By Day Three Dess had a method, a headache and a system of sticky notes that Pip described as "a serial killer's vision board, but organized."
The method was simple. Every lot got four passes. First pass: the object, with her naked eye, in good light, for as long as it took to feel what it was trying to say. Second: the loupe, the UV and the raking lamp. Third: the Provenance Letter's seal, which she was not allowed to break, but which she could weigh, sniff and hold up to a window. Fourth: the Condition Card in the drawer, which had to match the date of the last certification and the hand of the last appraiser.
Her father's hand. Over and over, three hundred and twelve times.
She had stopped letting that touch her by about drawer twenty. It was a skill. You looked at the loops of his R and the hitch before his W the way you looked at a crack in a vase, with interest and no feeling.
"Lot 31," she said aloud, for the record. Marcus sat on the library ladder at the far end of the room, peeling an orange, with the air of a man hired to guard a museum from boredom. "A child's tooth in a locket."
"That's gross," Marcus said.
"It's a baby tooth in a gold-plated locket with a lock of hair. 1974. Consigned by a woman named Rose Delacroix. Condition Card says original." She flipped the locket over and held it under the lamp. "It's original. Both are real. It's also, I'd say, the saddest thing I've ever held."
"What did she pledge it for?"
"I can't read the letter."
"I can." He popped a segment in his mouth. "Her son went through a stop sign in a company truck. It got handled."
"Was the son okay?"
"The son was fine. The other driver wasn't." He chewed. "It got handled very quietly. Rose paid the hammer in 1991, by the way. She wanted the tooth back. The hammer was a vote in a zoning meeting. We burned the lot, and then she asked us to un-burn it, because she'd changed her mind about wanting to have it back, so my aunt had it re-sealed as a courtesy."
Dess stared at him. "You re-sealed a burned lot."
"It's a Registry Book thing. Don't look at me, I just carry the oranges."
She made a note. She made a very small note beside the note: ask Cordelia about re-sealed lots.
Then she moved on to drawer thirty-two, because there were three hundred and eighty more and the hundred days had already become ninety-eight.
It was a strange kind of work. The Cabinet held a pocket watch, a child's tooth, a nineteenth-century trumpet with a dented bell, a signed first baseman's mitt, a pair of dentures in a velvet box (Marcus: "Don't ask. Seriously. I've asked."), a Victorian mourning brooch woven from the hair of a dead sister, a set of brass keys to a house that no longer existed, a baby's christening gown, a bowling trophy, a wedding ring so plain she knew immediately it was the real thing. Every object looked like what it was: the one possession someone could not bear to lose. And behind each one, in a sealed envelope the color of old tea, a worse truth.
Somewhere around lot thirty-five she remembered what Gus had said. Start with the drawers no one asked you to look at. The ones that are too neat.
She stopped. She stepped back from the wall, took off her gloves and did the thing her first employer had taught her to do with a cluttered estate: she looked at the room as a surface instead of a collection.
The Cabinet's brass pulls had a hundred years of oxidation on them. Each one had gone the same soft, brownish gold, darker at the edges where thumbs didn't reach. But if you stood at the far end and let the lamp rake along the wall, a handful of them caught the light a shade too brightly.
"Marcus. Does anyone polish the pulls?"
"Ambrose does the whole room every December. Why?"
"Because six of them are cleaner than the rest." She walked along the wall with her finger an inch from the wood. Drawer 12. Drawer 29. Drawer 44. "Brass only gets bright when a hand keeps touching it. A thumb, a pair of gloves, the same drawer opened over and over."
Marcus slid off the ladder and came to stand beside her. He didn't joke. "That's the ones that got swapped?"
"That's the ones that got opened more than the others."
Drawer 44 held a Victorian mourning brooch woven from a dead sister's hair. It was gorgeous, and wrong. The hair had been dyed, not aged. Under the lamp, the faintest cast of synthetic red gave it away, like a smile put on too carefully.
She wrote the number on a yellow note and stuck it to the plaque and felt, for the first time in two days, like herself.
By lot thirty-nine she realized she was whispering to them.
By lot forty, she had found the ninth fake.
It was a violin, an old Mittenwald with a faint crack in the table, and it was so good that she held it in her lap for ten full minutes before she spoke. The varnish was right. The scroll was right. Someone had even replicated the faint spirit-varnish smear that a long-dead player's thumb had left on the neck.
But the f-holes were cut with a power tool, very faintly, with a speed you could see in the micro-chatter on the wood. And on the underside of the scroll, so close to the shadow she nearly missed it, a pinhead dimple.
There it was again, small and neat and nearly invisible, with the curl of metal around it that only a hand could make.
She said "Cramp," and went to wash her hands, and stood in the powder room with the water running, thinking: nine.
She came back and sat down and said, in a perfectly level voice, "Lot 40 is not what it says it is."
"Another one?" Marcus slid off the ladder.
"A beautiful one."
"Eli's going to love this." He didn't sound amused any more. He sounded, for the first time since she'd met him, like a man doing arithmetic.
She had gotten used to the fact that Elias did not hover. He appeared in doorways, said a few words and vanished. Not a word the day before. Today, at four, he stood in the doorway for a full minute, said nothing at all, looked at the nine yellow sticky notes she'd stuck on the plaque of each fake, and left again.
"Does he do that a lot?" Dess asked.
"Think of it as concern," Marcus said. "He just doesn't have the vocabulary."
At six, someone knocked on the double doors, a quick, light, cheerful knock, the kind that expected to be let in.
"Marcus, you're on dinner duty. Go away." The door swung open and a young woman in paint-stained overalls banged through with a tray balanced on one forearm. She was small and round-cheeked, with a dark braid coming undone and a smear of lead white across one eyebrow. "Cordelia says you're not allowed to starve the appraiser. Hello! You're Dess. I'm Teddy. I'm the brother nobody talks about."
"Sister," Dess said.
"Sister. Brother. I get confused. Elias says I'm 'a hazard to a quiet life,' which is the nicest thing he's ever said." She plunked down the tray, which held a pot of coffee, two sandwiches and three cookies the size of coasters. "Eat. I've been told you work on sticky notes and spite."
"I work on sticky notes and spite," Dess agreed, and took a cookie.
Teddy Draycott was twenty-seven and she restored paintings for a living, out of a carriage-house studio at the bottom of the garden that Dess had seen from her window: a glass-roofed barn, lit all night, with an easel in the middle and a thousand brushes in jars. Within five minutes she had told Dess about her dissertation on Dutch varnish, her ex-boyfriend, a very bad opinion of Cordelia's tea and the fact that she was, strictly, not supposed to be in the main house after six.
"Because I talk," she said cheerfully.
"Do you?"
"Constantly. It's why they don't tell me things. I'm a very bad liar and a worse secret-keeper." She tipped her head. "Which is why I'm going to tell you something, because I like you. Don't trust my brother's face."
"Why not?"
"It never moves. He's very good at it. He learned it from our father." She picked up a cookie. "Trust his hands. They do what he means. Watch what he does when you're not looking."
"Am I being warned?"
"You're being befriended. It's a very rare thing in this house." She finished the cookie in two bites. "I'd like to see the fakes. Can I?"
Dess hesitated.
"Come on. I'm a conservator. I can't resist a good forgery." Teddy bent over the violin. For a moment her bright face went still and intent, and it was odd to watch, as if a lamp had been turned down. She ran a fingertip along the edge of the f-hole, not quite touching, and Dess saw her glance, quick as a bird, at the underside of the scroll.
"It's beautiful," Teddy said softly.
"Yes."
"I'd love to meet the person who made it."
"So would I."
Teddy looked up, and for half a second her bright brown eyes were not bright at all. They were frightened.
Then she grinned. "My brother wants a report by dinner. Do you have a report?"
"I have a number."
"Say it."
"Nine of the first forty lots," Dess said. "Counting the watch. Nine fakes."
Marcus whistled. Teddy did not move.
"That's twenty-two percent," Dess said, because numbers were a handrail. "If it holds across the Cabinet, ninety-one lots. About ninety-one favors. About ninety-one people who think they're still owed, or still owe, and aren't, and don't know it. And somewhere in the city there's a person holding the real ones."
"Holding the hammers," Teddy said faintly.
"Ninety-one hammers."
The room was very quiet.
"I'll tell Elias," Marcus said at last, and left, and she heard his boots go quickly down the hall.
Teddy stood with her hands in her overall pockets, looking at the violin.
"I'm going to go and get some air," she said brightly. "If you need anything, come to the carriage house. I'm always up. I sleep like a bat."
She went. She forgot her tray.
Dess sat for a long moment in the lamp's green circle, with nine yellow notes and three hundred and seventy drawers, and a growing, nasty, intimate feeling that the dimple in the violin had not frightened Teddy Draycott because it was a forgery.
It had frightened her because she recognized it.

