Marguerite Bell takes the oath of no one, because she is the one administering it, and at 9:00 on Monday morning in the Lakeview Ballroom of the Duluth Hilton, under a chandelier with two dead bulbs, she lays a leather folio on a long table, takes off her camel coat, hangs it on the back of her chair, and says, in a clear low unhurried contralto, “Good morning. I should like to begin by saying that I regret every minute of this.”
She’s fifty-eight. She is tall, with a straight back and a long handsome face and silver hair cut in a precise bob, and she wears a dark gray suit with a single pearl at the collar, and she looks, with the folio and the coat and the long fine hands, exactly like what she is: the general counsel of a reinsurance house with offices in four countries and a record of never having lost a coverage dispute.
I’ve been braced for a shark. I’d not been braced for good manners.
“I’m told,” she says, “that the Representative and Ms. Pruitt would prefer a smaller room. I considered it. I decided that nine witnesses and four lawyers would be uncomfortable in a parlor. The ballroom has a coffee service.” She pauses. “I’d like it recorded that the coffee is on Northgate.”
“You’re very kind,” says Priscilla Odum, from the other side of the table.
“I’m not. I’m thorough. It’s a different thing, and I’d rather you didn’t confuse them.” The faint ghost of a smile. “I find it helps to be disliked for the right reasons.”
---
There are, I count, twenty-three people in the room. It’s a long gilt ballroom with a stage at one end and a banquet table set up in a T, and at the head sit Bell and two junior lawyers with laptops, a court reporter, Ines Calloway, who has the dazed look of a woman made to watch her own employer take apart her own file, and Wendell Ash, who has put his hat on his knee.
Along the long side sit our side. Priscilla, with her clipboard. Ingrid, in her gray coat. Peter Ley, who has no standing and has been admitted as *a person Mrs. Sjoberg has asked to take notes.* Kask. Theo Marsh, in a suit for the first time in two months, with his red beard trimmed. And me.
And in a row of nine gilt chairs against the wall, in their best clothes, in an order they’ve sorted out among themselves with an elaborate casual courtesy that doesn’t deceive anybody, sit the nine.
Wilf Okafor, in a pressed blue shirt. Birdie Tolliver in a black pantsuit with a turquoise brooch, her arms crossed, her chin high. Pa Houa Vang, tiny and upright, in a quilted jacket, with Tou in a clip-on tie beside her to translate. Augie Brandt in a suit that must have been his father’s, with his feed cap under his chair.
Pastor Ben Ostrander, with his reindeer tie. Kayla Dunn in a green dress and a cardigan. Edith, in her good blue, with her handbag on her knee. Ellis Tarr, in the gray cardigan, with the hook folded on his lap. Marianne Voss, in her gray collar, with a notebook.
It’s the strangest sight I’ve ever seen. It looks like a family at a funeral.
“Article Thirty-One,” says Marguerite Bell. “I’ll read it, so that nobody may say they weren’t told. *The Reinsurers may, upon written notice, convene a Verification of Continuity in respect of any Custody the continuity of which depends upon the conduct of persons other than the Insured. At such Verification, each such person may be put on oath and asked to state the nature of what he or she holds.*”
She lays the page down. “I’d like each of you to understand that this is not a hostile proceeding. It’s a *clarifying* one. I’ve no wish to embarrass anyone. I ask only that you answer plainly.”
“And if we can’t?” says Birdie, at the wall.
“Then you’ll say so, Mrs. Tolliver. It’s an answer.”
“It’s a *trap,* baby.”
“It’s a question,” says Bell, mildly. “I find they’re often the same.”
---
She begins with Wilf.
He’s the first in the line, and he comes to the chair in front of the table with the slow shy walk of a man who has delivered mail for sixteen years in all weathers and has never once been asked to sit. He takes the oath. He folds his large hands.
“Mr. Okafor. You’re a letter carrier.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“You’ve signed an Instrument of Keeping. What do you keep?”
“I don’t know,” says Wilf.
There’s a small stir. One of the junior lawyers types.
“You don’t know?”
“No, ma’am. I was asked to hold a door. By a man in a hall, one Tuesday. He didn’t say what for.” He looks round, helplessly. “I said yes. I’d like to say it was a good reason. I don’t have a good one. I’ve been handing him a card every December for eight years, and he’s been handing it back. I figured it was a thing I could do.”
“What door?”
“The one he’d want opened. When the time comes.”
“Who decides when the time has come?”
“He does. Or the lady who counts.” He nods, with great simplicity, at me. “I’d do what she says.”
“Because?”
“Because she’s never told me a thing that wasn’t so,” says Wilf Okafor.
Bell writes a line. She does it with a fountain pen, in a small black notebook, with great economy. I find I cannot read her face. She doesn’t look pleased. She doesn’t look displeased. She looks, I think, like a doctor listening to a chest.
“Thank you, Mr. Okafor. One further matter. I understand that on Friday you were visited at your place of employment by a Mr. Gerald Voigt.”
“Yes, ma’am.” He swallows. “Postal Inspection Service.”
“Did he explain the nature of his inquiry?”
“He said there’d been an anonymous complaint about a carrier receiving gifts from a customer on his route.” The big hands tighten. “I’ve not. I returned every one. I’ve eight years of notes to show it. He took them, and he’s looking. My postmaster says I’m to be reassigned to the Cloquet route on Monday while it’s pending.”
“That’s thirty-one miles from Fourth Street.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“I’m very sorry to hear it,” says Marguerite Bell, and I’d swear, I would swear in any court, that she means it.
---
They go through the nine in the morning. It takes three hours and eleven minutes, and I’ll not set down all of it.
Birdie is magnificent. She says that what she keeps is *a stool, a pie and a boy,* that the stool is the third on the left at the Prairie Star and the pie is coconut cream and the boy is *the sorriest, politest, bravest son of a gun I ever met,* that she’s been told to hold a door and doesn’t know where it is, and that when the time comes she’ll put her truck in front of it.
Bell asks whether this is a figure of speech. Birdie says *no, baby, it’s a Peterbilt.*
Pa Houa says, through Tou, in a voice like the wind in dry grass, that she keeps nothing, that it’s the whole of the point, that a man brought her a box and she refused his money and put the box in her freezer, and that every morning she takes the quilt off the lid, looks at it, and puts it back.
Bell asks what’s in the box. Pa Houa says that’s not for her to know. Bell asks whether she’s curious. And the old woman looks at her, for a long moment, with her black unblinking eyes, and says, in English, one word:
“No.”
Pastor Ostrander says that he holds the door as a church holds a door, by being near it, and that he’s been doing it thirty years. Kayla says she holds it *because he said I was right.* Edith says she holds it as she holds her own kitchen, which is by feeding whoever comes in. Ellis Tarr says he holds it with one hand.
Voss says she’ll sit.
It’s a very odd litany. By noon, I think, the whole ballroom has gone silent. The junior lawyers have stopped typing. The court reporter, a plump young woman in a floral blouse, is wiping her eyes with the back of her wrist.
And then Augie Brandt takes the chair.
---
He’s a big, shy, red-faced man in his father’s suit, and he sits as a man sits who has been driving for twenty years and is no longer sure what to do with his hands. He takes the oath in a mumble. He looks at the floor.
“Mr. Brandt,” says Bell. “You’re a driver.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“What do you keep?”
“I don’t know what I’m holding,” says Augie.
He says it quite plainly, in the same tone as the others. But something in it makes Bell lift her head.
“Say that again, please.”
“I don’t know what I’m holding. I never did.” He looks, for the first time, at her. “I’d like to say I’d the sense to ask. I didn’t. I’m a driver. I’d been told: *when the door has to be reached, you take them.* I said sure. I figure there’s a place. I figure he’ll say. I’m to put the lady and the old man in the cab and go.”
“Where?”
“Wherever he says.”
“And if he can’t say?”
“Then I’d ask the lady who counts.”
“And if she can’t?”
Augie Brandt considers it. His broad face, under the light of the dead chandelier, has an odd, patient, inward look, the look of a man doing a sum he’s done many times and has never quite got to come out.
“I figure,” he says, “somebody’s got the rest. There’s nine of us. I’d say Mrs. Halvorsen’s got the house. And Mr. Tarr’s got a card with a time on it. And Mrs. Vang’s got a freezer, and the pastor’s got a roof, and Kayla’s got a van.” He lifts one shoulder.
“I’m the road. I drive. Nobody’s got the whole of it, that’s the idea. If you only had one of us, you’d have a driver with no place to go, or a place with no road. It takes all of us in a line.”
Nobody breathes.
It is, I realize, the best explanation of the arrangement I have ever heard, and it has been given, under oath, to a reinsurer’s general counsel, by a man in a borrowed suit who believes he’s confessing ignorance.
Marguerite Bell sets down her pen.
“Thank you, Mr. Brandt,” she says, very quietly. “That’s the clearest statement we’ve had.”
---
It’s two o’clock when she calls me.
She’s changed, in the lunch hour. I don’t mean the suit. I mean that she’s lost, somewhere between the sandwiches and the second pot of coffee, a degree of her glassy courtesy. She looks at me as I come to the witness chair like a woman looking across a river at somebody she’s decided to respect.
“Ms. Pruitt. You’ll be the last.”
“Yes.”
“You’re the independent assessor. You’ve certified a statement under Part B that the Key is held, in a dispersed manner, by nine persons, none of whom, on their own testimony, knows what it is.” She folds her hands. “I’ve heard nine people say that they hold a door. I should like to ask you the question which I’ve been putting, in one form or another, to nine.”
“Please.”
“What is the door?”
I look at her. I look at the long gilt room and the nine in their chairs, at Priscilla’s pale exact face, at Ingrid’s hand on her pad. I look at Theo’s beard. I look, for a moment, at the dead bulbs in the chandelier, which are the same dull gray as the sky.
I think about the corridor in my head. I think of the sixty-three, and the nine rooms and the sixty-fourth word. I think of an old man in a kitchen with a blue flame and a woman’s name he’d lost.
“I don’t know,” I say.
It’s the first time in my life I’ve said it on oath, and it comes out as clean as a coin.
“You don’t know.”
“I was asked to count. I’ve counted. I’ve certified what I can verify.” I meet her eyes. “I’m not the Key. I’m the *threshold,* as it was put to me. I count who goes in. I don’t know what’s in the room. I never asked, and he never said.”
“The Insured’s key consists of sixty-four words, of which, I understand, you hold sixty-three.”
“I hold nine rooms of seven. It’s not the same.”
“And the sixty-fourth?”
“Is not in the house,” I say. “I’m told it’s held by a person who remembers.”
“Which person?”
“I don’t know.”
Marguerite Bell takes off her glasses. It’s a gesture I’ve seen in other women a good many times in the last two months, and I’ve learned to wait for what follows it.
“Ms. Pruitt,” she says. “I’d like to read you Article 31, sub (d).”
---
I’d like to say it came as a surprise. It didn’t. I’d read the treaty excerpt at dawn.
“*If, upon a Verification, the Designated Person is unable to state the means by which the Key may be recovered, the Reinsurers may deem the continuity of the Key to be unverified as of the fifteenth day after the date of the Verification.*” She lifts her eyes. “I should like to put it to you plainly.
You’ve told me that the Key is held. You’ve told me it can’t be stated. You’ve told me that the person who can state it is, in the Representative’s own phrase, *a gentleman in an hour that may or may not come.* I’m obliged, as counsel to the Reinsurers, to treat that as an inability.”
“Yes.”
“The date is the twenty-fifth of January. Fifteen days is the ninth of February.” She folds her glasses. “I’m told that is one day after the lapse.”
“Yes.”
“I find that an odd coincidence.”
“It’s not a coincidence,” says Priscilla Odum, quite clearly, from the table. “It’s a trap. It’s been built, I think, to be sprung the day after we win.”
“I didn’t build it, Mrs. Odum. I *found* it.” Bell doesn’t look round. “It’s been in the treaty forty years. I’ve simply read to the end.” She turns back to me, and for the first time there’s something in her long handsome face that I’d call regret. “I’m sorry, Ms. Pruitt. I said so at the start. I don’t think you’ve done anything wrong. I think you’ve done something extraordinary. And I think it will not be enough.”
“What would be?”
“A statement of the means of recovery.” She says it gently. “Not the Key. I’ve no wish to know the Key. A *method.* A named person, a named place, a named procedure, that a stranger could follow. By the ninth of February.” A pause.
“If you can’t, I’ll deem the continuity unverified, and the policy will respond to a Key Loss, and the clients will be paid at par. I shall have done my job. And your man will go to a house in the country.”
“I see.”
“I rather hope you’ll prove me wrong,” says Marguerite Bell, and calls a recess.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!