Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 37

Meeting Seventy-Two

Linden Pointe Condominium Association is three stories of beige brick on the west side of Fenwick Township, forty-four units around a parking lot, and in the corner of the parking lot, labeled LOT C by a sign that had been up since 1988, there is a hole.

I had been told fourteen feet. It was nineteen. It had taken the last six parking spaces and the corner of a dumpster enclosure, and the asphalt around it had curled back at the edges like the lip of a very large cup. There was no fence. There was a single orange cone, set on the lip, with a sheet of printer paper taped to it. DO NOT. THANK YOU. M.O.

“It’s not quite a Nuisance,” said Mateo, at the edge, with his phone out of habit. The screen said No Service. “It doesn’t make a noise. It just sort of listens.”

It did. A hole of that size ought to have an echo. This one took the sound of our voices, down to the last syllable, and did not give it back.

Ms. Modupe Oyelaran met us at the door of Unit 12 in a gray cardigan with the sleeves pushed to the elbow and reading glasses on a cord. She was sixty-three, tall, narrow, with her gray hair in a flat twist and the stillness of a person who has spent a career being the one in the room who does not react. She had been a court reporter for thirty-one years. She shook my hand once, up and down, as if testing it for accuracy.

“Mr. Kowalczyk,” she said. “You are four minutes early. For the record, I am prepared.”

“I’m learning that’s a Declarant thing,” I said.

She looked past me at the Quarter Man, who had taken off his hat in the doorway, and at Ms. Gault, and at the dog. She did not blink at any of it. “Very well,” she said. “Meeting seventy-two. Please come in. Please do not step on the minutes.”

They were on the living room floor. I counted the binders later: seventy-one of them, black, three-ring, in four tidy rows along the wall, each with a typed label on the spine and a date. In front of the sofa, on a card table covered in a green cloth, was a gavel, a pitcher of water, a legal pad, and a single folding nameplate: M. OYELARAN, SECRETARY.

“I should explain,” she said. She sat. “In March of 2019 the last other director moved to Phoenix. Our bylaws require three of five directors for a quorum. I have been a director since 2014. I called a meeting the first Thursday of every month. I opened it and noted that a quorum was not present, and that no action could be taken. And I took the minutes.” She put her hand flat on the pad. “They are in order.”

“You did this alone,” I said.

“A quorum is a precondition of a decision. It is not a precondition of attendance.” She said this to the table, and for the first time her voice caught on the edge of something. “I had a view that if the meeting was not held it would not have happened. And if it was held and recorded, then at least it had been seen.”

I looked at the Quarter Man. He was standing very still, with his hat against the raincoat, with the face of a man who has been handed a mirror.

“She’s been in a field,” said Ms. Gault, in a very low voice, and I found I could not look at either of them.

I read the minutes. I want that known. I sat on the sofa for three hours and read a good part of seventy-one meetings, because Mrs. Okonkwo had told me, with her glasses on her forehead, that a Declarant who read the summary was merely a larger Dennis. They were extraordinary. Every meeting recorded the date, the time, the weather, the number present (one), and, at the bottom, under Other Business, a measurement. March 2019: the hole was a crack, two feet by a hand. By December, a depression, three feet across. By 2022, it had a name, Lot C Subsidence. Every month, in Ms. Oyelaran’s plain print, I could watch it grow.

I do not claim to be a geologist. I am a claims adjuster, and for thirty years I have gone to the house where the thing already happened and asked what caused it. It was in the minutes. It was in the October entries from 2018, before the last director left, in a line I almost missed. Roof drains: downspouts 4 and 7 discharge to Lot C, per contractor.

I took the legal pad. I walked outside in the dark with a flashlight, and the Quarter Man walked behind me with his hands behind his back, which I found oddly comforting. We looked at two downspouts that emptied into the corner of the lot, and a drainage easement on the plat that had never been dug, and a hole that was, when you thought about it, doing precisely what a stormwater basin was meant to do, with no permit, no fence and no sign.

“Excellent drainage,” I said.

“It is a very good hole,” said the Quarter Man. He sounded, I swear it, almost fond. “It has simply been given no job.”

We held the hearing at midnight, in the parking lot, with the Association’s one folding table. I called it under Section 6.2, Drainage, and Section 7.1, Maintenance of Common Elements, and the respondent was the hole. It was heard. I do not know how else to put this. I stated that the respondent was nonconforming, and the hole, which had been listening for six years, seemed to hold its breath. Ms. Oyelaran read the minutes into the record, the whole of the column of measurements, in her flat court voice. When she reached December 2022 I heard the edge of the asphalt settle half an inch, the way a person does who has been told that someone has been counting.

The Reserve was easy, and I am ashamed of how easy. Lloyd had driven out in the RV at eleven, sent by nobody, with the green notebook under his arm. He sat at the card table in his flannel and asked Ms. Oyelaran, with great delicacy, whether he might see the Association’s accounts.

She handed him one ledger. He opened it. His lips moved. After a while he looked up with an expression I had seen only once, when a column came out even.

“Sixty-one thousand four hundred twelve dollars and eighteen cents,” said Lloyd. “It’s all there. Every penny since 2014. You never spent a dime.”

“I could not,” said Ms. Oyelaran. “Expenditure requires a quorum.”

“I have never in my life,” said Lloyd, gravely, “met such an honest treasurer.”

“I am the Secretary.”

“You are,” said Lloyd, “the whole Board.”

The engineer’s estimate for a rated basin and a retaining wall was fifty-eight thousand. It was in the minutes, under a bid, from a firm in Grand Rapids, from 2020. She had been holding the bid for five years because she could not accept it.

So I used the second button in the menu. I had not used it yet. Appoint.

I want to describe the weight. The word was gray, and then it was white, and then, when I put my attention on it, my mouth filled with metal, a long flat taste of the whole sky leaning down on the point of a pen. A Declarant may fill a vacancy on the governing body of a Settlement that cannot reach a quorum. The appointee acts, under the Form, as the Declarant’s agent. The Declarant answers for the appointee.

I appointed the two people Ms. Oyelaran named, who were both at the meeting by then, in the parking lot, in coats over pajamas: Mr. Teague, a retired bus driver from Unit 31 who had been listening at his window for six years, and a young nurse named Priya Raman from Unit 4, who held a cup of tea and had not spoken. I asked each of them if they understood. Mateo asked the other question. Neither rang.

[Appointment: Linden Pointe Condominium Association, Board of Directors. T. Teague. P. Raman. Accepted. Charged to the Declarant, Section 15.9.]

[Exposure: 2.]

I felt it settle, the way a hat settles. It was not frightening. It was heavy and exact and it had my name on it.

At 1:20 a.m., in the cold, in the lot, with three directors and a quorum, a dog, a notary, a clerk, a treasurer and a man in a raincoat, Ms. Oyelaran called to order the seventy-second meeting of the Board of Directors of Linden Pointe Condominium Association. She noted that a quorum was present. She moved to approve the engineer’s bid. It carried, three to nothing. The hole made a sound like a long, slow breath going out.

“Is there any further business?” said Ms. Oyelaran.

There was not. She laid her hand flat on the gavel. I saw the Quarter Man lift his head.

“There being no further business,” she said, in the plain voice of a woman closing a door so as not to wake someone, “the meeting is adjourned.”

She struck once. It was a small, unremarkable sound on a card table in a parking lot.

The Quarter Man closed his eyes. His face did not do anything at all. After a while Councilman got up from the asphalt and went and leaned against his knees, and he put one hand down and left it on the dog’s head, and nobody said a word. Nobody needed to. He had been at that meeting for fifty years, and somebody had finally told him it was over.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!