Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 11

Service of Process

At 10:42 on Friday morning a roofer named Gus Tindall swears, under oath and in front of God and Judge Haskett, that he never touched the load-bearing wall, and I type it at two hundred and twenty-six words a minute without a single red line, because this is a county courtroom and my machine here is a plain black Stenograph that has never once been interested in the truth.

Q. Mr. Tindall, did you remove the wall between the kitchen and the dining room?

A. I never touched it.

Q. Did anyone on your crew touch it?

A. My crew works under my direction. I told them what I told you.

That is eleven words, and not one of them is an answer. I have been taking down men like Gus Tindall for six years. I know the little hitch before a sentence that has been rehearsed, the dry swallow, the way the eyes go up and to the left to check a script. I note it in the margin of my own head and I keep my wrists flat.

I slept two hours. Possibly less. I woke at three to a sheet of cream tape on my nightstand with a case number on it, and I did not wake Ike on the couch, and I did not wake Calder, who was sitting on my fire escape with his back against the brick because he had said he would not sleep somewhere with only one door. I got up and made coffee and read the sheet nine times. THE PACKS OF THE SABLE V. WREN DALY. Nobody had touched the keys. Constance had printed it on her own, and then she had gone warm and quiet in her case like a cat that has left a dead bird on the doormat.

Now Constance is under my chair, in the second case, the one I am not supposed to bring to this building, and Calder Voss is in the last row of the gallery with his coat folded over his knees, being very still.

He came in at nine-fifteen and sat down without looking at me, and the bailiff, who is a retired sheriff’s deputy named Pat Orlowski and has never trusted a man who sits that still, looked at him for a long time and then decided he was somebody’s cousin. Calder counted the room as he came through it. I did not hear him. I saw his lips move. Two doors, one of them locked. Four windows, painted shut. A clock with a loud second hand.

I am trying very hard not to look up there. It is not that I do not know him. I know him the way I know the date of a statute I have never needed: a fact on a card. His name is Calder Voss, and eight hours ago, on a roof, I read a list of things I once knew about him, in my own handwriting, and tried to feel them. The list says he drinks his coffee black. The list says he once drove four hours to bring me a casserole dish I had left at a funeral and said nothing about it for a month. The list says I trust him.

I read the list and I felt like a woman reading the minutes of a meeting she did not attend.

Beside the Stenograph, on the little shelf where my water glass sits, there is an index card. Not for him. For me, from me, in my own tidy print. It says: He is not a stranger. Act like it. If you are wrong, you will find out quickly.

It is nine words, and I have decided it is good advice.

“Mr. Tindall,” says Mr. Prewitt, the attorney for the homeowner, a thin man with a very tidy handkerchief, “let me ask it a different way. Between March first and March fifteenth, did any wall in the Hendry house come down?”

“There was some demolition.”

“Whose?”

“I’d have to check my records.”

“Mr. Tindall, did you bring the wall down?”

Gus Tindall opens his mouth, and the courtroom door at the back opens too.

I do not look up at first, because you do not look up in a courtroom for a door. That is the first thing you learn. The door will always open, and someone will always be late, and the Record does not care. I keep my eyes on the witness and my hands on the keys.

But the footsteps do not stop at the back. They come down the center aisle, steady, unhurried, and every person in Department 4 turns to watch them come. They are the footsteps of a man who has never once been told he cannot walk somewhere.

He is in his forties and wearing a suit that is a shade too good for the county building, charcoal wool with a faint blue thread in it, pressed to a razor edge. He has a leather portfolio under his arm. He has very clean hands. He walks through the gate in the bar, which is not permitted, and past the clerk, and past counsel, and stops at the foot of my little platform with a smile that is entirely courteous.

“Wren Daly?”

“Sir,” says Judge Haskett, from the bench, in a voice you could slice a tomato with. “This is a court in session.”

“I know, Your Honor, and I apologize.” He does not look at her. He is looking at me. “It will take one moment. I was instructed that it must be delivered in person, to her hand, during the hours she is at work. I am sorry for the intrusion. It is only a courtesy.”

“A courtesy,” says Haskett.

“Wren Daly,” he says again, gently, like a man calling a child in from the rain. “You are hereby served.”

He holds out a long envelope, cream-colored, thick, sealed with a disk of dark wax. It has my name on the front, and under my name it has a word. The word is Scribe.

I do not take it. I have an instinct about envelopes that are held out to me by strangers. I look at the judge instead, because the one thing I know about service of process is that it does not matter what I think about it. If I touch it, it is done.

Haskett sets down her pen.

Dolores Haskett has been on the bench twenty-two years. She has a face like a handsome hatchet and a manner of looking over her glasses that has reduced three prosecutors to tears and one visiting federal judge to a stammer. She looks at the man in the charcoal suit, and she looks at the envelope, and then, for a long second, she looks at me. It is not the look of a judge at a witness. It is the look she gives when she has seen the end of an argument before the lawyers have begun it.

“Who are you with?” she says.

“I am a process agent, Your Honor. Dwight Amory, licensed in this state. I serve for a number of clients.”

“And this client?”

“It’s a client of some discretion.”

“I will bet it is.” She does not raise her voice. “Mr. Amory, you walked through my gate. Do you know the penalty for that?”

“I do not, Your Honor.”

“Neither do I,” says Haskett, “because nobody has ever been stupid enough to find out. Ms. Daly, you are a sworn officer of this court. If you wish to accept that document on your own time, that is your business. If you wish me to have the bailiff remove this man, that is mine. Say which.”

It is, I realize, a lifeline. She is giving me the choice to refuse. In six years she has never done me a kindness in open court. She has never needed to.

But Margo taught me this too, when I was nineteen and had just sat for the certification. You can refuse service. People do. And the instrument sits on the courthouse steps all night, and it is served anyway, and every day you did not read it counts against you.

“I’ll take it, Your Honor,” I say.

“Then take it. Mr. Prewitt, Mr. Tindall, we will resume in fifteen minutes. Ms. Daly.” A pause. “You will not read it in my courtroom.”

“No, ma’am.”

“Good. Mr. Amory, you are excused. The bailiff will walk you out.”

The envelope is heavier than it looks. When I take it the wax is warm, as if it had been kept against someone’s skin. It does not smell of anything I recognize, which is the first thing wrong with it. Everything the packs touch smells of snow and wet fur. This smells like a new suit.

Amory bows, a quarter inch, and does not turn until Pat Orlowski has taken his elbow. As he is steered up the aisle, he passes the last row, and I see Calder look at him, once, with eyes that are not amber but are thinking about it. Amory sees it too. He lifts two fingers in a small, friendly salute and goes out into the hall.

Fifteen minutes. The courtroom empties into a murmur. Haskett is gone through the door behind the bench before I have stood. Prewitt wants a word with his client. Gus Tindall wipes his neck and looks as though he has been spared a hanging he did not know he had earned.

Calder is beside me before I have my hands off the keys.

“Do not open it here,” he says.

“I was not going to.”

“I know.” He stops. He seems to realize that he is speaking to me in the tone of a man talking someone down off a ledge, and for the first time since the flume I see him adjust, the way a man adjusts a tie. “I would like to be the one who does not tell you what to do. I am trying. I am not practiced.”

“You are doing fine.”

“That is a lie.”

“Then it should be red,” I say, and for one second the corner of his mouth lifts, and I feel the thing under my ribs I have felt all night, the vertigo of walking through a house I know by heart, with all the furniture moved an inch.

“Hallway,” says Calder. “There is a stairwell. Two exits. One camera.”

“I hate it when you do that.”

“You told me to do it. It is on a card.”

“Is it?”

“I have been reading your cards,” he says, “with your permission, since four o’clock.”

I had forgotten I gave it. I gave it, apparently, at four a.m., in a state I cannot recall, because I woke Ike and he made toast and I had talked, all of us had talked, in a ring around my kitchen table, Ike with his feet on a chair and Calder with his back to the wall. It is hazy. It has the quality of a dream I am being told about secondhand.

We go down the hall to the east stairwell, which smells of old floor wax and the steam pipes, and Calder holds the door, and checks the landing above, and checks the landing below, and nods.

I break the wax with my thumbnail.

The paper inside is not paper. It is tape. Cream, coiled, perhaps two feet of it, in the exact shade of Constance’s own roll, and it is printed in the exact typeface, the crisp narrow capitals of a machine that has been in one family for seventy years. For one bad second I think it is a message from her, from the machine under my chair, and my pulse climbs. Then I see the stamp at the head, a wolf’s print pressed into the paper, and a name below it, and the name is not mine.

IN THE MOOT OF THE SABLE RIVER VALLEY. THE PACKS OF THE SABLE, BY THEIR ADVOCATE-GENERAL ODILE PENHALLOW, PETITIONERS, V. WREN DALY, RESPONDENT.

I read it aloud, because it is what I do. Calder stands against the wall with his hands in his pockets and does not interrupt, not once, and I try to be grateful for it. It would be easy to be grateful.

“Petition to declare the office of Scribe vacant and the instrument forfeit. Whereas Marguerite Daly, Scribe of this Moot for fifty-one years, departed this life on the sixteenth of October. Whereas the Scribe’s office descends only by oath, sworn in the well before the Moot, on the instrument, in the presence of the Speaker. Whereas no oath has been sworn. Whereas the said Wren Daly has since presumed to take down the Record, to seal rolls, to bind wolves by typed vow, and to certify a Finding under the Scribe’s thumb—”

My voice goes thin. I clear it.

“—and to certify a Finding, being a person not sworn. The Petitioners pray that the Moot find every Record taken since the said sixteenth of October to be void for want of a lawful Scribe, that all Findings, rolls and vows of that period be struck, and that the instrument known as Constance be surrendered to the keeping of the Moot until a lawful Scribe may be sworn.”

I stop. I read it again in my head, the way I would read back a transcript to catch what the first time slid past.

“Void,” I say.

“Yes,” says Calder.

“Thaddeus Marrow’s Finding. Your sentence. The roll that saved you.”

“Everything of that week.” He says it quietly. “If the seat was empty, there was never a Record. There was a woman typing in a theme park.”

“And Ike’s vow.”

He does not answer, and I see the answer in his face. Ike is safe because I typed No wolf of this Moot will lay a hand on Isaiah Daly for the bottle, now or after, and the machine made it true, and the machine made it true because it was certified. If the certification goes, the vow goes. A wolf who chose could close a hand on my brother and be only a wolf, and not a sick one.

I have not eaten since a piece of toast at four. My hands are cold.

“She is good,” Calder says. “Penhallow. I should have warned you. I have not known her to lose.”

“Have you known her to lie?”

“Never on tape.” The corner of his mouth moves again. It is not a smile. “That tells you very little.”

“It tells me she reads the statute.” I look down the tape. “It says no oath was sworn. Was there one? Did Margo do the oath with me when I was little? Was there some ceremony?”

“I do not know.”

“You were there for the first night. You were there for the funeral. You knew her eleven years.”

“I know that I never saw you sworn.” He chooses the words with great care, and I notice them being chosen, and I notice that he knows I notice. “That is the whole of what I know. It is true.”

“It is not the whole of what you know about the question.”

He looks at me, and for a moment he is a stranger again, a tall man in a black coat in a stairwell, with a jaw like a closed door. Then it passes. “No,” he says. “It is not. I would like to tell you in a better place than this.”

“Noted,” I say, which is what I say when I cannot say anything else, and I go back to the tape.

There is more. It is addressed in the old forms, long and florid and entirely without contractions, and I read it the way I take down a deposition, flat, listening for the lie that is not in the words but in the architecture. The hearing is set for Saturday night at one in the morning, in the Justice Hall, before the Speaker and a full Moot. The respondent may appear with counsel. Counsel must be a person of the Moot or a person sworn to its secrecy, and may not be a wolf bound to the petitioners. The respondent may not sit in the Scribe’s chair for her own hearing; a substitute Scribe will be named by the Speaker.

“They are going to take my own machine away from me,” I say, “and give it to someone else to type my trial.”

“Truitt will name a neutral.”

“Who?”

“There is no neutral. That is the point.” He is not looking at me now but at the stairwell door, which is a habit with him and not an insult. “Nobody has trained on that instrument but a Daly in two hundred years. A substitute can sit down in front of her, and she will not type a word of it.”

Under my arm, in the case I brought from under the chair because I could not bear to leave it, Constance is warm.

I put my hand on the handle. It does not feel like comfort. It feels like a dog that has heard its name.

I read the tape a third time. There is a paragraph at the bottom I skipped: the part of a pleading you skim because it looks like boilerplate. In the Moot, it never is.

“Further, the Petitioners name as co-respondent Calder Voss, Warden of Harlan Reach, who with full knowledge of the vacancy did conceal the same from the Moot and did, by that concealment, procure the presence of an unsworn person in the well. Said concealment being a breach of the Warden’s office.”

I read it twice.

“Calder.”

“Yes.”

“Knowing concealment.” I make myself say each word as if I were reading them from a transcript of someone I do not know. “With full knowledge of the vacancy.”

He does not look away, which is the thing about him that I am going to have to learn, I think: that he never looks away. He only chooses what he lets you see.

“It is true,” he says.

“You knew there was no oath.”

“I knew Margo never swore you. I knew it on the night of the funeral.” His voice is level. It is the voice he uses on tape. “I did not know what it would mean until Ansel Truitt said the word Scribe to you in the Justice Hall, and you sat down, and the machine accepted you. I thought, she is sworn in some way I was not shown. I thought, Margo did something I do not know. I did not ask. That is what the petition calls concealment. I would call it a very great fear of the answer.”

“That is a lot of words.”

“I know.” He almost laughs. “I have been practicing.”

I want to be angry. I look for it in my chest the way I look for the cards in my shoebox, and the anger is there, a small hot coal, but it is shut up in a room I cannot get to. What I have instead is the plain fact of a man standing in a stairwell who told the truth when a lie would have been easier. It is a feeling I would have to describe as respect. It is not love. Love is on a card.

“Is there anything else in this document,” I say, “that you know before I read it?”

“I have not read it.”

“That is not what I asked.”

A long pause. “I think there is an exhibit,” says Calder. “I think there is always an exhibit.”

There is. It is at the very end, past the signature of Odile Penhallow, which is a long looping hand that someone has clearly practiced in the mirror, past the date, past the seal. A single line, in smaller type, the way an afterthought is typed by someone who knows precisely what it will do.

EXHIBIT B: INSTRUMENT OF RENUNCIATION OF THE SCRIBE’S OFFICE, SWORN IN THE WELL ON THE SECOND OF OCTOBER, THREE YEARS SINCE, AND SIGNED, W. DALY.

I stop breathing. Not dramatically. I simply stop for as long as it takes for a very large and quiet thing to turn over in my mind.

The second of October. Three years ago. I know that date. I have it in my hands, in a Fenwick Shoes box on a roof in Port Harlan, in the pale blue ink of a woman who knew what was coming and chose to keep a door shut. Do not let them tell you yet.

“Wren,” says Calder, very low.

I hold the end of the tape in my fingers. The little wolf print at the head is pressed into the paper like a thumb. Further down, in a box, is a signature. It is the signature I put on the back of my driver’s license, my lease, and my certification. The W has the little hook. The y is not there, because I have never made a y that way. There is only the smooth, upright, careful hand of a woman who has signed something under oath and not yet decided what she was giving up.

I have no memory of it. I have a hole in the shape of an entire evening, and in the hole, in ink I recognize, there is my name.

“I did not do this,” I say.

“Say it again,” says Calder, “into the machine.”

I look at him.

“Not for me,” he says. “For the tape. If it prints clean, you believe it. If it does not—” He stops, because he is not a cruel man, and he has said the thing that cannot be unsaid.

I put the case down on the landing. I open the latch.

The keys are warm, like a mouth that has been breathing against the glass. I rest my wrists. I type, slowly, with the paper feeding out into the stairwell air, I did not sign that, and the lug clicks, and a stripe of cream tape curls into my hand.

It is red.

Not a thread. A whole line, from the first word to the last, as bright and wet as paint.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!