By four o’clock on Christmas Eve the Ellery Methodist fellowship hall smells of ham, scorched sugar and floor polish, and I’m standing in its tiny church office with a fax machine older than I am and the telephone cord wrapped twice round my wrist.
“As it were,” says Pike, from Duluth, in the careful voice of a man dictating his own obituary, “I have the paper in front of me. Read me the clause again.”
I read it. It’s a single sentence of Condition 11, in Ingrid’s neat transcription, which she faxed to me from a Duluth copy shop at noon with a note in the margin that said *last chance, Joanna, do not bungle it.* “The Underwriter’s Representative may in writing waive the notice period of this Condition at any time before a hearing at which the point is raised.”
“Before a hearing at which the point is raised,” says Pike.
“Monday at nine.”
“It is Thursday.” He breathes. “It’s a thin clause. I wrote it myself, in a better year, with a notion of being obliging to people who traveled. I never imagined it would be needed.”
“Will you sign?”
“I have signed.” Paper rustles. “I did so at eleven, when Mrs. Sjoberg telephoned. I’ve been holding the page while I decided whether to send it. I’d like you to understand what I am sending.”
“Tell me.”
“A waiver by the Underwriter’s Representative. Which is to say by this firm. Which is to say by a firm that confessed to a client, over airport coffee on Tuesday, that it is insolvent; and that client will have to say so under oath.” He says it very evenly.
“Whitcombe will say that a waiver given by an insolvent representative, who by his own admission had a motive to keep the peace, is a waiver given under a cloud. He will say that I would sign anything that kept the Ninefold retainer alive. He will be partly right.”
“Which part?”
“The second,” says Pike. “I’d sign anything. I’d prefer it be this.”
I don’t know what to say. It’s an odd thing to be given a gift by a man who then lists its defects.
“The fax number’s on the cover,” I say.
“I have it.” The old, formal, tremulous voice drops lower. “Miss Pruitt. It’s a cost. I’ll not pretend it isn’t. You’ve asked me for a signature that Whitcombe will spend ninety minutes of Monday morning attacking, and which will, in the attacking, expose a thing about my firm that I’d rather have gone to my grave with. I ask only that when you’re in a room with the paper, and you’re tempted to be gracious about me, you’ll not.”
“I don’t have any gracious in me, Mr. Pike.”
“No,” says Pike. “It’s one of the reasons he chose you.”
The machine on the shelf gives a shuddering groan. A sheet of curling thermal paper begins to creep out of it, a quarter inch at a time, and I stand there with the phone to my ear and watch the ink come up out of the dark: a letterhead, a paragraph, a signature in a hand like a man walking carefully across ice.
It’s 4:11. It’s forty-six days to the eighth of February. It’s four days to Monday.
---
Ardis Brandt has been cooking since Tuesday.
I understand it only when I come out of the office and see the hall. It’s a long low room with linoleum floors and fluorescent lights and a stage at one end with a green curtain, and in the middle of it stand eleven folding tables set end to end in a single line, covered in white paper, with a plastic poinsettia at every fifth place.
There’s ham. There’s scalloped potato in roasting pans the size of washtubs. There are four kinds of Jell-O, a mountain of dinner rolls, a bowl of cranberry relish, two pans of Lutheran hot dish that the Methodist ladies are pretending not to see, and at the head of the table, on a card in Ardis’s cramped hand, a notice: PLATE FIRST. ALL WELCOME.
She’s done it every Christmas Eve for fifty-five years. It wasn’t hers to start. It was her mother-in-law’s, and the church’s before that. But she runs it now, in her gray cardigan with a paper apron, with a spoon in one hand and a clipboard of her own in the other, and by five the hall’s full.
I count. I can’t help it. It’s thirty-eight at the tables, and eleven in the kitchen, and two at the door taking coats. It’s farmers in good flannel shirts and mothers with babies and a table of old men in feed caps who keep stealing rolls. It’s a teenager with a cast. It’s the pastor of Ellery Methodist, whom I have not yet met.
It’s the biggest witness room I’ve ever been given. It’s a hundred pairs of eyes, and nobody in it has the faintest idea what’s about to happen, and I understand that this is exactly why Soren is here.
---
He’s in the third chair on the left, at the end, in the gray suit coat Edith packed for him, with his hair brushed and a poinsettia in front of him. He doesn’t know the town. He doesn’t know the hall. He is polite to the old man on his right, whose name is Gil, and who tells him at length about a drainage ditch.
I sit across from him. I’ve taken the chair opposite on purpose, because I know the minutes of his day, and because I know that the hour between 5:30 and 6:30 is the one Achterberg’s chart has marked, in three colors, as *the best.*
At 5:34 he looks up from the ham and finds me.
I don’t say anything. I’ve learned not to. He looks at my face for a long moment, with his gray eyes narrowed, with a kind of grave and anxious attention, as if I were a page whose words he’s almost sure of.
“It is 5:34,” says Soren. “You are Jo.”
It’s like having a window thrown open in a room I’ve been sitting in for a month. I put down my fork.
“I am.”
“I don’t know where we are.”
“Ellery, Iowa. It’s Christmas Eve. It’s Ardis Brandt’s supper.”
“I remember Ardis.” He frowns. “I remember a pot roast. I’m told I have lost a thing. Something with paper.”
“It’s all right.”
“It is *not* all right.” He says it softly, without heat. “It’s a very ordinary thing. I did it as a boy, in a rain, on the porch of a house in Duluth, with my mother. I find I can’t do it, and I find I’m sorry.” He turns his hand over on the white paper. “I should like to give you something before the time’s up. May I?”
My throat does something I’d rather not describe. I say yes.
He reaches into his coat. He takes out, from the left inside pocket, a small flat folder, and from the folder one card. It’s an index card in his hand. It says, in pencil, in architect’s capitals, with a date of last Sunday that I know he doesn’t remember:
*IF I DO NOT KNOW YOU: ASK ME NOTHING. LET ME LOOK AT YOU AS LONG AS I LIKE. THIS IS ALL I AM ASKING. S.*
“I wrote it for you,” he says. “I’m told I’m very forgetful, and I thought, there will be an evening when you’ll want to explain yourself and I’ll be hurt that I cannot answer. This is to say you don’t have to.” He lays it in front of me. “It’s the only thing in my pocket that’s yours.”
I’ve held my own against a woman with a cane at a funeral and a man with a legal pad in a boardroom. I’ve not been so good at this. I take the card and I hold it against the table under my palm.
“Thank you,” I say.
“It’s 5:41,” says Soren, and smiles, and, God help me, it’s his real smile, the one from a garage in Denver. “I’d like to meet the pastor.”
---
The pastor of Ellery Methodist is a man called Ben Ostrander, sixty-one, with a wide patient face like a loaf of bread, a clerical collar a little too tight and a red Christmas tie with reindeer on it.
He’s the one who ran the hall’s furnace down to the ground in the cold snap of two winters ago, and the one who wrote to a certain unnamed foundation in Denver to say that Ellery Methodist could not, in conscience, accept fifty thousand dollars for a new roof from a donor who would not give a reason.
I know it because Ardis told me in the kitchen. “He had a *hole* in the roof,” she said. “You could see sky. And he wrote them a letter, polite as pie, and he said that he’d be glad to take the money if somebody’d tell him what it was for, and nobody did. He said a gift that has no face isn’t a gift, it’s a hook.” She snorted. “He bought a tarp.”
It’s a refusal. It’s a refusal of Soren’s money, in the exact shape of the pencil list’s seventh line: *a pastor.*
Soren stands at 5:52. He is a little unsteady, but he stands, and the room goes quiet by degrees, from the table of old men to the babies. He has the quality he’s always had, even in the worst of it, of a man who has never in his life had to raise his voice.
He walks the length of the hall with the whole room watching, and stops in front of the pastor, at the end of the third table, and says, quite audibly:
“Reverend Ostrander. I am Soren Lindqvist. You wrote me a letter once, though I’m afraid I’ve lost the whole of it. I’m told it was about a roof.”
“It was.” The pastor’s face is utterly still. “It was a good roof.”
“You refused my money.”
“I did, sir. I’m sorry. It wasn’t personal.”
“It was the best letter I ever received,” says Soren. “I have kept it two winters in a drawer and I cannot recall what it said, and I know that I did not deserve it. I should like to ask you something. I’d like to ask it in front of this room, and I’d like you to answer once.”
“I’m a pastor, sir.” A small dry gleam. “Asking in front of a room’s the one thing I’m trained for.”
“There is a door,” says Soren.
He says it in the same words he said to Augie, and to Pa Houa, and to Birdie, and I see Weir at the end of the table go still with her pencil. It’s the same speech. It’s the only one he has. But each time, he says it as though for the first time and as though it were the most important thing in the world.
“I should like a person to hold it. Not open it. Not know what’s behind it. To stand by it, as a pastor stands by a church, because it is there, and for no reason that can be proven. Will you hear it?”
“I will.”
“Will you?” says Soren. “Say it freely. I’ll not mind a no.”
“I’m not a man who takes a thing without asking what it costs,” says Ben Ostrander. He’s looking, not at Soren, but at a long white table with a poinsettia, and thirty-eight faces looking back. “What does it cost?”
Soren turns, slowly, and looks at me.
I’d forgotten it’s a thing you can be asked, by a person who can’t remember your name. “Everything he has,” I say. “And an hour a day. It’s on the form.”
“And what’s the pay?”
“Nothing, Pastor.”
“That’s a very honest answer,” says Ostrander. “I’d put it on the church bulletin.” He puts out his hand. “Yes. Yes, I’ll hold a door. I’ve held the one over there for thirty years. It’s mostly open.”
The hall explodes in the polite, bewildered, hearty applause of a town that has no idea what it has just seen and has decided, on the whole, to approve.
I count. I write it on the third Instrument, at 5:58, with Ardis for witness.
*Keeper 5. B. Ostrander, pastor.*
Four to go. Forty-six days.
---
Arvid Kask finds me by the coffee urn at six-ten, with a paper cup in one hand and the clipboard in the other, and asks, with his usual air of apology for existing, whether I have the waiver.
I give him the curled sheet. He reads it standing up. He reads it a second time, with his lips moving, and then he takes a small black stamp from his coat pocket, a thing I’d never have guessed he carried, and presses it to the bottom margin of the page. It says RECEIVED, COURT VISITOR, and there’s a blank for the time. He writes 6:11.
“I’ll file it tonight,” he says, “by electronic means, to the Court and all counsel. I’d like to be plain, Ms. Pruitt. It will not be enough to carry Monday by itself.”
“I know.”
“It cures the notice. It does not cure the night.” He looks past me, at the long white table, where Soren sits with his hands folded beside a paper plate, pleasantly lost. “The Court will want to know whether a man who walks into a snow in the dark is safer in a house with nine people, or a house with one. I believe it’s a question that only the man himself can answer. I should hate to see it put to him on a bad hour.”
“So should I.”
“Then pick the hour,” says Kask. He tucks the stamp away. “I’ve found, in thirty-one years, that a court will believe almost anything said to it plainly by a person who’s been awake all night. It’s the only advantage the honest have.”
He goes off to find a roll. I stand by the urn and think about Monday, and a good hour, and what it would cost to spend it in a room full of strangers instead of a hall full of friends.
---
It’s the last forkful of cranberry relish. It’s the exact moment when Gil, on Soren’s right, is beginning a second story about the drainage ditch. I’m looking at the card in front of me, with its little capital letters. And I hear the door.
It’s the double door at the end of the hall, the one that gives onto the vestibule, and it opens with a long cold exhalation, and it lets in a gust of snow and a quiet like a held breath.
I look up.
Hartley Grosz stands in the doorway with his silver-headed cane in one hand, and in the other, held carefully at his hip like an offering, a large round dish covered with a white cloth.
He is in the camel overcoat. He is bareheaded, with his white hair brushed back and snow melting on his shoulders. He’s smiling, the warm, rueful, grandfatherly smile of a man who has never been refused. It’s a smile I’ve seen in a lobby in Denver, at the foot of a vault door, across the length of a glass conference table.
“Merry Christmas,” says Hartley Grosz. His baritone fills the hall without effort. “I do apologize for the intrusion. I’m told that, in this town, a person may come in out of the snow if he doesn’t mind being fed first.”
Nobody moves.
“I’m told it’s *plate first,*” says Grosz, pleasantly, and walks into the room.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!