At 4:58 a.m. on Monday I make the decision, and it takes the form of a pen.
I have not slept. I have lain on a motel bed in Sioux City with a cream envelope on my chest, listening to the ice machine and to a man who counts in his sleep. At some point around three, Soren said “forty-one” in a clear voice and turned over, and I understood that he was in Room 114 of Mercy Willows, reading the Walk to no one. I did not wake him. There are hours that belong to him.
Now I sit at the motel’s business center, which is a desk, a printer, and a laminated sign that says THIS COMPUTER IS FOR GUESTS, and I take a sheet of Ninefold letterhead from Theo’s fax and write, in blue ink, a list.
Exhibit A: Heron Foundation count, October 19 vote. Exhibit B: Hartung medical record, October 18, with consent. Exhibit C: Prairie Wing Children’s Hospital Endowment Fund, gift instrument, Section 4 (no lending). Exhibit D: Gray Heron Holdings, promissory note, $412,000. Exhibit E: Ames flight manifest, October 19.
I look at the next line for a long time.
Exhibit F.
I write: Guarantee of Payment, October 20, Gray Heron Holdings to a Michigan memory-care facility, $61,400, secured by assignment of Loss Proceeds, Policy 14-C.
The pen stops. It’s a perfectly good pen. It’s the one the Skillet gives away with the bill.
If it goes in, the Committee will know that Hartley Grosz, using money that belongs to sick children, pre-paid a woman’s care in exchange for her appetite for a catastrophe. The Underwriter will know that the chair of the Special Committee holds a financial interest in the key’s failure.
Northgate’s counsel will read Article Nine with a highlighter. And somewhere in Marquette, a facility administrator will look at his own file and see that the guarantor has become a defendant, and that a woman in Room 22, Level 3, has a bed with a clock on it.
If it doesn’t go in, Exhibits A through E still prove the loan was a fraud. But they prove only that Grosz stole. They don’t prove why he needs the key to fail by Christmas Eve. They don’t show the motive. A court can forgive a thief. It cannot forgive a man who has paid, in advance, for a funeral.
At 5:20, Theo calls. He doesn’t say good morning.
“I’ve got the exhibit list on my screen with a blank at F,” he says. “Calloway is awake and says she’ll witness either version. I’ll sign either version. I’m telling you that now so you know it’s not mine.”
“It’s mine.”
“It is.” A pause. “Jo, for what it’s worth, you could redact the resident.”
I look at the page. I had not thought of it, which tells me how tired I am, or how stubborn.
“I redact the resident’s name and the room number and the date of birth,” I say slowly. “I leave the guarantor, the facility’s state, the amount, the date, the assignment. The reader sees a stranger’s bed. Grosz sees the bed he built.”
“And Voss?”
“Voss sees what I did. Whether I hid the name or not.” I write RESIDENT: REDACTED next to F, and underline it twice. “I’d like her to see I tried. It’s not much. It’s the size of a pair of shoes.”
---
At 7:59:50 Central, which is a few seconds shy of 9:00 on the East Coast, where the Committee keeps its clocks, I press Send.
It goes in three copies. The Special Committee of the Board, care of Hartley Grosz, Chair. Harrow and Pike Underwriting, Cornelius Pike, Underwriter. And a third, which the engagement letter does not require and which I add in the very last second, in my own name: a single sealed courtesy copy to Judge Beatrice Cho’s chambers, care of Arvid Kask, so that nobody can say the Court wasn’t told.
The cover note is four lines. I wrote it at 5:44 and did not change a word.
“Delivered concurrently, in identical words, at 9:00 a.m. Eastern. Signed J. A. Pruitt, Independent Loss Assessor. Signed T. Marsh, Chief Operating Officer. Witnessed I. Calloway. Six exhibits attached. No copy has been given to any party before any other.”
Nobody has ever sent anything more boring in the history of commerce. It is the best sentence I know.
The business center clock says 9:00:11 Eastern. I sit with my hands in my lap, and Dale, who has been standing at the door all this time in a clean shirt and a tie he must have bought at a gas station, says, “That’s it?”
“That’s it.”
“No explosions?”
“The explosion’s in the paper,” I say. “It’s just in a very small font.”
---
At 9:12 the motel phone rings. It’s the lobby phone, on a coiled cord, bolted to a wall, and the boy in the hoodie holds it out at arm’s length with a face that says he has never seen it ring.
“A Mr. Pike,” he whispers. “He says it’s about a policy.”
I take it. The cord is about eight inches too short; I end up crouching by the desk with my ear against a rubber hand.
“Ms. Pruitt,” says Cornelius Pike. He is thinner on the phone, and drier, like paper before it’s folded. “I have been reading for eleven minutes. I should like to tell you that I have been reading, as it were, with admiration.”
“I didn’t ask for that.”
“No. That’s what I admire.” Something rustles. “You have, in a single morning, made a decision that I have been unable to make for six weeks. You’ve triggered, by delivery, my Article Nine obligation to notify Northgate of a possible breach. I couldn’t do it myself. Doing it would have told them my capital is negative. But if the information comes to me from an independent loss assessor, in a sealed report, concurrently, I am a recipient and not a confessor.”
“I didn’t write that to help you.”
“Quite. It’s the only reason it helps.” He coughs. It’s not a short cough. “I think you should know, since you take such pains to keep your ledgers clean, that the guarantee on page F-1 is not a thing I had seen. I want that understood. I knew about the Heron loan. I knew it was irregular. I knew, as one knows about the weather in a country one hasn’t visited, that Mr. Grosz was in difficulties. I didn’t know he’d made a wager.”
“A wager.”
“Isn’t that what it is, my dear? A man who pays in advance for a death?” He pauses. “I should like very much to say something comforting. I find I’ve nothing to say that wouldn’t cost me the policy.”
“Then say nothing.”
“I shall say it quietly,” says Pike. “As it were.”
He hangs up. The coiled cord swings. Dale hands me a cup of the motel coffee, which is exactly the temperature of a lukewarm apology.
I do one more thing before the hour is out, and I do it standing in the doorway so that Dale can see me do it. I take out the phone with the three-buzz number and type one line to Marianne Voss, with no greeting and no argument. Exhibit F went in at 9:00 Eastern. Resident name, room and date of birth are redacted. Her name is not on it.
The answer comes at 9:31. Three short buzzes, and then, a minute later, words: I’m so sorry. Thank you. I wish I could say I’d have done the same.
Dale reads it over my arm. He has put on the gas-station tie again, as though the day might need it.
“Is that a yes or a no?” he says.
“It’s a woman telling the truth about herself,” I say. “I’m not sure I’ve had many of those. I think it comes out as a yes.”
---
At 10:26, Calloway calls Theo, Theo calls me, and I take it on the sidewalk in front of the motel, in thirteen degrees, with my back to a snowbank.
“Ines has someone on the line,” says Theo. “She says it’s the most remarkable call she’s had in her career. I’m going to put her through, and you’re going to sit down, if you can find something to sit on.”
“I’m sitting on a snowbank.”
“That’ll do.”
There’s a click. A new voice, thin, high and a little breathless, a voice with oxygen in it somewhere, says: “Is this the young woman from the report?”
“This is Joanna Pruitt.”
“Helen Hartung.” A small clatter, as of a walker being set aside. “I’m eighty-one years old, I’ve a new hip, and I’m in a recliner in Scottsdale with a pillow under my knee. My niece found your Exhibit B on the family portal at nine-forty this morning. She read me the part that says I was under general anesthesia on the eighteenth.
“She read me the part that says I voted on the nineteenth.” She stops for breath. “I did not vote on the nineteenth, young woman. I was in a state of being sick on a nurse.”
I put my hand over my mouth. It isn’t to hide a smile. It’s to hold my face together.
“Ma’am. Would you be willing to say that in writing?”
“I would be willing to say it in the street,” says Helen Hartung. “I sat on that board for twenty-six years. I voted for a new roof on a pediatric wing and I voted against a statue of a donor. I know what my H looks like. It does not have a feather on it, like a hat.”
There’s a rustle. “That’s my initial, but it is not my hand. A man copied it. I’ve been looking at that flourish for ten minutes, and it is exactly the flourish of a man who learned to write from watching me sign things.”
“Mrs. Hartung.”
“I’ll swear to it. Ines has a notary coming to the house by noon. I told her I’d do it in a nightgown if she liked.” Her voice drops. “Is the young man all right? Mr. Lindqvist?”
“He’s asleep. He’s all right.”
“I knew his mother,” says Helen Hartung, “in 1994, at a luncheon, for the Lakeshore Women’s Auxiliary. She had a way of looking at a plate of food as though it had said something rude. I liked her immensely.” She clears her throat. “You tell him that the lady with the new hip remembers his mother, and that his mother was right about the pie.”
I sit on the snowbank. It is seven minutes before I can feel my feet.
---
At noon Eastern, which is eleven in the Sioux City motel lot, Dr. Aaberg’s report lands in two chambers.
I know the minute because Kask, who has been silent since Sunday, comes out into the lot with a printout and says, “Ms. Pruitt. I thought you would wish to see it before the other side does. This is not within my duties. I wish it noted that I’ll deny having done it.”
I read standing up, in the wind.
It is three pages. The first paragraph says what Aaberg promised. Intermittent capacity of a high order. A lesser restriction available. The proposed guardianship would substitute one person’s judgment for his during the very hours in which his own is excellent.
The second says: “The person best placed to provide it is not the petitioner.”
The third is the one I’ve been braced for. I know it by its first word, which is “However.”
However, Dr. Aaberg writes, the Court will wish to know that the respondent’s custodian of record, Ms. J. A. Pruitt, stated on tape in the presence of the visitor that she holds seven of nine components of a mnemonic structure, two of them unconfirmed, and that “no one holds the sixty-fourth word.” The undersigned expresses no opinion on the significance of that statement to any instrument not before this physician. He notes only that it was made without hesitation and with evident distress.
I read it a second time. My own sentence is sitting inside a medical opinion like a nail inside a cake.
“He had to put it in,” says Kask, behind me. “He told me. He said that if he left it out, someone would say he’d been bought. He said the only way to protect you was to write down the worst thing you said.”
“That’s the most terrible kindness I’ve ever heard of.”
“He’s a neurologist,” says Kask. “They have a certain sort of tact.”
---
We leave Sioux City at 11:20 for Lincoln, with Dale driving, Kask in front, and Soren behind me in his coat, who woke at 10:50 and asked me for the time, and got it, and has looked at the road since without saying one word that was not “thank you.” It’s the kind of silence that is also a kind of listening.
I do not tell him about the exhibits. Not yet. I’ve taught myself a rule: when the hour is short, I give him the kitchen and keep the war.
So I give him the kitchen, as the wagon crosses the Missouri into Nebraska, and he asks the questions he always asks. Is the stove gas? It is. Is the clock on it right? It is not. “Good,” says Soren. “A kitchen clock ought to be a little wrong. It shows the house is not waiting on the world.”
He watches a billboard for a personal-injury lawyer go by, a man with a flag and enormous teeth, and says that he wishes to be told when someone in the car is about to be sued.
At 12:12 local time, somewhere past Onawa, the phone Theo gave me buzzes against my knee. It’s a text, with an attachment. It’s from Calloway, and it’s three words.
“Don’t read this.”
I read it.
It’s a one-page document on the letterhead of Whitcombe and Ley, LLP, Denver, dated that afternoon and time-stamped 1:12 p.m. Eastern. It’s addressed to the Underwriter and to the Special Committee, and it is headed:
NOTICE OF LOSS EVENT. POLICY 14-C. CONDITION 14(c).
Its second paragraph reads: “The Insured has learned, from a report of a board-certified neurologist dated December 6 and from the recorded statement of the Insured’s own Custodian of Record, that the Key, as defined in the Schedule, is no longer wholly ‘held in the memory of, or recoverable by’ a Designated Person. By the Custodian’s own sworn words, ‘no one holds the sixty-fourth word.’ The Insured therefore gives notice that a Loss Event has occurred.”
I stop breathing. I do it quite precisely. I stop, and the wagon goes on.
The third paragraph says Proceeds are payable on or before December 24.
The fourth gives the Underwriter seventy-two hours to “dispute, cure or accept” the Notice, by 1:12 p.m. Eastern on Thursday, December 10. After that, the Notice stands.
Soren says, from the back seat, mildly: “It is 12:13.”
“Yes.”
“Joanna. Your hand is shaking in a manner I would describe as emphatic.”
I look at it. It is.
“Something is wrong,” says Soren. “I do not know what. But I believe I can say, with some confidence, that it is not you who is wrong.” A pause. “I should say that it is simply a very good piece of paper.”
I put the phone face down on my knee and turn to the window.
The report I wrote was true. The sentence on the tape was true. The notice is true, in the way a map is true of a country it is about to be used to invade. I am the claimant’s best evidence against my own client, and I am the only witness who cannot take it back, because I said it in front of a man who writes things down.
Seventy-two hours.
I look at my wrist. I write the number, over 4:38 and 7:44. 1:12, Eastern. The clock begins here.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!