Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 5

The Last Appraiser

At 2:10 in the morning the Draycott kitchen smelled like butter, and Elias Draycott was scrambling eggs.

Dess stopped in the doorway with Pip behind her and a police report folded in her pocket.

He was in shirtsleeves. His cuffs were rolled to the elbow. He had, apparently, been waiting up, because he had set out three plates, a loaf of good bread and a pot of tea, and he was whisking eggs in a copper bowl with the grim concentration of a man defusing something.

"Mr. Ambrose told you," Dess said.

"Mr. Ambrose tells me everything. It's the only way I'm able to pay him." He did not turn. "You went to your shop."

"Two of Strand's men were tearing it apart."

"I know. Your friend's statement to the police says they were looking for 'letters.' Are you hurt?"

"No."

"Is she?"

"Pip's fine," said Pip, from behind. "Pip's very hungry, actually."

He turned. For the first time all night, something crossed his face besides cool control. It was a small, rueful, almost boyish flicker that vanished as quickly as it came.

"Then sit," he said. "Both of you. There are enough eggs for a small army."

They sat. Dess had not meant to, but the chair was warm and the kitchen was brighter than the Cabinet Room, all copper pots and a scrubbed oak table, and her hands had begun to shake from adrenaline. Pip dug in without ceremony.

Elias set a plate in front of Dess and sat across from her. He did not eat.

"You promised me one thing," Dess said, "this evening."

"I did."

"Anders Strand told me to ask you what happened to the last appraiser."

He was quiet for a moment.

"Of course he did."

"Is that why you didn't answer me in the Cabinet Room?"

"It's why I said I'd tell you tomorrow." He glanced at the clock. "It's tomorrow."

Dess noticed that her hands were no longer shaking. That was worse. It meant some cool, practical part of her had moved into the house and started taking inventory.

Pip, chewing, held up a finger. "I'm not here. I'm furniture. I'm a very quiet ottoman."

"You're welcome to stay, Ms. Kowalczyk," Elias said. "I assume Dess is going to tell you all of it in the morning anyway."

"That is the most sensible thing anyone's said to me tonight," Pip said, and kept eating.

He looked down at his folded hands. When he looked up it was at Dess, and he did it directly, the way a man steps off a curb.

"The Registry's appraiser for twenty-two years," he said, "was a man named Raymond Whitlock."

The kitchen was very quiet.

Dess had expected it. She had spent the whole drive back expecting it, the way you brace for a step in the dark. It did not help in the slightest.

"My father," she said.

"Yes."

"My father sold boat insurance."

"I'm told he did that, too. For cover." Elias's voice was gentle. "He worked with my grandfather first, and then my father. He certified every lot that came into the Cabinet from the winter of 1998 to the spring of 2014. His signature is on three hundred and twelve provenance letters. He was the best appraiser the Registry ever had. My father still says so."

"In 2014," Dess said carefully, "he was arrested for forging a painting."

"He was."

"A little oil landscape. He sold it to a collector in Newport. He went to prison. He died there two years later of a heart attack." She heard her own voice go flat. "He told me he did it for the money. He told me he was sorry."

"I'm sure he was." Elias paused. "He didn't forge that painting."

She stared at him.

"It was made in the Cabinet Room," he said. "On my father's orders. For a client of the Registry who needed a very particular canvas to appear in a very particular catalogue. Your father agreed to take the fall. He never gave a name. He did two years of a four-year sentence, and died of what the prison doctor called a cardiac event, and the Registry paid for the funeral."

"And paid his family."

"Your mother had left by then. There was no one to pay but you." He did not look away. "There was a trust. It was administered through an attorney who is now dead. It would have come to you at thirty-five. I don't know whether it ever existed."

"I'm thirty-one."

"I'm aware."

Dess put down her fork. The eggs were perfect. It seemed unreasonably cruel.

"I'm going to say something," she said, "and I want you to listen to it as a statement and not a question. My whole life I thought my father was a small-time crook who got caught. I built a career in part by being the opposite of him. I've spent nine years being careful. And you're telling me he was a very big crook who didn't get caught, and that the only thing he did wrong was keep quiet about it."

"That is a fair summary."

Pip had stopped chewing. She was watching Dess with the careful, worried look she wore when a customer started crying over a candlestick.

"Dess," she said. "Do you want me to leave?"

"No." Dess found, to her surprise, that she meant it. "Stay. I'm going to need someone in the room who'll tell me if I'm being ridiculous."

"You're being ridiculous."

"I haven't done anything yet."

"I'm getting ahead of it."

Elias's mouth twitched, and it was gone again.

Dess looked at her hands. She remembered a weekend morning, the smell of solder and cold coffee in the kitchen on Wexford Road, her father's big warm hand over her small one, guiding a needle. She remembered him saying, You're a natural, baby girl. Don't ever let anyone see you're a natural.

She had not let anyone. Not once. She had spent her whole adult life being very, very good at being ordinary.

"You hired me because of that."

"I hired you because you're the best independent appraiser in New England who has no tie to any family on the Table of Ten." He said it quickly, and she watched him decide, in the half second afterward, not to say whatever came next. "That is true. It is also true that I knew who your father was."

"You didn't mention it."

"I'm mentioning it now."

"At two in the morning. In a kitchen. With eggs."

"I thought the eggs would help."

Pip made a small sound that might have been a laugh into her teacup.

Dess pushed her plate away. A tight, cold, furious part of her wanted to leave. Another part, the part that had stood over that dimple a few hours ago, wanted to ask the question she had held since ten o'clock.

"The fakes in the Cabinet," she said, slowly. "Do you have any idea who's making them?"

"No."

"Do you have an idea who isn't?"

He gave her a small, tired look.

"I'm told," he said, "that nobody is allowed in the Cabinet Room without a witness. That is the rule. And I'm told that, in the last year, at least once a week, a lot has been replaced by something very like it, and nobody saw anything. So I have the keys, and my aunt has the keys, and Marcus has a key, and Mr. Ambrose has a key. And my father has a key, in his bedside drawer, that he hasn't been able to use in two years."

"That's a short list."

"It's a very short list." His mouth tightened. "I don't like what it says about my family."

"What does it say?"

"That I'd like to be wrong."

She tried to read his face and could not. It was like reading a closed book by the spine.

"Anders told me to ask you," she said. "He's a Strand. He had every reason to want me to quit. Why should I believe anything he said?"

"You shouldn't. Believe the card." He paused. "And believe this. I have not slept properly in eight weeks. I have spent every one of those nights in that room, counting drawers, and I do not know who is robbing my family. That is not a thing I'd say to a stranger. I'm saying it because I'd like you to understand that I need you to be honest more than I need you to be loyal."

"That's the most unusual thing anyone's ever said when hiring me."

"I'm not good at this."

"No," Dess said. "But you're trying. It's strangely effective."

"You're doing fine," Pip said gravely. "I'd hire you. I'd also check the contract for a clause about being murdered, but I'd hire you."

He said it so quietly that she almost missed the weight in it. A man who counted drawers every night, who knew exactly how many hands had keys, and who loved at least some of the people attached to those hands. She thought, suddenly and unwillingly, that she would not have wanted his job for any retainer in the world.

He reached into the pocket of his trousers and took out a small white card, the size of a playing card, edged in gilt. It had been folded once and unfolded. He laid it on the table and slid it across to her with two fingers.

"This was in drawer seventeen, under the watch," he said. "I found it before you arrived. I didn't show you in the Cabinet Room, because I wanted your first impression of the watch to be your own."

Dess looked at it.

CONDITION CARD, it said at the top, in a neat engraved hand. Below: LOT 17. Waltham hunter-case watch. Examined and certified in original condition. And below that, a single signature in black ink, in a looping, slightly forward-leaning script she'd have known in the dark.

R. Whitlock.

And the date.

Eleven days ago.

She heard Pip put down her teacup.

"My father's been dead for nine years," Dess said.

"Yes," said Elias. "That's what I thought, too."

He sat back and let her read it again, and again, and a third time, as though if she looked hard enough the date would change.

It did not.

"Someone forged his signature," she said. "Obviously. Whoever made the watch. It's a good forgery. But it's a forgery."

"Is it?"

She picked up the card and held it to the light. She tilted it, and caught the shine of the ink, and sniffed it, and checked the paper, and felt her stomach drop.

"It's not a forgery," Dess said.

"No."

"The ink is two weeks old at most. The signature has the pressure on the loop, the little hitch before the W. It's his hand, Elias. It's him." Her voice cracked on the last word and she hated it. "How does a dead man sign a card?"

Elias said nothing.

Outside, a long way off, a clock struck the half hour, and the old house settled around the three of them like a held breath.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!