Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 9

Voluntary Disclosure

“That is a very good photograph,” I said. “Who took it?”

“A friend of the park.” Lyle Strommen tapped the glossy edge against his palm. He had a nice, easy voice, the kind that sells you a second house. “I don’t want to make this unpleasant, Ms. Aldersey. I’m a reasonable man. I have a modest offer on the Tuckerman land, and a modest interest in its being offered without a lot of noise. If an auditor’s report were to say the club is insolvent, the family would sell, and that would be a happy ending for everyone.”

“And if the report doesn’t say that?”

“Then I’d have to send this to your deputy director, with a note about fraternizing with the audited. And to the county paper, with a note about what the family keeps behind its fences.” He smiled sadly. “I’d hate for the boy in the picture to be known.”

I said nothing. I put my hand in my bag, found my phone, and touched the screen without looking.

“Mr. Strommen,” I said, “I have been recording this conversation since you said modest offer.”

His smile stayed in place. I will give him that. It only stopped being a smile.

“I’m a state employee. You’ve just offered to suppress a photograph in exchange for a specific finding in a state audit. In this state, that’s a felony. Also, I notice that the photo was taken from above, through the high window of the ticket office, which is on the second floor and locked. Someone gave you a key.”

“Ms. Aldersey.”

“For the record, I’ve been threatened by better men, and one of them was a priest.” I held out my hand. “I’ll take the photograph.”

He gave it to me. He gave it to me, I think, because he was too surprised not to. And then he did something I did not expect. He leaned in, very slightly, and lowered his voice.

“You’re a smart woman. Think about this. The family told you the story of the quarry, didn’t they? A small woman, a boy, something in the trees.” His eyes were very bright. “Ask Bea Tuckerman what she did afterward. Ask her where she goes on Tuesday nights, when the park is dark.”

He walked to a silver car, got in, and drove away at a polite speed. I stood in the lot for a full minute with my phone in one hand and the photograph in the other, and noticed that my hands were shaking only after I had counted the lines on the asphalt.

I spent the next ten days in the front office, mostly with Dale.

I will say this for Dale Tuckerman. When I put the photograph on his desk and said, “Somebody gave him a key,” he did not argue. He went the color of putty, opened a drawer, and handed me a phone. On it were fourteen texts from Strommen, spread over eight months, each one pleasant. He had been giving Dale small things. A dinner. A loan. An introduction. He had asked, in the sixth text, for a spare key to the ticket office, “for a surprise inspection.”

“I gave it to him,” said Dale. His voice was hoarse. “I didn’t know what he’d do. I only wanted it to be over.”

“It’s not over. But you’re going to tell me everything. Dates, dollar amounts.”

“And then?”

“And then I put it in a footnote,” I said, “and hand it to the state attorney general, and you never speak to Lyle Strommen again.”

He nodded. It was the first honest thing he had done in months, and he looked as if it had cost him a tooth.

That left the audit. The deadline was the thirtieth day, and the truth was a very awkward shape.

Here is what I had. The Herons had hidden a fund. The fund had been spent, honestly and wisely, on feeding and sheltering a hundred and twelve people whom no landlord, employer, or tax code would understand. They had broken the law by hiding it. If I reported exactly what I saw, in the plain words, the state would close the Away and seize the fund, and the pack would be dragged into a daylight it could not survive.

If I lied, I would be a liar. I do not lie in audits. It is the one vow I have never broken.

So I did the only third thing there is. I found a form.

There is a program, in every state, for a wildlife rehabilitation sanctuary: a nonprofit that cares for animals that cannot be released. It has its own tax status, its own inspections, and a great deal of plain-spoken paperwork. It requires only that the residents be, in the language of the statute, “native fauna whose medical condition requires seasonal containment.”

I stared at that sentence for a very long time. Then I wrote it down in my own handwriting.

I will not claim I did not squirm. I rewrote the draft four times. But every word I used was true. The residents were native. Their condition did require seasonal containment. I had a finding that said, in the clearest language I have ever put on paper, that the Herons had concealed a fund, that the fund supported a sanctuary, that the sanctuary was now to be registered and open to inspection on the usual terms, and that the club would pay back taxes and penalties of two hundred and twelve thousand dollars from the Rain Check balance, over two seasons.

It was the most honest document I have ever written, and the least informative.

Renata called me in on the twenty-sixth day. She had read it three times. She said, “Cilla, this is not what I expected.”

“No.”

“It’s a settlement. A closing agreement. It’s a good one. It’s possible you’ve just saved an entire town’s baseball team from bankruptcy.” A long pause. “I’m going to sign it. I’m also going to ask what’s in that barn.”

“Sheep,” I said.

“Sheep,” said Renata, after a silence. “Right. Very tricky, sheep.”

I walked out into the parking lot at five o’clock with the signed agreement in my bag and the sun low and golden and the whole ballpark smelling of cut grass. Ward was leaning against the gate with his cap in his hand.

“They told me,” he said. “Roz heard it on the phone line. Cilla, I don’t know how to.”

“Don’t thank me. It’s the law. I did it because it was right.”

“I wasn’t going to thank you.” He took a step. “I was going to ask you to a porch.”

The Tuckerman house is white clapboard, with a long front porch and a swing that has been repainted so often that the chains have a layer of enamel on them like a candy shell. We sat on it, the two of us, with a pitcher of lemonade between us, for a long time. We did not say much. At some point the swing stopped swinging. At some point I realized that his hand was over mine.

“Ward.”

“Say no,” he said, “and I’ll take you home.”

I did not say no. I will not say much about what happened next, because it belongs to two adults and a porch, and I am a person who puts details in the footnotes. I will say that his mouth was warm and tasted like lemon. I will say that the swing creaked. I will say that I counted nothing at all, which in my case is a kind of miracle.

In the morning, at the front office, there was a plain white envelope on my desk. It had one word on it in the block capitals of a woman who cracks peanuts with her thumb.

AUDITOR.

Inside was a single index card.

You solved the money. Now the other half of the bet. Be at the Away at four a.m. Sunday. Wear something warm. Bring your mother’s book. B.T.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!