Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 4

The Long Way In

The Corliss sheriff’s office smelled of burnt coffee and carpet shampoo, and its front desk had a plastic fern on it that had been dusted so often it shone.

Astrid signed her statement at ten past eight on Wednesday morning, at a gray metal desk in a room with one window, while Eero Radcliffe sat across from her eating a sandwich out of wax paper. It was a ham and cheese on white bread, and she knew without asking that it was the same sandwich he ate every day, because Berit sold him one on his way through town and had once been heard to say that she could make it in her sleep and sometimes did.

“Read it over,” he said. “Tell me if it’s wrong.”

She read it. It was three pages in his square handwriting, typed up by someone with a gentler hand than his. It said what she had said. It did not say what she had left out.

“It’s right,” she said, and signed it, and put down the pen.

Eero finished his bite. He folded the paper into a neat triangle, then folded it again.

“Doc Haugen called at seven,” he said.

“And?”

“Death was between eight and eleven Monday night. Broken neck, and some other things that go with a fall like that. Consistent with the stairs.” He put the triangle down on the desk. “And one bruise on the upper left arm.”

She did not say anything. She had learned long ago that if you let a silence run, other people filled it.

“It’s about the size of a thumb,” Eero said. “Doc says it could be from the fall. It could be from the rail, or the edge of a step. He says if he had to bet, he’d bet it was a hand.”

“A hand.”

“Somebody holding his arm.” He did not look at her. “I’m not saying that’s what happened. I’m saying he said it. And the sheriff says it’s an accident until there’s something more than a bruise. And he’s right to. And I’ve been thinking about how you stood on that porch yesterday and didn’t tell me something.”

Astrid felt the heat climb her neck. “I told you everything I knew.”

“You told me everything you were sure of.” He said it mildly. “That’s different.”

She looked at him. He had the face of a man who was not going to be unkind about it, which made it harder.

“I’m a very bad liar,” she said.

“You’re an excellent withholder.”

It was exactly what she had thought on the porch, and she almost laughed.

“There’s something wrong with the piano,” she said. “I didn’t want to say it until I could prove it, and I didn’t want to sound like I was trying to be interesting.”

“Okay.”

“It’s a long story.”

“I’ve got until nine.”

She told him. She told him about the seam in the bass, and 438 and 440, and the little quarter beat of sharp in middle C that Persis left like a thumbprint.

She told him about the napkin, and took it out of her shirt pocket and set it on the desk between them, and watched him read it twice without moving his lips. She did not tell him about the route book. She said only that Persis had always kept “a little something” in clients’ pianos, small, private things that people asked her to hold, and that she had a feeling Stellan’s was one of them.

When she was done he sat for a moment, thinking.

“Long way in,” he said. “Mind the left.”

“He’s left-handed.”

“I know. He’d tell you at the Fourth of July if you stood still.” He tapped the napkin. “You think he hid something in the piano and someone else knew.”

“I think someone got into the piano on Monday night, and I think someone else retuned the bottom of it to cover that they’d been in there. I don’t know what they took.”

“And you think they killed him for it.”

“I don’t think anything yet.”

“That’s a good place to start.” He stood up, and brushed crumbs off his uniform shirt, and picked his hat off the filing cabinet. “The house is still sealed. Sheriff’s given me till noon to finish up there, since the family wants the place back. I’d like it very much if you came and showed me what you mean. Not as a suspect. As, I don’t know. A consultant.”

“A consultant.”

“It’s a word. I don’t get to use it a lot.”

She looked at the plastic fern, at the dust-free shine on it, at the man who was holding his hat in both hands as Stellan had held his in the bakery, and she thought, Mind the left.

“Okay,” she said.

They drove out to Lighthouse Lane in her van, because Eero said his cruiser made the neighbors nervous. On the way he asked her to explain what a cheek block was, and she did, and he wrote it down.

“It’s the end of the keyboard,” she said. “Each end of the keybed has a wooden block, the cheek. It’s solid, mostly. It holds the key slip, the front rail, the case. If you’re making a hiding place and you’re clever, you cut the block hollow and cover it with a thin panel and screw the panel to the case from underneath.”

“Persis does that?”

“Persis has done it for forty years.”

“Has she ever been wrong?”

“About the screws, never.”

He nodded, and looked out the window at the lake, which lay a flat hard gray between the trees, and did not say anything for a while.

“I took lessons from her,” he said abruptly. “When I was a kid. Seven to twelve.”

She did not look away from the road. She had not known that. “You never said.”

“I never said to anyone.” His voice stayed level. “I quit after a recital. I played something wrong in the middle and kept going, and when I got to the end the whole room clapped like I’d done something nice, and I knew they were being kind. I couldn’t stand it. I never touched one again.”

A pause. “Persis came to our house the next week. She didn’t say anything about the recital. She tuned the family upright and went home. And I figured out later she’d tuned it exactly the same as it had been before, just so I’d know it was still mine.”

“That sounds like her.”

“It’s why I wanted to be a deputy,” Eero said, with the faint surprise of someone who had never put the two things side by side before. “I think. I like it when something that’s been left alone gets put right.”

She had no answer to that. She turned onto Lighthouse Lane, and neither of them said anything more until they were in the sunroom, and the door was shut behind them, and the lake light lay across the pine floor in long flat bars.

The Vestergaard upright sat where she had left it, lid up, a little crooked, as if it had been sitting up waiting for her. Her coat still lay across the bench.

She took her phone out first, and set it on the ledge of the window with the camera on, and told Eero what she was doing.

“I’d like to record the seam. In case somebody doesn’t believe me.”

“Good idea.”

She sat on the bench. She played the F below the bass break, and the F sharp beside it. Even to her unaided ear the seam was plain, a cool bright edge on the lower note, and she realized with a small shock that Eero had heard it too. She saw his head tilt, the way a dog’s tilts at a whistle.

“There,” he said. “Right there. What is that?”

“That’s the bass strings,” said Astrid. “They’re eight cents sharper than the rest of the piano.”

“I never heard that before.”

“You just did.”

He was quiet. The F sounded again under her finger, and faded, and the room held the memory of it. He said, almost to himself, “I think I could have heard it at ten.”

“Everybody could,” she said, “if somebody told them what to listen for.”

She took a moment, then, to look him in the face. He was the first person in a very long time who had looked at something she heard and said, Oh. That. She found, to her annoyance, that her eyes had gone hot.

“Okay,” she said, and turned back to the piano. “The long way in.”

She started by taking everything off. The music desk first, then the lid, then the front panel, lifting it free and leaning it against the wall. Behind it lay the working parts, the long row of wooden hammers and the dampers, and above them the big iron frame with its web of strings. She told Eero the names as she went, because he had asked, and because saying them aloud steadied her hands. Hammer, damper, action, rail.

“Where do thieves look?” he asked.

“The top. Under the lid, where there’s a gap behind the music desk. It’s the easy place. It’s where somebody hides a roll of cash in a hurry.”

“And you wouldn’t go there.”

“Persis never did.”

She slid the key slip off, the long thin board that ran in front of the keys, and set it on the bench. Then she pulled the pale felt strip from the left end of the keybed, and under it, where a person who was not looking for it would have seen only the grain of the wood, found a round-headed screw painted the same color as the case.

Eero leaned closer. “That’s the one.”

“That’s one.”

She took a screwdriver from her roll. It turned easily, which she had not expected. Too easily. She stopped.

“What?” said Eero.

“It’s been turned recently.”

“By who?”

“By someone who started and didn’t finish.” She looked at the head of the screw. A thin bright mark ran along its slot where the paint had been scraped, a fine clean line, and the screw sat a hair proud of the wood, the way a screw does when it has been backed out half a turn and left. “Somebody got this far, Eero. This week. And then they stopped.”

“Stopped why?”

“I don’t know.” She thought of a man coming home early to a lit kitchen. “Something interrupted them.”

He said nothing. His pen scratched.

She went on. When the screw was out she drew the left end of the keybed forward a quarter inch, as Persis had written, and lifted the little thin panel behind it with her fingernail. It came away with a sigh of old glue.

The cavity inside was a shallow, dark box no bigger than a hardcover book. She shone the phone light in. Wax paper. A flat package, folded small, tied with plain string. And nothing else.

“Oh,” Astrid said.

“Is that it?”

“Wait.”

She did not touch it. She sat back on her heels and looked at what she had found, and then at Eero, and said, because it was the truest thing she knew, “A piano’s secret belongs to the house until the house says.”

“Persis?”

“Persis.” She took a breath. “He left that napkin for me. That was the house saying. But there’s a man dead, and that changes who the house is.”

He thought about it. She liked him a great deal for that.

“I’m the law,” he said at last. “I can’t un-know what I’m looking at. But I can tell you I won’t open anything that I don’t need to. Let’s do it together.”

She nodded.

Together they lifted the wax-paper package from the cavity. It was lighter than she expected. She laid it on the music stand and undid the string, and unfolded the paper, and inside it lay two things.

The first was a page torn from a small field book, the yellow, waterproof kind surveyors carry in the rain. It was covered in pencil, in a small square slanted hand. Columns of figures, bearings, a rough sketch of a shoreline with a bandstand drawn in. Along the margin someone had printed in capitals, CORNER 14, TERN LAKE COMMON. AS FOUND. AS MOVED. And two arrows, one drawn dark and one drawn faint, with a distance between them labeled 14 FT.

The second was a disc of brass, the size of a silver dollar, with a short stem on the back where it had once been driven into the ground. Stamped into its face were three words and a number. WHITEFIR CO. SURVEY. 14.

Eero picked it up with two fingers, by the edges, and turned it to the light. The brass had gone dull and green in the grooves. He blew on it gently, a habit, and it gave back a soft, high note that Astrid could not help hearing, a faint ring, a G above the staff.

“Corner fourteen,” he said.

“Of the Common.”

“I know the Common.” His voice was very quiet. “They’re voting on it Thursday. Next week. The council. It’s the lot Harbor Light Partners wants for the condominiums. They’ve been through three study sessions. They keep saying the lot line runs to the bandstand.”

“Does it?”

He studied the page for a long moment. He was not a quick reader. He read the way he wrote, one careful word after another, and she watched his eyes go down the columns and across the sketch and down again, and then stop.

“Fourteen feet,” he said. “The real corner is fourteen feet inland from where the plat puts it.”

“Is that a lot?”

“If your lot starts at the stake,” said Eero, “it’s the difference between a condo with a lake view and a condo with a parking lot view. And if the real line is the one on this page, then the strip they want to buy doesn’t belong to the county.” He looked up. “It belongs to the public. It’s the Common. It was always the Common. Somebody moved a stake and sold a hundred feet of beach.”

“Twenty years ago,” Astrid said.

“Stellan was the county surveyor for forty years.”

“Persis’s note says he moved it for a friend. A dying man who wanted more beach for his grandchildren. Not for money.”

“It always starts that way,” said Eero. He sounded tired. He carefully set the cap back on its paper. “Who else knew?”

“Persis. Maybe Berit, half of it.”

“And somebody who decided to find out.”

She looked at the open piano, at the bright screw-head and the thin dark cavity and the long row of copper-wound strings above it, and at a spot below the bass bridge she had not yet looked at, where a narrow wooden cover lay over a hollow like the lid of a pencil box.

“There’s a decoy,” she said. “Under the bass strings. A card, red ink, a coffee ring. A recipe. I’d bet money it’s gone.”

“You want to check it.”

“I want to check it slowly. I have to slack the strings to lift the cover. It’s going to put a seam in the bass.” She tried a smile. “I’d be committing the same crime.”

“I’ll write that you did it for me.”

“It’s in your handwriting. It’s a legal document.”

“Is it?” said Eero gravely, and wrote it down.

She slackened the three strings at the bass bridge one at a time, with the lever, the way Persis had taught her, a quarter turn and a listen and a quarter turn. The notes sagged under her hand, one by one, falling into themselves. When there was enough give she lifted the narrow cover with a thumbnail and held her light inside.

Empty. A hollow of dust, a pale clean rectangle where something flat had lain for decades. Nothing more.

But something small and black sat in the corner of the dust, no bigger than the end of her thumb, a little wedge of rubber, cut crudely, with a ragged edge.

She did not touch it.

“Eero.”

He came over and looked down. He did not speak at first.

“That’s a mute,” Astrid said. “A tuner’s wedge. You push it between the strings to stop the ones you’re not tuning.” She pointed with the end of the lever. “Persis uses felt. Strips of red felt, I do too, every tuner I know does. This is rubber. Somebody cut it by hand out of an old inner tube, and it’s the wrong shape for these strings. It was in a hurry. It slipped. They couldn’t find it.”

“They left it.”

“They left it.” Her heart was going fast. “I think they were here for a long time, Eero. Long enough to retune a whole octave. Long enough to be sloppy.”

He had already slid a paper envelope out of his pocket. He used the point of his pen to nudge the wedge into it, and sealed it, and wrote the date and time on the front, slowly, with his tongue between his teeth.

“Okay,” he said. “That I can use.”

“Can you?”

“I can put it in a bag and call it evidence. I can’t put it in a courtroom and say it belongs to a man with a gadget.” He looked at her. “But I can find out who in the county cuts their own mutes.”

“A lot of old tuners do.”

“How many?”

“Three. Four.” She thought. “I can name four.”

“Then that’s where we start.”

She sat back on the bench and let out a long breath, and for the first time since Tuesday morning she felt the thing that Persis had meant when she said Go slow. It was not calm. It was more like the moment when a piano finally agrees with itself and you can hear the whole instrument settle into its own weight.

Outside, a car engine changed pitch. She heard it before she saw it. A heavy sedan, a deep D that rose and fell as it came up Lighthouse Lane, slowing as it passed the drive.

She went to the window. A pale gray car was rolling by at walking pace, windows up, a shape behind the wheel too far away to see. It slowed almost to a stop at the mailbox, and she stood very still, and then the engine rose again and the car went on past the bend and out of sight.

“Did you see that?” she said.

“Gray sedan,” said Eero, from just behind her, surprising her. He had written it in the pad already. “Fairly new. I didn’t get the plate.”

“Who drives a gray sedan?”

“Half the county,” Eero said. “The other half drives a gray something else.”

He closed the pad and put it away. And then, looking at the road, at the place where the car had been, he said very quietly, as if he were telling a secret to the lake, “He slowed down to look at your van.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!