By Wednesday night the Field had become a place, which is to say it had a smell. The smell was Lloyd’s generator, hot toner, and Mrs. Whelan’s coffee, and it hung around the trailer like a rumor.
There were seven of us at the card tables and a hundred and sixty-one pigeonholes copied. Lloyd had moved the machine onto the gravel pad under the flagpole, wired to the RV with an orange cord, and it ran with a sound like a man clearing his throat for a very long speech. Each sheet came out warm. Each sheet went to Brent.
He had set up in the corner under the model of the community with a label maker, three colors of highlighter, a legal pad and a dark laptop he used as a hard surface. He wore the navy blazer. I had stopped asking.
“Four hundred,” he said at ten p.m., sitting back. “That’s a random sample. Every twenty-eighth slot, from the first to the last, and I took the oldest paper in each. Mateo checked my draw.”
“Technically random,” said Mateo, who was asleep with his head on a stack.
“Here is what I’m hearing,” said Brent, and caught himself, and said, “here is what the paper says.” He turned the legal pad around.
A. Please send us the page. Requests to amend, or to restore Article XX. About thirty-two percent.
B. Disputes. A board against a neighbor, a neighbor against a board, a hedge, a boat. About nineteen percent.
C. Please advise. A Settlement has found something in its own Declaration that does not work: a number that repeats, a section that refers to a section that is not there, a rule that contradicts itself. About twenty-five percent.
D. Please come. Some form of: will you attend. About twelve percent.
E. Letters that do not ask anything. About thirteen percent.
“That’s three thousand six hundred in A,” said Brent, “twenty-one hundred in B, twenty-eight hundred in C, thirteen hundred in D, fourteen hundred in E, on the full docket.” He tapped the pad. “Give or take two percent. I sell houses. I can tell you that what people think is a thousand separate problems is usually five.”
“I thought there’d be more,” said Lloyd.
“There are never more,” said Brent. “There’s the same problem told by different people.” His hand was shaking very slightly on the pen. I understood that he had not slept either, and that he was happy, in a way he had not been happy at any of the forums.
I should say what had put it in his head. On Tuesday evening, at the Willow Bend Kiosk, he had found a copy of his own filing from the autumn, the Petition for Class Determination he had written for Phase Two, and he had read it over on the tailgate of his car like a man looking at an old picture. A class, he said, is a way of saying that one person’s question belongs to everyone who is standing in the same spot. A hearing is a hearing. But you can hold one hearing in which a thousand people are heard.
“The language is Section 15.8,” he said. “Common question, representative petitioner, notice to every class member, right to appear and be heard. Any member may speak. Nobody is bound who didn’t get a chance. I wrote it for annexations. It’s a drafting artifact, a little pocket in the form. I think it’s a hearing.”
“Does it satisfy 1.4?” said Mrs. Okonkwo.
She had come in from the trailer, wearing her reading glasses on her forehead and carrying the binder, which was the thickest it had ever been. She did not sit down. In my experience Mrs. Okonkwo sits at the moment she has decided to be persuaded.
“In person,” said Brent. “As long as the petitioner requires. If every petitioner is given notice and a seat, and a class member can stand up and say it takes me four hours, then the hearing runs four hours. It’s not shorter. It’s shared.”
“Where is the denial?” said Mrs. Okonkwo.
“There isn’t one. The rule isn’t that you can’t hurry a petitioner. It’s that you can’t hurry the petitioner.” He took a breath. “I’d like you to attack it.”
“I intend to,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, and sat.
They went at it until one in the morning. It was, I believe, the finest hour of procedure I have ever witnessed, and I have attended eleven annual meetings. Mrs. Okonkwo argued that a class hearing was a stamp with a good reputation. Brent argued that a class hearing was a door. Lloyd observed that the Reserve had never paid for a thing in its life that it didn’t first look at from two sides. Mr. Haldane, who was supposed to be asleep in his station wagon, appeared in the doorway to say that he would like it noted that he disagreed with everyone, and that if the Declarant was going to run it, he wanted the rules of notice in writing and the right to bring his own chair.
At ten past one, Mrs. Okonkwo took off her glasses and said, “The Ombudsman is persuaded. On three conditions.”
“Name them,” said Brent.
“Every class member must receive written notice by a Registered Agent, with a signed receipt, accepted. Section 15.3(f). No deemed delivery, ever.” She held up a second finger. “No class is bound on a question it was not told it was asked.” A third. “And Mr. Kowalczyk reads aloud, in the room, with his own mouth, the first petition of every class. The representative’s. In full.”
“Why the last one?” I said.
“Because in eleven years you have never read me anything in full,” said Mrs. Okonkwo. “You summarized. It is a habit. I should like it broken in public.”
“Noted,” said Mateo, to the table, and went back to sleep.
Ms. Gault, who had been compiling the classes on a series of index cards in a clerk’s hand, set them in five stacks on the card table, with a bobby pin to hold each one together. She did not say anything. She straightened the stacks with her fingertips.
I should record the letter, because it arrived at about the same time, and it did not feel, at first, like a thing that mattered.
It came at 11:40 in a cream envelope, thick stock, heavy as a deed, through the slot that had once been the Willow Bend Kiosk’s fifteenth door and now appeared, without explanation, in the trailer’s end wall. Abernathy, who had been dozing on the folding chair in his carrier jacket, woke at the sound of a flap and took it by the corner and said, “Beg pardon? Delivery’s complete,” and handed it to me.
The paper was watermarked with a small crest, a pair of cattails over a fountain, and the words EASTGATE LAKES MASTER COMMUNITY. The hand was typed, the margins exact.
Dear Mr. Kowalczyk. Congratulations, or condolences, as you prefer; I have held the office of Governor for nineteen years and know the sensation. I write to say that Eastgate’s Compliance Bureau (nineteen staff, three thousand nine hundred homes, no Nuisance on our rolls in fifty-one years) stands ready to assist with disposition of the docket. We would be glad to take any portion. Efficiency, I find, is a kindness that arrives on time. With respect, Patrice Holloway, Governor. P.S. I am told you will be using Section 15.8. A good choice. I should have used it myself.
“It’s a lovely letter,” I said.
“It is a very good letter,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, who had read it over my shoulder. “I distrust it.”
“Why?”
“Disposition,” said Mrs. Okonkwo. “Look at the word she picked. It does not say hearing. It does not say answer. It says disposition.” She took off her glasses again, and rubbed her eyes. “There are people who confuse the two for so long that they begin to think the second is a form of the first. It is a respectable mistake. Mr. Kowalczyk, I made it myself for thirty years in a room with a clock on the wall.”
At two in the morning Brent put his highlighter down. He had been going through the C stack. It was the stack I had avoided, because I knew what was in it, the way a man knows what is in a closet.
“Dennis,” he said. “I need to ask you something, and I’m going to ask it as the person who types your filings.” He held up a sheet. “The question that comes up most in C, the one in about a third of them, is two sections with one number. A repeated section. We’d need a representative petitioner, and a clean one. The oldest such petition in the collection, by date.” He turned it around so that I could read the brass numeral stamped in the corner. “It’s yours. It’s eight thousand nine hundred fourteen.”
I did not say anything. Mrs. Okonkwo put the glasses back on.
“You cannot hear that one,” she said, finally, “until she is asked.”
“I know,” I said. “Ms. Pomeroy would like to be asked first.”

