Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 71

The Hole in the Middle

Ines Calloway of Northgate Reinsurance Services has never in her life sat on a folding chair without first wiping it with a tissue, and at 10:05 on Tuesday morning she is doing exactly that, in Conference Room B of the Duluth Public Library, under a poster that says READ BOLDLY.

She’s in the gray raincoat. She’s in her fifties, narrow, upright, with iron-colored hair pinned flat and half-glasses on a chain, and she has flown in from Denver on the first plane, a fact she announces as a grievance. Beside her sits Wendell Ash, the younger inspector, a round, hopeful man in a brown jacket who has already asked Edith, in the corridor, whether the pie in the library’s vending machine is what the sign says it is.

“It isn’t,” says Edith, who has come as my witness and a plate of her own.

“Ah,” says Ash, with real sorrow. “I was afraid.”

We’re seven at the table. Ingrid Sjoberg, in her gray coat, with the policy folio. Kask, with the clipboard. Peter Ley, who has no standing to be here and has been let in on the strength of one sentence from Ingrid (“He is a member of the public, and the room is public”). Theo Marsh, by speakerphone from Denver, breathing like a man who has been awake since Christmas. Calloway and Ash. And me.

“I’ll be brief,” says Calloway. “We’ve a difficulty. I’d like to see whether it’s yours or ours.”

---

She lays it out in six sentences, in the voice of a woman reading a bill she has already decided not to pay.

Harrow and Pike ceased to practice at five o’clock on Monday. The firm was, under the primary policy, the Underwriter’s Representative, a named agent with named powers. The Conditions give that agent three jobs. It receives notice of travel (Condition 11). It conducts inspections of the Custody (Condition 9). And it confirms, or declines to confirm, that the Key is held by a Designated Person (Condition 14, part c). As of five o’clock Monday, nobody holds those jobs.

“Mr. Whitcombe’s office filed at 8:40 this morning,” she says. “A notice of motion to Judge Cho. He says the waiver Mr. Pike signed on Christmas Eve is void, because the person who signed it had, in his words, *a disabling conflict and a failing estate.* He says the Dec 28 ruling rested on it.

He says that without a Representative, Condition 14(c) is incapable of performance, and the Key must be treated as unconfirmed.” She folds the page. “I find the argument ingenious and I find it wrong. But I’m not the judge.”

“The waiver was a completed act,” says Ingrid. “It was given in writing, on the twenty-fourth, at 4:11 p.m., while the role existed, and before any hearing at which the point was raised. That is exactly what the clause says. A waiver doesn’t evaporate when the person who gave it retires. If it did, no contract could survive its signatory’s lunch.”

“I agree.”

“Then we’re in accord.”

“On the waiver, yes. Not on what comes next.” Calloway turns her half-glasses on me. “Ms. Pruitt, the notice requirement in Condition 11 is a thing of the past. You gave oral notice, he waived in writing, it’s done. But from this morning forward, if Mr. Lindqvist crosses a hundred and fifty miles, there’s no one to receive notice. And if he doesn’t, it’s a breach. You see the trap.”

“I do.”

“The same for an inspection. The same, on the eighth of February, for the confirmation.” She sets her hands on the folio. “It’s a hole in the middle of the policy, and the only question is who is to stand in it.”

I look round the table while she folds the page, because it’s a thing I do now: I count who has a stake.

Ingrid, whose firm has been paid nothing and who has not once mentioned it. Kask, whose clipboard has a small coffee ring on it and whose pen has not stopped since the twenty-first. Edith, who came as my witness and has already, I notice, put a paper plate of shortbread in front of the Northgate inspectors with the stubborn gentleness of a woman who feeds the enemy on principle. Peter Ley, who has lost a career. Theo, who has lost sleep.

And across from me, upright on her tissue-wiped chair, a woman from a treaty who has flown eight hundred miles on a holiday week to read me a clause in person, when she could have sent it by email. It’s not an act of hostility. It’s an act of respect, and I’ve been so long among the other kind that I nearly miss it.

“You came yourself,” I say.

“I’ve a rule,” says Calloway. “Bad news is delivered in a room.” She doesn’t look up. “I’ve been told it’s a failing.”

---

It’s Ash who produces the clause, and he does it with the apologetic air of a man handing round biscuits.

“It’s in the treaty,” he says. “Article Twenty-two. Not the primary policy. It’s our contract with the Underwriter, which you’ve not seen, Ms. Pruitt, and I’d have to ask Ines before I showed you.” He glances at her. She sighs and nods. “Successor Agent. If the Underwriter’s Representative ceases for any cause, the Insured may nominate a successor within thirty days. We, the reinsurers, must accept the nomination unless we’ve a reasonable objection in writing within seventy-two hours.”

“Thirty days,” I say.

“It’s the usual.”

“Then I’ve until the twenty-eighth of January.”

“That’s the primary policy,” says Calloway. She says it flatly. “I have told you the Article. I haven’t told you the schedule. The treaty has a Schedule C, and Schedule C says that in the event of a vacancy, and until a successor is accepted, the function devolves on the Underwriter’s *panel counsel* in the relevant state.” She looks at Ley, and at Ingrid, and at me. “For Minnesota and Nebraska, the Underwriter’s panel counsel is a single firm.”

Ley says, very softly, to the table: “I may not say.”

“I’ll say it,” says Ines Calloway. “It’s Whitcombe and Ley.”

Nobody speaks. A librarian in the corridor is pushing a cart with a squeaking wheel, and it goes by, and goes away.

“By the schedule,” she says, “from five o’clock Monday, Mr. Dennis Whitcombe is the Underwriter’s Representative, for all purposes of Conditions 9, 11 and 14, until the Insured nominates and the reinsurers accept someone else. He’s been so for seventeen hours. I’ve no idea whether he knows it.”

“He knows,” says Ley.

“You may not say.”

“I’m not saying. I’m sitting.” The tall young man looks at the library’s carpet. “I’m only noticing, aloud, that his motion this morning was filed at 8:40. And that a man doesn’t ask a court to void the waiver of an agent whose job he’s just been given unless he’s already reading the clause in a different light.”

Ash raises a finger, like a boy in a classroom. “May I ask something, Ms. Pruitt? Off the clause?”

“Please.”

“Why the dollar?” He glances at the page. “I read the file on the way up. You’ve been given a retainer and a salary and nine thousand dollars you’ve lent to a truck stop. You’ve been offered, I’m told, a rather remarkable sum to certify one word.

And you’ve refused it. I’ve been doing this eleven years, and I don’t think I’ve ever met an assessor who’d rather go broke than be convenient.” He turns his hat in his hands. “I only wondered where it comes from.”

“It doesn’t come from anywhere,” I say. “It’s what’s left when you’ve taken the rest out.”

“That’s not an answer.”

“It’s the one I’ve got.”

“It’ll do,” says Wendell Ash, and puts his hat on his knee.

---

I want a coffee more than I have ever wanted one. I get up and go to the window.

Outside, the Duluth morning is a long gray sheet over Lake Superior, with a plow going up Superior Street and a gull standing on a lamp as if it owns the lamp. I put my hand on the glass. It’s very cold.

“He can’t inspect,” I say. “Condition 9(b). Seal integrity only.”

“He can notice.”

“He can’t confirm the Key.”

“He can *decline* to confirm,” says Ingrid, behind me. “Which is, for all purposes of a Notice of Loss Event, the same as failing to. It’s a one-way door. A Representative who never says yes.”

“Then I need a successor nominated before he says no.”

“Yes.”

“And the successor can’t be Theo, because he’s an officer of the insured. Can’t be Pike. Can’t be Ingrid, because she’s my counsel. Can’t be Kask, who’s the Court’s.” I turn. “It’s got to be someone with no stake in any Keeper, no debt to Grosz, no office in Denver, no firm in Lincoln, and a thing I can’t ask for.”

“Which is?” says Calloway.

“Someone Northgate won’t object to in seventy-two hours.” I look at her. “You’ll have a reasonable objection to everyone I name. It’s your job to.”

“It’s my job,” she agrees, “to be careful. I’m not your enemy, Ms. Pruitt.”

“No. You’re a woman with a treaty.”

“I am.” The ghost of a smile goes over her narrow face, the first I have seen on it. “And I’ll tell you what I’d tell any insured in your position, off the record, in a library. The reinsurers will not object to a person who is *unmistakably* exact. That’s the whole of the test. They don’t care whom you name. They care whether the name will ever say a convenient thing.”

“That’s what he said about me.”

“I read the tape this morning,” says Ines Calloway. “I’ve been in this business thirty-one years. I thought it the best character reference I’d ever heard.”

---

There’s a price, and she names it at 11:20, with the air of someone setting down an object she dislikes.

“Before we can accept any nominee, we require one thing of the Insured’s assessor. A demonstration.” She nods at Ash. “Wendell has the Count Report. The serial numbers. A tier five sample, thirty cradles at random from the November count. You’ll recite them. Mr. Marsh will check them against the book, by phone, and Mr. Ash and I will witness. It’s not a courtesy. It’s a condition precedent.”

“You’ve already seen me do it.”

“We’ve seen you do it in a vault, in front of thirty-eight people, on a day you’d prepared.” She doesn’t blink. “Today you’re in a library. You’ve slept four hours. Your friend has been in court. You’ve no notes. And we’d like the record to show that the person who will certify, on Thursday, can do it cold.”

I look at Ingrid. She shrugs, gently. It means: *you can refuse. The cost of refusing is the cost of the answer.*

“Ines,” says Theo’s voice from the speaker, hoarse and small. “She’s—you can’t ask—”

“Mr. Marsh, I can.”

“Go ahead,” I say.

I stand where I am, with the gull in the window behind me. I shut my eyes. I’d forgotten what it’s like to do it, now, with the knowledge of what it costs. It’s like opening a drawer in a house you’ve been told is on fire: the things are all there, in their order, and you can feel the heat on the back of your hand.

*Tier five, cradle 1,447. Serial 7-7-3-1-A-0-9-4. Cradle 1,448. 7-7-3-1-A-0-9-5.*

I recite for nine minutes. Thirty cradles, at random, with the ten Ash picks and the twenty Calloway does. Theo reads the book from Denver in a thin, cracked, steady voice, and at the end of each one he says, “Match.” By the twentieth I’m sweating through my sweater. By the twenty-sixth I hear, from somewhere to my left, a small sound that I think is Kask taking off his glasses.

*Cradle 1,478. 7-7-3-1-B-1-1-2.*

“Match,” says Theo. And then, in a changed voice: “That’s thirty.”

I open my eyes.

Ash has put down his pen. His round pleasant face has gone very still, and for a moment I see, behind it, a man who loves pie and has just been shown a thing he’ll think about at night.

“It’s not the numbers,” he says. “I’d believed the numbers in the vault. It’s that you didn’t *pause.*” He swallows. “Do you see them? Is it a picture?”

“It’s a corridor,” I say. “I walk down it.”

“Does it hurt?”

I think about the answer I’d have given in the garage in Denver, at the beginning, and about the one I’d give now, and about the small flat honest word that sits between.

“Sometimes,” I say. “It costs something. I don’t know what.”

---

It’s 11:48 when Calloway lays her pen across her folio and says that Northgate is satisfied that the assessor can perform.

“I’ll accept, in principle, a nomination from the Insured,” she says, “within the seventy-two hours. I’ll accept it quickly, if it’s good. And I’ll tell you what I’ll not do.” She stands. “I’ll not tell you whom I’d choose. It would make me a party. But Ash and I are flying home at three.

We shall be in the Denver office tomorrow morning from eight. A nomination delivered by midnight on Wednesday will be treated as received before Mr. Whitcombe has done anything with Schedule C. A nomination delivered a minute after—”

“Is received after.”

“By a man who’s been the Representative for forty hours,” says Calloway, “and who has, I’d venture, some views on who ought to succeed him.” She buttons the gray raincoat. “He’ll name himself. It’s allowed. The treaty only says a successor, not an independent one. And he has a motion before a judge who, I’m told, likes a tidy file.”

She goes out. Ash lingers at the door with his hat in his hand.

“For what it’s worth,” he says to me, “it’s lemon meringue at the diner on Fourth. I asked. It’s real.”

“Thank you, Mr. Ash.”

“I’m very sorry about the corridor,” says Wendell Ash, and follows her.

Calloway stops at the door, with her hand on the knob, and doesn’t turn round.

“One thing more, Ms. Pruitt, since I’m leaving. I’ve read every page of your file, and Mr. Marsh’s, and Mr. Pike’s last letter. I’ve found nothing I could call a lie. It’s unnerving. In thirty-one years I’ve never read a file in which every person was telling the truth and the sum was still a disaster.” She turns the knob. “I’d like to be wrong about the ending.”

It’s 11:52 on Tuesday the twenty-ninth of December. It’s forty-one days. And I have until midnight tomorrow to find a person in the whole of North America who has never said a convenient thing.

I know exactly one.

I’m not sure she’ll answer the phone.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!