By eight o’clock on Saturday morning there were six people in the press box and one sheet of paper, and nobody could tell me how the paper had gotten there.
Sheriff Wray held it by the corners with a pair of tweezers from Gus’s first-aid kit. He had laid a clean towel on the console and set the page on the towel like a man serving a very small, very guilty fish.
“Walk me through it again,” he said.
“I was at the microphone,” I said. “From 5:14 until about 6:00. My mother was beside me. My father was on the stool.” I pointed. “The door was shut. The paper was not on the floor at midnight, because you stood in that doorway at midnight and I watched you wipe your boots on that exact spot.”
“I did.”
“It was there at 6:05.”
“And I was on the fourth step from the bottom,” said Wray, “with Ms. Ouellette below me, and nobody passed either of us, and I am not a heavy sleeper when I am sitting on a staircase I have been afraid of for twenty-two years.”
“I was awake,” Tamsin said from the bottom of the doorway. “I count people. It’s a habit.”
“Then somebody was already up here,” said Gus.
We all looked at him. Gus was holding a push broom he did not need.
“The booth’s been swept three times since Friday,” he said. “Mrs. Pell’s kids did the floor at ten last night. There’s no one hiding in a booth that size.” He glanced at the ceiling. “Unless there’s a way I don’t know about. And I know every board in this park.”
“Thirty-one steps,” I said. “Orrin took one out in 2003, boarded a room behind the radiator, and called it a renovation. We found that room because the math didn’t add up. Math doesn’t lie, Gus. People who hold the pencil do.”
“Don’t get poetic,” said Wray kindly. “Look at the paper.”
I looked.
It was a standard letter sheet, not quite white, a little thick, with a faint ribbed watermark. It had been typed, not printed. The letters had the slight unevenness of a machine with a slipping carriage, and the lowercase e sat a hair too high in its line. Under the sentence, the pencil stroke ran from margin to margin, ruler-straight, a hard bright yellow that had dented the paper.
“Typewriter,” Wray said. “Manual, not electric. An old one. Which narrows the field of suspects to every attic in the county.”
“Turn it over,” I said.
He looked at me.
“There’s a form number in the corner of the back,” I said. “Hold it to the window.”
He lifted the sheet with the tweezers. Morning came through the paper, and there, ghosted into the fibers where the watermark crossed, were letters in a small gray capital type that I could have recited in my sleep.
STATE OF [REDACTED] — DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE — FIELD AUDIT DIVISION.
“That’s a pad of workpaper stock,” I said. “It’s ours. We use it for handwritten schedules. It has a ribbed watermark so nobody can photocopy a page and call it an original. There’s a number under it.”
“Can you read it?”
I could. I took a pencil from my pocket and, with the side of the lead, shaded very lightly across the corner the way I had done in a hundred audits, to raise a number from a page that had once been stamped.
TC-1148.
I stood there with the pencil in my hand.
“That’s the case number of the audit,” I said. “The one I opened on the day of Orrin’s funeral. The Herons’ file.”
“Your file.”
“My file.” I heard my own voice, flat and professional, like a woman reading out a total she did not believe. “I turned it in on Oct 13. It was boxed and sealed in the Capitol records room under my name. It was boxed with workpaper stock. Eleven blank sheets of this paper were in it.”
My father, on his stool, put down the crossword.
“Meaning,” said Wray.
“Meaning someone with access to a sealed audit file took one blank sheet out of it, typed a sentence on an old typewriter and brought it to a ballpark through a locked staircase in the night. That’s one idea. Here’s the other.” I made myself say it. “Someone has been in my box.”
Nobody said anything. In the corner, my mother’s silver pencil moved on a pad of ordinary paper. She was writing slowly, in a hand that wandered. I could not see what.
“There’s a simpler question,” said Tamsin. “How did a sheet of paper get under a closed door when a deputy sat on the stairs. You’re all doing the audit. Do the door.”
We did the door.
It took forty minutes. It was a plain pine door, painted gray, hung to open inward. The gap at the bottom was a quarter inch, enough for paper but not for a hand. Wray got down on his knees and looked at the threshold with a flashlight and said it had been scored, recently, by a thin blade, along the underside, so that the paper could be slid under from a rail on the other side. A rail. Something laid flat and passed through.
“From the outside,” I said. “But the outside is the stairs.”
“The outside is the stairs, and the landing, and the roof of the stairwell,” said Gus slowly. He had gone over to the window. He was looking at the long, shallow tin roof that ran from the press box down over the top section of the grandstand, fourteen feet of rusted metal with a gutter at the edge.
“Nobody’s out there,” said Roz, coming in with a plate of cold biscuits and no apology. “It’s thirty feet to the field.”
“It’s an eight-foot drop to the walkway of section two,” said Gus. “It’s fine if you’re twenty. It’s fine if you’re a certain kind of thing.”
I looked at the window. The latch was a brass hook, the original, bent at the end from years of being closed with a thumb. It was undone. I had not undone it. Nobody in the room had.
“Somebody was on the roof,” said Wray, “and came in through the window while we were all watching the field, and left the same way, and I didn’t see him because I was looking at a staircase.” He rubbed his face. “I have been a sheriff for twenty-three years. I have never been so thoroughly outmaneuvered by a piece of paper.”
“He’s not a man who wants to be caught,” said my mother.
We all turned. She had not looked up. She was writing, and she said it to the page, in her slow, ruined voice, each word set down like a coin.
“He wants to be counted.”
I went over to her. On the pad, beside her silver pencil, were four letters in a trembling capital hand. C. A. L. And then a long dash.
“Mom,” I said. “Who’s Cal?”
She looked up at me. For a second her eyes were clear and gray-green and entirely hers.
Then my phone buzzed on the console with the name I had saved on Oct 13 under Contacts, and I looked at it, and I answered it, because there was no one else in the world I would have answered it for in that moment.
“Cilla,” said Renata Lindqvist, from a long way off. Her voice was thin and careful. “I need you to listen. I’ve just had a call from the records room. The seal on TC-1148 was broken on Oct 20. Someone signed for it, using your badge number and your signature, at 4:12 in the afternoon.”
“I was at the Away at 4:12 on Oct 20,” I said.
“I know,” said Renata. “You were on camera in Tallow Creek buying a bag of salt. I checked. Cilla, that’s not the worst part. Whoever signed for it took the box. And they left another one in its place, on the shelf, sealed. It’s the same size. I haven’t opened it. I think you should be here when I do.”

