Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 25

The Second Spoon

He knocks at six forty-one. Three taps, a pause, and a fourth.

I open the door and he is standing on the landing in his gray coat with a cardboard tray in one hand. Three coffees. In the other hand, held loosely against his thigh as if he’d forgotten it was there, is a square of hotel notepaper folded twice and chewed at one corner.

“Day two for me,” says Ezra. “Day five for you. I read your letter at six thirteen, sitting on the edge of the bed, in my socks. I read it three times. I didn’t have to ask what was going on.”

I can’t say anything. I hold the door frame.

“I brought three because I thought Peter might be here,” he says. “And because I’d like to know what you want to do about the fact that I believed you before I saw your face.”

“You believed me.”

“I believed the handwriting. It’s a very good letter. You underlined a verb twice, and I’d never have done that.” He steps in. He puts the tray on the dresser. He opens his arms, and I walk into them, and I think: it has been five days, and I have started this man over four times, and this is the first morning I didn’t have to.

“I’m sorry,” I say into his coat. “I don’t know why I’m crying. It’s just that you walked in and you already knew.”

“I know,” says Ezra. “It’s a strange thing. I’ve never been so glad to be told something.” He holds me for a while, with one hand flat between my shoulder blades. “I’ll tell you what I’d like. I’d like to be asked about the things I don’t know. I’d like the rest of it to just be true.”

“It is.”

“Then it’s the best day I’ve had since Tuesday,” he says, and then, with a faint frown, “which I’m told doesn’t count.”

I take his letter out of my pocket and put it on the dresser beside the coffee. I show him the line about Jonah. He reads it over my shoulder, with the tray balanced on his other hand.

“You told me,” he says.

“You told me.”

“Yes. I’d like to be the one who asks him. If that isn’t out of turn.”

“No,” I say. “I’d rather ask him myself. I’d like it to be as myself. But I’d like you to know that I’m asking because you saw it first.”

“That’s fair,” says Ezra. He sips the coffee, which is black, and makes a face. “Win says people only drink this because they think it’s virtuous.”

“Did she say it to you?”

“She said it to the tomato man.”

I laugh, hard, and the pipe knocks in the wall in response.

The Listening Room is open when I get there, with the glass door propped on a folded newspaper and the long table already covered in index cards. Win has found a roll of masking tape and a marker. Down the length of the wall by the brass plate she has begun a timeline, one strip per day, each strip labeled in her upright hand: DAY 1, DAY 2, DAY 3, DAY 4. A fifth strip, blank, waits at the end. Under each she has noted what crossed and what didn’t.

“It’s not ornamental,” she says, without turning. “I’d like to be able to check myself.”

“It’s beautiful.”

“Don’t be nice. I’m looking for the hole.”

Peter’s already there, in the corner with a mug, reading Win’s strip for Day 3 with the air of a man proofreading a will. When he sees me he stands, as he always does, a half second too late, and says, “Is Ezra coming?”

“He’s gone to find a hardware store. He says if we’re going to build a wall of paper he’d like to do it properly.”

“I like him,” says Peter. “It’s very inconvenient.”

“It’s very useful.”

“It’s both,” he says. “It turns out that’s quite common.”

Jonah comes in at eight forty with his thermos. He sees the wall and stops. He looks at the five strips of tape, the cards, the four of us. He doesn’t say anything. He puts the thermos on the long table, slowly, with both hands, and sits in the chair at the end.

“Hi,” I say.

“Hi.”

“Could I speak to you? On the back stairs? As yourself.”

For a moment, nobody breathes. Win has stopped writing. Peter has put down his cup.

“Yes,” says Jonah. “I’d rather you did.”

The back stairs of the Listening Room are narrow and dim, and smell of old cardboard and dry plaster. We sit on the third step from the top, with a gap of about a foot between us. On the landing below, there’s a window with a crack across it, and a view of an air shaft where a single pigeon is arranging itself on a pipe.

“I’m going to say what I think,” I say. “And you can tell me I’m wrong. I think you’ve been awake at six twelve. I think you’ve heard the spoon.”

He doesn’t say anything. He’s looking at his hands.

“I’m not accusing you. I’m asking.”

“I know.” His voice is low. “I’ve been waiting for someone to ask.”

“Since when?”

“Since the morning after Win told me she wasn’t going to tell me something.” He rubs his thumb along the edge of his thermos lid, a small, circular gesture, like someone worrying a worry stone.

“That was the third day by your count, I think. I don’t know how you’re counting. I woke at six twelve in a room over a bakery. There’s an oven below me and the family upstairs has a toddler, and I’d never heard a spoon fall on that floor in my life. It rolled. It stopped. And I thought, very clearly, *That’s yesterday. I remember yesterday, and it hasn’t happened yet.*”

“And you said nothing.”

“I said nothing.” He lifts his eyes. They’re red-rimmed, steady. “Win said she wasn’t going to tell me. It wasn’t mine. I thought: if I say I know, I’m making her tell me, and she isn’t ready. And I thought if I say nothing, maybe she’ll come to it.” He laughs, briefly, without any pleasure.

“That’s the easy version. The true version is that I was afraid. I thought if I said it, the day would end. And I’d like to say, plainly, that I didn’t want it to end. Not yet.”

I wait.

“I like this day,” says Jonah. “I’m sorry. I know that’s a terrible thing to say. You were scared and Win was frightened and everyone was trying to work out the rules, and I’ve been walking around the Listening Room in a state of mild awe, thinking, *I get to hear it again.*

“I get to hear her say the sentence, and the click, and the thirty-eight seconds, and I get to press the key. I get to do it as many times as there are mornings. And I thought, God help me, that it was the best job I’d ever had.”

“That’s not terrible.”

“It’s a bit terrible.”

“It’s a bit terrible,” I agree. “It’s also honest.”

“I tried not to lie. I didn’t. I said, ‘It’s my favorite job in the building,’ and it is. I said, ‘I don’t have to say anything.’ It’s the nearest I got to the line.” He looks at me with something that might be defiance. “I didn’t tell Win I knew, and I didn’t tell her I didn’t. I just waited. It’s the cowardly third thing.”

“I used to do the third thing,” I say. “For about thirty years.”

“Does it get better?”

“It gets different.” I lean my shoulder against the wall. “Jonah, I’m sorry. I’m sorry I didn’t see it. I’ve been so busy keeping you out of the room that I didn’t notice you were already in it.”

“You couldn’t have known.”

“I could have asked.”

“I didn’t want to be asked,” says Jonah. “I want to be clear about that. I’d have said no. I’d have said I was fine. I’d have used a joke.” He smiles, a crooked, wet, unhappy smile. “It took Ezra to see it. I’d like to buy him a drink.”

“He saw your lips move.”

“I thought I was being so careful.”

“You were. He’s a lighting designer.”

“Of course he is,” says Jonah.

We sit for a minute. Down in the air shaft, the pigeon has fallen asleep on its pipe.

“I’m going to tell Win,” I say. “Now. You’ll be there. I’d like you to say it yourself.”

“She’ll be furious.”

“She’ll be hurt. That’s different.” I stand and put out a hand. “She told you she’d tell you first. I don’t think she’s going to mind that you got there before her.”

He takes my hand and lets me pull him up. He’s got a dusty smear of plaster on the back of his sweater.

“Do you want to know what I wrote?” he says. “I kept a log, too. In a notebook I have to buy at the corner shop every morning, because the old one is gone by six twelve. I rewrite it from memory. I thought I might forget.”

“Of course you did.”

“It’s mostly questions,” says Jonah. “I’d like you to look at it.”

Win does not shout. I want to say that, because I’ve seen her very quiet and I’ve seen her very angry and she did neither.

She listens to him on the long table’s far side, with her glasses off and the marker capped in her fist, for the whole of the story. When he says *I was afraid it would end,* she shuts her eyes. When he says *I thought it was the best job I’d had,* the corner of her mouth moves.

“Mr. Sarkis,” she says, when he’s finished.

“Win.”

“I told you I wasn’t going to tell you something today. I did not say that you couldn’t know.” She opens her eyes. “I’ve been very careful, over the last three weeks, to treat people as if they were incapable of keeping up. I told you I wasn’t ready. It was a fair thing to say. It was also a convenient one.”

“I’m sorry.”

“I’m sorry too,” says Win. “I’d like to say that I’m sorry I made you wait. And I’d like to say that I’m very, very glad that you’re here.” She puts her glasses on. “You’ll sit down. You’ll tell us exactly what you’ve seen. And you’ll show me your notebook, which is either a work of genius or a very expensive list of questions.”

“It’s mostly questions.”

“Questions are the only thing I trust,” says Win.

By noon the wall has six strips of tape and a fresh heading in Win’s hand. WHO. She’s made a list on a card: Win. Jonah. Hazel. Peter. And beneath, a short line, a question mark on its own.

“Four of us,” she says. “One who knew from the beginning. One who joined on the second day. One who joined on the third. And one who has worked beside me for six weeks, and whom I should have asked.”

“The groom isn’t the only one with memory,” says Peter drily.

“I’ve stopped calling you the groom.”

“It’s a relief.”

“You have no idea.” She taps the card. “What do we have in common?”

Nobody answers.

“Win said the sentence,” says Jonah, slowly. “I pressed the key. Hazel made the silence. Peter was in the room.”

“You were all in the room,” says Win. “And so was Lorraine, and so was Philippa, and so were sixty other people.”

“Not everyone in the room is awake,” says Peter.

“No.” She looks at the wall. “That’s the part I’d like to understand.”

“Maybe it’s the people who’ve been told something,” says Jonah.

“Ezra’s been told,” I say.

“And he’s not awake.”

“And Philippa knows everything, and she isn’t.”

“Then it’s not being told,” says Win. “It’s not being in the room. It’s not saying a sentence. It’s something else.” She straightens a card on the wall. “It may be that it hasn’t finished choosing.”

It’s the first time anyone has said it. Nobody argues.

I’d like to tell you that the afternoon is a revelation. It isn’t. It is a long, slow, careful accumulation of small tests, and a lot of tea. We try reading the reel aloud to an empty room. We try to move the gala up by an hour, and learn that it makes no difference to the reset.

Win tests whether the Listening Room itself is an anchor by leaving the building for forty-five minutes and walking the length of Ludlow Street in a straight line, then returning, and finding nothing out of place. She comes back with her cheeks pink and says, “Nothing at all. I’d like that on the record.”

At three my mother arrives, in a garment bag and the coat I’ve never seen, and says, “You’re still tall,” to Ezra, and “Hm,” and hands him a folding chair, and I can feel a smile on my face I did not decide to put there.

At eight, Win says her sentence a fifth way, and Philippa nods at three, and the applause starts in the back, and it isn’t for a performance. At eleven, the room empties, and Win suggests the test we’ve all been circling.

“I’d like us to stay,” she says. “Here. All of us. At midnight and through it. I’d like to know where we wake.”

“In our beds,” says Peter.

“Probably. I’d like to see it.”

We put out five cushions on the floor by the long table. I get my brass clock out of my bag; I’ve carried it all day, like a talisman. I set it to six twelve myself, for the first time, to see whether it rings in the room or on the dresser. Ezra, who has joined us because he is a man who cannot stay out of a stage crew, puts the kettle on in the back and brings tea round on a tin tray.

“If you vanish, I’d like a note,” he says.

“I’ll try.”

“I’d like a good one.”

At eleven fifty-eight, we are sitting in a ring on the floor of an old dental supply shop with a clock between us. Peter is cross-legged with his hands on his knees. Win has her shoes off. Jonah is holding his notebook against his chest. Ezra has his arm along the back of my shoulders.

“Nobody says anything false,” says Win.

“Nobody says anything we don’t mean,” I say.

“Peter, would you like to say a last word?”

“I’d like to say that I’m very glad it was this room,” says Peter. “If it had to be a room.”

“That’s the best thing anyone’s said all week,” says Jonah.

Midnight comes. It passes. We don’t sleep. We sit, and we look at each other, with a little gap in the air where the ordinary quiet should be. At one, Win lies back with her glasses on her chest. At three, Jonah is breathing evenly and Peter’s eyes are closed. Ezra is awake beside me. He doesn’t speak. He holds my hand, and the clock between us ticks in its brass case like a very small heart.

At six eleven, I realize I’m holding my breath.

The pipe in the wall knocks. The window goes gray. Peter opens his eyes and looks at me across the floor, and I see him understand what I understand, which is that in forty seconds nothing will have changed or everything will.

At six twelve the alarm rings.

I don’t see the room go. I don’t feel it. There’s no flash and no dizziness. One breath I’m sitting on a cushion with my hand in Ezra’s, and the next I’m lying on my back on a narrow bed, in the sloped light of a third-floor room, with my heart going like a hammer and the brass clock, which was on the floor of the Listening Room, ringing on my dresser.

In the hall, the kettle clicks.

Above me, a spoon falls, rolls, and stops.

I breathe. I let the breath out. The test is done, and I’ll go and tell Win that we woke where we always wake, that the room doesn’t matter, that nothing we did in the night was enough to—

Above me, another spoon falls.

It’s a different sound. Smaller. Brighter. It lands on the same boards, a little closer to the wall, and rolls the wrong way, toward the window instead of away, and stops against something I can’t see.

I lie perfectly still, with my hands flat on the blanket and my breath held in my throat. Nobody is upstairs. There’s an attic. The attic has a sloped ceiling and a slow old pipe and nothing else.

My phone rings in my hand before I’ve decided to pick it up.

“Hazel.” It’s Peter. His voice is odd, very quiet and very clear. “Did you hear two?”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!