Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 3

Forty Witnesses and One Liar

On the second night of the inquest, Dane Kessler takes the stand in a gray three-piece suit and tells the truth so beautifully that I want to hire him.

“With respect, Madam Scribe,” he says, “I have never laid a hand on Thaddeus Marrow.”

The tape comes out cream. I have to stop myself from checking it twice. It is a quarter to one in the morning, and the Justice Hall smells of cold popcorn machines and forty people’s wet wool coats. Calder stands behind my chair with his arms folded, where the bond keeps him. Every few minutes he mutters a count of the exits. I am starting to find it restful.

Truitt leans forward in his rocker. “Alpha Kessler. Did you pay anyone to harm him?”

“I have never paid a wolf of Harlan Reach to harm anyone.”

Clean.

“Did you know he was dying?”

“Everyone dies, Speaker. It is the great equalizer of my profession.”

Clean. Somebody in the Kessler pews chuckles. I have been taking this in for ten minutes, and what I notice, because noticing is all I am good for, is that he never once says no. He says never. He says I have not. He builds every answer like a house with the front door painted on.

I type it exactly. Each stroke is a plank of his house. I do not say a word.

When he steps down he pauses by my table and smiles, a man who has been told his tie is straight. “With respect,” he murmurs, “you have your grandmother’s wrists.”

“Noted,” I say. Calder’s count of the exits stops, mid-number, for the first time all night.

Dr. Raman is next. She sits as if the chair might bite, hands flat on her knees.

Q. Doctor, when did you examine the body?

A. At approximately ten p.m. on Sunday.

Q. And when did you file your findings with the Moot?

A. At approximately four a.m. on Monday.

Q. Six hours later.

A. Findings were delayed.

Q. By whom?

A. No further comment at this time.

The tape is clean. Of course it is. The delay is a fact, and she has handed it over with her face turned away. Lucinda Marrow, in the front pew, folds her pearl-gray gloves in her lap and looks at her medic with a tenderness that makes my skin crawl.

“Call Isaiah Daly,” says Truitt.

I do not drop my hands. I want that noted somewhere.

My brother comes through the saloon doors in the pressed shirt from the bar, escorted by two of Lucinda’s pack, and he does not look at me. He looks at Judge Hickory’s cracked wig. He sits down and puts his palms on his knees exactly the way Raman did. It breaks my heart a little. Everyone in this room sits as if the chair might bite.

“Mr. Daly,” Truitt says, not unkindly. “Have you ever been inside the Marrow residence?”

“No, sir.”

My machine prints the red line under the word No before the sound is out of his mouth.

Ike does not know what it means. He hears the paper hiss and thinks it is the crowd. He glances at me, bright and baffled, and I look him in the eye and type the word No, exactly, in front of forty people.

I reach for a memory and find the shape of a hole. Ike turns seven. It is a backyard in August. There is a cake. I know there is a cake because there is always a cake. Nobody has a face. The candles have no light.

“Do you owe a debt to anyone in this pack?”

“No, sir.”

Red. Another tug behind the ribs, light as a pickpocket’s.

This one takes a morning. First day of school, a yellow bus, someone’s hand around mine on the walk to the curb. I know the hand was warm. I know somebody stayed on the sidewalk waving until the bus turned. There is a curb, a bus, and a long gap where the person goes.

I put my hand on the arm of my chair. Calder shifts his weight behind me, a half step, as if the floor had tilted.

“Where were you on Sunday night?”

“At the Drowned Rat. I closed up.”

Red. And I smell, or fail to smell, the shoebox. All day it has carried my grandmother’s hand cream, lanolin and rose and a little menthol, in my bag, on my knees, in my hair. I lift the cuff of my sleeve to my nose and breathe, and it smells of wool. The box smells of cardboard. I do not know what I am missing, because I cannot remember what it was. I only know it was in the room a moment ago.

That is three. Three lies, three gifts, three pieces of my brother’s love I will never get back. I have not known anyone to give so much while saying so little.

“Thank you, Mr. Daly,” Truitt says, with an odd gentleness. “Step down.”

Ike stands, still holding onto his smile. When he passes my table he leans in and whispers, very low, “You are the best, Counselor,” which is a thing he used to say to me in the parking lot after every spelling bee. I think. I used to know.

“The Speaker will note,” says Lucinda Marrow, “that the Scribe’s own brother has just called her tape a liar.”

Her voice carries to the rafters. She has risen and she is smiling at me, with all that warmth.

“Mrs. Marrow, sit down,” Truitt says.

“I will not, Ansel. I move to challenge the Scribe’s neutrality. The tape has marked me. It has marked her own blood. The Scribe is a young woman of eleven days’ standing, grieving, tired, and in the keeping of a man who has confessed to murder. I do not accuse her of anything. Bless her heart. I ask only that she recite the oath of her office aloud, on the Record, so that the pack may be easy.”

My mouth is dry. “The oath was taken before the Speaker alone.”

“And I ask that it be taken again before the Moot.”

Calder’s hand comes down, not on my shoulder, only near it, a warmth in the air. He says without moving his lips, “You do not have to.”

“Granted,” says Truitt, because he has no choice. The law is on her side.

I stand. My knees remember how. I put my right hand on the brass lug, and it heats so quickly I feel it in my teeth.

Every wolf in the room goes quiet. Even the sleeping boy has woken, and is watching me with his mouth open. In forty pairs of eyes I see the same light my brother had on his face when I typed his No. They are waiting to find out whether I am something they can use.

The oath is eleven lines long and every Scribe has said it. I say the first one slowly.

“I am Wren Daly, a human being.”

I do not hear the paper. I feel it, the long slow slither of the tape leaving the machine behind me, and I turn.

It comes out of the left side of Constance in a perfect curl and lies on the dusty boards at my feet. Cream, cream, cream, and then a line the red of a cut finger, running under two words of the seven I have just spoken.

Under human being.

I know nothing about it. I am, I am sure of it, twenty-nine years old, born in Port Harlan Memorial, five foot six, a person who has never in her life been anything but what she looks like.

Forty wolves hear the hiss of that paper, and my own machine tells them what I am before I know it myself.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!