Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 45

A Third Hand

The man the Board found for the handwriting was seventy and retired and had a bad hip, and he did not rush for anyone.

His name was Hollis Weir. He had run the questioned-documents bench at the state crime laboratory for twenty-two years, until the budget committee decided the bench could be an outsourced line item.

Now he worked from a spare bedroom in a house near the river, with a north window, a binocular microscope, and a collection of brass rulers that Rusk said he had once seen used as a pointer in a lecture hall. The formal examiner’s queue stood at eleven weeks. Rusk had telephoned Weir at noon and asked only whether he would look at nineteen small pieces of paper before Thursday.

“A preliminary,” Weir had said. “Not a report. I’ll tell you what I can see in three hours. I won’t tell you what I’d swear to.”

“That’s what we need.”

“It’s also what people forget I said.”

They went to his house at three, in the Board’s sedan: Rusk driving, Pryor in the passenger seat with a briefcase on his knees, and Lindqvist in the back beside Petra. Cora had been told she could come. She had said she would rather wait at the lodge.

It was Lindqvist who had insisted, in her small exact voice, that her client at least be asked, and Cora who had answered after a long pause that she did not want to watch a stranger decide whether she was a liar.

So it was Petra, silent, with her hands in her lap, who sat on an upright chair in Weir’s spare bedroom and watched an old man take her mother’s handwriting apart.

He worked at a drafting table under the window. The room smelled of dust and warm lamp. Nineteen items lay on the table in labeled sleeves: the rent receipt from the notebook, the twelve gray cards from Lyle’s envelope and coffee can (a county deputy up north had fetched the can on Lyle’s written consent, and a courier had brought it down by two), the yellow carbon of the waiver with its witness line, and five exemplars.

Three of them were Cora’s: a grocery list, a library card signed in a faded hand, and the back of a Christmas card that Lindqvist had retrieved from Cora’s bureau. Two were Petra’s, her old timesheet and the lodge’s intake form from the week of the rescue.

Weir did not speak for an hour and a half. He turned each sleeve over with a pair of long tweezers. He laid a brass ruler against a stroke and breathed through his nose. Once he said “hm,” and Pryor leaned forward, and Weir said, “Not you. The paper.”

At twenty to five he took off his glasses.

“I’m going to tell you three things,” he said. “I’ll tell you them slowly, and I’d like Ms. Lindqvist to write them down. And I’d like it understood that I haven’t had the ink analyzed, or the originals out of their sleeves, or the time. This is an hour’s looking.”

“Understood,” said Lindqvist.

“The first thing is that every one of the questioned writings was made by the same hand. The fourteen aren’t fourteen. They’re one. The notebook receipt, the twelve cards, and the witness line on the carbon. The same person wrote all of them.”

He held up a finger. “That’s a strong statement, and I’m not walking it back. The letter forms are identical in construction. The baseline wavers the same amount. The pen lifts come in the same places. I’d put that at better than ninety percent.”

“The second thing?” said Pryor.

“The second thing is that the hand isn’t Mrs. Bale’s.” He laid the Christmas card beside one of the gray postcards and angled the lamp. “I’ll give you the reason, and I’d ask you to see it for yourself.”

He moved aside. Pryor looked, and then Lindqvist. Petra stayed where she was until Weir said, not unkindly, “You may come and look, Ms. Bale. I won’t ask you to touch.”

She stood at his shoulder. The two signatures lay one above the other under the lamp. They were so alike that, at the distance of a room, they were the same word. At the distance of a hand they were not.

“Look at the C,” Weir said. “On the Christmas card, the loop closes early, because Mrs. Bale writes quickly and her wrist is leading. On the postcard, the loop closes early too. It’s copied. But the stroke that makes it is slow. Look at the thickness. A fast stroke has a thin tail where the pen leaves the paper. This tail’s thick. The writer slowed down to make the shape. It’s a drawing of a signature, not a signature.”

“A forgery,” said Petra.

“I use the word simulation. It’s a more accurate word.” He sat back. “A good simulation. The best I’ve seen in a long time. And a patient one. Someone studied her hand and practiced it, and could do it in their sleep, almost. Almost. The tell is the slowness, and it’s slight.”

“Almost in their sleep,” Pryor said slowly. “That’s your phrase?”

“It’s an examiner’s phrase. A person who has done a signature a thousand times doesn’t think about it. The pressure becomes even. In these, it’s too even. A real signature has a tiredness. This has none.” He tapped the card. “These twelve years of postcards, I’d say, were written by someone who was never tired.”

Nobody laughed.

“And the third thing?” said Lindqvist, whose pen had not paused.

Weir turned the carbon over. The witness line lay under the lamp, a looping P and a looping B.

“The third is that this one’s the same hand as the others. And it isn’t Ms. Bale’s either.” He glanced at Petra. “I compared it with your timesheet. You have a straight P, and you close the bowl of your B with a flick I don’t see here. This writer closes the B in two strokes. I’d put the chance that you wrote this at very small, and I’ll say it carefully. I’d put it below one in ten, on this look.”

Petra’s knees went loose. She put a hand on the back of the chair.

“I’ll say what I’m not saying,” Weir went on. “I’m not telling you who did write it. I’m not telling you the signatures are Mrs. Bale’s mother’s or her daughter’s or anyone’s. I’m telling you a person with a very good eye and a lot of patience produced a version of two people’s names, and I can’t see her, or him, in the paper.”

“Is there anything else you can say about the hand?” Rusk asked.

“One thing.” Weir picked up a brass ruler and held it a little away from the paper, so that its edge lay along the slant of the postcard’s script. “Whoever it was, they were taught penmanship in a school with a model. A Palmer-style drill. The capital forms are too regular. It’s old-fashioned. It’s the hand of someone over sixty.” He set the ruler down. “I’d say seventy or more. But a hand can lie about its age. I wouldn’t write that in a report.”

It took Petra a moment to understand why the word seventy had gone through her like a cold needle. Then she heard, in her head, the quiet kitchen on Alder Court, and the radio playing a bar of cello, and Vera Sloan saying I’m a notary.

She said nothing. It was not her question. She stood by the lamp, and the silence in the room grew a degree colder, and Rusk was already looking at the same thing she was, with the same face.

“Preliminary,” Weir said again, softly. “I’ll say it once more. Preliminary. If somebody walks into a hearing room tomorrow and says Hollis Weir says Ms. Sloan wrote the cards, I’ll deny it in print.”

“Nobody will say that,” said Pryor.

“Somebody will. People are fond of a name.”

He would not be drawn further. Rusk wrapped the sleeves in their envelopes while Weir lowered himself onto the edge of the bed to rest the bad hip, and on the way down the front path Pryor stopped Petra with two fingers on her sleeve.

“I saw your face when he said seventy.”

“I watched her sign her statement on Monday,” Petra said. “Every page. She writes small and upright, almost printing. Nothing like those loops.”

“That is a layperson’s observation about a woman who knew she was being watched.” He said it kindly. “Mr. Weir hasn’t seen her hand, and he has said himself that a hand can lie about its age. Please do not carry that sentence anywhere tonight. Not to your mother, not to your daughter, and above all not to Alder Court.”

“I won’t.”

“I know you won’t. I’m saying it so that I have said it.”

Petra nodded. In the car she sat with her hands under her thighs, as she had as a child on cold buses, and watched the river go by in pieces between the warehouses. She was trying to remember whether Vera’s carbons, laid out on the lemon oilcloth, had carried a single signature of Vera’s own, and found that she could not. Everything she had seen of the woman’s work had been typed.

---

They had gone eleven miles back toward the city when Rusk’s phone rang through the car’s speaker. He took it without slowing.

“Rusk.”

It was a woman’s voice, thick with the flat vowels of a county seat, and what she said was brisk and a little defensive. She identified herself as the postmaster of a branch two hours north, and said she had been handed an order at one o’clock by a sheriff’s deputy, and that she had read it three times, and that she had opened Box 4410 at two with a witness from the Board, as directed, and had put the contents in a bag.

“What’s in it?” said Rusk.

“That’s why I’m calling.” A pause, filled by the hum of tires. “It’s rented to a firm. Denner Survey, Inc. Rental began twelve years ago October and has been paid annually since. The term ran to the end of October. It was renewed in person, with two days to spare.”

“When, exactly?”

“Last month.” She rustled paper. “Tuesday the twenty-ninth. It was done in person, at the counter, in cash. I wasn’t the clerk, I was in the back, but Danielle was on the window, and she remembers because it was the first time she’d seen anyone come in for that box. She says it was a woman. Tall. A gray coat, long, with the sleeves too short. She wore a pencil behind her ear.”

Nobody in the car moved.

“Danielle says the woman signed the form with a name. She printed it, then she signed. Danielle noticed the signature because it was beautiful. She says she thought, that’s a person who learned to write properly. She read the printed name upside down. Cora Bale.”

Petra’s breath left her.

“Thank you, Ms.—”

“There’s more. You’ll want to hear the contents.” The postmaster’s voice had dropped into the careful register of a person describing something she wished she had not seen. “There’s no mail in the box. Not in the ordinary sense. There’s a rubber stamp in a plastic bag. RECEIVED, PAID THROUGH. And an ink pad. And a flat cardboard box, and in it, standing on edge, a stack of postcards. Gray. Printed. About a hundred and twenty.”

“Postcards.”

“Every one signed already, at the bottom, in blue ink. And dated. Mr. Rusk, they’re dated ahead.” A beat. “Each has a first of the month on it. The first is next month. The last is, I counted, ten years from now.”

The car slowed. Rusk had not touched the brake. It was the traffic, a line of red lights across the rise, and he came to a stop in the left lane and sat with both hands on the wheel.

“There’s one more,” the postmaster said. “On top of the stack. It isn’t gray. It’s yellow. Like a carbon. It’s addressed in the same hand. To Cora Bale, care of Denner Survey, at the box. There’s no stamp. It was put in the box, not mailed. It was waiting.”

“What does it say?”

“I’ll read it exactly.” Paper crackled. “It says, in blue ink, Thank you for renewing. See you at the hearing.”

---

The lodge dining room was empty by the time they got back. Someone had pushed the long tables into a rough square and left the chairs stacked, and a single fluorescent tube over the coffee station hummed to itself, throwing a cold blue wash across the linoleum. It was almost nine. Petra had not realized how long they had been in the car.

Cora was at the far table, with her coat on the chair and her hands around a mug that had gone cold. Tilda was beside her, with her geography map unrolled under her elbow, pretending to read. She looked up as the door opened. She looked at Petra’s face and at Pryor’s, and closed her pencil case with a click.

“I’ll go to the room,” Tilda said.

“You don’t have to,” said Cora.

“I want to.” She gathered the map, rolling it carefully so the delta would not smudge. At the door she stopped and said to Petra, in an ordinary voice, “I ate dinner. Grandma made me eat the soup. It was fine.” And went.

Lindqvist sat down across from her client. She laid her pen parallel to the edge of the table, and then, for the first time Petra had seen, picked it up again and held it in her hand like a thing she might need.

“Cora,” she said. “Where were you on Tuesday the twenty-ninth?”

Cora looked at her. She looked at Rusk, and Pryor, and finally at Petra, with an expression Petra had never seen on her mother, a bewildered, unguarded look, like a woman checking her pockets for a key.

“The twenty-ninth,” she said. “I was at the lodge.”

“All day?”

“I went to the library at ten. I came back at noon. I had lunch.” Her voice was careful. “Tilda had a half day. We, I think we walked. We walked to the pond.” She stopped. “I think.”

“You think.”

“I’m sure.” She said it too fast. “I’m sure. I’d know where I was.”

Rusk, at the end of the table, had set the bag with the postmaster’s photographs on the linoleum. He did not open it. He said, in the flat voice of a man who has learned that kindness is a form of accuracy, “Mrs. Bale. Do you own a gray coat?”

Cora turned her head.

Her coat hung over the back of the chair beside her, with its sleeves tucked in, as it always was, as Petra had seen it in every room for two weeks. It was a long coat, a good wool, the color of a rainy road. The sleeves, tucked into each other like the folded arms of a sleeping person, were an inch too short.

“I’ve had it for thirty years,” Cora said. Her voice cracked, and was steady, and cracked again. “I’ve had it as long as I’ve had a daughter.”

Nobody spoke. Under the humming tube the blue light lay on the table like water. Petra looked at her mother’s hands, long hands, with the knuckles swollen at the joints and a faint blue ink stain on the side of the right forefinger, and she heard her own voice from a long way off, saying nothing, saying nothing at all.

“Mrs. Bale,” said Rusk, gently, “where is your pencil?”

Cora put her hand to her ear. It was an old reflex, the instinct of someone who has worn a pencil there for forty years. She touched her gray hair and the arm of her glasses.

She drew her hand away. Between her thumb and finger was a short, sharpened yellow pencil, worn to a stub, that none of them had seen her put there.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!