The Chancellor-Registrar of the Nine was waiting for them at the bottom of the Annex stair with a lantern, and he had not slept either.
Dessa knew it from his collar. Cormac Sill had been correct for as long as she had known him: white hair brushed flat, gray coat, a small gray bow of a mouth that looked as if it had been drawn with a ruler. Now the top stud of his collar was missing and there was a smear of ink on his cuff, and the lantern in his hand shook very slightly, so that the light ran up and down the wall like a pulse.
"Miss Rook," he said. "Mr. Ardrey. Thank you for coming before the sun."
"You said please," said Dessa.
"I did. I should like it noted that I have not written the word in some years." He turned. "It is a long way down. I would take your hand, Miss Rook, if I thought you would give it. I find that I would not."
"No," she said. "Probably not."
She had slept for three hours on a bench in Ember's kitchen, with Teodora's shawl over her feet, and had woken to the sound of rain on the roof, steady and warm. That had been the first good thing. The second was Odo coming in at five, soaked, with his muffler steaming, to report that the Frost had stopped at the edge of Rope Walk in the night and gone around the lit streets the way water goes around a stone. It had not retreated. It had simply not come in. The Lower Flues lay in a long, dark, wet crescent of living chimneys, and on every side of them, quiet as a held breath, the blue-green shimmer waited.
A hundred hearths, she had thought. Three hundred. Eight hundred more.
She followed Sill down.
The Valve Gallery was as she remembered, a long stone room with nine iron wheels the size of cartwheels in a row along one wall, each with a brass plate: KETTLE, WELL, LATCH, LOOM, BELLOWS, WEIR, CRADLE, EMBER, LANTERN. She had last seen it with the gold wheel half shut and a man in a green waistcoat with his hand on it. Now the gold wheel hung loose on its axle, as though somebody had given up. Sill did not look at it.
"There is a further stair," he said. "It is not in the Registry's plans. I had it cut myself."
It went down behind the Lantern wheel, through a narrow door that she had taken for a cupboard. It was steep and spiral, and the walls were smooth and black, and with every turn the air grew thinner and colder and more still. Lucan came behind her. She could hear his breath. About the thirtieth step, without a word, he reached forward and took her hand. His was cold. It was a clean, plain, ordinary cold. She was so grateful for it that she walked half the next flight with her eyes shut.
The Stone stood in a round room at the bottom, in the dark.
She had seen it once, from a distance, in a vision, and once through the wall. It was not what she had expected. It was lower than she had thought, no taller than a table, a great plain slab of black hearthstone with a pale flat top, set into the floor in the middle of a ring of worn steps, like the hearth in a farmhouse kitchen that nobody has lit since a death. Iron bands ran across it. They had been forged in a single piece, thick as a man's wrist, and across the center of them was a long jagged white line like a flaw in a plate. The crack ran from one edge to the other. It had widened since she saw it.
"A hand's breadth in a night," said Sill. "It did that when the gold valve would not turn. It will do it slowly now. At the twenty-eighth night, I estimate, it will give."
"Estimate?"
"I have no instruments for a thing like this. I have a measuring tape, and a man who counts." He set the lantern down on the lowest step. His long hands were not quite steady. "I did not ask you down here to tell you about the lock, Miss Rook. I asked you because I have lied to you by omission for a very long while, and it has come to me in the last day that I have very few days left to stop."
She did not answer. Lucan's hand tightened on hers.
"The Nine swore, in the Snuffing, that no pipe should go into the Stone," said Sill. "You have seen it. You saw it through the lamp. You have spent a night, I have no doubt, turning the Flue over in your mind like a coin, looking for the other side."
"Yes."
"There is one." He folded his hands. "I did not swear."
It was so quiet in the round room that she could hear the lantern flame.
"I was thirty-three. I was the Chancellor's clerk. I stood behind the Hosts with the Book of Compacts, and the Hosts took the oath, and they did not think to ask me. A clerk is furniture. I have always been grateful for it." His voice stayed perfectly level. "Four years later, when Aldric Ardrey was dead and the Hosts had settled into their new warmth and I had been made Chancellor in my turn, I began to build a pipe. It was a small one. It did not go into the Stone. It went into the wall of the Vault beside it, through the skirts of the hearth, to where the warmth leaks out into the Flue. I reasoned that it was a tap on a drain. I thought that I was not breaking the oath. I thought that I was merely not wasting what the Stone was throwing away."
"You were using a technicality," said Dessa.
"Yes. I was extremely proud of it." A flicker of something that was nearly humor crossed the long gray face. "You will understand me, I think, as no one else could. I read the oath, and I read the word into, and I thought, this is the sort of word that a man writes who does not expect to be read."
"Tobiah said something to you."
"In the pantry. On the last night. I have told you." He looked at the Stone. "He said that it would be a thing that it lets. I understood him to mean that the Stone would let the warmth through. I took it as leave. For twenty years I have taken it as leave. I have only lately begun to wonder whether he meant something else by lets."
"What?"
"That it permits." He swallowed. "That the Stone permits. That it chooses. That the warmth did not leak, but was given, and that I stood at the end of a pipe like a thief at a window, drinking a thing that a dying man had left on the sill for his friends."
Dessa found that she was gripping Lucan's hand quite hard.
She was angry. She had expected to be. What she had not expected was how tired it was, a plain flat tired anger without a single bright edge. She thought about eleven thousand people on Kettle Row and a hundred and forty days of a widow's life, and a pipe the width of a man's arm, cut by a clerk who had been proud of a word.
"The Hosts didn't know," she said.
"They did not. I told them it was the Registry's. I said that it was a boiler." He bowed his head. "It is why I hold, Miss Rook. It is the reason I have held for twenty-five years. If I let it go, the oath is not broken by the Nine, because the Nine never knew of the pipe. It is broken by me. I have been trying very hard to find a way for it to be broken by someone else."
"And now?"
"And now I am tired." He said it quite simply, in his dry gray voice, and it was the most frightening thing she had ever heard him say. "I have counted. I have counted the days. I do not know how to hold a valve against a thing that wants to go out. I shut the gold wheel to save a woman I have been failing for a quarter of a century, and the Stone cracked, and the Frost came down the hill in the morning. I should like very much to be told that I was wrong."
"You were wrong," said Lucan.
His voice was flat and cold and exact. "You were wrong at every turn. You were wrong to build the pipe, and you were wrong to hide it, and you were wrong to shut the wheel. I am obliged to say so, Chancellor, because my father was wrong in the same way, with fewer excuses, and I have lived my whole life in the shadow of it. I would be much easier in my mind if you could manage to be the villain."
"I am sorry to disappoint you, Mr. Ardrey."
"I am more sorry than you are."
It was an extraordinary exchange. Dessa stood between them in the cold, one hand in a man's cold fingers, and watched two honest, stiff, miserable people look at each other in the lantern light and not look away. Then Sill turned to the Stone. He raised his hand toward the top of it, and she saw for the first time that above the crack, cut into the slab's pale upper edge, there was a hollow. It was a small, smooth, upright hollow, no larger than a loaf of bread, with a round top and straight sides. It was the shape of a door.
"There," said Sill. "That is the second lock. Aldric's letter says it needs a Keeper's spoon, laid by a hand that has not been asked. I have never been able to make it fit. I have tried every spoon in the Registry."
She did not take out the spoons. She did not need to. She had both of them, in the lining of her coat, one in each pocket, and she felt them warm against her ribs as a hand is warm in a glove. A small clear thread of sound went up from the Stone. It was a single note, and then the voice came.
Little spoon.
It was the patched voice, the voice with the stitches showing. It said it softly, like somebody turning a page.
Hold.
Sill had gone white to the lips. She had never seen a man go so completely out of color. He stood with one hand still raised, and a vein in his temple ticked, and his mouth worked.
"That is the word," he said. "That is what it says to me, in the Annex, at night. I have heard it for twenty years. Hold. I thought that it was an order." His voice cracked. "I have never, in all that time, heard it say anything else."
Cormac, said the Stone.
Sill made a sound she would remember for the rest of her life. It was not a gasp and it was not a sob. It was the small, shocked, wounded noise of a man who has just been called by his name by someone he buried, and the iron key at Dessa's throat, the one that said HOLD, went suddenly and entirely warm.

