Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 69

Eyes Open

Joan Halvorsen listened to the whole of it with her chin on her fist, and when Tess had finished, she said, in the flat dry Montana voice that had once talked a rancher out of a shotgun, “So you’re asking me to stand in a field and watch you not do something.”

“Yes.”

“For free.”

“Yes.”

“Good,” said Joan. “I was afraid it would be something hard.”

It was half past one in the morning. The Bench kitchen had emptied except for the people who mattered, and the stove ticked in the dark. Tess sat at the end of the long table with her notebook open and a cold cup of coffee. Across from her sat Joan, sixty-three, silver-braided, in a man’s wool shirt, with the gray glint of a woman who had lost a Closure and kept her badge.

Beside her, Tobias. At the head, in a rocking chair someone had dragged in from the porch, sat Birdie Haugen with her arms folded, scowling at the floor.

Ansel stood by the window. He had not sat since they came back from Dutchman Road.

“Say it again,” said Birdie. “The short way.”

“A Warden can’t witness alone,” said Tess. “That’s the hinge. Weir’s whole design is a room where I’m the only one standing, with my eyes shut, saying one word. If I’m the only witness, then whatever happens in that room happens in my memory, and when the lid shuts it takes my memory with it. All of it. All the faces. That’s what Marr told the children: *and then there is nothing to remember.*”

“And if you’re not the only one?”

“Then it’s not a witness. It’s a quorum.”

---

“I’ll tell you what bothers me,” said Joan.

She turned her cup in her fingers. It was a plain white mug with a chip in the rim, and she held it like a thing she’d had a long time, the way some people hold a hand.

“I lost Nine because I was the only Warden in the county. When it went, it went all at once. I stood in a kitchen with my hand on a stove and I felt it go. Like a hinge. And I thought, if there’d been another one of us in the room, anyone, a deputy, a cook, I might have had somebody to look at.” She shrugged. “I never found out if that’s true. It’s only what I’ve thought about for years, nights.”

“It might be true.”

“Might’s good enough.” Joan set the mug down. “Walt taught me one thing I’ve kept. A Warden isn’t a person who sees. She’s a person who says what she saw, to somebody who’ll remember it after. That’s the whole job. You say it and somebody’s got it.” She tapped the table once. “So I’ll stand, and I’ll watch, and I’ll say what I saw. And if I can say it afterward in my own words, then the board hasn’t got it, has it?”

“No,” said Tobias, softly. “That’s Margit’s page, the last paragraph. I didn’t want to read it. *A witness who speaks is not a witness who forgets.*”

“That’s what *witnessed* means,” said Tess. “It means *I’ll carry it.* Not *it’s finished.*”

---

Wynne had the count by half past two, and she gave it to them in her small slanted hand on a sheet torn from a feed-store pad.

She had spent the evening in the bunkhouse with the thirty, going bed to bed with a cup of tea and a pencil and no opinions. She read it out at the table in the flat voice she used for numbers. Eleven were sure they would speak against it in the meadow, whatever it cost them.

Nine were sure they would say nothing and stand at the back. Six wished to go home, and had been told they were free to, and did not want to leave. Four did not know.

“Orrin’s one of the six,” said Wynne. “He says he’d like to be useful, and he can’t see how. He’s afraid he’s already said it.”

“He has,” said Tess. “In 2001. So have Margie and Rudy and Doreen.”

“Margie and Rudy and Doreen are all in the eleven,” said Wynne. “Every one. That’s the part I wrote twice to be sure. Of the four who said yes aloud to Weir and are sleeping under this roof, three want most to take it back, and the fourth is afraid he’s forfeited the right.”

“That’s the whole difference,” said Joan, “between a rite and a confession.”

Wynne looked at her sheet. Then, very quietly, she drew a small neat line under the last name on the list, and held the pencil still. It was her own. She had written *Wynne, one of 211* at the bottom, and then, beside it, in even smaller letters, a thing she did not read aloud.

---

Ruth Ansley brought Peter at three.

They came up the lane in the dark, with Ruth in her green coat, leaning on her stick, with Peter Osgood’s arm through hers, and with Burt in his old Chevy crawling behind with the lights low. The snow had almost stopped. The sky to the east was black with a thin gray line.

Peter was lucid. She saw it the moment he stepped into the lamplight: the way he stopped on the porch and looked at the boards, and at the house, and at her, before he spoke. It was a look she had come to dread and treasure in about equal parts. His good hour had been given back to him, like a coin returned.

“Warden Fourteen,” he said. “I’ve been told I’m needed.”

“If you’re willing.”

“If I’m willing.” He smiled, a gaunt, bright, ruined smile. “I’ve been asked a lot of things since 1971, Ms. Okafor. I’ve been asked to sign, and to sit, and to say what I remembered. I do not think I’ve once been asked to stand in a field and say what I see.”

“It might be dangerous.”

“I’ve the memory of a sieve. I hope you’ll allow me to be more afraid of the other thing.” He took off his hat, and the thin white hair stood up in the lamplight. “I stood alone for Two. I stood alone and I said it, and I’ve been paying for it a very long time. I’d be glad to do it once with two other people.”

“There’ll be three of us,” said Joan, from the table. “You, me and the girl.”

“The girl,” said Peter. “Of course. The girl’s always the third.”

---

They worked at the table until four.

It was Tobias who drafted the words. He wrote in pencil on the back of Margit’s page, slowly, in his lessons-from-Lena hand, and when he had done he read it aloud, and the kitchen listened in a silence that was nearly religious.

The Warden of the Fourteen would not close her eyes. She would not say *witnessed.* If a child said no, she would say, *I saw her say no.* If a child said yes, she would say, *I saw her say yes,* and then she would say what else she saw: who stood where, who held a paper, who wept.

She would say it aloud, in the hearing of the Warden of Nine and the Warden of Two, and each of them in their turn would say what they saw, in their own words, and no two would be alike.

“It’s untidy,” said Tess.

“Of course it is,” said Joan. “That’s the point of it. Marr’s rite is tidy. Fourteen hands in fourteen holes and one word. You can’t tell a lie in a tidy room, but you can’t tell the truth either. You can only agree.”

“And when the three of us have all said what we saw?”

“Then there’s three different memories of it.” Tobias folded the page. “And not one lid on earth is big enough to hold three people’s accounts.”

Birdie got up and put another log on the stove, and stood with her back to them, looking into the fire.

“I’d like it noted,” she said, “that I hate all of it, and that I’ll bring the thermos.”

---

At five, she went out to Odum’s car and opened the trunk.

The caseworker had parked it in the lee of the calving barn, with a blanket over the hood, and slept in it for three hours with her shoes off. She stood now at Tess’s elbow in a coat over her pajamas with a mug of tea going cold in her fist. The evidence bag lay in the trunk where Hoyt had left it, wrapped in a gray moving blanket, and the pine board inside it sat as still as a cutting board has any right to.

“It’s been doing something since midnight,” said Odum. “I don’t know the word. I put my hand on the blanket at two and it was like a dog’s flank. I thought I was dreaming.”

Tess laid two fingers on the plastic.

It was warm. Not as warm as it had been in Caldwell. But as she held her hand there, the warmth moved, a slow pulse running along the grain from the hinge toward the burned *14* in the corner, as if the board were turning over in its sleep. She felt it go through the bones of her wrist, a small, dry, wooden whisper. She could not have said it was a word. But if she had been asked to put one to it, she’d have said *Tamsin.*

She took her hand away. She stood for a moment with it pressed to her coat, as if it had been burned.

“Is it dangerous?” said Odum.

“I don’t know. I think it’s the same as last night. It’s only listening.” Tess shut the trunk. “But somewhere in Notus there’s a bigger one, and I think they talk.”

---

Greta woke at six.

It was a thing Tess had learned to watch for: the particular lightening in the room, the change in the old woman’s breathing. She went in with Ansel behind her and a lamp. The Lead of the Fourteen lay propped on her pillows with her hair in a gray fan and her eyes open, and they were not a child’s eyes any longer. They were seventy-five years old, and clear as water, and very tired.

“It’s the Eve,” said Greta.

“It is.”

“Then I have until noon.” Her voice was dry and quiet. “I know, you needn’t tell me. I can feel the hour. It goes out like a tide, Tess, and it comes in again, and I can tell you to the minute where I am in it.” She patted the quilt. “Sit. I’m lucid. It won’t be long, but I’ll do what I can with it.”

Tess sat. She took the old hand, which was warm and dry and very light.

“There’s a third ask,” said Greta. “Margit never said it aloud. She thought it would spoil it. But I’ve been the Lead for thirty years, and I have stood in a kitchen and a yard and a meadow, and I know what the meadow was.”

“What was it?”

“It was Margit saying my name.” The old woman smiled. “That’s all. That’s the third ask. She didn’t ask me anything. She stood in the grass in her good coat, and she said, *Greta,* and she waited. And I understood that whatever I said next, she would still be there and know my face. She’d remember me whatever I did. It’s the one thing a child can’t be taught, you see. It has to be given.”

“The Warden says the child’s name.”

“And waits.” Greta’s hand tightened. “Not for yes. Not for no. She waits to see what the child does with being known. That’s all they need. It’s all anyone wants.”

---

At seven the kitchen smelled of toast and wet wool, and Connie Ibarra was braiding her daughter’s hair at the end of the long table with the concentration of a woman defusing something.

“It keeps coming out crooked,” said Connie. “She wriggles.”

“I’m a good wriggler,” said Hazel, with her chin tipped up and her eyes on Tess. “Are you going to the judge again?”

“To a policeman. About a sidewalk.”

“Did you do a bad thing on the sidewalk?”

“I stood on it.”

“That doesn’t sound bad,” said Hazel, and thought about it, and decided to be generous. “You can have the last toast.”

Tess took the toast. Over the child’s head, Connie met her eyes and did not ask the question she had been carrying since midnight, which was whether it would be today. Tess did not answer it. Some questions are kinder left standing.

Ansel walked her out to Nora’s sedan. He had not slept and did not pretend to. He held the door and looked at the blue line of ridge to the east, where the Long Meadow lay under its snow.

“Go,” he said. “I’ll keep the Bench. Nobody gets past the gate who hasn’t been asked in.”

“Back by eleven.”

“I’ll be here,” said Ansel, and shut the door on her, gently, like a man putting a lid on something warm.

---

The state police office in Meridian was a low tan building beside a Dairy Queen, and at nine o’clock on Christmas Eve it held a receptionist in a Santa hat, a plastic tree, and a tall, unhappy trooper who offered Tess a cup of coffee in a way that suggested he’d looked up whether it was legal.

Sergeant Ede had brought a second chair for Nora Feld. He had brought a tape recorder and set it between them, and put his hat on the table, and looked at it for several seconds.

“I’m going to read you the complaint,” he said, “and I’d like you to know I think it’s garbage.”

“Then why are we here?” said Nora.

“Because it came on letterhead, ma’am. From a lawyer. And I’m a sergeant who’s twenty-nine.” He smoothed the paper flat. “*On the night of the twenty-second, one Tess Okafor did knowingly hold herself out as a public officer by presence in uniform at 2210 Larkspur Lane, Caldwell.*” He looked up. “Were you in uniform?”

“I was in my winter coat.”

“With a badge?”

“My badge was surrendered to the Department on December fourth. Mr. Weir keeps it.” She gave him the date. “I wore my father’s watch.”

“I figured.” He rubbed his face with both hands. “I don’t want to be a man who files a case against a woman for standing on a sidewalk, ma’am. I’ve got a daughter. She’s four. She’d be ashamed of me by Easter.” He cleared his throat, embarrassed, and went on briskly. “I made some calls last night.

“The complaint’s date-stamped six-oh-four p.m., before the entry, before anyone knew you’d be there. Which means somebody wrote it first and waited for you to arrive.” He stopped. “Ma’am. Would you look at the type?”

He turned the sheet around.

It was an ordinary typed page, on cream laid paper, a little over-inked. Tess read it once and put her finger on a word. Under the pad of her glove was the o in *officer,* and it was raised, a hair above the line, with a faint notch in the top curve, just as it was in the card on Hazel’s collar.

“There’s a Selectric,” said Tess quietly, “in a records room in Fairview.”

“There’s more than one,” said Nora, equally quietly. “If I were drafting this, Sergeant, I’d ask where else they were.”

“I’m an honest man, ma’am. I’m going to log it as a defect of the document.” Ede stood and held out his hand to Tess. It was a big, raw, cold hand, and the grip was careful. “And I’d like to say, off the record, that this department takes a dim view of being used.”

---

They were out by ten past ten.

The snow had stopped completely. The sky over the interstate had split into a high bright blue with a few streamers of cloud, and the world lay clean and glittering from the hills to the sky. Nora drove her gray sedan, and Tess sat with the window cracked and her notebook in her lap, and neither of them spoke until they were on the Larch County road.

“It’s the third document,” said Nora, at last. “The card, the affidavit, now this. Three documents with the same typewriter, three lawyers, and an honest cop. If it were my case, I’d call it a pattern.”

“It won’t help by noon.”

“No. But it helps by Friday.” Nora’s mouth turned up. “I know that’s a ridiculous thing to find comforting.”

“I find it comforting.”

“Good. We’re both ridiculous.” The road dipped through the cattle guard onto Bench land, and the sedan’s tires hummed on the pipe gate. Nora frowned and slowed. “That’s odd. Who’s that?”

Ahead, on the lane, Burt Haskell was running.

He was a heavy man, and he ran like a man who had not run in a decade, with his arms stiff and his hat gone and his breath going up in a white cloud. He waved both arms in the road. Nora stopped the car. He wrenched the door open.

“It’s Tamsin,” he said. “She’s gone. Her bunk was cold at eight. We looked in every barn. Birdie’s got the dogs out. And Ansel,” said Burt, and his voice cracked, “Ansel’s gone after her, he took off up the ridge at nine with nothing, not even a coat, and said not to wait.”

“Where?” said Tess.

“The Long Meadow,” said Burt. “She left a note on the pillow.” He held it out in a shaking hand. “It’s only one line. It says, *I’m going early so nobody has to watch.*”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!