped the horn against his ear. “She gave me a lecture on my blood pressure! She says I’m *salty!*”
There was a laugh, and Strand, to Tess’s surprise, did not quell it. The old doctor went on, in his loud, kind, aggrieved bellow, to say that Greta Haugen’s mind came and went like weather, and that he had been telling her family so for two years, and that there was a difference between a woman who forgot her keys and a woman who needed a stranger in the house.
He had signed nothing about her. He had been asked, in October, by a “very polite young man with a briefcase,” whether he would, and had said, in his own words, that he’d sooner sign a confession.
“And Dr. Ames?” said Nora. “Does he write to you?”
“Never in my life!” said Dr. Halloran, with enormous contentment. “I don’t care for him. His father was the same. A cold hand!”
---
They had brought Greta herself, because she insisted.
She sat at the end of the front row in her gray shawl, with her white braid over her shoulder and a paper bag on her lap, and Birdie at her right hand, rigid, like a woman guarding a pot on a stove.
Tess had avoided looking at her all morning. It was a small cowardice, but it was hers. There was a place where a face should have been, and the place was bright, and smooth, and empty, and she had learned that the longer she looked at it the more it hurt.
She knew the shawl. She knew the long hands, the cracked knuckles, the rhythm of the breath. She knew the voice. It was only the face that had gone.
“Mrs. Haugen,” said Strand, from the bench. “I’d like to ask you a few questions, if you’re willing. You needn’t answer. It is your right to be heard, and nobody here can make you.”
“I’d like that,” said Greta Haugen.
She said it clearly, and in a high, small, polite voice, and Tess’s stomach turned.
It was the voice of a child. It was the voice of a girl of ten or eleven, very well brought up, who was sitting in a strange room among grown-ups and wanted to do right. She had folded her hands on the paper bag. She held herself very straight.
“Do you know where you are?” said Strand, gently.
“It’s a school,” said Greta. “Is it a school? It smells like a school. Are you the teacher?”
“I’m a judge.”
“Oh.” She considered that. “My mother says a judge can make anybody stand in the corner. Is that right? But I haven’t done anything. I only walked in with the others. We came through the gate.”
She turned in her seat and looked, with grave bright interest, at the gallery, at the men and women of the Long Table who sat in rows in their dark coats, and at Harlan Voyles, who had stood against the back wall through the whole of the hearing with his big hands hanging and his eyes lowered. “Why is Mr. Voyles so sad?”
Nobody answered. A man in the third row had put his hand over his mouth.
“Mrs. Haugen,” said Strand. Her voice was perfectly steady, but she had set down her pen. “Is there anything you’d like the court to know?”
“Yes.” Greta looked at her, and for a moment her whole figure shifted, a small adjustment in the shoulders, as when a lamp is turned a quarter inch. When she spoke again, the voice was low and dry and old, and every word fell like a stone dropped into a well.
“I’d like the court to know that I am a fool, but I am not a fool in the way he means. I forget my daughter’s name and I remember a gate. That’s not a thing you put in a letter.”
She smiled, vaguely, at Strand, at the room, at nobody.
“Is it time for the bread?” she said.
---
Strand dismissed the petition at eleven fifty-one. She did it from the bench, from a handwritten page, in the flat bare voice of a woman delivering the last sentence of a long hard paragraph. She found the nomination to be unsupported and the principal signature to be false.
She found the physician’s letter to have been prepared before the examination it claimed to describe. She ordered the clerk to refer the matter of the signature to the Ada County prosecutor, and the matter of the letter to the Idaho Board of Medicine, and she dissolved the temporary appointment of any person to any office in respect of Greta Haugen.
“And I will say this,” she said, without lifting her eyes. “This court has seen one adult with her wits stolen in the course of a week, and one without her wits made to look in a mirror. I don’t know what is going on in this county. I intend to find out. Court’s adjourned.”
The gavel fell. Pickering was already gone. Ames sat with his head slightly bowed, as if listening to a sermon in a language he didn’t speak. Tess found that she had been gripping the rail so hard that the carved wood had printed itself into her scarred palm.
On the steps, Harlan Voyles was waiting.
He stood with his back to the wall, at the corner of the portico, with his feed cap in one hand and a bundle in the other. It was something round, wrapped in a flour sack and tied up with twine. He did not look at her. He looked at the street, at a bus, at a woman with a pram.
“Warden.”
“Harlan.”
“It’s not that I want to be thanked.” His voice was a quiet rasp. “I’d like to put this where it belongs. I turned my bowl down on Wednesday and told them I’d stand at the gate. It doesn’t sit right, standing at a gate with a vote still in my pocket.”
He held the sack out in both hands. “Take it to the Table. Tell them Harlan Voyles gives up his seat, and the bowl, and the name on the chair. Not for spite. For Lonnie. It’s his name I’ve been holding, and I’m tired.”
“The Table could refuse.”
“They won’t.” He almost smiled. “They’ll give it to Nell. She’s a better listener than I ever was.”
Tess took the bundle. It was warm, and heavy for its size. She held it against her chest, feeling the round, smooth, familiar weight of a bowl made by hands she would never see, and did not trust herself to answer.
---
She found Gil Dunmore in the stairwell.
She had known she would. He had gone out at the break and had not come back, and the Ada County deputy at the door of the courtroom had said that the sheriff of Larch County had gone downstairs to “get some air.” The fire stair at the east end was a gray concrete shaft with a painted yellow rail, a window with wire in the glass, and a single, flat, fluorescent tube.
He sat on the landing between the second and third floors with his hat on his knee and his big shoulders against the wall. He had the look of a very large animal that has been quietly sick for a long time and has decided to stop hiding it.
He did not rise when she came down. He said, in his slow, genial drawl, “Doreen was good.”
“She was.”
“Strand’s going to remember that. I’ve known her fifteen years. She’ll push for immunity.” He turned the hat a quarter turn. “I heard Doreen’s evidence from the hall. I couldn’t come in. It’s the only time in my life I’ve stood in a hall and not gone in.”
“Gil.”
“Warden.” He looked up. His round face was gray in the fluorescent light, his small eyes red. “Is it on the list? Is it Margie?”
She said nothing. She put her hand on the rail and sat down on the step, two below him, with the bowl in her lap. She had not meant to cry, and she found that she was not going to. It was the kind of tiredness that is past that.
“I knew you’d have it by morning,” said Gil. “Rojas called. I’ve been sitting here deciding whether to tell you before you asked.”
“How long?”
“Since ‘ninety-nine. I was campaigning, my first run for sheriff, which I lost, and a man in a brown hat came to a fish fry in the Grange hall and shook my hand. He said he was with the Department, and he admired my wife’s pie.” Gil’s laugh was a small sick noise.
“He knew her maiden name, Tess. Her mother’s name. A woman I’d never met, who died in a nursing home in Weiser in nineteen eighty-one. He told me, kindly, in the parking lot, that my wife was one of a number of persons who’d been, quote, *the Department’s responsibility.* That she’d been placed. That she didn’t know. That it would hurt her very much to be told.”
“And you believed him.”
“I looked at Margie across the lot. She was laughing. She had a pie plate in her arms.” He shut his eyes. “I’d been married to her twelve years. She’d never once said a word about where she came from. I thought, *he’s right. She doesn’t know.* And the man said, ‘We’ll never trouble her. All we ask is that you keep your radio open, and keep the Bench off the wire.’”
“The radio.”
“The radio’s the whole thing, isn’t it? Everybody said so. Ansel said so. Walt said so. A county where the sheriff’s scanner is on every kitchen counter. It was *meant* to be on every counter.” His voice broke, steadied.
“I never gave him a thing about the Bench. Not a name, not a den, not a ledger. I swear on the sheriff’s oath and my wife’s head. I gave him the *weather.* I gave him who was on shift. I told myself it wasn’t a betrayal because it wasn’t *news.* I’ve been telling myself that for twenty-seven years.”
He wiped his face. “I’ll resign. I’ve drafted it. I’ll leave the keys to the evidence room with Rojas.”
“No.”
“Tess—”
“You’ll stay the custodian of the Roll case,” said Tess, “because you’re the only man in Larch County who is already known to have been wrong, and has nothing left to hide. Rojas will co-sign. And you’ll tell Margie yourself. Today.”
He stared at her. Then he put his face in his big hands and his shoulders shook, once, twice, and he said, very low, “She’ll leave me.”
“She may.”
“She might. She’s a better person than I am. She’ll hear it and she’ll put her coat on.”
“And she’ll be alive when she does,” said Tess, “and not in a van.”
For a while neither of them spoke. A door banged on a lower floor. Somewhere a janitor’s cart rolled and stopped. The light flickered once in its tube.
Gil lifted his head, and the expression on his face was one she was to remember, with a clarity she did not want. It was the face of a man who has just remembered something he did not know he had forgotten.
“Margie rang me this morning,” he said.
“When?”
“Eight-ten. Before court. I was in the truck. She said, ‘Gil, don’t be cross.’” He swallowed. “She said a lovely young nurse had knocked on the door on Tuesday, from the county, with a letter. A reunion. A lunch for ladies who had a connection. She said she’d packed a cardigan. She said she was sorry to go early, she’d have liked to bake for it, and not to worry about supper.”
“Where was she calling from?”
“I looked at the number just now.” He held up his phone, with a hand that would not keep still. “It’s a Nampa exchange. It’s not our house.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!