Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 97

The Gymnasium

Pueblo Central High School’s gymnasium holds sixteen hundred people on folding chairs, and at 6:50 on Tuesday evening, ten minutes before the meeting begins, it holds eleven hundred and four, by the count that I take from the doorway, and every one of them is over sixty-five.

It’s a long high echoing room with a varnished floor, striped for basketball, and a stage at one end with a banner that says GO WOLVES. The bleachers are pulled out on both sides. In the rows below, in winter coats, with canes and walkers and clipboards and thermoses of tea, sit eleven hundred retired schoolteachers. There are women in cardigans with tight white curls and men in tweed jackets with leather elbows. There are three rows of people in wheelchairs.

There’s a woman with a hearing trumpet, and a very tall old man with a clip-on tie that says WORLD’S BEST PRINCIPAL, and in the front row, in a lavender coat and a hat with a small feather, a tiny ancient lady with a cane across her knees, who is looking at me across forty feet of basketball court with bright blue eyes like a bird’s.

“That’s her,” says Dolores Quint, at my elbow. “That’s Mrs. Bascombe.”

“She’s ninety-one.”

“She’s ninety-one and she’s never missed a meeting. She taught second grade in Pueblo for forty-one years.” Quint’s voice shakes. “She taught me to read.”

I look at the little figure in the lavender hat. She raises one gloved hand, an inch, from the head of her cane, and lowers it.

It’s the most alarming thing that’s happened to me since the vault.

---

I’m not an adjudicator. I want that clear. I’ve no license for it, no standing, no robes. I’m an independent loss assessor employed by the company whose valuation I’m about to explain, and my only qualification is that I once said *I don’t know* in a hotel ballroom.

I’ve a folder. It’s thin. I’ve been up since four going through it with Priscilla, on the phone, from the Pueblo Holiday Inn, with Theo reading numbers down the line from Denver and Ingrid in the next room, in her coat, dictating, from memory, the relevant paragraphs of the Colorado Public Employees’ Retirement statutes.

“You’re to say what happened,” Priscilla had said. “In the plainest words you possess. You’re to say what’s known and what isn’t. You’re not to say what will occur.”

“They’ll want to be told they’ll be paid.”

“Then you’ll disappoint them.” A dry pause. “It’s what an adjuster’s for, Pruitt. It’s the only job in the world in which one is *hired* to tell people what they don’t wish to hear.”

At 7:00, a man in a bow tie taps a microphone. The room goes still.

---

It’s a very ordinary meeting, at first. It’s the kind of thing I’ve sat through in a hundred church basements. There’s a chairman, who’s seventy-eight, with a white mustache, and who reads the minutes of the last meeting aloud with a slow, dignified, unembarrassed hesitation at the longer words. There’s a motion to dispense with the reading of the treasurer’s report. There’s a woman in the third row with a question about the parking.

Then the chairman puts on his glasses and says, “We come now to the matter for which the members have been called,” and eleven hundred people draw a breath at once, with a sound like wind in a field of dry corn.

“The trustee, Mrs. Quint, will speak.”

She does it badly. She says so, at the start. She stands at the lectern in her gray wool suit with her white hair like dandelion fluff and a sheet of paper that she doesn’t look at, and says, in a high thin voice that carries to the back of the gym with the unfortunate clarity of a woman who has taught children to read:

“Friends. I’m so sorry. I’ve voted wrong, and I’ve been lied to, and I’m going to tell you everything.”

She tells it for nine minutes. She tells it, I’ll say, extremely well. She doesn’t spare herself. She says that in the month of January she voted, with another director, to table a report that said the Fund’s largest outside asset was overstated by eleven million dollars. She says she did it out of fear. She says she was told, by a man she trusted, that if the news got out there’d be a run, and that she believed him.

She says his name, quite steadily, and an old woman near the front says *oh no* in a small voice, and there’s a murmur through the gym like a stone dropped in a well.

“I should like to say,” says Dolores Quint, “that I read the working papers. All four hundred pages. And I should like to say that the first person to tell me what was in them was the lady in the blue suit who’s standing at the back.”

Eleven hundred heads turn.

I’d like to say that I stood tall. I didn’t. I stood in the doorway with my folder against my chest like a girl at a spelling bee, and eleven hundred old schoolteachers looked at me, and the whole of the long varnished room hung, for the length of one slow breath, in the sort of silence that a classroom keeps for a thing it’s been told it must not laugh at.

“Ms. Pruitt,” says the chairman. “Would you step up, please?”

---

I tell them in twenty-two minutes.

I stand at the lectern. It’s too tall. Somebody brings me a box to stand on, a wooden thing painted green, with a stenciled label that says PE EQUIPMENT, and a small outbreak of kindly laughter goes through the bleachers and helps. I say my name. I say what I am and who pays me. I say that I’m not a lawyer, a trustee or an actuary, and that nothing I tell them is advice.

And then I tell them what’s true.

I say that the Fund holds, as one of many assets, a share in a custody book maintained by a Denver company, and that in September a certificate was issued putting the book’s value at eight hundred and eleven million dollars. I say that three more units were counted than existed.

I say that I found it because I’d been in the vault in November, and remember. I say, since it’s the point, that the overstatement was eleven million, one hundred and four thousand dollars, and that the Fund’s share of that is a little under three million.

A sound goes through the room.

“The restated certificate,” I say, “has been issued. I’ve read it. It’s correct. Mr. Marsh of Ninefold has signed it, and so has the independent valuer, who has joined in the correction. It means that the Fund’s reported funding level is not the figure that you were told in October. It’s lower, by about two and a half percent.”

“Two and a *half,*” says a man in the third row, loudly.

“Two and a half percent. Not a quarter. Not the whole.” I try to keep my voice level. “It’s not a thing I’m pleased to say. I wish I could say it was nothing. It isn’t. It’s a gap. It’s a real one.”

“Will we be paid?” says a woman near the aisle. It’s a high cracked voice, and she’s standing, holding a walker, and she’s trembling all over like a leaf.

It’s the question. It’s the one I’ve known for ten days would come.

---

I’d like to describe what I want to say. I want to say *of course.* I want to say it as a thing you say to an old woman in an aisle with a walker, in the voice of a person who has been brought up to say the kind thing, and who knows from fourteen years of claims how much more it costs, afterward, than the true one.

“I don’t know,” I say.

The gymnasium is silent.

“I can’t tell you. I’m not able to. It’s not mine to promise.” I swallow. “I can tell you what’s been done. The man who made the error has resigned every office he held, and has put, in writing, a sum of money in trust toward the gap. His family’s done the same. It’s a good deal smaller than what’s needed, and it’s not a gift.

It’s what he’s got.” I take a breath. “I can tell you that the Underwriter has confirmed that the correction doesn’t void the policy, and that the Fund remains a client. I can tell you that the rest depends on a number of things I can’t see, and on the Fund’s own lawyers, who are better than I am.”

“That’s not an answer,” says a man in tweed.

“No, sir. It’s what I’ve got.”

“It’s a damn poor one.”

“Yes,” I say. “It is. I’d rather give you a poor true one than a good false one. I’ve been offered, in the last three months, a very great many good false ones.”

I hear, in the silence, a very small dry tapping, and I look, and see that in the front row, on the gym floor, the tiny lady in the lavender hat is striking her cane against the boards. She does it three times, evenly, like a teacher calling a class.

“May I?” says Mrs. Bascombe.

---

She doesn’t use the microphone. She doesn’t need to. She stands, which takes some time, by stages, with a hand on the chairman’s arm and a hand on the cane, a little bent figure in a lavender coat no taller than a twelve-year-old, and she turns, not to me, but to the room.

“I taught second grade,” says Mrs. Bascombe. Her voice is high, thin, extraordinarily clear, with a faint Colorado twang. “Forty-one years. I’ve had, by my count, about twelve hundred children. I’d like to tell you what I learned.”

Nobody moves.

“I learned that when a child says *I don’t know,* there are two kinds. There’s the one who doesn’t know, and says so. And there’s the one who knows, and doesn’t want to tell you, and says it to be left alone.” She leans on the cane. “You get to know the difference. It takes about three years. It’s in the eyes.”

A laugh goes through the room, soft and relieved.

“I’ve been looking at this young woman for twenty-two minutes. She’s got a green box under her feet. She’s told us she’s not a lawyer, and she’s told us she’s not sure. And she’s told us three things she could have kept to herself, because they weren’t to her credit.” The bright blue eyes turn on me.

“She said she found it because she’d *remembered.* She said her name was on the papers. She said she’d rather give us a poor true answer. I’ve heard a great many men in suits say a great many things about this Fund, in nineteen years of meetings. I’ve never heard one of them say *I don’t know.*”

“Hear, hear,” says someone in the back.

“I’d like to say that I believe her,” says Mrs. Bascombe. “And I’d like to move that this meeting *not* demand an immediate withdrawal of funds. I’d like to move that we give the trustees and the Fund’s own counsel *ninety days.*” She lifts the cane an inch.

“I’ve been paid a pension for thirty years by a fund that was in the hands of honest people most of the time. I’d rather have the honest ones for ninety days than the angry ones for ninety minutes.”

“Second,” says a hundred voices.

---

It carries. I’ll not give the count. It was, I’m told by the chairman, the largest majority in the history of the Fund on a matter of any importance, and it passed by a show of canes.

It’s 8:44 when the doors at the back of the gym open, and a stout, silver-haired man in a dark overcoat and a pale blue tie comes in alone.

I’d not been told. Nobody had. I see him over the heads of the old teachers, in the doorway, with his hat in his two hands and his round pink face quite white, and I see it go through the room like a draft: a murmur, a rustle, a turning of heads. It’s the sound a congregation makes when somebody enters late during the Gospel.

He’s seventy-four. He’s in a dark overcoat that is a little too big, and he looks, in the gymnasium of a high school where he’s never been, with eleven hundred people who know exactly what he’s done, like a very old, very plump, very gentle boy who has come to school on the wrong day.

“I do beg your pardon,” says Lyle Sumner, in his soft courtly voice, into the silence. “I should like to speak. If the meeting will allow it. I shan’t be long.”

Nobody says anything. I see Dolores Quint put her hand over her mouth.

“I’ve no right,” he says. “I’ve come only to say a thing that I’ve not been able to put in a letter. I’ve the greatest respect for this body. I should like to say that I’m sorry.” He swallows. “I don’t expect to be forgiven. I wished only to say it in the room.”

It’s a very long, very terrible silence. Somebody coughs. Somewhere in the bleachers a cane falls, and clatters.

And then, from the front row, in a lavender coat with a feather in her hat, Mrs. Bascombe turns.

She’s ninety-one. She’s four foot ten. She’s quite alone in the middle of the gym floor with the whole room watching, and she looks down the long varnished court at a man who has cost her, by a small but real fraction, the security of her last years. She considers him, as she must have considered a boy who had put a frog in the inkwell.

“Lyle Sumner,” says Mrs. Bascombe, in her clear high teacher’s voice. “You were in my class, the year you turned seven. You sat in the second row. You were a very *nice* boy.”

“Mrs. Bascombe.” He’s gone the color of paper. “I—I had hoped you wouldn’t—”

“You wrote me a card every Christmas for sixty years.” She leans on the cane. “I thought it was the nicest thing. I’ve kept them all.” A long pause. “I’ll tell you what you’ll do. You’ll come down here, and you’ll sit on this folding chair, in front of everybody, where I can see you. And you’ll listen to what the people you’ve hurt have to say. All of it. For as long as it takes.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“And at the end,” says the old lady, “I’ll decide whether I’m going to say *thank you, dear.*”

---

I’ll not tell what followed. I was not asked to stay for it. I was thanked by the chairman, with a handshake and a small gold pin in the shape of an apple, and by Dolores Quint, with her arms round me in a very tight, very brief, startled embrace.

I went out through the side door of the gym into a clear freezing night with the stars out over Pueblo like salt on a table and my coat over my arm, and I stood in the parking lot for some minutes and shook.

It’s a small thing, shaking. I’ve learned to do it after, never before.

My phone buzzes at 9:20. I look at it. It’s Theo, and he’s typed in capitals, which he’s never done in his life.

*CALLOWAY JUST CALLED. BELL HAS BROUGHT FORWARD THE SECOND SESSION OF THE VERIFICATION. WEDNESDAY 8 A.M. EDITH’S KITCHEN. SHE SAYS IT’S NOT HOSTILE. SHE SAYS SHE’D LIKE TO SEE THE METHOD WITH NO REHEARSAL. SHE SAYS TO TELL YOU THE KEEPERS WILL BE GIVEN NO WARNING AND SHE’S SORRY. ALSO WILF HAS BEEN SERVED. POSTAL INSPECTION. HEARING THURSDAY.*

I read it twice. I put the phone in my pocket. I look up at the stars.

It’s eleven hours to a kitchen. And somewhere in it, behind someone’s ear, there is a pencil.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!