The folder is the color of a manila envelope that has been left in a drawer for nine years, which is to say the color of weak tea, and it is tied shut with kitchen string.
Not ribbon. Not a rubber band. White cotton kitchen string, the kind you truss a chicken with, knotted twice in a bow so neat it looks like a decision. Across the front, in the tall slanting hand, is the title I have been carrying around in my head since 1:24 like a stone in a shoe.
NINE KEEPERS.
“I would like to be the one to untie it,” says Soren. “If that is permitted. It seems a thing I ought to have done myself.”
“It’s your folder.”
“Is it?” He looks at it with the polite wariness of a man handed somebody else’s baby. “It is 1:31. I find I am not sure which of us it belongs to. I shall untie it and we can discuss the matter.”
He untangles the bow with long, patient fingers. Nobody breathes. Achterberg has gone to stand at the sink with her back to the room, which I understand is a courtesy, and Kask has put his lanyard in his pocket, which I also understand. Ardis Brandt has refilled every cup at the table without being asked, because her hands need something to do, and Cornelius Pike sits at the end of the bench with his homburg on his knee and the gray, careful stillness of a man at somebody else’s funeral.
The string comes free. Soren lays it on the yellow table in a coil, and turns the cover back.
---
There are nine forms.
They are printed, on heavy cream stock with a deckled edge, and they are identical, and each one has a number in the corner, one through nine, in pencil. At the top, in small capitals: INSTRUMENT OF KEEPING. Under that, a line of black type that I read twice, because I read things twice now.
*The Keeper holds nothing. The Keeper is asked once, in person, and says yes or no freely. A no is recorded and the instrument is void. A yes is recorded and the instrument is whole.*
“That is rather good,” says Soren, to nobody. “I do not remember writing it.”
Below it are five ruled lines, and I take them in the order they come, like reading a menu in a language I almost speak. NAME OF KEEPER. WITNESS, who must be neither Keeper nor Insured nor Attorney-in-Fact. DATE AND PLACE OF ASKING, which must be a kitchen or a room with a table, because somebody has crossed out the word *office* and written *table* above it. SIGNATURE OF KEEPER. And, at the bottom, boxed and set apart as if it were the only line that mattered:
REFUSAL RECORDED: *What was offered. By whom. On what date. Refused.*
“It’s an inverse application,” says Pike, and I jump, because I’d forgotten he was in the room. “A normal instrument records what a party takes. This records what he declined.” He has put on the folding glasses and is reading the form upside down, from across the table, with the gift of a man who has read other people’s paper upside down for forty years. “I’ve never seen it done. One doesn’t, as it were. One’s trained to count the taking.”
“Then what does a Keeper do?” I say. “The nine. What do they do?”
Nobody answers. I turn the form over, and on the back, in pencil, there’s a single line.
*They do not hold the Key. They hold the door.*
---
I’d like to tell you that I understood it. I didn’t, and I’ve promised myself to stop pretending to understand things I’ve only read once.
What I understand is the arithmetic. Nine forms. Nine blanks. Sixty days from the moment a physician confirms the Key is held, which was 11:58 this morning, which gives me until the eighth of February at fourteen seconds past that minute. I count it twice on my wrist, and then, because it’s the kind of arithmetic that makes numbers swim, a third time on the back of the recipe card in front of me, in block letters, the way I’d do a claim.
*10 Dec - 8 Feb. 60 days.*
“Joanna,” says Soren.
“Yes.”
“May I see the list?”
I don’t know what list he means, and then I do. Under the forms, flat against the bottom of the folder, is a single sheet of yellow legal paper, folded in thirds, and soft along the folds the way paper goes when it has been taken out and put back a great many times. I hadn’t seen it. I put it into his hand.
He opens it. He reads. His face does the thing it does when a good hour is passing through it, a sort of stillness, a clearing, and I think, as I have thought a hundred times since the first night at the Prairie Star, that it’s the most private thing I have ever been allowed to watch.
“It is dated,” he says. “January the thirtieth, 2017. In pencil. It is a list of nine.” A pause. “It is not a list of people.”
“What is it?”
He reads it aloud, slowly, in the voice he uses for things he’s decided to take seriously.
“One. A cook. Two. A driver. Three. A clerk. Four. A nurse. Five. A child. Six. A carrier of letters. Seven. A pastor. Eight. A man with one good hand.” He stops. “Nine is blank. There is a mark where something has been rubbed out.” He holds it to the window. “It was a word, I think. A short one.”
Nobody moves.
“A cook,” says Ardis Brandt, at the stove, to the kettle. “Well, hell.”
---
It’s Dr. Achterberg who says it, finally, in her flat Minnesota voice, without turning from the sink.
“Ms. Pruitt. How many of those have you met?”
I don’t answer at once. I’m doing the thing I do with a loss list, going down it with a finger, one line at a time, and what I get is a feeling like missing a stair.
A cook. Ardis. A driver: any of forty Night Watch truckers, Mina, Hank, Lyle, Ruth, Augie. A clerk: Lorraine Teague, nineteen years in closed claims, in her sister’s spare room in Sioux City.
A nurse: a woman in a hospice fleece with a crossword and a pair of shoes in a paper bag. A child, if you count nineteen, and a girl with her phone in a choir pew counts. A carrier of letters: a man in Duluth who delivers the mail up Fourth Street in the snow. A pastor. A man with one good hand.
“Augie,” I say. “Augustus Brandt. He drives a flatbed with one arm.”
“Brandt,” says Ardis, sharply.
“No relation,” says Soren, to her, apologetically, with his eyes on the list. “I have wondered. I believe it is a very common name in this part of Iowa.”
“He’s my husband’s cousin’s boy.”
“Ah,” says Soren, and there’s a silence, and then, in a very small voice that could not be anything else, he says, “Oh.”
I look at the date on the paper. January thirtieth, 2017. Two weeks after he sat at this table, with the radio on, and ate a heavy potato dish he can’t name. Nearly ten years before I ever walked into the Prairie Star in the dark.
“You wrote this before you knew any of us,” I say.
“I wrote it before I knew *you*,” says Soren. “I don’t know about the rest.” He turns the page, and looks at the back, which is blank, and turns it again. “It is rather as if I had made a shopping list for a store I had not yet seen, and then gone out and found that the store was there.”
“That’s not possible.”
“No.” He considers it with perfect courtesy. “I think what it is, Joanna, is that it is not a prediction. I think it is a description of the kind of people who say no. They are quite a lot of cooks, in my experience. And clerks.”
“And nurses.”
“Yes. I think so.” He lays the sheet down. “I think I went about for nine years looking for the person who would not take what I offered. I think I found, at the end, that they were everywhere, and that they were nearly all of them in service of someone.” He is quiet. “It is a very hard thing to put in a will. I suppose I did it with a form.”
---
At 2:40, the kitchen empties by degrees, the way a house does after a funeral, in a series of small excuses. Pike has gone out to the car to let Fenn see he is alive. Kask has taken the clipboard onto the back step to write a supplement he is very much not looking forward to. Achterberg has stayed, in the corner chair, with the tablet on her knee, because the cure says she confirms, and she has decided to interpret that as continuously.
I do not move from the yellow table. I have put the nine forms in a stack in front of me, squared them, and I’m sitting with my hands flat on the top one like a woman keeping a lid on a pot.
At 3:10, Soren speaks, from the window, in the light voice of a man who has made a decision.
“I should like to ask Mrs. Brandt something.”
I want to say *no*. I want to say it so badly my teeth hurt. It’s the first Instrument, and it’s the first person, and the rules on the form are plain: asked once, in person, freely. If he asks and she says no, the form is void. There are nine forms and no spares, and I haven’t got to the end of the first hour of having them.
But it’s his hour, and I have promised myself, and him, and a card in my vest, that I’d stop making that kind of choice for him.
“It’s 3:10,” I say. “You’re clear.”
“I am. Thank you. For the record, I know that.” He crosses the kitchen to where Ardis stands at the Chambers range with her wooden spoon, and he stops a polite distance away, as you would from a bull or a bishop. “Mrs. Brandt. May I say something that is not a request?”
“You can say what you like in my kitchen, hon. I just won’t promise to like it.”
“I have a form.” He holds up the top sheet, Number One, blank. “It names a person to be a Keeper. It does not ask them to hold the thing you hold. That is already yours, and you are keeping it well. It asks them only to be one of nine people who will stand at a table, someday, if the house falls down, and say what they have seen.”
“What would I see?”
“I do not know.” He says it plainly. “I do not know what you would see. It is the truthful answer. I am asking you to stand at a table for a purpose I cannot explain, for a person who may not recognize you, on the word of a man who cannot remember why he wrote it.” He lowers the form. “I would understand if the answer is no.”
Ardis Brandt puts down the spoon.
It’s the first time in the whole day I have seen her put it down.
“I’m seventy-nine,” she says. “I’ve cooked for the Methodists and the Lutherans and the school board and two funerals a month since 1971, and I’ve never once said yes to anything I didn’t understand, and I’ve been right about that every time but one. The one was my husband.” She wipes her hands on her apron. “No, hon. Not because I don’t like you. I like you fine. I’d feed you till you burst. But I’ve got one thing to keep, and I’m keeping it, and I’m full.”
The kitchen is entirely silent. I can hear the oven ticking.
“Thank you,” says Soren, very softly. “That is the answer I should have given.”
“Is it void?” I say. My voice comes out wrong. “Number One. Is it void?”
“I should think so.” Soren looks at the form, and then does a thing that undoes me completely. He takes a pencil from his pocket, and writes on the top line, in capitals, ARDIS BRANDT, and then on the bottom line, in the box, in a small clear hand, the whole of what she has just said. *Offered: a place at the table. By: S.L. On: December 10. Refused.* He signs it.
Then he folds it in half, and hands it back to me.
“There,” he says. “It is not an Instrument. It is a record of a refusal. I think those are what I’m collecting.”
---
I know how a thing sounds when it’s true. It’s most of the job. This sounds like it.
It also sounds like a clock, and the clock has stopped being abstract. I’ve lost one form of nine in four hours, I have sixty days and no spares, and the first person on the list was the one I’d have sworn was easiest. Ardis said no, and she was right to, and she was kind, and I’ve no way of getting her back. I know it, the way you know your own address. The form said once. It didn’t say twice.
I fold the refused sheet and put it in my vest, with the boats and the napkin and the sticky note, and the card that says THANK YOU FOR THE PLATE, which Soren has pushed across the table without a word.
I’m squaring the eight remaining forms when Achterberg speaks from the corner.
“Ms. Pruitt. A question I may not ask as your physician.”
“Ask it.”
“Has it occurred to you that you can’t do this alone?”
“Yes.”
“Good. And that you can’t do it with people who want something?”
“Yes.”
“Then I’ll ask the question that’s actually mine.” She puts the tablet down. “If the people who qualify are the ones who say no to him, how do you ask one of them to say yes?”
It’s the question I have been trying not to hear since the second page of the green letter. I haven’t got an answer. I say so.
“I don’t know,” I say. “I think I ask them the way he did. I think I tell them it’s all right to say no.”
“And if they do?”
“Then they’re the ones I want.” I hear it as I say it, and put my hand against my mouth, and laugh, because it’s the stupidest thing I have ever said in a kitchen. “No, I mean. It’s a trap. It’s a very kind trap. If I’m asking only the people who’ll refuse, I’ll be refused by every one of them, and I’ll have nine records and no Keepers.”
“Yes,” says Achterberg. “That is rather what I thought.”
---
By seven we have eaten again, a pot roast Ardis denies cooking, and the folder has gone into the steel case, and the case has gone, by consensus, into the bottom drawer of the Chambers range, where Ardis says nobody would think to look because nobody has ever dared. Pike has left, with a short stiff bow and a promise to put the dismissal in writing, and Fenn has been seen to hold the car door for him as if it were a very small coffin.
Soren has been gone since 5:50. He is at the window with the card in his hand and a plate of pie going cold on the sill. He doesn’t know me. He has asked me twice who I am, and I’ve told him, and he’s said “Ah,” and put his hand briefly over mine on the arm of the chair, as you would on a stranger’s, to thank her for the information.
It doesn’t hurt the way it did. That’s the terrible thing. It hurts the way a tooth does after you’ve stopped noticing the tooth.
At 8:40, there’s a knock.
It’s a young man’s knock, three raps, clean and respectful, the knock of someone who has been taught that knocking is a courtesy and has never once been refused. Ardis looks at me. I look at Kask. Kask has risen, with his clipboard, in the doorway of the back hall.
Peter Ley stands on the step in the pigeon-colored topcoat, with snow on the shoulders, and a long envelope held in front of him like a man bringing flowers to a wake.
“Mrs. Brandt,” he says. His face, in the porch light, is the face of someone who has been told it’s an ordinary errand. “I’m very sorry to trouble you at this hour. I’m Peter Ley, of Whitcombe and Ley. I’ve been asked to serve you with this.”
“What is it?”
“It’s a subpoena, ma’am.” He swallows. “For a deposition. Monday morning, the fourteenth, at ten. In the matter of Ninefold Custody.” His eyes flick, once, to me. “I’m told you’re a person with knowledge.”
Ardis takes it. She looks at it for a long time, the way she looked at Grosz’s hat.
“Is somebody going to tell me what I know?” she says.
“I believe,” says Peter Ley, painfully, in his boy’s voice, “that’s the purpose of the deposition.”
She hands the envelope to me, unopened, with her thumb pressed to the corner, as you would hand a stranger a hot dish.
“You said you’d take it,” says Ardis Brandt. “On the card.”
“Yes.”
“Then I’d say it’s time.” She folds her arms. “Sit down, hon. I’ll make more coffee. And somebody get that boy a plate. It’s a long way back to Lincoln, and he looks like he hasn’t been told he’s allowed to eat.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!