The morning packet left at seven, and by a quarter to, Hollis had already lost three arguments about it.
He lost the first to the landlady, who had decided in the night that a man with a splinted leg could not be carried down her stairs by one porter and a nephew, and who had commandeered the coal-man as well. He lost the second to the porters, who set the chair down on the wharf boards with a gentleness that was an insult in itself.
He lost the third to the harbor wind, which came across the Redhaven basin smelling of tar and fish and took his hat clean off his knee and rolled it, with great dignity, toward the water.
Perrin Vail caught it. He had come down at six, in the dark, to see the chair off, and he stood now with the hat held against his chest, solemn as a verger.
“I’ll mind your instruments,” he said.
“You’ll mind a good deal more than that.” Hollis took the hat back and looked at it. “Perrin. If Madam Brandt says a thing is so, write it down as hers, even if you agree. Especially if you agree.”
“I know.”
“I know you know. I’m saying it because I’ll not be there to.” He put the hat on his knee and turned it around once, and Iva saw that he was stalling, and she understood that nobody in the world had ever been able to make Hollis stall before this week.
The packet lay against the wharf with her gangway down and her stack breathing. Gulls sat along her rail in an orderly row, the way they did when a boat was about to leave, as if they had been told. A boy was rolling barrels up the plank. The sky over the basin had just gone from black to the dirty gray of a slate that has been washed and not yet dried.
“You’ll want to say something,” said Hollis.
“I’ve said it.”
“You said it last night. It’s morning. People say different things in the morning.” He looked up at her, and his face in that light was thin and clear and entirely without defenses. “I’ll start. I’m not any good at this. I think I’ve been waiting for you to be in trouble, a little, so that I could be useful, and I find I’d rather be useless and have you not in trouble. That’s all. I don’t suppose it makes sense.”
“It makes sense.”
“Does it?”
“I’ve spent a month waiting for the next thing to be taken from me so that I’d know I was alive.” She crouched beside the chair, so that she did not have to speak down to him. “I’ve changed my mind about that. It’s an expensive way to find out.”
He took her hand, and for a moment neither of them said a word, because there was a porter within earshot who plainly wished to be told whether the gentleman was going or staying.
“Ordinary things,” said Hollis.
“Every day.”
“The kettle in my sister’s kitchen has a lid that doesn’t sit. I shall have a great deal to say about it.”
“Say it.”
“And you’ll write back.”
“I’ll write back about the weather in Sallow,” said Iva, “if I get there.”
He went very still. He had not been told, in so many words, that she meant to go; he had been told that she would not go until she had been given leave, and he had made himself believe it, because he needed to. She watched him decide not to say anything, and it was the kindest thing anyone had done for her that month.
“Come back,” he said. “I’ll not ask you for the how.”
She kissed him, briefly, on the forehead, like a woman seeing off a brother, because the porter was looking, and because if she had done it properly she would not have let him go.
---
Venable received her at nine, in chambers, because the chamber itself was being swept for the noon.
It was the first time Iva had seen the arbiter without the gown. She wore a gray woolen dress with a brooch at the throat, and her bad hip was propped on a cushion in a deep chair behind a table whose surface had been wiped clean of everything except one inkwell and the sealed tin. The tin sat in the middle like a small coffin.
Wray stood at the window with his hands behind him, and Hobb sat by the door with his hat on his knee, and the room smelled of camphor and cold toast.
“I am told,” said Venable, “that you wish to carry a sealed exhibit out of this jurisdiction.”
“Yes, madam.”
“On the strength of a telegram from a man who has already lied to this court once, by leaving at night.”
“He told Mr. Hobb and me the truth when it was safe to,” said Iva. “He left a carbon of the true letter. The telegram says come alone, and bring the cold disk. I think the second part matters more than the first.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s the part Pask would not have written. Pask could make Senn write come. But Pask wants the disk destroyed, not carried across a strait. If Senn were writing for him, he’d have asked me to leave it in Redhaven.”
Venable considered this for a time, tapping the arm of her chair with one finger.
“That is not nothing,” she said. “It is not a great deal either. Mr. Wray.”
“Madam.” Wray turned from the window. He looked, as he always looked, as if he had been issued a face for work and kept it in a drawer at night. “I have a view. The disk is an exhibit in a referral to this office. It is cold, and it has spoken, and the only living person who heard it in full is the person I wish to prosecute. I would prefer it stayed in a safe.”
“And?”
“And I would prefer more that the other witness, Senn, was not lost to the outer ports with whatever he is holding.” He turned a pencil end over end. “I can seal the tin with the circuit’s wax. I can put a clerk’s log in it. If the seal is broken in front of anyone but the collector, I shall know, and I shall say so under oath. That is the whole of what I can do.”
“And what would you have her do, Mr. Wray, if the seal must be broken?”
“Break it before a notary,” said Wray. “At Sallow there will be one. There always is.”
Venable looked at Iva for a long moment.
“There are conditions,” she said.
“Yes, madam.”
“The tin goes in your hand and not in a box. It does not leave your sight, including when you sleep.
“A notary, or a magistrate, or a port officer, is to be present at the opening, and you will take his name, his hour and his seal. You will write down every hour of the journey, on the circuit’s printed log, and you will sign it at the beginning and the end.” She paused. “And Mr. Hobb will stand surety for the exhibit in his own name, to a sum he and I have already discussed.”
“Thirty dollars,” said Hobb comfortably. “It is a figure I can lose.”
“Mr. Hobb.”
“Madam, I am a solicitor. I have lost larger sums on worse people.” He looked at Iva over his spectacles. “I assure you I have never once regretted this particular loss in advance.”
She had no words for it, so she said, “Thank you.”
“Do not thank me,” said Venable. “The estate has nineteen days left to pay its balance, and it is ninety-seven dollars and eighty-four cents short. A woman who gives up her working days to run to a harbor is a woman who is not making that sum. I want it on the record that I know this.” She picked up her pen. “I do not want you to come back to me on the last day and tell me you spent the other eighteen looking for a bolt.”
“It’s not a bolt.”
“It never is.” The old woman almost smiled. “Go and get your things.”
---
The noon was nothing like Iva had feared. It was worse. It was courteous.
Maddox received them in the antechamber of the Mutual’s Redhaven office, a long room with a carpet and a window onto the harbor, and he had had the table laid. There was a pot of coffee. There was a plate of small hard biscuits, arranged in a fan. There were two documents on a blotter, side by side, as neatly as a pair of gloves.
He rose when she came in. Hobb she had expected to be treated as furniture, but Maddox gave him the second chair and poured for him first.
“Miss Dane. Mr. Hobb.” He sat. “I have only one thing to say, and I shall say it before the coffee cools, so that you may not feel you were kept. The offer stands as I made it.
“The Mutual forgives the balance, the two thousand eight hundred and eighty dollars and the forty dollars of costs, and does not call Mr. Carrad’s note. In return you release the Mutual and its trust department from all claims arising out of the certificates, including the thirty-five, and including any claim by Miss Nell Brannock, who I understand has been tested by Mr. Hollis.”
“You understand a good deal.”
“It is my trade.” He said it without malice. “I should add, because it will be asked, that I have not discussed the offer with Mr. Pask. I am not instructed to treat with him. The committee did not ask me to.”
“Will the committee honor it?”
“If I say so, yes.” He looked at her steadily. “I have been entrusted with the matter in a manner that does not require me to ask. That is not nothing, Miss Dane. In my experience it is rare.”
Iva looked at the two documents on the blotter. One was the release, six pages, stapled at the corner. The other was a smaller sheet, a single page, headed in a clerk’s script: Schedule B, Instruments Withdrawn. She had seen it. She knew what it said, the list of eleven frames, and the twelfth, and the note about maintenance.
She thought about the money. She thought about Carrad’s shop, and the long tired face of him in the back room with a cup of strong tea. She thought about ninety-seven dollars and eighty-four cents, a sum she could have made with a good month’s collecting, and about the fact that she had not had a good month in six weeks and had no hope of one.
It would be so easy. That was the horrible thing. She could feel how easy it would be, in her hand, like a coin that was already warm.
“No,” she said.
“I beg your pardon?”
“No, Mr. Maddox. I’ll not sign it.” She heard her own voice and was surprised at how little it shook. “I don’t doubt you’d keep your word. I don’t doubt the committee would too.
“But there’s a girl at the Shoal who was told her hands did not reach, and she’d be out of the Mutual’s reach by my own signature, and so would every girl in every upper room that I haven’t seen yet. I don’t know how many there are. You do. I’d be signing away an answer to a question I don’t know how to ask.”
Maddox looked at her for a few seconds. He did not look angry, and that was the worst of it. He looked as if he had hoped to be wrong about something and had instead been right.
“I’d hoped you’d say that,” he said, “and I’d hoped you wouldn’t.”
“Which hope will you keep?”
“The first, I think.” He drew the release toward him and laid his hand flat on it. “Mr. Hobb, you have my regret and my compliments. I should like it recorded, since you’ll record it anyway, that the Mutual made the offer in good faith.”
Hobb inclined his head, which was all the answer there was.
Maddox was already half-turned to the window. He picked up the small sheet, Schedule B, and folded it once, and, as he did so, Iva saw that he had written something on the back of it in pencil, in a fast, cramped hand not meant for her. She read it upside down, in the instant before it vanished into his coat. It said: No. 7/8 Sallow. Not ours?
“Mr. Maddox.”
“Miss Dane?”
“What’s seven and eight?”
His face did nothing at all. He was good. He was, she thought, very good, trained for thirty years to keep his face still in a room of lawyers, and taken by surprise now by a girl from Pell Street.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “A note to myself.”
“Of course.”
“I should tell you, in fairness, that I do not know what it means.” He buttoned his coat. “That is why it is a question mark. The Mutual’s schedule lists twelve frames: eleven withdrawn for maintenance, one at the Shoal. Seven and eight stand among the withdrawn. Nothing in our books says they went to Sallow, or anywhere.
“If someone has put frames in a school and called them ours, the Mutual would like to know it before you do.” He bowed slightly. “I should be grateful if you’d tell me.”
“I’ll tell the arbiter.”
“Of course.” He picked up his dispatch case. “One more thing, Miss Dane, and I give it to you as one who’d like to be liked, not as counsel. Mr. Pask has bought passage on the half past four feeder. He did it an hour ago. He had his clerk buy it, and the clerk is a poor liar.”
“Does he know?”
“That you intend to be on it?” Maddox shook his head. “He knows nothing, I think. He has merely observed that it is the one boat in the harbor that no one has any reason to take. And that is a reason.”
He left. Hobb sat for a moment with his hands on the head of his stick.
“Well,” he said. “That was a first-rate piece of refusing.”
“I thought I should be sick.”
“One does.” He rose. “It passes. It is quite a good sign.”
---
The tin was small. She had thought, before she held it, that she would feel its weight, as one feels the weight of a thing one has been told is important. It weighed no more than a tea caddy. The circuit’s wax was a hard red seal on its lid, stamped with the arbiter’s chop, and on its underside, scratched in pencil, Wray’s neat hand had written: Exhibit 14, Estate of A. Dane. Do not open except before a notary.
She packed it in the carpetbag between two stockings. She packed a spare dress, the log, three pencils, bread and cheese from the landlady, who cried a little.
The long envelope that Carrad had given her she put in the inside pocket of her jacket, against her ribs. She did not take the list of effects. Perrin was to keep the accounting. He had gone white when she told him, and had said, in a hoarse voice, that he would keep it as if it were his own, and she believed him.
She wrote the first entry in the log at ten past one, standing at the landlady’s table. Ten past one. Exhibit 14 in my hand. The tin is sealed; the seal intact. I am going to Sallow.
She stopped. Under it she added, because it was true and she would not have it said later that she had left it out, I do not know why.
There was a small noise behind her. Brandt stood in the doorway in her traveling cloak, the one she wore when she went to the Shoal, with her mouth set. She had not been sent for. She had walked, apparently, a mile in the cold.
“You are going to ask me to come,” said Iva.
“I am going to tell you that I will not.” Brandt came in and set down on the table, very carefully, a small flat packet wrapped in a handkerchief. “I am seventy-one. I cannot take a feeder in November and be of use at the end of it. But I can give you this.”
It was a loupe. It was a good one, brass, in a leather cover, the kind an examiner of documents wears on a cord about the neck.
“It was Ada’s,” said Brandt. “She left it with me for safekeeping, the year before she died. I never gave it back. I was not sure you would want it.”
Iva took it and turned it over. On the rim, so small that she would have missed it if she had not been taught how to look, there was a single pin-prick.
“If you must read a mark,” said Brandt, “read it with her eye.”
Iva put the cord round her neck. The brass was cold, and then it was not.
“Go,” said Brandt. “The boat does not wait for old women.”
At twenty to two she shouldered the bag and went up the hill toward the committee hall, with the tin against her hip, and found that she was not afraid. She was merely awake, every nerve alive, like the moment before a stair climbed ten thousand times is discovered to be missing a step.
She did not see Pask yet. But she knew he was somewhere in the town, with a ticket bought that morning, counting the hours to half past four.

