Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 3

The Guest in the Back Row

Illustration: The Guest in the Back Row

Ezra arrives at ten forty carrying a garment bag and a box that used to contain biscuits.

I know this because I have watched him arrive often enough to dread the sight of the box. It contains photographs from university, requested by my mother for a display titled Before the Big Day. There are several of Ezra and me that do not belong beneath that heading.

“You look ready to interrogate a witness,” he says.

“I’m collecting statements.”

He glances at the paper in my hand.

“Should I have brought a lawyer?”

“I’d prefer a qualified physicist.”

He offers the box. I take it and lead him toward the dock. I tell my mother we need air. She looks at the lake, which supplies the entire property with air, but doesn’t argue.

Ezra Abara is thirty-two. Theater lighting designer. Former partner. Current friend, a category I have maintained through careful punctuation for seven years. We dated for two years, loved each other badly at the end, and became people who send birthday messages that arrive exactly on time.

He is wearing a gray shirt with a fraying buttonhole. I know the shirt. I don’t know why that undoes me more than a suit would.

At the dock, he sets the garment bag on the dry bench and waits.

“I’m living this Saturday again,” I say. “This is the forty-ninth time.”

He doesn’t laugh. I appreciate that before he says anything else.

“What do you mean by again?”

I tell him. The clock. The spoon. The bride I become every morning without permission. I do not tell him the things he has said in other cycles. Those versions of the conversation belong to a man who cannot remember consenting to them.

He sits on the bench.

“Are you sleeping?”

“Physically, yes. Emotionally, I think I’m operating several time zones behind.”

He looks at me steadily.

“Do you need help leaving?”

It is the question I have wanted from everybody. Not whether my brain is functioning correctly. Not whether Peter knows. What do I need right now?

“I don’t know yet.”

“Okay.”

He moves the box so there is room beside him. I sit.

I point toward the path. In a moment, Peter’s sister will walk past carrying two white umbrellas even though the forecast is clear. She does. Ezra looks from her to me.

“She thinks the photographs will look nicer with them,” I say.

“Maybe you heard her mention it.”

“Maybe.”

He is allowed a reasonable explanation. I am not owed belief just because I have had weeks to accumulate mine.

“If this is happening,” he says, “what carries over?”

“Memory. Mine. Nothing I write. Nothing anyone else remembers.”

“That sounds lonely.”

I look at the water.

“Yes.”

He opens the biscuit box, giving my face somewhere else to be. Photographs spill across the bench. A university lawn. A kitchen with a damp patch on the ceiling. Ezra holding a lamp while I record a classmate scraping a chair across floorboards for an experimental film.

I remember the chair. I remember being furious that the microphone caught us laughing.

“We used the wrong take,” I say.

“You said the laugh was the useful part.”

“Did I?”

“You were occasionally generous to your own work.”

There is a photograph of us outside our first shared flat. My hair is shorter. His hand rests on my shoulder. Neither of us is looking at the camera because somebody beyond it is making an argument about parking.

I don’t remember the argument. I remember being loved without needing to make a speech about it.

“That one doesn’t have to go on the display,” he says.

“Do you want it?”

He studies the picture.

“I have a copy.”

The answer reaches me slowly. Seven years is enough time to throw out a great deal of paper.

“How’s the tour?” I ask.

“Starts in three weeks. A different city every few days. Very glamorous if you enjoy cable ties.”

I tell him about my documentary work, the film whose interview subject keeps moving a noisy necklace. We talk like people who once knew the texture of each other’s entire days and now have to request samples.

The distance is real. So is the ease. I have spent too long pretending one cancels the other.

A waiter comes down the path offering coffee. I start to tell him Ezra takes his with milk, then stop and look at Ezra instead.

“Do you want any?”

“Black, thanks.”

“Since when?”

“A couple of years. Coffee backstage is safer without a dairy variable.”

He smiles as he takes the cup. It is such an ordinary change. There must be hundreds of them. People he calls after work. Food he no longer likes. A city he loved that I have never visited.

I have memories of loving him. That doesn’t make me an expert on the person sitting beside me. I will have to ask him things, and he will have to decide what he wants to tell me.

“What’s the best place you’ve worked recently?” I ask.

He tells me about a tiny theater whose ceiling leaked during the final rehearsal. The crew moved the lights rather than cancel. I listen without comparing his story to anything I already know.

It sounds like him.

He takes a bent photograph and smooths it against his knee.

“Peter seems kind.”

“He is.”

“Are you happy?”

I look at the white chairs on the lawn.

“Sometimes.”

He nods. He doesn’t seize on the answer. I am grateful and, shamefully, disappointed.

“Why did you keep coming?” I ask.

“To the wedding?”

“No. After we broke up. Birthdays. The bad year with my mother. Every time I asked you for a perfectly reasonable friendship-shaped thing.”

He turns the photograph over.

“Because I care about you. Sometimes being friends was easy. Sometimes it wasn’t. I got to decide whether I could do it.”

I move my hand toward his, then stop.

“And today?”

“Today you’re supposed to marry someone else.”

“I know.”

“I’m not saying that to punish you.”

The breeze lifts one edge of the photograph between us. We both put a finger on it. Our hands touch, and the contact is so small I cannot hide the meaning behind its size.

He looks at me. For a moment I know exactly how it would feel to close the distance. I know it from memory, which is not the same as permission to do it now.

“Hazel,” he says softly. “What are you choosing with Peter?”

“I’m not asking you to change that.”

“Then what are you asking?”

I pull my hand away. Embarrassment rises so fast it almost feels like anger. I want to put us back into the safe category, where nobody can ask why I keep touching the edges of it.

I make myself meet his eyes.

“I’ve never wanted to kiss you after we broke up,” I say.

The alarm rings.

I am in my room. Six twelve. The spoon lands above me while the truth of my own sentence comes apart.

Fifty.

Ezra is still asleep somewhere, preparing to arrive at a wedding he has never attended before.

I am the only person who remembers wanting him.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!