Thaddeus Fenn looks into the room over Ellis Tarr’s shoulder, and sees me at the kitchen table with a cold cup of coffee, and for the length of one slow breath his entirely pleasant face does something I’ve never seen it do. It forgets itself.
“Ms. Pruitt,” he says. “I had understood you were in Duluth.”
“I had understood you were in Cheyenne.”
“I was. On Saturday.” He lowers the envelope, which he’s no longer holding, since Ellis took it. “It’s a good deal faster by air. I trust you found it so.”
“I did.”
“Then we’ve the same travel agent,” says Fenn, with a small bleak smile, and for a moment, in the cramped dim hallway over a shoe repair, we look at each other like two people who have been writing to one another for weeks under assumed names.
He’s about fifty. He’s lean and clean, in the pale raincoat and a gray scarf knotted just so, with a face like a very good clerk’s: smooth, regular and forgettable. The rimless glasses give him the look of a man who hasn’t a single opinion that couldn’t be defended in front of a committee. I’ve spent two months afraid of him. I find, to my embarrassment, that he’s shorter than I am.
“I’d like to come in,” he says. “I’d like to say a thing, and I’d like to say it in front of a witness who isn’t my employer. May I?”
“Plate first,” says Ellis Tarr.
Fenn looks at him.
“It’s a thing they do in Minnesota,” says Ellis, gravely. “I’ve picked it up on the telephone. You’ll have a cup of coffee, Mr. Fenn, or you’ll say it on the stairs.”
---
He takes the coffee. He takes the stool, which Dale has surrendered with a flourish like a head waiter’s, and he sits on it with his raincoat on and his gloves in his lap and the cup held in both hands. Nobody speaks until he has drunk half of it. I’ve begun to suspect that it’s the most powerful rule I’ve ever seen.
“I’d like to begin,” says Fenn, “with an admission.”
“Go on.”
“I opened the book.”
Nobody moves. In the corner by the radio, my father has gone as still as the plastic hand.
“On the third of December,” says Fenn. “In the Harrow and Pike vault. When the boy was called away. Mr. Grosz’s instruction to me, in the car, was perfectly clear. I was to inventory the outside of each container. I was not to open, to disturb or to read. He was most particular. He said, *Thaddeus, I’ll have no part of a trespass.* I said that I understood.”
“You opened it anyway.”
“I opened Box 1140.” He doesn’t look away. “It had a red-lidded bin and a strip of tape on it, and a label in Mr. Lindqvist’s hand. *Not to be opened until the Weir woman reports to the house.* I’d no idea what it meant. But I stood there with a young man who was photographing a shelf and a boy who’d been called to a hospice, and I thought: *this is the thing.* It’s the one he’s been guarding.
I knew it as you know a face.” He turns the cup. “I took the lid off. I slit the tape. I took out a small green book and I read it, in eleven minutes, standing up, with a steam kettle I’d had the foresight to bring.”
“A kettle,” says Priscilla, in my head. It’s an absurd detail. It’s the most damning I’ve heard.
“I’ve no excuse,” says Fenn. “I’ve thought about it a great deal since. I’d like to say it was curiosity, and it was. I’d like to say it was duty, and that’s partly true. But I think it was neither.” He lowers his voice. “I think I wanted to know what sort of man could make thirty-one people send his money back.”
---
It’s a quiet room. The radiator knocks. Down on Larimer Street a delivery truck backs up, beeping, and the sound comes in through the old glass like a slow clock.
“What did you tell Mr. Grosz?” I say.
“Nothing.”
“You photographed it.”
“I photographed the *outside.* I handed him an inventory of sixty-one containers and sixty-one photographs, as instructed. I said that all seals were intact, as I’d found them.” A thin smile. “It was the first lie I’ve told him in twenty-two years. It’s a very curious sensation. One feels one’s ears go hot.”
“And the names?”
“I have them.” He taps his temple, once, with a gloved finger. “I’ve a good memory. It’s why I’m useful. I read thirty-one entries in eleven minutes, and I remembered every name and every sum. I told Mr. Whitcombe one.”
“Tarr.”
“Mr. Tarr. Because it was the easiest, and the safest, and because it was already in Mr. Whitcombe’s own file. The garage had been logged in a Ninefold security review in November. I presented it as an inference from the booth logs. It was a modest deception.” He looks, with sudden candor, at Ellis. “I’m very sorry for it. I’d have preferred another route. The subpoena was the only one that didn’t involve a telephone.”
“It’s no matter,” says Ellis, composedly. “I was going to speak anyhow.”
“Yes. So I’d gathered.” Fenn sets down the cup. “I should like to say, Ms. Pruitt, that I’m not here as a friend. I’m an employee of Mr. Grosz, and I’ve served him since a time when he was a man with a wife. I’m here because of a promise.”
“To whom?”
“To Mrs. Grosz.”
---
He says it so quietly that I think for a moment I’ve misheard.
“Margit Grosz died eight years ago in March. I’d been with the family fourteen years. She’d the same illness as your Mr. Lindqvist. It came upon her slowly, over six years, and Mr. Grosz bore it as he bears everything, by taking charge of it.” Fenn looks at his gloves.
“He rearranged the household. He moved her into a facility he’d built, and then into another, and then into a room of her own in the one that bears her name. And he sat with her every Thursday for six years and four months. I know because I drove him.”
“Every Thursday,” I say. I think of the tape. *Every Thursday. I’d bring the cheesecake.*
“On the last Thursday,” says Fenn, “she did not know him. It was the first time. She looked at him for a long while, and she said: *Hartley, I think you’ve got the wrong room.* And he said, *Quite possibly, my dear.* And he sat down in the chair and held her hand for two hours and nine minutes.”
He’s silent a moment. “She died on the Tuesday. I was in the corridor. She’d asked for me the Monday night. She was very lucid. It’s the thing they say happens, in the last hours. She made me promise something.”
“What?”
“She said: *Thaddeus. He’ll try to hold on to everything. It’s what he does. He’ll build a wall round whatever he can’t bear to lose, and he’ll call it a kindness.* She said: *When he goes too far, I’d like you to tell the person he’s going too far with.*” He raises his eyes. They’re very gray, very tired, quite steady. “I’ve waited eight years. I’d thought it might not come.”
“And it has.”
“I think it came on the third of December,” says Thaddeus Fenn, “when I read the word *Returned* thirty-one times in a green book and understood what he was trying to buy.”
---
It’s Dale who finds his tongue first. I’d have bet my license on it.
“You’re a sneak,” he says, with great energy. “You’re a house-sneak and a book-sneak. You’ve been sitting on my daughter’s tail for ten weeks, in a gray car, with a map, and you come into a man’s kitchen and say you’ve got a *conscience.*”
“Mr. Pruitt.”
“I’d like to hear you say you’re sorry.”
“I’m very sorry.”
“Say it to her.”
“Ms. Pruitt,” says Fenn. “I’m sorry for the parking lot at Hollis Junction. And the clip on the church floor. And the Dunn girl’s mother’s van, which I hadn’t the authority to refuse and had, I’m afraid, the authority to arrange.” He takes off his glasses. Without them the face is naked and a little older, with the red mark of the nosepiece on either side.
“And I’m sorry for being the sort of man who could do a thing for twenty-two years and discover on the twenty-fifth of November, in a motel in Nebraska, with a plate of eggs in front of me, that I’d never once been asked to say no.”
I put my hands on the table. I feel the Formica under my palms, cold and a little sticky. It’s the most ordinary surface in the world.
“What do you want?” I say.
“Nothing.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the one I have.” The faint, dry smile comes and goes. “I’d like to tell you what I know, and I’d like it not to be taken as a bargain. I’d like to be as little use to you as possible. I’m a man who serves a subpoena and hands it to a gentleman with a hook, and walks away. But I’d like you to know before you leave Denver that Mr. Whitcombe means to call two more witnesses on the twelfth.”
“Who?”
“Dr. Achterberg. She’ll be served tomorrow at six, in her office, by a young woman with a tablet. And Mrs. Lorraine Teague, of Omaha, who, I believe, has been asked by no one to be anywhere.” He puts the glasses on again. “He means to ask them each one question. *Did the respondent, at any time, offer you a payment?*”
“They’ll say yes.”
“They will. Honestly. It’s what he’s counting on.” Fenn stands, and buttons the raincoat, and draws on the gloves, finger by finger. “You see the design. He has a list of persons from whom Mr. Lindqvist tried to buy something. He’ll say it’s a pattern. That a man who is impaired, in an altered state, has been scattering money for nine years to anyone who’ll stand still.
That the Instruments are a form of payment by other means.” He looks at Ellis, and at me. “It’s a good argument. I’d have thought of it myself, in a better year. And the Court may like it.”
“They *refused,*” says Ellis Tarr.
“Yes. But a refusal, sir, in a courtroom, is only the second half of an offer.”
---
He goes out at 2:09 by the hall clock. He doesn’t offer to shake anyone’s hand. At the door he stops, and turns, and says to me in the grave soft voice of a man who has had a long time to think about the order of his sentences:
“One more thing. I’ve not told Mr. Grosz about the book. He believes the tape is on the shelf. He believes the seal was intact. I’d ask you not to mention it.”
“I’ve a Representative who’s going to write him a letter.”
“Then you’ll want to word it carefully.” He touches the brim of a hat he’s forgotten to wear. “I should like to be fired by him, in person, at a time of my choosing. It’s the one dignity I’ve left.”
“Mr. Fenn.”
“Yes?”
“Why did you tell me?”
He thinks about it. Dale, at the wall, has stopped breathing.
“Because it’s what she’d have wanted,” says Thaddeus Fenn. “And because in nine years of loyalty I never once saw him lose a thing, and I should like, before the end, to see him do it well.”
The door shuts. His steps go down the stairs, light, even, unhurried. Below, the street door opens and closes, and a car starts, and a little gray sedan pulls out into the traffic on Larimer.
I call Priscilla from the landing, with the door shut, at 2:20, because it’s the first thing I ought to do and the last thing I want to.
She listens to the whole of it without a sound. When I’ve finished, there’s a pause long enough that I check the screen to see if the call has dropped.
“Pruitt,” she says. “You understand what he’s given you.”
“A confession.”
“A confession of a trespass, in the presence of two witnesses, one of whom is your father.” She sounds, to my astonishment, almost amused. “It’s inadmissible and it’s perfectly honest. I can’t use it. I may not even write it in my letter, because I’d be citing a source I’ve promised not to burn.
But I may do this.” A pencil taps. “I may add a sentence to my Condition 9 notice, to the effect that *the Representative has reason to believe that the container was opened by a person acting for the lender.* It isn’t a lie. It’s a belief. I’m entitled to those.”
“He asked not to be named.”
“I’ll not name him. I’ll name the *act.* It’s what the clause is for.” The tapping stops. “He’s a sneak, Pruitt. But I find I’d rather like to shake his hand.”
“He’s got a wife.”
“He’s got a *dead* wife, which is a different obligation. It’s the strongest there is.” A breath. “Go and find your father. I think he’s been alone in a room with a stranger for too long, and I’d not like to see what he sells him.”
---
It’s Ellis who breaks the silence. He’s lowered himself onto the sofa beside my father, with the hook on his knee, looking at the door.
“I’ve known sneaks,” he says. “I’ve watched forty years of them come and go. I’d never, to be candid, met a sneak with a wife.”
“It was *her* wife,” says Dale, indignantly. “It was Grosz’s. It’s a different thing.”
“It’s the same thing,” I say.
They look at me.
“It’s the same thing,” I say again, slowly. “The thing he’s afraid of. The thing Fenn’s afraid of. The thing the whole autumn’s been about. A man sits with someone he loves who doesn’t know him, and holds her hand, and calls it a kindness. And then he builds a wall.” I look at the faded card on the wall. *The lady will be a while. Be kind to her.* “Soren didn’t build one. That’s the whole difference. He left every door he could.”
“Is that what the ledger’s for?” says Ellis.
“I think it’s what it’s *about.*”
My phone buzzes against the table. It’s a text from Weir, who has never in her life sent one. It’s four words long, with an exact full stop at the end, and the time stamped in the corner as though it had been written by someone for whom a clock was a creed.
*Please come home. He asked.*


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!