Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 36

Six Failed Attempts

Dr. Anneliese Ketterer kept her laboratory in the back half of a hardware store in Dunmore, behind a door marked EMPLOYEES, and on Wednesday morning, five days to the Cutover, she let us in past a rack of rakes with the air of a woman admitting the plumber.

“Shoes,” she said. “There is dust that matters and dust that does not. I would like to keep them separate.”

There were mats. We wiped. Ruth Mallender, the DA’s clerk, in her wool coat, with a jar of almonds under one arm and a banker’s box in the other, wiped with great thoroughness. Agent Salvesen wiped as if auditing the mat. Odessa Hennig did it with a flourish. Docket had been left in the car, under protest.

The lab was a long cold room lit by bar fluorescents, with steel tables, a ventilator hood, and a wall of bare hard drives hung on pegboard, each tagged in a small upright hand with a case number and a date. Along the back wall, a pair of monitors showed columns of hexadecimal like the surface of a very quiet lake. A radio on a shelf was tuned to a station playing Bach, low.

Ketterer herself was sixty, narrow, in a gray cardigan with leather elbow patches and a pair of glasses she wore on her forehead and looked through only when she had to. She had been a state examiner for thirty years and had retired to a private practice, she told me, mostly because she disliked being interrupted.

“Ms. Haldorsen,” she said. “You are the person who counted.”

“I’m a witness.”

“You are a person who counted. In my experience it is rarer.” She pointed at a stool. “I asked the District Attorney’s office to include you this morning, over some objection from the County. I want you here because there is a thing on this report that I can read and you can recognize. Sit. Do not touch anything that has a cable.”

I sat. They arranged themselves around the long table. Ruth Mallender took out her almonds and put the jar down at the exact center of the steel and did not open it. Salvesen opened her grid notebook. Hennig sat with her hands in her lap, as she had at Hester’s, but without the recital posture, and I saw her look at the radio and then at the doctor with something like affection.

“The Court ordered a supplemental report on Friday, due that afternoon,” said Ketterer. “I asked for until Wednesday, because the Review Room machine, QA-REV2, which I imaged on Sunday afternoon, had a great deal more in it than the County’s last description led anyone to expect. The Court was kind. I have written forty-one pages. I will not read you forty-one pages.” She lowered the glasses from her forehead and put them on. “I will give you the six that matter.”

She took a remote from the table and pressed it, and a screen on the wall came on, a pale gray rectangle with a table.

“First. Removable devices. The Court ordered every device logged in six years. There were two hundred and thirty-eight, of which two hundred and thirty-one are ordinary: thumb drives that people plugged in to print a recipe, or a retirement slideshow, or a spreadsheet they were not supposed to take home.

I have listed them. I would like to talk about seven.” She pressed the remote. “Seven devices appear on more than one machine in the Center. Of those, six are accounted for. They belong to staff, or to the vendor’s installation team, and have been identified.

The seventh is a volume with a serial that ends in 6E1.”

“The one on the 9:42 export,” I said.

“The one on the 3/17 export at 9:42:11, and the trim at 9:44:37, yes. You have read my letter.” She looked pleased, in a bleak, scholarly way. “It is a physical flash volume, not a network share. It appears on exactly four machines. The server in the rack, on a Sunday night this month. The workstation in the training room, once, on another Sunday. A dispatcher’s position, once, at night. And QA-REV2, the Review Room machine.”

“How many times on QA-REV2?”

“Eleven,” said Ketterer.

The room was quiet. The Bach went on at the edge of hearing, a cello, going up a staircase one step at a time.

“Eleven. One occurs on 3/17, six years ago, the morning of the edit. It was mounted at 9:40 and removed at 9:51. The other ten are within the last ninety days.” She pressed. “They are these.”

A table of ten rows. Dates. Times. A column of durations.

“Each one,” said Ketterer, “is preceded, within about ninety seconds, by a login to the workstation as GHALDORSEN. And each one is followed, within about a minute, by a session of the account TCHADM2. You have seen these pairs before.”

“Forty-one sessions,” said Salvesen. “Ten from the Review Room.”

“Ten from the Review Room. The County has maintained, in its filings, that Ms. Haldorsen’s credentials were used, which implies her hand. The question I was asked, and the one I have spent a week on, is whether a hand was involved at all.” She turned to me. “Ms. Haldorsen. Are you a good typist?”

“I’m an average typist.”

“Do you make mistakes?”

“A lot.”

“Of what kind?”

I thought about it. “I always get my password wrong the first time. It’s a thing. Yusuf makes fun of me. I type it too fast and I swap two letters. I get it right on the second try, or the third.”

“How many attempts, as a rule?”

“Two. Sometimes more. When I’m angry, five or six.”

Dr. Ketterer took off her glasses. She did not smile. But there was a sort of quiet luminous satisfaction in her face, the look of a surgeon who has found the thing she was told to look for and is about to be kind about it.

“I have your authentication history for four years,” she said. “It is on the domain controller, which the Court allowed me to image on Monday. On sixty-one percent of the days you worked, you failed at least once before you succeeded. The median is two. The longest run is nine.” She pressed the remote. “The mean number of failed attempts before each of these ten logins is zero.”

Nobody said anything.

“It is not a person who types badly and has a bad morning,” said Ketterer. “It is a script. It runs from the stick. A small program on the volume, set to launch when the volume is mounted, that writes your cached credential to the login screen in under a second, and then signs in. I have recovered the launcher. It is eleven lines. It is not elegant. But it is exact.”

“And the credential?”

“Copied from the machine. It is your own password, in an old form, from the last time you changed it, and it was captured on a machine in which you had stored it. I think you had the habit, as most of us do, of letting the computer remember.” She said it gently. “I think someone remembered it for you.”

Hennig was writing, fast, with her small barbed hand. “Doctor. Can you say that plainly, for the purpose of a jury of twelve people who have never seen a login history in their lives?”

“Of course.” Ketterer looked at the wall. “Ms. Haldorsen makes mistakes when she types her own password, the way most people do. Whoever used her account did not make a single mistake in ten tries. Therefore, whoever used it was not typing it. It was a machine, carrying out a recording. And a machine can only do that if somebody walks into the Review Room and puts the stick in.”

“Ten times,” said Salvesen.

“Ten times in ninety days. Late at night, mostly. Between twenty-three hundred and three.” She turned the screen. “The door has no reader, only a key. I would observe that it is a plain key.”

“Marcy, Roy, the facilities master,” I said. “And two or three others I don’t know about. I’ve had that list in my head for a week.”

“I have the camera,” said Ketterer.

She said it with the faintest hint of showmanship, and pressed the remote, and a screen of a different kind came up. It was a still from the hallway camera, grayscale, shot from above, at an angle that flattened everything, a hallway I had walked ten thousand times with a coffee. Break room on the left. Server room on the right. The door of the Review Room in the middle, with the dented kickplate.

A figure stood in front of it. It was a person in loose gray coveralls and a baseball cap, with a janitor’s cart beside them and a key in the lock. Their head was lowered. The cap hid everything.

“The hallway camera retains thirty days,” said Ketterer. “Of the ten sessions, four are within the window. In each, a figure with a cart appears at the door in the three minutes before the stick mounts. Here. Here. Here. Here.”

She advanced the stills. They were nearly identical. Head down. Cart. Key. Three minutes. Gone.

“The Center is cleaned at night by a contract crew,” she said. “Three people, from an outfit in the next county, working a schedule I obtained on Monday. Their roster has three names. This figure is a fourth.

I have asked all three of the employees, through the contractor’s manager, who is a very polite man named Mr. Baptiste, and none of them remembers anyone else on the crew. None of them has ever been in the Review Room.

The manager says the room is not on their route. It never was.”

“So somebody dresses as the cleaning crew,” said Mallender.

“Somebody has coveralls and a cart and a key,” said Ketterer. “That is not the same as dressing up. The cart is the contractor’s. It has a number on the side. I have identified the number.

Cart six. It is kept in the janitor’s closet at the end of the hall, on the other side of the break room, and it is unlocked.” She advanced the still, and I saw, very slightly, in the corner of the frame, a pale thing hanging on the cart’s rail.

“That is a lanyard.”

“Can you read it?”

“I cannot. It is turned in.”

I felt every hair on my arms stand up. I did not say anything. Hennig, at my elbow, set her pen down and put her hand flat on the table, the way you do on the rail of a boat.

“I can only say that the figure is not tall and not heavy,” said Ketterer. “That the hand on the key is the left hand. That is, I think, as much as the camera can be asked to say. It is not an identification. It is a posture.”

“A left hand,” said Salvesen.

“On four of four.”

Neither she nor Mallender looked at me. I was grateful.

“I have more,” said Ketterer. She did not sound like a woman who would be sorry for it. “The next two items are the dongle and the door. Please bear with me. They are the dull part.”

They were not dull. She told us, in her flat unhurried voice, that the USB license key found in the rack’s back panel had been logged by the recorder as inserted at 23:48 on the Friday of the purge, forty-three minutes before the RETAIN-ADJ job began, and that before that it had last appeared on the evening of the trim, six years ago, at 9:44. In between, she said, the recorder had never once seen it.

“It was out of the machine for six years,” said Mallender.

“It was out, or it was in a binder with a name on it. You will recall the binder.” She flicked to the next table. “The Center’s server room has a badge reader. At 23:46 that Friday, two minutes before the dongle, the reader logged a card, a facilities master, number two, for forty seconds. The room’s door sensor says it was held open for three minutes and eleven seconds.”

“FAC-MASTER-02,” said Salvesen. She had it in her notebook already. “I believe it belongs to a Mr. Orrin Ravenscroft.”

“It was issued to him, yes. He reported it lost.” Ketterer turned another page. “Eleven weeks ago. He telephoned the help desk. A ticket was opened to deactivate it. I have the ticket.”

She brought up a screen. A form, plain gray, in a software I did not recognize. A request. A reason. A status.

*Status: Closed. Resolution: ACCOUNT RETAINED PER DIRECTOR. Closed by: TCHADM2.*

I made a small sound. I could not help it. I had read that phrase before, on a ticket closing my own suspension, and I had thought, *this is a person who is very sure of a sentence.*

“That is the same resolution text,” said Mallender, slowly.

“Word for word.” Ketterer put the glasses back on her forehead. “I will not interpret. I will tell you only that the card has not been deactivated for eleven weeks, that Mr. Ravenscroft’s report that it was lost went unactioned because a person with administrative rights typed a sentence the Director never authorized, and that it opened the server room at 23:46 on a night when the Director was at home in bed.

We know, because Mr. Kellaway’s home telephone shows a call to a pizza shop at 23:20.”

“And it opened it,” said Salvesen, “again.”

“Sunday night.” Ketterer pressed the remote. “Yesterday, in the very early morning, I imaged the legacy server at six, by the Court’s order, with the County’s counsel present. I found a log. The stick, 6E1, mounted on the server, SRV-1, at 23:52 on Sunday night, for four minutes. The card, FAC-MASTER-02, was read at 23:49.”

“Sunday,” I said. “That was the day we went to Hester’s.”

“The stick is not finished,” said Ketterer. “That is my main finding, and I put it last on purpose. Whatever is on that stick is still being used. It was inserted five days before the Cutover, four minutes, on the server that holds the recorder’s catalog, with the badge of a man who reported it lost. I did not see what it did. The image, by definition, is what remained after.”

“What does the label say?” I asked.

“Excuse me?”

“The volume label. Every stick has one. Mine says SOURDOUGH.” My throat was dry. “It’s a thing people do. Name the drive.”

“Ah.” For the first time that morning, the doctor looked at me directly and did not look away. “I had hoped you would ask. I did not want to lead.” She advanced the screen one last time, and the table gave way to a single line.

*Volume label: BOOKS.*

The Bach had stopped. A new piece began, a slow one, a sarabande.

“It was in the registry on the 3/17 mount, and it is the same today. A volume called BOOKS. And in the machine’s cache of folders it has visited, I can see one directory name, from the morning of the edit. It is not much.” She read it off. “*Q1 FINAL.*”

I thought of a woman in a basement office with a bad compressor, who did the books at night, who left a message that said, *I’ll bring a folder Friday.* I thought of the Sheriff in a gray suit with a pink slip in a sleeve. *Tell him I have the books.* I thought of a left hand on a key.

“It’s hers,” I said. “It’s Dinah’s. It’s the books.”

“I make no statement as to that.” Ketterer put the remote down very carefully on the steel. “I will say that a volume called BOOKS has been in the possession of the same person for six years, who has plugged it into the same machines, to do two kinds of work.

To make your name look like a thief’s, and to make Dinah’s call look like less than it was. I think those are two sides of one purpose, which is to keep a particular set of numbers where it is.”

Ruth Mallender had not touched her almonds. She sat with her gloved hands folded on the table and said, in a low, even voice that I had not heard from her before, “I would like a copy of the camera still of the lanyard. Not the enhanced one. The original.”

“It is in the box.”

“And I would like Mr. Ravenscroft in my office by noon.”

“I have telephoned him,” said Salvesen. “He is in the hall.” She closed her notebook, and the sound it made was like a door shutting in a long, quiet house. “Doctor, I need to ask you one thing, and then I need to ask the group a thing, and I will be quick.”

“Please.”

“The badge. FAC-MASTER-02. It is still active.”

“As of seven this morning.”

“And a man who reported it lost eleven weeks ago has not had it turned off.” Her voice was quite level. “Mr. Kellaway told me last evening that the deactivation ticket was closed by someone who was not him, and he has no idea who.

Cade, the systems administrator, has told me by telephone, with his lawyer present, that the account called TCHADM2 does not exist in his console. It was removed on a Saturday. Yet it closed a ticket eleven weeks ago, and it closed another one this Tuesday at 11:12, a work order to change the lock on the Review Room door.”

“That was yesterday,” I said. “They boxed my desk.”

“They did.” She looked around the table. “So the account is live. Somewhere. And the card is live. Somewhere. And the stick is live, and in five days the Cutover is going to put a very large number of people in that building at six in the morning.”

“You can have it turned off,” said Hennig.

“I can.” Salvesen set down her pen. “But if I turn off the card, I will have turned off the only thing in the county that is telling me who is walking through that door.”

There was a silence in the cold room, and the cello in it went down a stair.

“We leave it on,” said Dana Salvesen. “A badge you can see is better than a badge you cannot.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!