Hartley Grosz eats a plate of Ardis Brandt’s ham at the end of the third table, between a farmer and a teenager with a cast, and for forty minutes he does not say one word about anything that matters.
I watch him do it. So does the hall. It’s an extraordinary performance, and the extraordinary part is that I can’t tell whether it is one.
He takes his coat off and hands it to a woman at the door, who has no idea who he is. He accepts a paper plate. He takes ham, scalloped potato, a roll, a spoonful of the cranberry relish, and he sits where he’s pointed, and he praises the potatoes to the farmer, who tells him about a drainage ditch. He laughs in the right places. He asks the teenager how the arm is healing, and listens to the answer.
Ardis comes down the line with her spoon and puts a second helping on his plate without being asked. He thanks her by name. She says, “Eat, Mr. Grosz,” and he says, “Hartley, please,” and she says, “I’ll call you what you tell me when your plate’s empty.” It’s the nearest I’ve heard anyone come to a verdict.
He looks at me once, over the rim of a coffee cup, with his blue and untroubled eyes. It’s a look that says: *I am abiding by the rules of your house. Note that I am doing so.*
I note it.
---
Soren’s hour ends at 6:03. I see it go. It happens between one bite of pie and the next. His face stays the same, and his hands stay the same, but something behind his eyes switches over to the other lamp, and he puts down his fork and looks around the long white table with a gentle, courteous, perfectly empty attention.
Gil, on his right, is saying something about a ditch.
“I do beg your pardon,” says Soren. “What is the time?”
“Six-oh-four,” says Gil.
“Thank you.” He writes it on the back of his hand. It’s a habit I’ll be glad of as long as I’m let to keep it.
Grosz, at the end of the table, has stopped eating. He’s watching Soren the way a man watches an old clock he once repaired. There’s no triumph in it. I’d have been easier if there were. There’s a long, quiet, honest regret, which is, as I’ve learned over twelve weeks, the single most dangerous thing in him.
He rises before he speaks to me. I’d not expected that.
He carries his plate down the length of the room, past the farmers and the babies and the table of old men in feed caps, and he stops beside Soren’s chair, and he stands there with his cane hooked on his forearm, waiting to be seen. It takes Soren a while. He looks up at last with that gentle, polite, unreachable face.
“I beg your pardon,” says Soren. “Have we met?”
“We have,” says Hartley Grosz. His baritone has dropped to nearly nothing. “Many times. We lunch.”
“I’m afraid I’ve mislaid it.”
“That’s all right. I remember for both of us.” Grosz bends, stiffly, and sets his cheesecake plate on the paper tablecloth by Soren’s elbow, with a fork beside it. “My wife’s. I thought you might like a slice.”
“How kind.” Soren looks at it. He picks up the fork. “It is very good. I think I knew a lady who made this.”
“You did,” says Grosz.
I’m too far to hear what comes after, and I’m glad. I see only that the old man lays his hand, once, lightly, on Soren’s shoulder, and takes it away again, as you’d touch a wall in a house where someone is sleeping. Then he straightens, and turns, and looks for me across the hall with the other face on, the careful one, and I understand that I have just been shown what it costs him to be what he is.
“Joanna,” he says, across forty feet of paper tablecloth. “A word, when you’ve a moment. I’d not take you from your friends.”
Ardis has turned. Kask has half risen. Weir, by the wall, has gone as still as a post.
“Not in front of everyone,” says Grosz gently. “It would not be fair to them. May we use the kitchen?”
I look at the church kitchen, through its serving hatch: a long steel counter, a pass-through, two industrial sinks and a coffee urn the size of a toddler. It’s the most public private room in Iowa. There’s a clock over the door and a window onto the hall, and six Methodist ladies in aprons, who aren’t pretending not to listen.
“The kitchen,” I say. “The ladies stay.”
“Naturally,” says Hartley Grosz, and picks up his plate.
---
He sits on a stool by the steel counter, with his cane across his knees and the covered dish he brought still unopened beside him. I stand. It’s a small thing, and I want the height.
“I brought a cheesecake,” he says. “My late wife’s. She was Danish. I asked the Brandt woman whether it would be taken amiss, and she said anything made from butter was welcome.” He lifts the cloth. It’s a good cheesecake: tall, pale gold, with a glaze of cherries.
“I don’t expect you to believe it’s only a cheesecake. I’d like you to take it as the first honest thing I say tonight. I came to talk to you, and I knew I’d not be let in without a plate.”
“You’ve been told how it works.”
“I’ve been told a great deal in the last week,” says Grosz. “Not by you. You’d be astonished how much of it is true.”
“Say what you came to say.”
“Very well.” He folds his hands on the head of the cane. “On the thirty-first of December you owe the reinsurers Part B of your engagement: a certificate that the Key is intact, or is not. You’ve resisted giving it for three weeks. I’m told, by two sources whom I’ll not name, that you intend to certify on the last day, that the Key *is* held, in nine persons, by arrangement, on a lapse clock that doesn’t expire until February.
I’d like to suggest you do not.”
“I certify what I can verify.”
“You can verify nothing.” He says it kindly. “You hold the serial numbers of two thousand nine hundred and eleven cradles in a head that’s never lost one, and you hold a man who cannot tell you what day it is. I’m not insulting you, Joanna. I’m describing your evidence.”
“I have five Keepers.”
“You have five people who said yes to a tired and charming man in a church hall, with a plate in front of them.” He lets that settle. “I don’t say it to wound them. I say it because on the eighth of February, Judge Cho is going to ask each of them what they were *keeping.* And not one will be able to answer. Because not one of them knows. It’s the point. It’s the design. It’s what he meant.”
“And?”
“And I propose,” says Grosz, “that you certify, on the thirty-first, that continuity is *unverifiable at this time,* which is a statement of fact. You do not say it has failed. You do not say it’s lost. You say that no independent assessor can confirm it. And I’ll withdraw the Notice. I’ll withdraw the Loss Event petition. I’ll tell Whitcombe to drop Monday’s motion.” He opens one hand, palm up.
“I’ll underwrite Mrs. Voss’s sister’s bed for two years, outright. I’ll release Mrs. Tolliver’s note at the Prairie Star, which, as you know, I hold. I will pay your retainer, in full, with interest, for the work you’ve done. And I’ll leave Soren in a house in Duluth, with that gray woman and whoever else he likes, for as long as he lives.”
Nobody in the kitchen moves. One of the Methodist ladies, with a dish towel, has stopped in the act of wiping a plate.
“What’s the cost?” I say.
“Your certificate.”
“That’s not a cost. That’s a sentence.”
“It’s a sentence you can sign in good conscience,” says Grosz. “Unverifiable. I’d not ask you to lie. I’d ask you to be exact. It’s the thing you do best.”
---
I want to say that I see through it at once. That’s not how it goes. It goes, as the true ones do, in layers.
The first layer is that it’s a good offer. I know what Birdie’s note weighs on her; I’ve seen her count it on her fingers at three in the morning. I know the arithmetic of a nursing home bed in Duluth. I know what two years of quiet would be for Marianne Voss, and what a house with a gray woman and a stove would be for a man who can’t fold a boat.
The second is that it’s *true.* I can’t verify. I’ve told myself so every night for a month, in the dark, on a cot, with my hand on a coat that has a sleeve in its lining. I hold a memory of a vault and a man who can’t remember me.
The third layer takes longer. It’s the one I find, I think, by looking at the cheesecake.
“Unverifiable,” I say. “In a certificate to the reinsurers.”
“Yes.”
“Under Condition 14.”
“Yes.”
“Which lapses, on a failure to *verify,* the Insured’s protection.” I turn it over, with my adjuster’s tongue against the roof of my mouth. “A certificate of unverifiability starts the cure clock on the Key all over again. It isn’t a middle path. It’s a declaration of loss with a courteous face.
The minute I sign, Mr. Grosz, the policy treats the Key as not confirmed held, and the Notice you withdraw goes out again the next morning on a different date. And this time the evidence of loss is a licensed assessor’s own signature.”
“You’ve a remarkable mind.”
“It’s not remarkable. It’s a clause.”
“Then you can see my difficulty.” He sets his cane against the counter. “I am sixty-eight. I’ve spent a lifetime building a thing that is, as of this autumn, held in the head of a man who will forget it. If it’s lost, the fault is no one’s, and a great many people will be made whole.
I do not hate Soren. I never did. I’m asking you, as a person who has had to be exact all her life, whether you think a world with a key in it is safer than a world without.”
I look at him. It’s a very strange feeling. For one moment he’s not the man with the cane. He’s the other thing: a frightened old man in a church kitchen with a cheesecake.
“I think,” I say, “that the world with a key in it has, for the first time, nine people who’ve said they’d hold the door. I don’t think anyone has ever tried that. I’d like to see what it does.”
“And if it fails?”
“Then I’ll certify it failed. On the day it did. In my own name.”
“Not before.”
“Not one day before.”
“I’d hoped,” says Hartley Grosz, with a small bleak smile, “to be refused with more heat.”
---
He rises. He puts on his coat from the hook by the hatch, not hurrying, and takes the cane, and leaves the cheesecake where it sits. At the kitchen door he turns.
“I’ll be fair with you, as it were. I’ve heard your friend Mr. Pike use the phrase, and it has a pleasant ring.” He lays a hand on the frame. “You have until nine on Monday morning. At nine, in Duluth, I shall instruct Mr. Whitcombe to put the respondent on the stand and ask him a single question. It’s not a cruel question. It’s about a lunch in March, at a restaurant in Denver with a green door. I have a recording.”
“Of what?”
“Of a man who, at a quarter past one on a good day, said to me, in a clear and measured voice, what he was prepared to give if I asked it.” He considers. “I did not know, at the time, that he’d be quite so generous. I merely had the instinct to keep the tape.”
My mouth has gone dry. “You taped him.”
“I’m an old man who keeps records. So, I understand, are you.” He nods to me, as one professional to another. “Monday, at nine. If you’d rather I never played it, you know where to find me. I’ll be at the Brandt motel, which I’m told is clean.”
He goes out through the hall, past the long tables and the poinsettias and the wide eyes of a town that has no idea, and the doors let in a long white breath of snow and close behind him.
---
Ardis is at my elbow almost before he’s gone.
“That man’s never been told no,” she says.
“No.”
“You did, though.”
“I said not before the day it failed.” My hands are shaking. I hide them in my sleeves. “It isn’t the same.”
“It’s near enough.” She’s looking at the cheesecake. Then, with the grave deliberation of a woman about to commit an act, she takes a knife from the drawer and cuts it into twenty-four slices. “Plate first,” says Ardis. “That’s the rule. And it’s good butter. I’ll not have it wasted because of who brought it.”
I almost laugh. It breaks into a cough. I take a slice and hold it on a paper plate, and I look at it in the bright, bad, kind light of that church kitchen, and I find that I can’t taste anything.
Weir finds me in the vestibule among the coats at 7:05, with her clipboard against her chest and her gray eyes narrowed.
“I heard it,” she says. “I’m sorry. The hatch carries.”
“I’d rather you did.”
“May I say one thing, not as the observer?” She doesn’t wait. “In nine years of watching people choose, I’ve noticed that the offers worth refusing are the ones that are *kind.* Cruelty is easy. Anyone can say no to a threat. It’s when a man hands you a house and a bed and a note released and says, *I only want what’s safest,* that you find out what you’re made of.”
She looks down at the floor. “I’ve never had to find out. I’ve only written it down.”
“What would you have done?”
“Taken it,” says Charlotte Weir, at once, with a very small frightened smile. “I’d have taken it, God help me, and I’d have signed. It’s why I’m an observer.” She straightens. “I’m glad it was you who was asked.”
It’s 7:14. It’s four days to Monday. And there’s a tape, in a restaurant with a green door, of a man saying what he was prepared to give.
I know what he said. I think. It’s the one thing I’ve never asked.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!