The sheriff’s office on Sunday morning smelled of burned coffee and floor wax, and the dispatch radio muttered to itself like a man in a waiting room.
Gil Dunmore sat behind his desk in a church sweater with a pie tin at his elbow. He looked up when Tess came in, and for half a second she saw a tired sixty-one-year-old man glad of company. Then he saw her face.
“Friend,” he said carefully. “You look like you’ve been dug up.”
“I broke chain of custody to bring you this.”
She put Walt Bannerman’s notebook on the blotter between the pie tin and the phone. She stood with her hands at her sides and watched him read.
It took him eleven minutes. She counted. He read the first pages without expression, the way a man reads a menu. At the Sept 14 page he stopped, and his lips moved, and he set a hand over his mouth as if he might be sick. Do NOT call Gil. G’s map is in an unlocked drawer.
“Aw, Walt,” he said into his palm. “Aw, hell.”
“Tell me what you saw when they found him.”
Gil had the look of a man who had been waiting a month for somebody to ask.
“His boots. Red clay, Warden. Fourteen clay, there’s nothing like it in the rest of the county. It was all over the boots and the cuffs of his trousers, and his body was in his own yard under the ladder, tidy as a made bed.” His voice was very flat. “I took the boots off him myself, at Pete Aldrich’s. I put them in a bag, and I put the bag in my trunk, and I told Pete to write down a fall.”
“Because you thought the Bench killed him.”
“Because he’d been poking at those deaths and I thought, God forgive me, I thought they’d had enough.” Gil lifted his eyes. “If I’d asked, I’d have had to do something about the answer. A sheriff who accuses the Bench starts a war. Greta wouldn’t forgive it and she’d be right not to. So I signed the fall, and I told myself a peaceful county was a good enough monument for a good man.”
“There are five dead,” Tess said. “Four on the Bench. And Walt.”
He flinched. It was the only time she ever saw him do it.
Then he opened the bottom drawer of his desk, took out a manila folder, laid it in front of her and said, “Here’s the map. It’s been in that drawer eleven years with the lock off.” He found a key on his ring and put it in the lock. It took him three tries. “I’ve never locked it before. I’d like it noted.”
“Noted.”
“Now. What do you have?”
She laid it out. Silver snares of Tarkington braid. Mabel’s statement, in her own words, on a legal pad Mabel had signed. A coil of cable with the same four digits on a tag as the sleeve on her evidence, in a shop on Route 9, in plain sight. A white pickup with a cracked taillight, and the nineteen-year-old who drove it. A man who knew a warden had been bitten before anyone should have.
“Birdie called me Friday about your arm,” said Gil gently.
“So you’ve known since Friday what I am.”
“I’ve known since Friday what you’re going to be. Different thing. A lot number isn’t a warrant. Mabel’s an old woman who loves the boy. Judge Ferris will want more. Get me the Reyes kid’s statement and a recording of Raymer saying anything at all. Do that, and I’ll wake Ferris at supper. He owes me for the hay.”
“Monday?”
“Moonrise is at six. I’ll have two deputies at the Spar Fork gate by four.” He gave her a long look. “Get some sleep, friend. You won’t, but I’d like to say I told you to.”
She found the Reyes brothers in the old calving barn at four that afternoon.
It was clean. Straw bales, a stove, a long plank bench, a stall made up with a cot. Ansel stood by the wall with his arms folded and his face like something carved. His brother sat on the bench, elbows on knees, his hands hanging between them, and did not lift his head when she came in.
“He told me everything last night,” Ansel said. “I asked him to tell you himself.”
Emmett Reyes looked about fourteen. His eyes were swollen. He kept turning a cap in his fingers, around and around by the bill.
“Walk me through it,” Tess said. She said it as she would to a hurt animal. “From the beginning. Don’t leave out the part that makes you look worst.”
“It was the spring,” said Emmett. “At the fire hall, at the pool table. Colt Raymer. He was funny, ma’am, he knew everybody, he bought a round for guys who couldn’t drink yet. He paid for my truck’s transmission. He said there’d be a guide job for me, a real job, off the Bench. I thought I could get out.”
“Out of what?”
“Out of being, you know. Anybody’s grandson.”
Ansel’s folded arms tightened, but he said nothing.
“Then he said hunters kept walking into Fourteen and getting hurt,” Emmett went on, “and if he knew where we denned and where we ran, he could steer the clients away. For safety. So nobody’d have to find us.” His voice broke. “I took a picture of the map on Mormor’s wall. When everybody was asleep. I sent him run nights. He’d text, Tuesday okay? Whose ridge? Like a checklist. Like I was being careful.”
“And the wire?”
“I saw it. At the gate, in August, in the truck bed. I said, that looks like silver, and he said it was stainless. He said he braids his own for his traplines.” Emmett’s mouth shook. “When Perry died he said it was poachers. He said he’d find them. I wanted so much for that to be true.”
“And Walt?” said Tess.
“I knew after Walt.” He looked up at last, and what was in his face she had seen on young men before, men who had done a thing in a hurry and watched the world close over it. “If I told, I was the one who got Walt killed. If I kept going, I was the one who’d get somebody else killed. So I did both. Lonnie taught me to drive.”
She let the quiet sit. She was counting her own pulse, because it was the only thing steady in the room. “Thursday night. Who knew I was bitten?”
“I told him.” Emmett’s voice was barely there. “I texted him that night, after, from the barn. He wrote back, what a shame, pal. He asked what day you’d turn.” He swallowed. “I thought it was weird. I thought, why would he want to know that?”
“So did I,” said Tess.
She sat down on the bench beside him, not too close. She did not forgive him, and he did not ask her to. “Here’s what happens now. You sign a statement. You wear a recorder. Tomorrow morning you text Colt that the Long Run is at Fork Meadow, not the Long Meadow, and you keep him talking.”
She set her pocket recorder on the bench between them. He looked at it as if it might bite.
“Totally,” said Emmett. “Ma’am.”
“Don’t say totally.”
“No, ma’am.”
Ansel pushed away from the wall. He put one scarred hand on his brother’s head, once, hard, then took it away as if he’d touched a stove.
Tess stayed on the Bench that night. She accepted a cot in Birdie’s kitchen, not the calving barn, because the fever had come back as promised and she could no longer feel her feet, and everyone had the grace not to remark on it. She slept in bursts, drenched, dreaming in smells. Near dawn the fever broke like a plate, and she woke soaked and cold and clear.
An engine was turning over in the yard. 5:38 by the stove clock.
She got to the porch in her socks. Ansel was already standing in the frost with the barn door open behind him and his face gone white. In the dust where the pickup had been sat a scatter of red plastic, a cracked taillight finally broken the rest of the way, and, on a straw bale inside the barn, set down neatly, the little recorder she had given Emmett.
By 5:40 the white truck was gone from the yard, and so was he.

