Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 52

Plate First

Nora Kimball arrives at 8:10 on Friday morning in a green Subaru with one headlight out and a banker’s box on the passenger seat, and the first thing she does, before she has shaken a single hand, is walk into Ardis Brandt’s kitchen without knocking and say, “Mrs. B., I’m so mad at you I could spit.”

“Wipe your feet,” says Ardis.

“I’m forty-seven years old.”

“Wipe them anyway.”

Nora wipes her feet. She is a small, square woman in a wool coat with a lawyer’s tired eyes and a Sioux City Bar lanyard still looped around her neck, as if she’d got out of bed and into a courtroom in a single step. She sits at the yellow table.

Ardis puts a plate in front of her, eggs and toast and a rasher of bacon cut with the kitchen shears, and the lawyer looks at it the way you look at a bill you’ve been dreading for thirty years.

“Nineteen eighty-nine,” says Nora, to me, with her mouth full. “Fifth grade. My mother was on the line at the packing plant and my dad was gone, and there was a free lunch ticket, and every kid who had one got a different color tray so the lunch line could tell. Mrs. Brandt stopped using the trays. She said they were a shortage of trays.” She chews. “I’ve been trying to pay it back since I was twenty-six. She won’t take a nickel.”

“I take eggs on Sundays,” says Ardis.

“She takes eggs on Sundays. Ms. Pruitt, I’m told you have a problem.”

“I have several.”

“Start with the one that’s served.”

---

I give her the subpoena, and the forms, and the fourteen hours since I last slept, in order, the way I’d lay out a loss. Nora reads the subpoena standing, with her coat on, and then the cure declaration, and then the Dismissal that Pike’s office faxed to the Ellery library, God knows why, at 1:58 yesterday afternoon.

She reads Ibsen’s order from Tuesday, which I’d printed at the Ellery library. She reads the part on the nine Keepers over my shoulder, because I couldn’t stop her, and when she’s done she sits down and eats her bacon.

“Well,” she says. “He’s a clever man.”

“Who?”

“Dennis Whitcombe. Sixty-one, white mustache, thirty-eight years at the same firm. I opposed him once in a probate dispute over a dead farmer’s tractors. He wins by finding the one word in a document that nobody has put weight on.” She taps the page. “Here. Schedule 3, paragraph 2. ‘Retrievable from a physical, documentary, or human source, *whether or not identity is known,* by a Designated Person.’ Everyone read the middle. He’s reading the end.”

“Designated Person,” says Nora. “Who is that, under this policy?”

“The Key Person, and his attorney-in-fact by the Condition 22 notice.” I find the page on my wrist, nearly. “It’s in the Definitions.”

“So, you and him. Right now, today, the Designated Persons under this policy are two people, and neither is Mrs. Brandt.” Nora puts down her fork. “He’s going to put her under oath on Monday, ask her very nicely whether she holds something, ask whether she’s a Designated Person, and when she says no, he’s got a sworn statement that the source of the Key is a human being outside the policy.

“That’s not a Loss Event. It’s a pre-loss event. It’s a hole, and he’ll say the cure has to be re-examined.”

“Pike dismissed it.”

“Pike’s an Underwriter. Whitcombe represents the insured corporation, which is the other party on the policy, and which can argue Pike’s cure was a mistake of fact.” She shrugs. “You can’t hide a person in a drawer, Ms. Pruitt. Not on paper. Paper wants to know the name.”

“The Keepers are the name.”

“I read that.” Nora looks at me for a long moment. “You’re asking me to believe that a man who can’t remember his own address wrote a defense to a lawsuit in 2017.”

“Yes.”

“I believe it,” says Nora. “That’s the problem. I’ve never seen a good lawyer fail to leave a back door.” She pulls the banker’s box toward her. “What are your terms?”

---

The terms are Ardis’s, and I write them down on the back of the Dismissal in the order she gives them, while she cuts a second rasher with the shears and doesn’t look up.

One: the deposition will be taken in this kitchen, at this table, at ten on Monday, because she is seventy-nine and has never once testified in a room with a flag in it. Two: nobody asks a question until the plate is empty. Three: the plate is for everyone. Four: if she says she’s done, she’s done, and the lawyer who argues is welcome to take it up with her wooden spoon.

Five: the court reporter will sit on the back step stool, because Ardis will not have the machine on the table, and if she can’t hear it, it can’t be too loud.

“Six,” says Ardis. “That nice boy who says sorry before he knocks gets coffee.”

“He’s the opposing counsel’s associate.”

“He’s a person,” says Ardis.

Nora calls Whitcombe at 9:20, from the back step, on a phone older than most of her clients. I watch through the window over the sink. She talks for eleven minutes, with her free hand flat against the porch rail, and for the first four she says nothing at all but *yes* and *I see*.

For the next four she says, very evenly, *Dennis, she’s a school cook. You put her in a conference room with a camera and a transcript and a lawyer from Omaha shouting about the fourth amendment of her own refrigerator, and I’ll have the Des Moines paper on the sidewalk by lunch.* Then she says *no*, and *no*, and *yes, he can bring the hat*, and hangs up and stands there with her breath going up in a gray cloud.

“He agreed,” she says, coming in. “On three conditions. Mr. Pell tapes it, on his own machine, for the record. Your side gets a copy of the tape and the transcript at the same moment, no earlier. And Hartley Grosz, as the Chair of the Special Committee, will sit in.”

“Will he,” says Ardis.

“He asked.”

“Then he’ll eat,” says Ardis, “like anyone else.”

---

It costs six hundred dollars. I want to say that plainly, because I’ve been plain about the other ones.

Nora’s retainer is nine hundred, which she says is a fraction of her rate, and which she says she’ll waive, and which I will not let her waive. I’ve a rule about people who work for me. I write her a check on the Kearney account at 9:48, with my own hand, for six hundred dollars, and I sign it J. A. Pruitt, and the account balance when I’m done, which I do on my wrist, is eleven dollars and forty cents.

“Keep it,” says Nora, holding the check between two fingers. “I’ll cash it after I stop eating Mrs. Brandt’s bacon for free.”

“Cash it today.”

“Why?”

“Because I’d like to be someone who paid,” I say, and I hear the thing I’ve just said, and Nora hears it too. She puts the check in her coat pocket without another word, and goes out to her Subaru for a legal pad, and I stand at the sink and look at the eleven dollars and forty cents on my wrist, and think that I have never in my life been so poor, nor so lightly dressed for it.

Ninefold’s first salary posts on the fifteenth. I’ve checked. That is also the day of the hearing. I try not to read anything into it.

---

I’ll tell you about Saturday night, and I’ll try to tell it right.

Reverend Dahl’s Methodist hall is a low brick building two blocks from Linden with a linoleum floor, a kitchen with a pass-through window, and a stack of folding cots under a tarp in a back room that smells of coffee and church-basement radiators. It’s where the ice storm put forty-one people in 2017.

Ardis arranged it, by telephone, in four minutes, on the grounds that you can’t put a man back in a motel after he’s been brought home. She said it like that. *Brought home.* I didn’t correct her.

We have six cots. Dale has taken the one by the door, and is snoring in a minor key. Kask has the one by the window, with a thermos, and a paperback western he reads with an expression of deep betrayal. Achterberg is at a motel on the highway, because, she said, she’s a physician and not a camper. And at the far end, under the one high window, in a gray light thrown across the linoleum by a streetlamp, are Soren’s cot and mine.

It’s 10:14. He’s awake. I know it from his breathing, which I have learned the way you learn a stair.

“I should like to ask a question,” he says to the ceiling, “if you are awake, and it is not an imposition.”

“I’m awake.”

“It is 10:14, I believe. I am not sure of the date.” A pause. “May I ask who you are?”

I’ve done this nineteen times since Thursday. I do it without breath, now. I say my name, and the thing I am, and the three facts on the card, and where he is, and the date, and that it is a Methodist hall, and that the hall has a pass-through window and a radiator that knocks. I say that he’s safe and ill and exact. I say that I’m his adjuster, and that he asked me for the kitchen.

“The kitchen,” says Soren. “Yes. I do know about a kitchen.” He turns his head on the folded coat he uses for a pillow, and for a moment, across four feet of cold floor, I see his face in the streetlight, thin and open and a little afraid, like a child’s when he’s trying not to be. “Thank you. It is a very civil thing to do, to say it all so evenly. May I ask whether I am meant to know you?”

“No.”

“That is a relief.”

“It’s a bad hour, not a bad man.”

“I am told.” A silence. “You wrote *Joanna* on your wrist. I saw it, at supper. And a number, a nine. Am I right in thinking that someone told me, at one point, that we are in love?”

My throat goes. I don’t know what I’d planned to say. I say the truth, because I’ve no other currency.

“I love you,” I say. “I don’t know what you think of me tonight. You’re allowed not to think anything. I don’t need you to say it back.”

“It is odd,” says Soren, slowly. “I have been wondering all evening why I trust you. I thought it was a feature of the arrangement. A courtesy of the fiction. But I find, lying here, that it isn’t a feeling of having been told. It’s a feeling of having been *kept*.”

He lifts his hand off the blanket and holds it out into the cold between us, palm up, in the dark. “May I? I should like to find out whether my hand knows yours. My hand has been more reliable than the rest of me.”

I get off the cot. I kneel on the linoleum, and put my hand in his.

He holds it for a long time. He counts my pulse with two fingers against the inside of my wrist, I think without knowing he’s doing it, and says “Seventy-six,” and then, very softly, “It is quicker than it was a minute ago,” and I laugh, and the laugh comes out wet.

“It’s a hazard,” I say.

“The very greatest,” says Soren, and for a moment I think he’s come back, and then I see that it’s only the phrase, a stone he’s skipped across a pond, and the water has closed behind it. “Joanna. I should like to tell you something I find I do remember. It is not about you. It concerns the list.”

“Tell me.”

“It says *a nurse*.” He’s quiet. “I remember the night. The night my mother died. March. I came in from the airport, much too late, and the night nurse had stayed past her shift to meet me at the elevator. In the corridor I tried to give the night nurse my watch, because I had nothing else of value on my person, and I wished her to know that she had done something for me that could not be paid.

“She put it back into my hand, and said that she was so sorry.” A breath. “She did not say *but*. It was the first time anyone had refused to be paid by me. I remember thinking it was the kindest cruelty I’d ever been shown.”

I do not move. I do not even breathe.

“Mrs. Voss,” I say.

“Is that her name?” says Soren, interested. “How very strange. I had the idea it was a woman I should not meet again.” He closes his eyes. “I wrote it down. *A nurse.* I did not know I had written *her*.”

---

It’s an ugly thing to know in the dark, and I lie there with my hand in his until it’s dead to the wrist, and I do the arithmetic.

The nurse on the list is the woman who has put a petition in front of a judge to take him away. She is the woman who ran a van off a road in Nebraska, and bought a clerk, and sat outside a church in a brown car. She is also the woman who sat with a dying woman for eight hours and told her the lie about the car, and carried the shoes ten years.

She refused his money in a corridor in March of 2016, and she refused mine in a hotel breakfast room on Tuesday. That is, as it turns out, a thing she does.

And she is on a list written in 2017, as the fourth of nine.

I’ve been trying to hunt her down. I’ve spent weeks, God help me, trying to find the weak place in Marianne Voss. I never once put her where he did, which was among the people who’d said no.

It’s 11:48 when his hand goes slack in mine. I put it back on the blanket. I sit on the cold floor under the high window, and I take the pen out of my vest and write on my wrist, under the nine, in letters so small I have to hold it to the light.

*4.*

---

The notice to Kask had gone in at 1:06 on Saturday afternoon, twenty-four minutes before the forty-eight hours ran out for a Monday departure at 1:30. Kask, who has the manner of a man asked to hold someone else’s coat, initialed it Sunday morning with a stub of pencil and says, “It’s fine, Ms. Pruitt. It’s *fine.* You’re all very good at this.” He hasn’t, I notice, written anything down for two days that I’d call an insult.

On Sunday, Soren is good from 11:40. He sits at the yellow table with Ardis, who has given him a bowl of dried beans to sort, and he sorts them, speckled from plain, with a patience I would have said was impossible in a man with that much to lose.

“This one is cracked,” he says, holding up a bean.

“It’s a bean, hon.”

“It is a bean with a history.” He sets it aside. “I find that is true of most things, if one looks.”

Ardis looks at me over his head. It’s the look of one woman to another across a child’s, in a room with a stove, and I take it, and put it somewhere I’ll be able to find it.

At 6:02 that evening, the phone on the kitchen wall rings. It is a black rotary, older than Nora, with a cord that’s been stretched out of shape by the weight of fifty years of people carrying it to the stove. Ardis wipes her hands. She listens. She says “uh huh” three times and “he can” once, and then hangs up.

“That was Peter Ley,” she says. “The nice boy. He said to tell you he was told to say it in writing, but he figured a phone call would do.”

“What did he say?”

“That Mr. Grosz will be attending on Monday, in person, and has asked to be seated first.” She folds the dishtowel into a neat square. “And that he says he’d like to be asked nothing, and given a plate.”

“He’s already had your plate once,” says Nora, from the doorway. She’s been sitting in the front room all afternoon with her legal pad on her knee, and her voice is dry as a bone. “Mrs. B., he knows the rule. He’s coming to see whether it holds.”

“It holds,” says Ardis.

“It held in a kitchen on Thursday with nine people in it. On Monday there’ll be a court reporter, and a recorder, and a lawyer, and the man who owns the paper on the whole thing.”

“It’s a kitchen,” says Ardis Brandt, “not a courtroom, and I’m the one with the spoon.”

She hangs the dishtowel on the oven door. Then, without turning around, in a voice so quiet I’m not sure I’m meant to hear it, she says, “He’ll want me to say no, you know. To the Keeper thing. In front of everybody. That’s the whole show.”

“I know.”

“And I’d have to say it.”

“I know.”

“Well.” She picks up the wooden spoon, and looks at it, and sets it down on the counter, handle out. “It’s a good thing I’m not afraid of being right.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!