DUNMERE PASS, Hall inventory, Wednesday, March 11. Item 9 of 9: One chair, oak, ladder-back, rush seat, no card. Condition: dusted weekly. Never sat in. Entered in the Dunmere Book each year since 1957 as “The Chair.” Clerk’s note, N. Haddad: I have dusted this chair for eleven years and never once asked who it was for.
Noor met me at the Dunmere hall at nine with a screwdriver, a flashlight, and her husband, who was holding a very large coffee and a look of cheerful dread.
“I am here as a witness,” he said. “I have no legal training and I’m told that’s an asset.”
“You’re here because you’re tall,” said Noor.
Dunmere was a smaller Pass than Pell, with a smaller hall: a low brick building at the edge of a wide white valley, with a stove, a long table, and a row of folding chairs. It smelled of floor wax and old coffee. At the head of the table, beside the Clerk’s seat, stood a single chair that did not match the others.
It was oak, dark and polished with handling, with a rush seat gone the color of tobacco. I had seen it in January and had thought: that’s the one Ines Pell set.
“1957,” said Noor. “The week the First went silent. She came here on a Friday, in a wagon, and put it down without a word and drove away. Nobody ever moved it. We set a place for it at Roll Day. We’ve always done that.” She laid her hand on the top rail. “It’s the most superstitious thing in my whole Pass, and I’m a Pass of accountants.”
“Has anyone checked the seat?”
“It’s a seat.”
“It’s rush,” I said. “You can see the underside. Some of those strands are dyed a different brown. Somebody re-wove it, and not very recently, and not very well.”
Noor’s husband made a small noise into his coffee.
---
The seat came out in four minutes. Noor did it herself, on her knees, with a screwdriver and the particular tenderness of a woman handling a sleeping person’s dog. Under the old rush, between the frame and a layer of folded burlap, there was a hatbox.
It was a round pasteboard box, cream, with a small brass clasp. On the lid in pencil someone had written, in large careful letters, DO NOT CARRY. NOT YET.
“Well,” said Noor in a small voice. “That’s my Wednesday.”
We lifted it out between us and set it on the long table. Her husband went to the kitchen, I think to pour out his coffee, and stayed there for a while.
“Do not carry,” said Noor. “Not yet. She meant it for whoever opened it. She knew somebody would, someday, and she wanted them to stop and think before they ran off with it.”
“Are you going to stop and think?”
“I’ve been stopping and thinking since Saturday. I’m very good at it now.” She wiped her hands on her trousers. “I have kept this Pass’s accounts for eleven years, Jo. I have audited every dollar. And all that time, sixty-eight years of it, there was a ledger under a chair I dusted every week.”
“You didn’t know.”
“That’s what an audit is for,” said Noor, “and it didn’t work.”
Inside lay a ledger, narrow, bound in blue cloth, with a leather corner. The first page said in copperplate: ROLL OF THE FIRST PASS, 1952-1957.
I turned the leaf, and my stomach turned with it.
---
It was a list of names. Fifty-one of them, in a column down the left margin, each in a different hand, as if every person had come up to the table and signed. Beside each name was a date of entry. Beside each name too, in a second ink, was the name of another Pass, and a date in October 1957.
HALLAM, RUTH, 18, entered Mar. 1952. Taken in by the Eighth, Oct. 1957.
PELL, AUGUSTIN, entered 1952. Taken in by Pell.
Fifty-one names. Fifty-one households. Every one of them carried by another Pass the month the First closed. No strike. No Not Present. Each name had been written down, and each name had been handed, one by one, to a table that would keep it.
“They weren’t struck,” I said. “They were moved.”
“Like the building,” said Noor.
“The First closed by transferring its Roll to the other eight.” I looked up. “That’s not a closure. That’s an evacuation.”
“Why?”
“I don’t know. Look at the last page.”
---
The last page was not a name. It was a paragraph, in a different hand: sharp, slanted, fast. I recognized it from a letter in the Pell vault. Ines Pell.
The First lends its roof to the Pell Pass, to be returned upon asking. The Roll is not to be kept in the roof, for a Roll and a roof together can be found. Dunmere shall keep the Roll, in a place where no one will sit. The key shall be kept in the Book, on the leaf that is cut. When the First asks, the Eight shall hear it and shall answer.
Nothing else.
I read it aloud, because I read everything aloud now. Noor stood very still.
“On the leaf that is cut,” she said. “That’s the one from the Book. The one Hollis found the stub of, in January.”
“The Book was bound with a leaf missing,” I said. “Before anyone started writing in it. It wasn’t lost. It was taken out on purpose, and the key to the First was on it.”
“Where’s the leaf?”
“I have no idea.” I held the page flat with my fingertips. “But the other part is in plain English. The roof was lent. Pell holds it as a bailee. And a bailee has to return it when the owner asks.”
“The First asked,” said Noor. “On Thursday. Find me a room.”
“It asked for a room. It didn’t say where. It said, find.” I looked at the paragraph again. “The barn is the First’s. The Kennels belong to the First, under a loan, and the Pass of Pell has had use of them for sixty-eight years. If the First asks for it back, Pell owes the roof.”
Noor sat down in the empty chair’s absence, on the floor, with her back against the table leg.
“Those are Mick’s wolves,” she said. “Those are Teo’s eleven. That’s the Third in three weeks.”
“That’s the Third in three weeks.”
“And you’re going to tell them.”
I stood there with the blue ledger open on my forearm and looked down the column of names to the one I had already read twice.
HALLAM, RUTH, 18.
“I’m going to tell Dot first,” I said. “And then I’m going to go and see a woman in a wheelchair who has been waiting for forty years for somebody to come and ask her a question.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!