The Vickstrom piano was already in tune, which was the first thing wrong with it.
Astrid Fogelberg found that out by accident, with her coat still on and her tool roll still under one arm. She had come into the sunroom the way she always did on a Vickstrom day, through the side door that Stellan left unlatched for her, and she had set her case down by the bench and lifted the lid of the old upright and played an octave, just to say hello.
C, then C. The two notes sat together without a flicker between them, like two people who had agreed on the story before anyone asked.
That was not right. She had not been here in six months, and nobody tuned a piano for a living because pianos behaved themselves for six months.
She played the fifth above. Then the third. Then she walked up the middle of the keyboard one note at a time, listening for the small wobble that tells a tuner a string has wandered, and found none. The middle of the Vestergaard upright was clean as a swept porch.
“Well,” she said to the room. “Somebody’s been showing off.”
The room did not argue. It was a good room for a piano, a glassed-in porch on the lake side of the house with a floor of wide pine boards and a rag rug that had been there longer than Astrid had been alive.
Beyond the windows the lake lay flat and pewter-colored under a low sky, and a single bare birch leaned over the dock like a person trying to hear something. The house smelled of coffee and wood polish and, faintly, of the sweet sour smell of rhubarb that never fully left Stellan Vickstrom’s kitchen.
She stood there with her hand on the key cover and let the quiet settle.
It was a habit she could not break. She had been born with a defect or a gift, depending on who you asked, which was that every sound she heard arrived with its name attached. The refrigerator in the kitchen was a low G, a little flat.
The clock on the mantel ticked at a steady pace and sounded, to her, like a very small person tapping on a very small drum. A kettle somewhere in the house had cooled and settled with a faint creak. A B flat, she thought, before she could stop herself.
“That is a B flat,” she said out loud, and then felt silly, because the kettle was not listening.
Her mentor used to say that Astrid heard the world like a bill she had to pay. Persis Kettleson said a lot of things like that. For forty-five years Persis had tuned every piano in Whitefir County, and she had a saying for most occasions and a look for the rest.
Astrid pushed the thought away, because Persis was in a bed at the Linden Court Care Center in Corliss, forty minutes south, and had been there for three weeks, and thinking about it right now would make her useless for the next four hours.
She took off her coat. She hung it on the end of the bench. She opened the tool roll on the lid of the piano, where the felt strips and the lever and the mutes and the little brass fork lay in their pockets, and she looked at the instrument and did the thing she had been taught to do before touching any piano that was not hers.
She asked it a question. What did you do while I was gone?
She worked up from the middle again, past the part of the keyboard where she had already listened, and into the treble, and found the treble sweet and in agreement with the middle. Then she went the other way, below middle C, down toward the part of the piano that sounds like furniture being moved in another room.
The tenor notes were clean. The notes below them were clean too, each string agreeing with its twin, and for a few seconds Astrid let herself think that somebody had simply hired a better tuner in her absence, or that Stellan had decided to go to the new man in Pelham Landing after all and had forgotten to cancel her.
Then she hit the F below the bass break, and the whole bottom of the piano went wrong.
It was not out of tune. It was in tune, and it was in tune to somebody else’s pitch.
She did it again, slowly, with her eyes closed. Down an octave from the F she heard it, a thin, bright edge that did not belong to the note beside it. She went up one key and the edge disappeared. She went down one key and it came back. She played the F and then the F sharp, and the F sharp slid into the middle of the piano like a person walking into a room and finding out it was the wrong party.
A seam. Right across the keyboard, a seam, the way a carpenter might find where one board met another in a floor that had been repaired too quickly.
The bass strings were tuned eight cents higher than everything else in the piano. Eight cents is not much. A person at a dinner table would never hear it. A person at a piano who had spent her whole life learning to listen for nothing else would hear it the way you hear someone clearing their throat in a church.
Astrid knew exactly what eight cents meant, because she had spent a childhood being taught it. It was the difference between 440 and 438.
Every piano in Whitefir County was tuned to 438. That was Persis’s doing.
Forty years earlier she had decided that the old reed organs in the country churches, the ones that wheezed and sat a little low, deserved not to be sung over, and she had set the county a hair flat out of plain stubbornness and never changed her mind. Newer tuners used an app, and the app said 440, and everybody agreed the app was right, which was how you could tell they had never played a hymn with a reed organ in January.
Only two people in the county still tuned a piano to 438 on purpose. One was lying in a bed in Corliss. The other one was standing in this sunroom with a lever in her hand.
Which meant that the middle of this piano had been tuned by Persis’s hands, or something shaped like them, and the bottom of it had been tuned by somebody who used a screen.
“That’s not possible,” Astrid said.
She said it to the piano, because there was nobody else in the room, and because there was a part of her that had already started to understand how many things about the morning were not possible.
She put her ear down close to the open lid. She played the F again. Then, because she could not stop herself, she played middle C and held it, and listened for the thing she always listened for first, the quarter beat of sharp that Persis had left in middle C of every piano she had ever touched. It was a signature. It meant I was here. It meant nobody else had touched this.
The sharp was there. A quarter beat. Barely there. Exactly the width of a hair.
So Persis had tuned the middle of this piano in the spring, and nobody had touched it since. And the bottom had been tuned by somebody who did not know Persis. Or who knew her too well.
Astrid straightened up.
“Mr. Vickstrom?”
It came out smaller than she meant. She cleared her throat and tried again, louder, pitching it at the open door that led into the house.
“Stellan? It’s Astrid. I let myself in. Door was open, like you said.”
The house answered with its usual small noises. The refrigerator hummed its flat G. The clock on the mantel tapped. Somewhere a pipe ticked as it cooled.
Stellan Vickstrom was seventy-seven years old and had been a county road surveyor for forty of them, and in all the years Astrid had been coming to this house he had never once not been in it on a tuning day. He sat in the kitchen with the radio on and a plate of something on the table, and every twenty minutes he would call through the wall, “How’s she coming?” as if the piano were a baby in the oven.
He wasn’t calling now.
“Mr. Vickstrom?”
She went through the door.
The kitchen was a long room with yellow curtains and a window over the sink. A pastry box stood on the counter, tied with blue string, the lid still shut, the bow still crisp. The string was the first thing her eye landed on, because there were only six colors of string in Tern Lake and everybody in town could read them like a calendar.
Monday was blue. Berit Tollefson at the bakery tied every Monday box in blue, and Tuesday in green, and Wednesday in red, because she had decided long ago that a person should be able to look at a box and know how stale it was without asking. Stellan had bought a rhubarb kringle every Monday since his wife died. This was the Monday box, unopened.
Which meant he had not eaten his kringle.
That was the second thing wrong with the morning, and it landed a little heavier than the first.
There was a plate on the table with a fork on it and nothing else. There was a mug beside it, with a film on the coffee. The radio was off. The back door was closed. On the far side of the room, next to the pantry, the narrow door that led down to the cellar stood open, and the light in the stairwell was on.
Astrid stood very still.
She told herself a number of reasonable things. He had gone down to check the furnace. He had gone down for a jar of something. He was down there right now, sorting through the pickled beets, and had not heard her over the sound of his own radio, which was off.
“Mr. Vickstrom,” she said, “are you down there?”
She went to the open door and looked.
The stairs were steep, the kind you find in houses built by people who did not expect to get old. Thirteen wooden treads, a runner of faded carpet held down with brass tacks, a plain handrail on the right. Halfway down, one slipper lay on its side on the seventh step, the sole turned toward her, as if it had been set there to be found.
At the bottom, on the concrete floor, in the pale light of a single bulb, lay Stellan Vickstrom.
She did not scream. She would think about that later, a little ashamed, as if screaming had been the correct thing and she had missed her cue. What she did instead was stand at the top of the stairs with one hand flat on the doorframe and hear every sound in the house at once. The refrigerator. The clock. Her own breath, which was an A, a little sharp.
“Stellan?”
He lay on his side with one arm bent under him and his face turned away. His glasses had come off and lay a foot from his hand, folded, as though he had set them down to rest his eyes. His cardigan was buttoned wrong, by one hole, the way it always was.
There was no sign that he was going to move.
She knew that. She went down anyway. She went down the first four steps with a hand on the rail, calling his name, and when she got to the slipper she stopped, because the carpet runner on the seventh tread was loose at the corner, a brass tack standing up out of the wood, and she understood that she was looking at the thing that was going to be written in a report.
She could see his face from there. She could see that it was not going to be all right.
She went back up the stairs, backward, one step at a time, and she did not touch the rail again.
In the kitchen she found her phone and her fingers were clumsy on the screen. She pressed the numbers and listened to it ring, and when the dispatcher answered, Astrid knew her by the voice before the woman said her name. Marlene Pruett, who had a laugh like a screen door, who had once dispatched an ambulance to Astrid’s father’s funeral by mistake and apologized to everyone individually.
“County dispatch.”
“Marlene, it’s Astrid Fogelberg. I’m at Stellan Vickstrom’s on Lighthouse Lane.” She heard how steady she sounded and did not trust it. “He’s at the bottom of his cellar stairs. I think he’s dead.”
There was a short, bright silence on the line. A hundred small sounds on Marlene’s end, a keyboard, a chair, a cough.
“Are you with him, hon?”
“I went down four steps. I didn’t touch him.”
“Okay. You did right. Go outside and wait on the porch. Don’t touch anything else. I’ve got Eero Radcliffe about ten minutes out, and the ambulance is coming behind him. Stay on the line with me.”
“I’m okay,” Astrid said. It was not true, and Marlene did not say so.
She went to the front porch because she had been told to. She stood in the cold with the phone pressed to her ear and Marlene’s voice in it saying small useful things, you’re doing fine, they’re on their way, tell me what you can see. The lake lay beyond the lawn. A pair of mergansers sat out on the water like two punctuation marks, and she told Marlene about them because it was something to say.
Under it all, though, her mind kept going back to the sunroom.
It was an ugly thing to be thinking about, and she knew it. A man was dead at the bottom of his stairs. She had known him her whole life.
He had given her a quarter every Halloween when she was small and a lecture about the proper way to coil a measuring chain when she was twelve. He had stood behind her at the back of the church on the day of her father’s funeral and said nothing at all, which was the right thing, and the only right thing anybody had said.
But a part of her could not stop hearing the bass.
Persis did not leave a mess. Persis would never have left a piano with a seam in it, not for a day, not for an hour. Persis had also not left her bed in three weeks. The middle of that piano was hers, from the spring, signature quarter beat and all. The bottom was somebody else’s, from last night, and it was the bottom that had been done by the app.
She turned the sentence over until it had edges.
You could copy a signature. You could not copy the place it came from.
The signature was real. The seam was not. So the seam had been made after Persis, by someone who did not care about the pitch of the county, or did not know about it, and who had done the job in a hurry. Why? Why would anyone retune the bottom of a piano in the middle of the night?
She knew why, of course. There was only one reason a tuner ever slackened bass strings.
You slackened them to get at something underneath.
“Astrid? Are you still there?”
“I’m here.”
“Tell me about those ducks again.”
She told her. She heard a car coming along Lighthouse Lane before she saw it, the rising whine of a county cruiser, an E flat that went down to D as it slowed. She told Marlene she could see them now. She said thank you. She hung up and stood alone on the porch with her hands in her armpits.
The cruiser pulled up behind her van and stopped. The door opened, and a tall man in a tan uniform got out slowly, like a man who had learned that hurrying did not make a thing less true, and looked at her across the roof of the car.
“Astrid,” said Deputy Eero Radcliffe.
“He’s in the cellar.”
“Okay,” he said, and took out a small pad from his shirt pocket, and a pen, and looked at the pad as if it might tell him what to do next. “Okay. You stay right there.”
He went into the house. Astrid stayed. She stood on the porch and listened to his steps cross the kitchen, and stop, and go down, and go quiet.
She should have kept still. She knew that. But after a while the quiet pulled at her the way a loose string pulls at a tuner, and she went in after him as far as the sunroom, and stood by the piano, and did not touch it.
She crouched instead and put her phone’s light across the lower strings through the open lid.
The bass wires were copper-wound, dark, a little furred with the dust of decades. She looked for the places where the dust ought to be. And in three of them, near the bridge, it was not.
The copper was bright there in thin, clean bands, the exact width of a thumb and a forefinger, where somebody had pinched the strings to hold them slack. The tuning pins above them, the ones she would have turned by feel, showed fresh bright rims where a lever had lived on them in the last day.
Someone had been inside this piano last night. And someone had put it back together so neatly that if she had been a worse tuner, or a gentler one, or one with a better opinion of the world, she would have gone home believing it had been a quiet morning.
It was the neatness that frightened her.
Behind her in the kitchen she heard Eero come up the cellar stairs, one step at a time, and say quietly to nobody, “Oh, Stellan.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!