Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 34

The Wharf Offer

The packet to Redhaven left Carrad Shoal at dawn, and Brandt rode it in the opposite corner of the cabin from Iva, with a rug over her knees and a file open on her lap, and did not speak to either of them for the first four hours.

“It’s not rudeness,” Hollis said, low, when Iva had looked at the rug for the fifth time. “She’s a magistrate’s examiner on her way to a hearing where one party is her subject. She can’t be seen to have rehearsed anything.”

“She slept in our kitchen.”

“She slept in Tarrow’s kitchen. There’s a difference, and she’ll tell you what it is in about nine words.”

Iva looked at him. He was sitting with his bad leg stretched into the aisle and the copper-braced cane across his lap, and he had the long gray look of a man who had spent two nights on a kitchen chair and one day buying brass.

In the hold, under a tarp lashed to the deck rail, were two crates of instruments, a dial gauge, a set of tension weights, and a reference lever he had wired Redhaven for, and every ounce of it had come out of the eleven hundred dollars.

“You spent it all,” she said.

“I spent most of it. I kept forty for the lodging.” He tipped his head back against the bulkhead. “I’d say it’s a poor way to run a business, but I don’t have a business. I have an oil can.”

“Hollis.”

“I’m not complaining. I’m reporting.” He opened one eye. “Tell before writing, remember. It’s a good rule. I made it up.”

She took his hand, the one without the cane, because there was nobody in the cabin to see and because the alternative was to say something large. His thumb moved once across her knuckles. Across the cabin, Brandt turned a page and did not look up, which Iva decided to read as a kindness.

The coast went by in strips: gray water, a thin white line of surf, the dark stand of firs above Low Hook where nothing had been rebuilt, a lighthouse she’d known by sight since she was nine. She had last stood in Redhaven in the worst year of her life. She was going back with a wire from the circuit in her coat, a bill from Hobb she had not yet opened, and thirty-five strangers and seventeen others written on the back of an envelope.

Her left hand lay open on her knee. It was warm from his.

She had not asked the wood of the cabin wall what it remembered. She’d learned not to, in her own bed, in the dark. A ship’s bulkhead had been a ship’s bulkhead for forty years, and the only thing she could have heard in it was a plank’s first purpose, which was to keep out the water.

That, at least, was a purpose she could rely on.

---

Redhaven came up out of a lid of cloud at three in the afternoon, a long gray harbor with a grain elevator at one end and the circuit hall’s copper dome at the other, and Hobb was waiting on the wharf.

He had not changed. He was the same rumpled, kind, indifferent-to-hats man she remembered from the worst year of her life, in a coat with a button missing and a leather case under his arm that had been mended with a bootlace. He took her hand in both of his and held it a moment too long.

“Miss Dane,” he said. “I’m sorry I couldn’t be at the island. I’ve been reading your wires in the order they arrived, and I’d like it noted that they got more interesting as they went.”

“I’d like it noted I didn’t do it on purpose.”

“No one ever does.” He smiled at Hollis. “Mr. Fen. We’ve corresponded. You’re taller than your handwriting.” Then, with no change in tone, he glanced across the wharf. “I’ll have a word with Miss Dane, if I may. Ahead of the other word.”

“What other word?” said Iva.

He did not answer. He simply moved his head a quarter inch.

Lucan Pask was standing at the end of the wharf with his back to the harbor, in a gray overcoat and a good hat, with his hands folded over the head of an umbrella nobody needed. He was looking at her. He had the posture of a man who had been waiting for a long time and wanted it understood that he had not minded.

“He’s been there since the noon packet,” said Hobb quietly. “I didn’t invite him.”

“No,” said Iva. “You wouldn’t.”

She walked to the end of the wharf. She did not hurry. Hollis came behind her, and she heard the cane on the planks, slow and steady, and was grateful for the sound.

“Miss Dane,” said Pask. He took off his hat. “And Mr. Fen. I’d like to say how sorry I was to hear about the Carrad matter. These things can be so disproportionate.”

“Don’t,” said Hollis.

“As you like.” Pask replaced the hat. “I won’t keep you. It’s been a fatiguing week for all of us, and I’d rather not begin the panel in the kind of mood the island seems to produce. Walk with me to the end of the pier. Five minutes. Mr. Fen may come. I’d prefer it, actually. I’d like a witness who isn’t mine.”

It was the kind of thing a person said when they had already decided what they were going to offer, and wanted it to look like a favor.

They walked. The wharf narrowed to a short pier, empty at that hour except for a heap of lobster pots and a cat on top of them. The water below was the color of slate. Pask stopped at the rail and rested one gloved hand on it.

“I’ll be plain,” he said. “I find a plain offer easier to refuse and easier to accept, and I’d like you to be able to do either.”

“Go on,” said Iva.

“The Mutual has no interest in destroying you. It has a loan. A loan, I need hardly add, taken by your late mother in good faith, signed by her in front of two witnesses, and used, I think we can say, for your direct benefit. Your counsel’s fee. Two years of your restitution escrow. A little under four thousand dollars in all, which the Mutual is entitled to see repaid.” He let a pause fall.

“From the fund Miss Orr administers. That is where your escrow went, I believe. It’s very tidy. The money is in one place.”

“It’s in the pocket of seven families,” said Iva.

“It’s in an account at the Mercantile on Lantern Street, which is a different thing, and I am not unkind. I would not take a penny from the families. I should be content with what remains of the first two escrow years, say twenty-eight eighty, less what has already been disbursed. I’d consider the rest settled.” He paused again.

“And I’d withdraw my objection to your restitution altogether. No ratification argument. No suggestion to the panel that you have adopted the arrangement by keeping its benefits. Your suspension would proceed on its own merits. I think you would find those merits quite good.”

“And in return.”

“In return, you withdraw your funding of the free retest. The fifty-two.” He said the number as if it were a little dull. “It’s a generous impulse. It’s also a stunt, Miss Dane.”

“The thing will make the Mutual look careless, will make the candidates look like clients of a charity, and will make the whole of the circuit’s work, the real work, the slow work, seem like a job for a pair of kind amateurs with a lever. You’d do better to leave it to the inquiry.”

“Which will take a year,” said Hollis.

“Perhaps eleven months.”

“And during that time thirty-five people stand on certificates your bank printed on a dead woman’s name.”

“Mr. Fen.” Pask’s voice was patient. “They are standing on certificates that have been found, by a magistrate’s examiner, to be valid under a genuine arrangement. I am not speaking out of turn. I am quoting the interim finding.”

He was, and that was the worst of it. Iva held the rail with her good hand. The cold came up through the iron into her palm.

She had made her peace, over the last week, with the way a true thing could be used. She had made her peace with Pask’s accurate quotation, his reasonable tone, his tidy sums. It did not make her less cold.

“I’d like to think about it,” she said.

Hollis’s head turned. She did not look at him.

“Of course.” Pask smiled, the first time she had seen him do it with something like warmth. “Overnight. I’m at the Harlow, on the corner of the exchange. I’ll be in the breakfast room at seven, and I shall be there until eight, and after eight I shall be at the hall. I tell you this because after eight I can no longer treat the matter as a negotiation.” He touched his hat. “Mr. Fen. Miss Dane.”

He walked away down the pier with the umbrella tapping, and the cat watched him go.

---

“You’re not going to,” said Hollis.

They were in the lodging he had found, a narrow place over a chandler’s with two rooms and a stove that smoked, and he had set the instrument crates in the corner and sat on one of them with his cane across his knees. Hobb had gone to fetch the papers. The window gave on a cobbled yard and a line of washing that the wind was turning to flags.

“I said I’d think.”

“You said it to hear what else he’d say.” He rubbed his knee through the cloth. “I know the face. You make it at me when I tell you a measure is good and you want to see if I can say why.”

“Then I’m very bad at poker.”

“You’re not bad at it. You’re only bad at it with me.” His voice was gentle. “Say it. I’d sooner hear it than have you carry it.”

Iva sat on the edge of the other bed with her hands between her knees.

“It’s twenty-eight eighty,” she said. “If I say yes, it comes out of the fund. It’s mostly the second year’s escrow, and the second year is what Tamsin has already started to pay out. To a woman called Ines Gorey who lost her husband at the Low Hook closure, and who I have never met, and who has been, according to Tamsin’s last statement, buying coal on it.” She stopped.

“And the fund shortens by twenty-eight eighty, and Pask says the rest is settled, and I walk into the panel with no ratification argument against me and no suspension fight. The suspension proceeds on its merits. It might even be lifted. In a year. Or two.”

“And the seventeen. And the thirty-five.”

“Stay as they are. Unretested. Nell with her certificate, which is true now by law and false by every fact I know.” She looked at the stove. “I’d have a clean slate. A chance to work. I’d have my own name back by spring.”

“And you’d have taken it out of Ines Gorey’s coal.”

“Yes.”

“And you’d have let the Mutual choose which of its fifty-two to correct.”

“Yes.”

“Then I think you’ve said it,” said Hollis.

She had. She hadn’t known it until the words were out, and then she could not take them back, nor did she want to. A part of her was sitting very quietly at the bottom of her own chest with its arms folded, saying: you could have had it. Eleven months. A clean line. And a bigger part, flat and level and surprisingly unafraid, was saying: and you would have known.

“I’d like it noted,” she said, “that I took a night.”

“It’s noted. You took the night and you spent it on me.” He grinned, lopsided. “I’ll want a receipt.”

“You’ll get a receipt.” She laughed. It came out odd, thin, with something under it. “God. I don’t want to be right about this. I wanted to be a person who could take the clean line.”

“You’d have been terrible at it. You’d have spent your whole life checking every certificate you ever signed against its own purpose.” He put out his hand, and she took it. “It’s the thing I like best about you. Mind you, it’s very bad for business.”

“Is that a complaint?”

“It’s an invoice.” He kissed her knuckles, once, a quick, rueful kiss. “I’ll sleep on the crate. Nobody’s coming to throw me out.”

“Don’t be an idiot, the other bed’s twice the size you need.”

“I’ve a knee.”

“I have a knee too, in a manner of speaking. It’s my shoulder.” She moved over and made room, because the lodging had two rooms but the second had a roof leak, and because for once she did not want to be alone with a decision she’d already made.

She slept badly, with her hand in his, and woke twice to the sound of the cat arguing with a gutter.

---

The wire from Carrad was in the lodging’s pigeonhole at six.

Hobb brought it up himself. He had a roll under his arm and a bag from a baker’s, and he knocked in a pattern that was probably meant to be tactful. He put the bag on the table and held out the wire to Hollis with two fingers, as if it were damp.

Hollis opened it standing. He read it once. This time he did not fold it.

“What does it say?” said Iva.

“It says what it said before, only with fewer words.” He passed it across. It was short, typed in Odell’s capitals but dated from the Shoal.

COMMISSION CANCELLED STOP DEPOSIT RETURNED UNDER SEPARATE COVER STOP NO FURTHER DEALINGS ON RETIRED INSTRUMENTS STOP CARRAD

“That’s not a hold,” said Hobb.

“No.” Hollis sat down on the crate. “That’s a door shut. The first one was the bank being afraid. This is the bank being told.” He pressed the heel of his hand against one eye. “I’d have liked another week. Another week of thinking it might come back.”

Iva read the wire twice. She was aware, distantly, of Hobb unwrapping a bun for her and setting it on the table. She was aware of the cold in the room.

“It’s because of me,” she said.

“It’s because of Pask. And a loan. And a man called Carrad who doesn’t have a spine.” Hollis’s mouth twitched. “It is not because of you. If you tell me it is, I’ll go and stand in the harbor.”

“Mr. Fen,” said Hobb, mildly, “the harbor is thirty degrees. I’d rather you didn’t.”

“Fine. I’ll sulk indoors.” He folded the wire in half, and in half again, and put it in his shirt pocket with the other. “Mr. Hobb. If you’ve the docket, I’d like to read it before I do something unwise.”

“I have the docket.” Hobb took the roll from under his arm and spread it on the table, pinning the corners with the bun, a saucer, and Iva’s mug. He had a small neat hand and a way of underlining things twice. “I’ve read it three times. I’d like you both to read it once, and I’d like Miss Dane to tell me what she sees.”

It was a docket sheet, two columns, on the circuit’s thin green paper. The caption was the one she’d have known in her sleep: IN THE MATTER OF THE COLLECTION LICENSE OF I. DANE, REVIEW OF REMIT. Below it, the parties. Respondent, I. Dane, by counsel R. Hobb. The Circuit. And then:

INTERESTED PARTY: HARBOR MUTUAL COMPANY OF REDHAVEN, BY ITS TRUST DEPARTMENT. WITNESS: L. PASK, TRUST OFFICER.

She read it. She read it again.

“Trust officer,” she said.

“Yes.”

“Not counsel. He’s been telling us for a week he’s the Mutual’s counsel.” She heard her own voice go up. “In every room. He drafted my mother’s will, for God’s sake. He wrote the facsimile clause. Hobb, he said it to Brandt in the shed, he said ‘as the Mutual’s counsel.’ Brandt let him.”

“Brandt let him because a conference is permissive,” said Hobb. “A panel isn’t. The docket says what a person is, and the docket is a sworn paper.” He tapped the line with a pencil. “He filed this himself. Two weeks ago, in his own hand, under his own title. A trust officer is an employee of the lender. A trust officer is not a lawyer, and is not an officer of the court, and cannot cross-examine anyone. Nor can he, strictly speaking, argue.”

“Then who does?”

“That is what I should like to know.” He underlined it twice. “If there is a Mutual advocate, he’s not named. I’ve asked the clerk. The clerk looked pained and told me the interested party would ‘appear by its witness.’”

“So Pask intends to testify,” said Hollis slowly, “and argue by testifying.”

“I think Mr. Pask intends to be a witness who happens to say things in the order of a speech. It is an old trick. A permissive chair allows it. A strict chair does not.” Hobb sat down heavily and unwrapped a second bun. “Which is why I should like to know the chair. I’ve been told the panel is three. I’ve been told two of them. I have not been given the third.”

“Is that usual?” said Iva.

“No.” He bit the bun. “It’s very much not.”

At seven, from the window of the lodging, they watched Pask cross the cobbled yard on the other side of the street with his umbrella, headed for the Harlow’s breakfast room. At ten past seven Iva watched him through the glass of the corner restaurant, stirring his coffee, alone at a table for four.

She did not go in. At eight he looked at his watch, snapped it shut, and left.

---

The circuit hall stood on the exchange, under its copper dome gone green, and a roster was pinned to the board in the lobby, as it was for every sitting, under a glass frame that had once been polished.

A knot of people had gathered. Tamsin Orr was there, small and brisk in a gray coat with a notebook, speaking to two women who stood close together and looked at nobody. Iva knew one of them, from the photograph in the fund’s first statement, as Ines Gorey. She saw Rue Ansley, who had come on the same packet, in her good dress and gloves, with Nell beside her.

Perrin Vail had a stack of folders and a pencil behind his ear, and he nodded at Iva once without a word.

Brandt came in last, walking alone. She took a place at the back of the lobby, near a pillar, where she could see the board and not be seen to be part of anything.

Hobb, at Iva’s elbow, took his spectacles from his pocket.

“Presiding,” he read aloud. “Examiner Hester Calloway. Member, Examiner Dorrance Lyle. Member.”

He stopped.

Iva read it past his shoulder. She read the line, and then the name, and then, because her mind did not want to carry the two together, she read the line again.

The third seat of the panel that would sit in judgment on her license and on the money that had paid her way, had been filled that morning by the rotation of the circuit’s board of examiners. The rotation was statutory. The name was in black ink, in a clerk’s tidy hand, on the glass.

Member, Examiner of Instruments H. Carrad, Carrad Shoal Training Yard.

Behind her, very softly, Hollis said a word she had never heard him use.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!